← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1355/2017allowed

Punjab State Power Corporation And ORS v. Kulbir Kumar

2023-03-13Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi11 pages

     !"#$ #  

# %&'(#&) * '

+,, - .

/% %& '0&1'12'1 % '

'%3&1* ,,,22&44

%* 5&1*-* 6-4/ 16-7 ,,,&*2'

& %  

 

    

  

 



 

 



   !

"#$%&""%$%%    !"

#  $

%&& '() *    "

+"

 

   *  

 , #  $

%&& '() -

 "

*

"'&(("%$') "

      ""

,   '

() '(0 ,       '% ( '(1   

'

""

  "

   (2 (0 '(()  "           

3  

    * 

4 ,-"

 5 

   

* 

) (% '((1

* -  - *   

)(0%  '1 (& '((1

 /  

   " 



 (1 (0 '((1

"  *  (2 (0 '((1



* * 

6  ,   * ,  "

 '((1

 / - 

8 * "  

9 * /  (:

() '((1     * "   (1 (0 '((1

 *  "   /"



< "

* * " "    "



(1 ( '((&  " ,

/ -  

      * "

"

2 (& '((& "

" 

$ *  

;

" 

,    

  ,*

   "

* "  " !  8;

= 

%

  

   , ""

  "

  ,

<       3  / - 

+"

 " " "       (2 (0 '(()  "





 " "



+"

      "

           

 *

  ,*    -  ,    * * !      * ,  * "   , * "  

"    '% ( '(1    ,  ,     '

() '(0      '% ( '(1 ,  "          * "  8;

=  "  

, "

 ,   "

 



  "

    " " ,   '

() '(0 "      ,     ,        "

    " 

 "        " " "

 "  *

5    

  "      "

    

     "

 "

 , "

"

  ,  ,"

            (2 (0 '(() *  "

>       "  "  ,    

* ;

 ,    3 "

   ,  

   "  *   ;

" " "

, *  "

& * '((1 , * '((& ;

     * /     

  

5     3     ,

?

 *   "

 

* '((1 

 /  * '((1 

* * "  "

"

+"

   "

"     !

    "

" 8;

=  

   

"    

  , / -    

"  /    8;

= , *    

> *  " 

 ! " "     

 , ,

> 

   *    ,    "   *  ! " " "   

 

;

 * , @ 

 3 >

5 A3B $

'1''( '1'' '(()  *+,  

,

*

-   

- - .

/ 

(0 (:

'(% , @ 

 3 > ,   * *   *      "           " *  ,   

 *

 " :



  

    

   

                          

         

             

           

                                      

      

 

  

  

    ?

 @ 

 3 > ,   "

   *     

>  

    ,   * * '((1  " "



* '((&      *

> *     

 C /  , *      

8   , "  * / * "  * 

>  

 -"



)  ,  @ 

 3 > *+,  

,  0

12!/         "

  

?

   * "       *      !  ,   

  "

"

> 

   *   *  /  "

+"

  ,  @ 

 3 > 3  $

1'0% :::

 ,-0

3

*



   0

,/ ,-0

3  44 .0 . - .

/  '& (1 '((( 3     ,  -  "

* , *     "   * / "  , / 

 " 1 2



 !       "

 # "

 $   %  #  & 

  

  '     



 "     (        

    # "



  

     )(           # "

    '      

  '         

* +     # " 



  '         

    

# " ,-     

   

  

   



  

./   01 2

"   

 "                 3142     3  1)2

    

     

      

   

  

 

    

 

     5

       $   % 

#   & 

   6   

  

 

  

/ # " 

   

   

  

  "         7



7    

 

7  

  7'     

   



        /            

        

   '         # "     +   

   /              

   

'             

  "      

  7



7 

    

 # "    '    8  / 

    '        

 # "/      

  / 9  

:$          

   $

       

'   

     

       

 # "  $   % 

#  & 

         

  

 : 

  



 /    

              

        

    # " %   

  

 

     

  /       

       0 1 2 

      3  12  

 



 



  

:



         



                    

    

     



 + 

        

/



3/ 

 

 



 

  

 3  /         

   

 3 / 

 



  

  

   3 

  

  



  

      

   /     + 

      

     

  ;# "  



 

   $   % 

#   & 

        

    '           

     # "9



        # "

   

   

   

  

   '     

 +   

   

 # "

   

  



 # "- 

"

  

       

     

  



 

    /  

 

   '       

 

  



 +            )(      



$   %  #  & 

  </  

   

      /     :$    

         # " 

$ 

'        

  # " 

  

      / 

    

'       # "   

   

       

    



:$"  /    

( /    '       

  

    :  $        + 

     

 

44%  $  



 5   "

   

 

>  

  ,   

      "

* * "

,    ,  *

?

     -"

"   ,   ,    /  "

"

     

@ 

 3 > 3  $

':2'

:2:

 . .4 - - .



*

+  /  ) (% ::%    

      !

+"

   * ,   "          *   ,       

+"

  ,   '

() '(0     '% ( '(1       

 "*  ,

<   "*

"&%'(""%$') 

  ,   

 1)38    "  

!

#

6   "= 

08 =- 6    

08 =-