← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4133/2014dismissed

Sukhdev Singh v. Suresh Kumar & ANR

2015-09-23Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih4 pages

       

!"# $#%&'&()

 *

+ ,-.$#/&(0. 122#33!(" 4#5',' ,5#'.6,7!5!($!(".#5 1#'2($#("' ) 8 9  99

5#'#(") 5 !05!7&(0.(#5:$/%!"#

5".#!22#33!(" ;;;  <.#".#5 5#25"#5'   3%!3 2!2#5' 7!= ># !33?#$ " '##".#@,$07#("A

 >#5# #55#$"".#5#25"#5'5("A

 <.#".#5 ".# @,$07#(" '.,3$ ># 5#25"#$ &( ".# $&0#'"A ;;;  99 5!3 ,&" &3#$>=".#23!&("&

?!'$&'7&''#$>=".#"5&!3 %,5"/&$#@,$07#("!($$#%5##$!"#$  

'#/#(".# !22#!3 25# #55#$ !0!&('" ".# '!&$ $#%5## !&3#$ !($ ?!' $&'7&''#$ /&$# @,$07#(" $!"#$  

: ".# 23!&("&

 &' ># 5#".&'%,5"&(".&'5#0,3!5'#%($!22#!3 !5"&#'"".# 3&':.#5#&(!

"#5:?,3$>#5# #55#$">=".#&55&0&(!32'&"&(' &(".#',&" (!',&" &3#$>=".#23!&("&

:.#25!=#$ 5!$#%5##

5 &(@,(%"&(: 5#'"5!&(&(0 ".# $# #($!("' 57 &("#5 #5&(0 &( ".#2''#''&( ".#23!&("&

/#5".#',&"252#5"=".!"&'!

!5!: '.?( &( 05##( %3,5 &( ".# '&"# 23!( !22#($#$ ?&". ".#23!&("!($7!5-#$>=3#""#5' "?!'7!&("!&(#$".!"

  ".# ',&" 252#5"= ?!' '&",!"#$ ?&".&( ".# !>!$& $#.   ".# /&33!0#!($".#23!&("&

.!'>##(,'&(0".#'!7# 5".#3!'" 75#".!(+ =#!5' 3!&("&

.!$%('"5,%"#$!>,($!5=?!33   !>," 8 B 8 ( "? '&$#'   ".# ',&" 252#5"= !($ !' $# #($!("' ".5#!"#(#$ " $&'2''#'' ".# 23!&("&

5%&>3=: ".,':".#',&" ( $# #(%#: &" ?!' 23#!$#$: &("#5 !3&!: ".!" 23!&("&

.!$(5&0.":"&"3#5&("#5#'"&( !5! '.?(&(".#'&"# 23!(: !' ".# '!7# #B%3,'&/#3= >#3(0' " ,5#'. 6,7!5 $# #($!("   # #($!("   !3' .!$ "? 23"' &( ".# !>!$& $#.: !' $#2&%"#$ &( ".# '&"# 23!( 3!&("&

 !($ .&' >5".#5 !& 6&'.!( ?#5# &( %%,2!"&(   ".#&5 5#'2#%"&/# 25"&('&(".#!>!$&$#.:!''.?(&(=#33?%3,5&(".#'&"# 23!(.,':".#5#?!'(C,#'"&( 23!&("&

>#&(0".#?(#5 &(2''#''&( ".# !5!  (!$,#!($%725#.#('&/#%('&$#5!"&( ".#7!""#5 &( &'',#: >". ".# %,5"' >#3? %(%,55#("3= 5#%5$#$ ".!" 23!&("&

!&3#$ " 25/# ".# &$#("&"=   ".# 252#5"=: !' !$7&""#$3=".#5#?!'(5#%5$&(5#0!5$"".#?(#5'.&2 ".#',&"252#5"=?&".&(".#!>!$&$#. ".#/&33!0# 3!&("&

,-.$#/&(0.%(%#$#$&(.&'%5''#B!7&(!"&(".!".#$&$ ("-(?!>,"".#3#(0".!($?&$". ".#!5#!&(C,#'"&( !".#5:.#!$7&""#$".!".#.!$!(".#5 !5!:>,".#$&$(" -(?".#(,7>#5 ".#'!&$252#5"=.,0.:.#%3!&7#$" .!/#5!&'#$%('"5,%"&((".#"?'&$#' ".#252#5"=:>,"

  %(%#$#$".!".#$&$("-(?!'"?.#(".#>,($!5=?!33' ?#5#5!&'#$("?'&$#' ".# !5!.#23#! ".#23!&("&

".!".#.!$%('"5,%"#$!>,($!5=?!337#!',5&(08B 8( ".# "? '&$#'   ".# 252#5"= ?!' !3' >#3&#$ >= ".# 5#25"

,5(&'.#$ >= ".# 9%!3 77&''&(#5  7,%. ': ".# '&"# 23!(5#3&#$,2(>=".#23!&("&

5#7!&(#$,(25/#$(5#%5$ !'(#&".#5".#7#!',5#7#(" ".#',&"252#5"=?!'$#2&%"#$ ".#5#&((5'-#"%.7!2?!'$5!?("'%!3#$5! "'7!(?!' #B!7&(#$ #&".#5 " 25/# ".# '!&$ 23!(  .!/# ! %3#!5 !($ %55#%"2#5'2#%"&/# ".#'&",!"&(:!($"#3!>5!"#,2(".# 2'&"&( ( ".# '2": ! 9%!3 77&''&(#5 ?!' !3' !22&("#$:>,"=#"".#5#?!'!7>&0,&"=!'5#0!5$'".#&$#("&"=  ".#252#5"=/&'D/&'".#'"!($'#",">=".#23!&("&

.# "#'"&7(= !&2!3 < %,3$!3'(">#5#3&#$,2(!'.# %(%#$#$&(.&'%5''#B!7&(!"&(".!".#.!$$#2'#$!"".# &('"!(%#   ".# 23!&("&

 !($ ?!' (" #/#( !?!5#   ".# %("#("'   .&' !

&$!/&" B < E  .!" >#&(0 ': &" ?!' %(%3,$#$".!"".#$&'2,"#>#&(0!'5#0!5$'".#&77/#!>3# 252#5"=: 25/&'&('   5$#5 F ,3#    ".# $#   &/&3

5%#$,5#: 5#C,&5#$ 5#C,&'&"# $#"!&3' ' !' " &$#("& = ".# 252#5"=('.5":23!&("&

%723#"#3= !&3#$"25/#.&'%3!&7 .,': ".# (3= 5 ".# &(#/&"!>3# %(%3,'&( ".!" %,3$ ># 5#!%.#$?!'".!"',&"?!'3&!>3#">#$&'7&''#$ 9#!5(#$ %,('#3 5 ".# !22#33!(" %,3$ (" 2&(" ," !' " .? ".# %(%3,'&(': ".!" .!/# %(%,55#("3= >##(

 5#%5$#$>=>".".#%,5"'>#3?:?#5##&".#5%("5!5="".# 2'&"&((5#%5$5',

#5#$ 57!(=7!"#5&!3&33#0!3&"= (".#?!-# ".#2'&"&(!''#","!>/#:".#5# .!5$3= #B&'"' !(= 05,($: 3#!'" 23!,'&>3# &( 3!?: " &("#5 #5# ?&".".#$#%5##>#&(0!''!&3#$C,#'"&( 3!?:7,%.3#'' !(= ',>'"!("&!3 C,#'"&(   3!?: !5&'#' 5 %('&$#5!"&( 22#!3>#&(0$#/&$ 7#5&"&'!%%5$&(03=$&'7&''#$ #2"#7>#5

:

+ !@!( 5,( !33&  ,$0#