High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/1402/2023disposed of

Vice Marshal Tajinder Pal Singh Chhatwal v. Ashok Wig

2025-11-12Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel3 pages

!"#$%$ &' ((

)

' *+(,, +

!"# $%& '(

!"# )

!"# *"& ++,, ----- , + -(

/ .

&'/ %!+ () %&+ , &'

! "#$!

% & ! ' (")

(* + ),

- ./$ )0 1 !

23 45!2 ")

2 ! /6

! 7,8

4 / 6

3 29 ," $%& %"*" "*, !& ,"

/+* ' #%"012345.610 7 & !& , #"',*"& ++,, & !+' &+ +8/""9 0 :*"+"# % " #% & %"3*" "*+#% , !" ,5 ,%$"', / ++"%"*&%" ;'

) + /( &% "' % %,

$&%&%"'$&%,,(% '+"&

%# "*& "</, '+)"'% ! "! #!

$ % & #

'()

*+, *!! -& &, & ,

% " "* #='% ,% +"# % ' #%" .02 "* & "% /, ') # .22. +* /( & #")+, % * ,,='

,($%&%&+'!%$"*+"!%"" #%"017"* 4.0"*: 7>70 &%;' %#% ,'#% %"$ + %# '+" &%+ %!' % & *"&+'+""* #")+, %' #%".02"*& "% /,')#.22.&#")+, % % #")+ $%&%&?+ %! *%%%""*@3< ,% %& .610: 7>70 "=',( & #")+, % % " #" % "+''&)"% +"# '"*9% +#% ,, ! " ,' #%"012345"*.6104.6345"*: 7>70

&%"'' #" & &#"+ )/%"*+"!%"" #%"017 4.0: %&,(/"

)" ##"))"

% $& ;'? +" $%&&#")+ %!,( "$#"*%"* #%"012345"* .6104.6345"*: 7>70$&%#&) &+"#')"* +#% ,, !*")& % &"'*" ,

% #='% ,%

#")+, %#

"$! )" % +"*"' #"))%) " & "! #&% +%#%+, "* ;'%# )% %" " +#,' ) +"# ' ,#&%# ,%%*")#,%+% &'/ %! ;' %# %""*& # &%"'% "*')) %,( %)%% & ,"&%#&%# %*%)%(;' %#%"',("+ ",

& ," $%& ##")+ (%

%"35"&#"# %""' 4 : !

;%!%$"*& %# "*& "</, '+)"'% ! "! #!

3'+ 5 ,"&+""'#)"*&%"'%

3'+ 5A&+ ," $%& ##")+ (% %"35 % %+" "* &'

3%5

&+ ," $%& ##")+ (% %"35% )% "&, %" '

)$%& %#%"" & ) & !% /*%, ' #%"017"*.610 #%" 4.0"*: 7>70 & % , %" '

) ('& "&%),*" % %" "&"'"*#")+;'% %#%"*"% %+" +, $ 3%%5 ,"#, %*(& &%"'& " ,! %"&)% "*& , ," ," $%& ##")+ (% %"35A & ) %,*"+*"#"% %""*&#"# , %""'$&%#& & ,,% '/% /,( ;' %# & )$%&"' % %*,'# /( ( "/!

%") &% /"! 3%%%5

& %(% %# " ?+ %%"',(&#")+,#" "*&+ ,3%#,' % &+ +8/""95"& % , %"

3%!5 %#& ++,, 8 % "/ /"'11( "*

%% ?+# & &#"# , %""'& ,, #% &) %

,?+ %%"',( , + ((

) 0 &&+ 9% "

&&+" /,