Kenzo Nutrico Private Limited v. Tata Consumer Products Limited
!"!
#$%&'
'
( #) * +!
+!,
-!.!
/ ''''''
!
!
+ 0 +"*"
#"*.
++ /* "-!.!
/ '''''' "1 #/
2$ 3-2'4 44
!
"
#
$% $&
'$$(
"
))))) 44
'5+67 * #
#
" + $
, $
- (
.
//-
"
0
1
&##
%
"
(
2
+
"
#
+(%
4
&
%
(
#
(
#
4+ 5 % + "% +"
+ & +##6&
%
& (
+
# & # 7 # +
72
"
#+
(
#
%
(
(6 (
(
.
//-(6 (
##
8 "+ +(%
#+
(
2 #
#
29:92:25+#
4+ 7
& (
+
(+
"
;+
"
##
%
"
$
(
%
#
& ;+ #
<
%
" *
"
#
+
"
##
%
" (
8 +(%
" #6
4+ :
# & # / #
+ # +
&
% " % '+& !
8&.
+ (
(+ %
(
#
* #
#
+ (
" +
$
#
%
%"
##
%
(
(6%+ +
"
&6 +(%
8
1( .
+ %6##
$ (
+ +#
#+ (
#
9
+
## &
( "
+(%
#+ &
4
&
%
4+ 5 (
+
=
#+ #
(
+
(6
+ &
4+ 7
#
% " (
<
%
+
(
" > (6%+ +
8
+(%
# ( %
%"
&%+ +
+
"
% (
%
(6 #
5 I have heard the learned counsels for the parties.
9 , * 4
" &
%
& (
+
"(6
+
#+ *
#6
#
% " (
+
+( (
#
(6%+ +
.
;+
6 #
#
(
" + $
&
%
%"
##
%
" (
" - = #
4
" (
+
&
%
(
#
"(6 #
#+ *
6 (
(6
+
"
#
& (
#
&
"
% (
%
8
+ (
( & +
+ #
+ $
=
&+
+ $
.
+
6 ;+
4%
4
"
(
+
&%
&
+
% ? *
+ "+
(
(6
.
+ + $
&
* %
+
6
(6 8
1( $+# % .
+
!
" #$%!
+&%
1( $+# % .
+ &' (& (
(& (
#))* (
#+))
5 ,
- !.
*
+
+
6
*
#
"
+&%
"8
1( $+# % .
+ #
/
- .
+
+
! "
!
! #
! ! " #
! $
% &
%! &
! #"
! "
' !
! #"'$ ! ! ! %! & $
( " !
! !
!$ ) $! *
!"' !!$ ! $
' !"'
+ !
! ! !
,
,-
.
+
-
/ !
')0' $
1 - 21
!" 3 /
/
!!
"
!
!$2 )4
/ 3 /
!!
5
!" ! "
' !
! "
$
#
" +!
!"'
5 !
!
" !
6
'
' !
$
' !
$
!
- 789 : !
;1 $
" / 1 - 2
!" ' ! #"
! "
'
!
< '$ !
!
=">!
?@/ @AB + !
$ !
$
$
! !
$!
!"
#
1 - 21
!" 0
! $
( #
"$"
! "
+
'
'
!"
$
'
!
" 5 #
5'
#
!$ ' $ ! + ! !' $
?
$ '
$! #
!!
$ ! ! !' !
!(
" ! ' ' ! !
"!(
5 7 *
# & # "
+&%
#
&' (& (
(& (
#))* (
#+))
, - .
+
+ ) 1 $
' $ ! !
<
' ! "
! ! !"
+ ! !1
!
!!
'
!!"
+ ! ! #
+
$ !!
!
$
! " "
! "
!"
' $
! "'!!
! "'
' $
7
' "
!"
!"
C < ' ! "
' ! " !"
' !!$ !
!
+
$
+ "
! "
1
' !
0 !
!
D D
!
$ !
!
' #
D
D
$
1 >< !
' / !
!
!"
$
!"
/ $
$
$
'
!
!!"' ! "
' $ ' !
#
! ! " #
$
!
"!
! "
" ! ! E
!"!" !$!$ =" >!
6
!!"! " (
!"
1 +
1 '$
' !"
! ! ! " !!$
! "
! "
: ! ! !
!$ !
! !
5 / = "
"
+%
+
(
"
##
%
" (
+ $
& " : .
;+
6 #
#
8
1( '+
= @ % '+& .
+
"8 +
9,7 $
A2 !.
+ 8 6 ( /5-7??2?? B%%% /-5C&%
%
% $ (
+ #+ (
#
+(
%#
+
+ &$
2
## (
(
% #
( "4
%%+ (6
(
2 @
( #
(
@ + $ + (
%
9
(
;+
%#
#
&
# % % #
( + $
2/
5 ;+
&
#6 " (
1( '+
= @ % '+& .
+ %&'
'
544
$ D
&E
F
E
D
(
F
E