High Court of Punjab and HaryanaTA/935/2016allowed

Apurva v. Navtej Singh

2017-02-16Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi12 pages

! "!#$%$&'

(

)'

*+)),)+-

),)+-.

/012

!"#"

$%

& '

'( )

$* + ,

&'

' (

- #-

#

.

#

/ !

0#

#

# )

"

.

"

! "

0! ! .

#

#"! #

1 "

23*$425

6$3$ 745$42*

#

! # "

.

! !

$*

.

/ ! !

"

0#

0! 6

8

#

$%

/

#

)

!

!9

)

#

!

" )

+ "

# '

#

! ) !" #

6 # ) !"

#

'!

#

0

!"# $% &' ( ) *

+

! ,- .(% / *.($+++ +

0# ! & *.& $++$

, " 0*1. /.&. $++, +

$#+ "2 3

)&4

1/ 533 $++

,

( .6 ( $++

, ! #.&( .&4.&( &6 *. 2 7&68& $++# ,,,

-% 19 * $+0 , :"# + $+ $ ):,! $+,: . "0 $9; .&$++

/ $#" , & $+ " / $ !.% /4..&4. )' *$+$ # / #! 6

! !" '!

03405&$5657&(

#

!

" #

0 :

!

"

"

#

$

%

& '(

!"

#

"

!

.

#

" /

! ; )

)8!9:*%#%!

/%3;02 !

#

# # !" '! #

# 0 <

$%

# 0&% !0 #

#

6

!0

&2(&!(

$% #

=

$% + # #

# &2(>

"

!

#

#

-

" " 0 &(888888888 &!( #

# "

" !

0 & ( " ? &

( " !

" ? &

(

#

##

# = @6

# . #

#

"

"6#

-

A

6 " 8

# 6

#

!

" 6

2*@B$44@

" 1 " .

" / # 1 "

.

"

6 9 #

$%

!

#

#

"

"

#

6

6

#

6

9 #

#

"'

$%&2(

24/ #

$% ! )

"

!

#

"'

!

"

/ " #

# )

!

-

A -

A -

;

#

"'

$%&2(

"

"

/ 5 % &" & :!0 < 4$4 11:. 11:4" (=. - .

!

"

!

"

6

# !" - .

25%2@72 # !"!9

-$%:0!+1<19$%:&. 11:4"

>" . A

#

#

#

"'

$%

" "

"

6

!

!

" #!"

/ !

! # !

#

" "

)

!" /

! 8

$0+1 &$< -1$& :. 3;0!5!30 .#

=/ #

!

!

" 6

"

"

#

)

)

>

!

!# = 6

8 #

"

"

221 .

)":<& &&$<)7;&"$"0. ()"0% .#

9 / ! =8

#

"

$%&2(&!( &

(

"

!

9

!

#

6

8

!

# "

#

!

)

"

8

# ! ! 8

" !

! ! #

" !

/

#

"

!

!

# -

$%

8

" #

"

#

!

#)

/ !

" #

" #

# #

8

,

" #

! ! A, #

$%

!"

-

#

"

!

#

&C !" ( 2$ - .

)>% )1$05 !5$#:&" $& < ?% :& $&&#$1 0;0 $&&"& :!0. (@?% :&

@ #

# )

!"

#

#

'

$% !

#

#"

" !

)

6 -

A

-

A -

#

#

8

# "# "

27/ )310? %:$<&A":0$&A:&$. =

0$%% . >

#

"'

$%

"

2%/ ! #

"'

$%&2(

6

-

A

#

!

0

#

"

/

! !"

)

2*@B$44@

1 "

" 1

1 "

A . 2* 6

8

#

$%

/

#

)

!

!9

)

#

! "

)

+ "

# '

#

! ) #

1 # #

#

9

# #

! " ! !" A

"

&5 &"-$%:0$<:$<;09%:. -0& 9=(B35$ $&A:<-350&?7

& :!0.

3;0!5! 30 5 60& 30$ 8% 0$ 8$&79 3?0. +

( -0& 9@ 2

; - ;

67*%$42* $27$425 -

6$%@$425 *%$425 !"

! !

#

! ! "

!

!

/

#

! 8

! "

"

#

)

#

!" '!

"53%3&"0&"& :!08% ! 5$1"3&" :!0%.

/2 .&$& &"$8%50$ +1)&#:&"&" :!0%.

@/2( . ! 0$%%8%)"11$7%.

/ 2 ( ! ?% :&8&!%:$+1.

=/ 2

"

#

# # !" '! #

"

0#

$*

.

!

#

"

0! /

#

" ! !

! 6 )

!

! # #

# !

#

#

# ! 8

$*

.

#

! #

#

!

!" #

$*

!"

! !

.

"

-

A

!0

-

A

.

" !

" #

" 6 -

A .

"

#

# ,

!0 !

# #

25$$423 /),)+-2 ; , )

B DB , ! DB