High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1245/2017dismissed

Iqbal Kaur v. Dhian Singh (Deceased) Th Lrs

2018-08-14Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan4 pages

!"#!$%&%"'()*)* +,-./0 11!--'

2!0&/& 3%'%'43 5!$!&!5 30"/436)

!&1"'5!'

0!&!' (

0)))%--758"$ !#"0 3!11!--' ) : '8%!;"# 3!8!0<!' &<5!%' 3!11-%$ %"'7 3!5!-="# 5=& 3 3&"$$/00!5%'0!#%-%'4 3!10!&!' 11!-7%&$"'5"'!5) 11-%$ %"'%&5%&1"&!5"#) :: 3%& %& ' 11-%$ %"' #"0 ,0%'4%'4 "' 0!$"05 3! 6) & "# 0!&1"'5!' 3%'%'437;3"3&&%'$!5%!5) '8%!;"# 3!8!0<!' &<5!%' 3!11-%$ %"'7;3%$3%&5/-= &/11"0 !5,='##%58% "# 3!11!--' 7&<!%&--";!5&/,>!$ "-->/& !?$!1 %"'&)3!-!4-0!10!&!' %8!75! %-&"#;3"<38!,!!'#/0'%&3!5 %'10"# 3!11-%$ %"'%&5%0!$ !5 ",!%<1-!5!5&10 =@0!&1"'5!' %' 3!<%'11!-) 11-%$ %"'%&5%&1"&!5"#)

%'11!-

-%' %##%&%'&!$"'511!-,!#"0! 3%&"/0 38%'40!<%'!5 /'&/$$!&&#/-%'," 3 3!$"/0 &,!-";) 0%!# #$ & 0! 3 3!1-%' %###%-!5 &/% #"01!0<'!' %'>/'$ %"'0!& 0%'%'45!#!'5' 3%'%'43#0"<%' !0#!0%'4%''=

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

&/% 10"1!0 =) %&04/!5 3 /'5!0&/$3$%0$/<& '$!& 3!$"/0 &,!-";38!!00!5%'5!'=%'4%'#8"/0"# 3!1-%' %##11!

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

-/$A= D3! 3!0&1!A%'4@0!&"'!5( !&@"

D3! 3!0 !1"0 ,-!( !&@"