High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1135/2017dismissed

Munish Kumar & ORS v. Som Pal & ORS

2018-08-07Mr. Justice Satpal8 pages

!"# $#%&'&() *

* +(&',-+.!/!($",#/' 00#11!("' 2#/'+' . !1!($",#/' #'0($#("'

/#'#(") /3,!(4$5%!"#!($ /&',!63,!(4$5%!"# /",#!00#11!(" 77777

,# !00#11!("'801!&("&

' !/# !99/&#5#$ ",# :+$9.#("' !($ $#%/##'$!"#$

;!($

0!''#$6<",#1#!/(#$$$&"&(!1 &'"/&%" +$9#4 &($ !($ $$&"&(!1 &5&1 +$9# / &5&'&(4 !

&$( /#'0#%"&5#1<

/&# !%"'(#%#''!/< /!$:+$&%!"&( ",#%!'#!/#",!"4'+&" / $#%1!/!"&(=!' &1#$6<",#!00#11!("'801!&("&

'"",##

#%"",!"",#<!1(9 =&",$# #($!(".0!1'( !6/!=#/#:&("=(#/'&(0''#''&(&( #>+!1 ',!/#' !' %0!/%#(#/' &(" &($+ !.&1< !(%#'"/!1 0/0#/"< &# !9/&%+1"+/!11!($.#!'+/&(9 *?!(!1' .!/1!'"",##@"#(" 8 ",',!/# !($ ",!" ",# !11#9#$ '!1# $##$ $!"#$

#@#%+"#$ 6< ",#&/ !",#/ .0!1$# #($!("&( /#'0($#("' !($ *?!(!1'=!' &11#9!14 (+114 5&$ !($ (" 6&($&(9 +0( ",# /&9,"' ",# !00#11!("' " =!'

+/",#/0/!<#$",!"/#'0($#("' !($ 6#/#'"/!&(#$ /.!1&#(!"&(9",# '+&"0/0#/"< ,#!00#11!("'!/#",#.&(/'(' .0!1/#'0($#(" ,# '+&" =!' &1#$ ( ",#&/ 6#,!1 ",/+9, ",#&/ .",#/4 =& # .0!1 /#'0($#(" " =!' 01#!$#$ ",!" &/! &(9, '( !,:!$!4 9/#!" 9/!($ !",#/ !00#11!("'801!&("&

'!($9/!($ !",#/ /#'0($#(" =!' ",#=(#/&(0''#''&( ",#'+&"1!($.#!'+/&(9;?!(!1' .!/1!',# 0/0#/"< $#515#$ +0( !6/! 9/!($ !",#/ ",# !00#11!("' ,#/#!

"#/4

!6/!"/!('

#//#$",#'+&"1!($"/#'0($#(".0!1",/+9,! !.&1< '#""1#.#(" +$9.#(" !($ $#%/## $!"#$ A BB 0!''#$ 6< 1#!/(#$ #(&/ +6 +$9#4 !

&$( !($ .+"!"&( A;A &( $# #($!(" .0!1=!'&(%/0/!"#$&(",#/#5#(+#/#%/$"=!'4",+'401#!$#$ ",!" ",# 01!&("&

' !($ /#'0($#(" =#/# %0!/%#(#/' &( ",# 0/0#/"< =,&%,=!'!(%#'"/!1 &("&($+!.&1< /0#/"<"=!' +/",#/01#!$#$",!" ",# 01!&("&

' %!.# " ?(= ",!" $# #($!("'8/#'0($#("' !($ 6< 01!<&(9! /!+$!($",/+9,.&'/#0/#'#("!"&(.!(&0+1!"#$",##@#%+"&( '!1#$##$$!"#$

,#!00#11!("'01#!$#$",!"",#&/ !",#/.0!1 /#'0($#(" ,!$ ( /&9," " "/!('

#/ ",# '+&" 1!($ =&",+" !(< 1#9!1 (#%#''&"</ /",#6#(# &""",#:&("#'"!"# ''#''&( ",#'+&"1!($=!' '"&11=&",",#01!&("&

'!($",#&/ !",#/.0!1/#'0($#("%%/$&(91<4 ",#0/#'#("'+&" /$#%1!/!"&(!'=#11!'0#/.!(#("&(:+(%"&(=!' &1#$ .0!14$# #($!("8/#'0($#("!00#!/#$!($!$.&""#$",# %1!&. ",#!00#11!("'&(",#=/&""#('"!"#.#(""=!''"!"#$",!",#(#5#/ #@#%+"#$",#'!&$'!1#$##$$!"#$

&( /#'0($#("' !($ +" ,&'=( /##=&11,#'!&$/#'0($#("',!$.!$#,&.%('+.# 1&>+/ /%&61<!($",#/#!

"#/"?,&."!(

&%#=,#/#",#<.&9,",!5#9"

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

* =!' /#9&'"#/#$ '+. '

8D +" ",# ""!1 '!1# %('&$#/!"&( '4

8D=!'0!&$"/#'0($#(""=!'!9/##$",!"",#'!1#$##$ =+1$6##@#%+"#$&( ",#0#/'(80#/'('!'$#'&/#$6<!.!""!( !($!/!&(+""!"# #@#%+"&( ",#'!1#$##$=!' &@#$!' B

B !($ ",#/#!

"#/ #@"#($#$ " ;

6< .+"+!1 %('#(" ",# 0!/"&#' #0!/!"#=/&"&(9&(",&'/#9!/$=!'!1'#($/'#$(",#/#5#/'#'&$# ",# !9/##.#(" " '#11 $!"#$ B

* ' ;

=!' ! ,1&$!<4 $# #($!("'8 /#'0($#("' !($ /#.!&(#$ 0/#'#(" 6# /# ",#

&%# +6#9&'"/!/(; ;

6+"/#'0($#("$&$(""+/(+0,#/#!

"#/4 ,+'6!($' /#'0($#("' !($ !00/!%,#$ /#'0($#(" 4 =, $#.!($#$ ! '+. ' A4;

8D &( !$$&"&( " ",# !9/##$ '!1# %('&$#/!"&( ('#>+#("1<4 ! '+. 'A4 A4;

8D =!' 0!&$ 6< .0!1 =,&1# $#0'&"&(9 ",# '!.# &( ",# 1!( !%%+(" .0!1 &( &($ &'"/&%"

/&.!/<0#/!"&5#9/&%+1"+/!1!($+/!1#5#10.#(" !(?3"$4!

&$( ,+'!""!1'+. ' B4 A4;

8D=!'0!&$"/#'0($#(",#/#!

"#/4 '!1# $##$ $!"#$

=!' #@#%+"#$ 6< .0!1 &(

A /#'0($#("' !($ "&''0#%& &%!11<01#!$#$",!"'+&"0/0#/"<=!'",# '#1 !%>+&/#$0/0#/"< .0!1#=!'=#11=&",&(,&'/&9,"""/!(' #/",# '!.# " &' +/",#/ '"!"#$ ",!" #5#( & &" &' 0/#'+.#$ " 6# !( !(%#'"/!1 0/0#/"<4 ",# '!1# %('&$#/!"&( ,!' 6##( +'#$ 6< .0!1 " 0!<

,&' $#6"',#'!&$/#'0($#("'01#!$#$",!"",#'+&"=!' &1#$6<",#01!&("&

'&( %11+'&(=&",",#&/ !",#/.0!1/#'0($#("=&",!.!1!

&$#&("#("&( "%!+'#1''"",#. #01&%!"&("",#=/&""#('"!"#.#("=!' &1#$!($(",#6!'&' ",#01#!$&(9'4 11=&(9&''+#'=#/# /!.#$)D E F,#",#/ ",# 01!&("&

' !/# #("&"1#$ / $#%1!/!"&( !' =#11 !' &(:+(%"&(4!'!11#9#$G

F,#",#/ ",# '+&" ",# 01!&("&

' &' (" .!&("!&(!61# &( ",# 0/#'#(" /.H F,#",#/ ",# 01!&("&

' ,!5# 9" ( %!+'# !%"&( !($ 1%+' '"!($&" &1#",#0/#'#("'+&"H A F,#",#/ ",# 01!&("&

' ,!5# (" %.# &( ",# %+/" =&", %1#!( ,!($'H

F,#",#/ ",# '+&" &' 6!$ / ((D:&($#/ !($ .&'D:&($#/ (#%#''!/<0!/"&#'H ; F,#",#/",#01!&("&

'!/##'"00#$ /. &1&(9",#0/#'#("'+&"6< ,&'=(!%"!($%($+%"H #1&# G 5&$#(%# =!' 1#$ 6< 6", ",# 0!/"&#' 3#!/(#$ "/&!1 +/" %(%1+$#$ ",!" ",# 01!&("&

' !&1#$ " 0/5# ",# !(%#'"/!1 (!"+/# ",# '+&" 0/0#/"< ''+# =!' $#%&$#$ !9!&('" ",# 01!&("&

' !($ &( $# #($!("' !($ ''+#' 4 4A!($;=#/#$#%&$#$&( $# #($!("' !($ #5&$#(%#=!'1#$6<$# #($!("' !($ ( &''+# =,&%,=!'!%%/$&(91<$#%&$#$('#>+#("1<4",#'+&" &1#$6<",#

!00#11!("'801!&("&

' =!' $&'.&''#$ (

00#!1 &1#$ 6< ",# !00#11!("'801!&("&

'=!'!1'$&'.&''#$6<",#$$&"&(!1&'"/&%" +$9#4 &($ 99/&#5#$",#/# /.40/#'#("!00#!1,!'6##( &1#$ 3#!/(#$%+('#1 /",#!00#11!("'!/9+#'",!"6",",#1#!/(#$ %+/"' 6#1= ,!5# 9/''1< #//#$ &( /#"+/(&(9 ",# &($&(9' !9!&('" ",# !00#11!("'801!&("&

'+&"0/0#/"<&(>+#'"&(=!'$+1<0/5#$"6#!(%#'"/!1 &( (!"+/# ( ",# 6!'&' .+"!"&( @ 8 !' =#11 !' ",# 0#$&9/## "!61# @ 8 #/#1<6#%!+'#",#0/0#/"<=!'"/!('

#//#$&( $# #($!(" 8.0!16<=!< :+$9.#("!($$#%/##$!"#$ A BB '+

#/#$6< ,&' !",#/ !6/!!($",#/#1#!'#$##$&( $# #($!("8.0!1(

6< (9/& =& # !6/! !($ .",#/ .0!14 &" $#' (" %,!(9# ",# (!"+/# ",# '+&" 0/0#/"< /#5#/4 '!1# $##$ $!"#$

&( /#'0($#("' !($ @ &'",#/#'+1" /!+$ !($.&'/#0/#'#("!"&(!'$# #($!(".0!1+'#$"/#.!&(+($#/",# &( 1+#(%# 1&>+/ " &' ",+' 0/!<#$ ",!" ",&' !00#!1 6# !11=#$ !($ ",# &.0+9(#$:+$9.#("'!($$#%/##'6#'#"!'&$#%('#>+#("1<$#%/##&(9",# '+&" &1#$6<",#!00#11!("'",/+9,+" ,!5# ,#!/$ 1#!/(#$ %+('#1 / ",# !00#11!("' !($ ,!5# 0#/+'#$",# &1# " &' (" &( $&'0+"# ",!" ",# !00#11!("' /#1&#$ +0( .+"!"&( A;A4@ 8!($",#0#$&9/##D"!61#@ 8 4"#'"!61&',",#(!"+/# ",# '+&" 0/0#/"< " 6# !(%#'"/!1 / %0!/%#(!/< ",#/ #5&$#(%# &( ",&' /#'0#%",!'6##(1#$"&' +/",#/("&($&'0+"#",!" !6/! !",#/ .0!1 "/!('

#//#$ ",# '+&" 0/0#/"< &( ,&' '( .0!1 ",/+9, ! !.&1< '#""1#.#(" +$9.#("!($$#%/##$!"#$ A BB =!'0!''#$&(",#%&5&1 '+&" ; &1#$ ( ; BB +"!"&( A;A =!' '!(%"&(#$ &( ",&'

; /#9!/$ ' 0#/ .+"!"&( A;A4 !6/! "/!('

#//#$ ,&' 1!($ %.0/&'#$ &( 5!/&+' ?,#=!"' &( ,&' '( .0!1 !($ ,&' =& # (9/& ' 0#/ .+"!"&(A;

;@;4(9/&=& # !6/! +/",#/"/!('

#//#$",#'!&$ 1!($&( .0!16<=!< /#1#!'#$##$;

$!"#$

(",&'5&#= ",#.!""#/46",",#1#!/(#$%+/"'6#1=,!5#/&9,"1<,#1$",!" ",#0/0#/"<&(",#,!($' /#'0($#(".0!1=!'("!(%#'"/!1 &(" &($+!.&1<0!/%#(!/<0/0#/"< ",!'6##(5#,#.#("1<+/9#$",!"",#'!1#$##$@ 8&'",# /#'+1"

/!+$ !($ .&'/#0/#'#("!"&( ,&' !/9+.#(" &' ""!11< +('+6'"!("&!"#$!($&'/#:#%"#$6#&(9+("#(!61#,#/#&'(",&(9(/#%/$ " ',= ",!" .0!1 #5#/ %,!11#(9#$ ",# '!&$ '!1# $##$ ( ",# 0/#'#(" 0/%##$&(9'4 ,# &1#$ ! =/&""#( '"!"#.#(" !$.&""&(9 ",# 01#!' "!?#( 6< ",# !00#11!("'=,&1#'"!"&(9",!"",#'!1#$##$$!"#$

=!'",#/#'+1"

/!+$ !($ .&'/#0/#'#("!"&( " ",&' '"!9#4 &" &' /#1#5!(" " ("# ",!" !9/##.#(""'#11$!"#$ B

*@F;8 =!'+($+6"#$1<#@#%+"#$6< .0!1&( !.!""!(!($!/!&(+""4,+'6!($' /#'0($#("' !($ !/(#'".(#< '

8D=!'$+1</#%#&5#$6<,&.!"# #@#%+"&( ",#'!1#$##$=!'#@"#($#$6<=!< #($/'#.#("@I #'0($#(" .0!1 "#'"& <&(9 !' F &( ,&' %/'' #@!.&(!"&( ,!' !$.&""#$ ,&' '&9(!"+/# +0( ",# !9/##.#(" " '#11 @F;8 !' =#11 !' @ #'"&.(< F .0!1 /#'0($#(" 4 &( !%" /#5#!1' ",#

!%"+!1.!"/&@ ",#%!'#"$&'%1'#'",!"",#'+&" &1#$6<",#!00#11!("'&' #("&/#1<=&",+"!(<.#/&"F.0!1!$.&""#$",!"",#'!&$!9/##.#("" '#114!'=#11!'",#'!1#$##$=!''%/&6#$6<&,!1,!($4%+.#("F/&"#/ +6,!',!($!,#($#/'"$=&"(#''#'"",#'!1#$##$@,# !%"+. #@"#('&( $!"# #@#%+"&( '!1# $##$ 5&$# #($/'#.#(" @I &'

!1' !$.&""#$ 6< ,&. .0!1 +/",#/ '"!"#$ ",!" ,# /#0!&$ ",# 1!( 'A4 A4

8D"!?#( /.",#6!(?!"!

&$(#'0#%& &%!11<'"!"#$",!",# ./"9!9#$,&'0/0#/"<=&",",#6!(?5&$#./"9!9#$##$@F 83!( =!'!5!&1#$ /",#0+/%,!'# "/!%"/ "#/'#11&(9",#'+&"1!($4,#!$.&""#$ ",!5&(90+/%,!'#$'.#",#/1!($&( &(",#(!.# ,&'=& # #6&=, ,!' &1#$ ",# 0/#'#(" '+&" ( 6#,!1 ",&' .&(/ %,&1$/#( 3#!/(#$ %+/"' 6#1=,!5#",+'/&9,"1<,#1$",!"",#0/#'#("!00#11!("'801!&("&

',!5# &1#$ ",# 0/#'#(" '+&" &( %11+'&( =&", /#'0($#(" 4 ",#&/ !",#/ =&", ",# .!1!

&$#&("#("&("$#0/&5#/#'0($#("' !($ ",#6#(# &"' '!1# $##$ @ ,#< ,!5# .&'#/!61< !&1#$ " 0/5# ",#&/ %!'# (",#/ !/9+.#("5#,#.#("1<+/9#$&'",!".0!1=!'+($#/",#&( 1+#(%# 1&>+/ !"",#"&.# #@#%+"&( ",#'!1#$##$0!/" /.",# !%"",!"",#/#&'( #5&$#(%# " 0/5# ",# '!&$ !''#/"&(4 ",&' 01#! &' (#9!"#$ 6< ",# '0#%& &% !$.&''&( .0!1",!"",#'!1#$##$=!'#@#%+"#$&(0+/'+!(%#"",# !9/##.#(" " '#11 $!"#$ B

* 5&$#(%# ( /#%/$ 0/5#' ",!" %('&$#/!"&( ,!$0!''#$"/#'0($#(",#/# /#4 $(" &($!(< .#/&"&(",#!/9+.#("'/!&'#$(6#,!1 ",#!00#11!("' ",#/!/9+.#(",!'6##(/!&'#$ 3#!/(#$%+('#1 /",#!00#11!("'D01!&("&

'!/#+(!61#"0&(" +"!(<>+#'"&( 1!=.+%,1#'''+6'"!("&!1>+#'"&( 1!==,&%,.!<6# &(515#$ /%('&$#/!"&(&(",&'/#9+1!/'#%($!00#!1 ",",#&.0+9(#$ :+$9#.#("'!/#=#11/#!'(#$:+$9#.#("'/#($#/#$! "#/0/0#/!00/#%&!"&( !($%('&$#/!"&( ",##5&$#(%#(/#%/$ -##0&(9 &( 5&#= ",# !%"' !($ %&/%+.'"!(%#' !' $&'%+''#$ !65#4 $ (" &($ !(< &( &/.&"<4 &11#9!1&"< / 0#/5#/'&"< &( ",# &.0+9(#$ :+$9.#("' !($ $#%/##' $!"#$

!($

; 0!''#$ 6< ",#

* 1#!/(#$$$1&5&1 +$9#/&5&'&(!

&$(!($1#!/(#$$$&"&(!1&'"/&%"

+$9#4 &($4/#'0#%"&5#1<4=,&%,=!//!("!(<&("#/ #/#(%#6<",&'+/"

/#'#("!00#!1&'4%('#>+#("1<4$&'.&''#$=&",(/$#/!'" %'"'

! ',=!/ "#$ #$%&$'()*+%$',*$-./$+ , "#$ #$%%$&,% '01$./$+ ,