← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4075/2014allowed

Gurpyari Singh & ORS v. Kamaldeep Singh

2016-09-29Mr. Justice Arun Monga10 pages

 

       

        

 !!  

"" #   $%"  !"

        &  '

 (")* !

"" '

!+,!(")*   ----  

.!

""/01

/0 * !2  %    ,!"( 

)(! ,! +

""( "%1    

   

            

     

    

   

    !

"

# $ 

 %    

 

& '!(

   !

)  !

*    +  !

  , %

  -  !

    !

    "# 

 "    #  %





%  

  

 

& '

   !

)  !

  

  +  !

 %  ,-

.

  -  !

(   /    !

   "

# *   %

%  0 %  

 

& '*

   !

)  !

&



    ,     +  !

    -  !

*     !



, '

 "#    "

  #      

    

  %     

 

& '

   !

)  !

%   (   +  !

-      -  !

&



      !

-      ( %  2 

 



 

  %   1     

0 

  

  0   

     %     

%  1   

& '( & '

 %   



    1

  (-

   

   .

     

    

 

 0    

0      '  

 

0

 1   



 

 

  

 



  1  

0%  

 



& '(& ' 

  



%



3 !,%,!"( 

))  %  ! "3

4   4)!, *  '

 (")"  "

  ,!"



""/01

/0 ,%! !

 !" %! 5 !6""  77  !!! !



%! ! !" ! !! 

%!2

 

!!)

!, !  !6"",%( 2



8 "! ! % 

!, ,8 !! %" & %!  !.!!

, ! 

% !!   , "

(9"! !"

!  ! 

:* ( ! ,2!

) ! 

: ,%! "

3

!, ! " % *)% !") 5% " ) ! ! %! 5  !6"", "( 

% %  !    ! 6"") % !  ")  " )  !"  !  6"" ( % !""    ;  )  !  "(  

""  3

  % % "","* 

* <  (""!

* 3 3*"& 



 !

 

%)! ! (! !3

!( %8   ! % 6"":

!  ,%!% % ,

*, " ! %(!!  * )!

)  %  !"( 

 ,"!

  "(",", :

!  ,%!"( 

!"1  !

""! !! = & %!  !(   % "  :   ,%  !  !   (       !  "(



* !  )! "!"(



  * & 3 )'

!+,!(")"  "

  ,!"

   1  ,%!( %

*"% !6"".!    ,!"(



)" "2  < 

!

 ! !%

* 4/0 !; 7 !;>*:*  ")

 " "    *(       )   !"  )  "(  

""  3

  !6"":

!  ,%!6"" !""

!!

  !( "!*94  !  & % !  !( "!*! 8 94 !  ! ! >*!

( "% " )! )    ! ,(9%,")!

)

!3

 

 % !    !""  :

!  ,%!% 5!,  %  (!

 ;

 !)! "

!  %  ,:?,"

%3

 

.

 

 4

 0

 5675(/$"*#589: ;!*! "  " 

!

,+ !*(!!  % ! ,%

 '

 (") )2  %  !"( 

 ",", ""(   =( 

! %,"* 

* <   " 3 3*"& 

)(!! !

1 5;

  "5#/   %

  

  %

 0 

0



0   "<#&   

   % 

%        %       

         

 "=#)

    0

!

0

0     .



  ">#/ 

%'  "

# 

 "#  % ":#(  

  *   

  

 % 





0



    <  ?

  

 

   

@ 

 % 

 

  %



1



 





    %   

 





 "9#-    A  * 

  %

  

   

  '

  

3 <   "4 3 3*"& 

) !

1 @ 

 

    

0  

           

0      % 

 B

 "

#       0

 0

 



       0

  

C "#       

  

%      1

  C "

#



 

0 

03 ;  ,

%(!   *  <12   ! % ,1 "<  ) *!  ,

%(! "  *  !(* )  !

! ( %)! *  "* % !6""& !  !( %) (! !6""!,%) !

1 <   0

-<  

             

    +   D>D8568D    



     A    1    

 

1 $<:DDDE!     



  1 

%  1

0

  1       

  

 1 558568D% 0   0)2

1 &  

  / %           <D0

 (   

       0

566=3 ! !  ! !,)!!

! !  !( !

* 77      % 

) 91.! ! % "  ! , ,,!!3

,"(!

*% 

"8 !% ! 8     .!8 , !3

 !*( !% !6"")3! , (!

 

* !6"")( @AB;%*()! ( ! 3

,"(

%!  6""(!%(%; ""(!%! ,

*>*!2  % %

* <    " %," (% ! !6"")6""  !  & %!  !( "! 94  !   

!

%! ( " !

  !

( " ! 8 "! .!   !"(

! !,

%( %! ,)"" ""  * .!  "* %   !  (   %      !  "    !  6""  .!  "(

, "3

  "(2

! ," 

*  3 3*"& 

 "(!*   " % *)% !")

" ;%*(5  

%   ("".!

 !% " 

* 4/0 ;  7 !>*( """,   .! !   !%  !<  )! "%    ,8 !

* <   )(!!

"(!!%" ! %= "

! (%!

! %

*  

"

!

  ! "))! ( ","" *)(!   * ;! ( )*

8  ,"!% %""! %*( !*,+ 6""( ,%,( !

* !



  " ! 15%)! ,2 (!   

*  6"")% !")%;""(! (!! " ! %)%,%) !

)!  ! ,% '

,!(")8 

* 

!%  ,)!3

) " !,

% !  ,"8  "((!" !

", *( !

 "" , *" C   !:?,"

% 3

    

  ! 

 "#$%&'(!&$&)(! !

 (!!  *(

*  /03&3)

*  ! & 2,3

)7( "

" !

"( ", "

   3 3*"& 

)! 

%!  ,"8  "( .!3 "D! :?,"

%3

!"!! * *   +  (   

  $%%&, (!!$'$ 

","  /0 3&3

"())!

*  !& 2,3

)7!,   ,+ E !+ , *)! "*  !2  %

*" C   !:?,"

%3

&+2+!? /

0 !

1 



 >5  .

( 

0  %

  %1F

 5DD 

 % 

 

%        %

0 ;



  *  

 +-."#&/0123 &041% &56 7

 



 1  GH 

<7I<6@3 <7)1

 

(  <:> * 

%  

0 0*    

  

 >5  .

* ( 56581   10  

           %   0   J       *  /   

    

  /      %   0    1

J    

 8D( K1

/ 

( 565:%  %%     % 



 /    0  

 K1

/  ( 56=:0

 <6<

/

    *  / 

 

0 (  =6:

 K1

/  ( 56=:   .

* ( %     % 

     0    /     0     

 *  /  01   (  =7<"5# *  /   

 (  <:> *  /  %



    %  

   

 % 0 J     

2  % 01  (  =7< *   /  /  (  =7<"5# 

 %

0   %%   

  



 

0

J    

   0  +  

0        



 67"5# * *1 

 "(

# ( 5679  



 

 >5  .

*   (     % 

 0      %  



3 .! );

%! ,"8 

  "(  (!"    !  

")   %  E  !   %)!    ,!=( 

  .!  

""1

 .!2  % 

! "3

    "")! " 

"""( !"! "#$  

%

  %&'%& ()& *+,-.

& (/,&01 &(./ %&'%& &)/ '

&1 &(./