Jaspal Singh v. Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd & ANR

 
 
  


  !

"#$ %$&'(')* + 

"(,"-')./ ,,$--")# 0(

"1(/')"23")"'4-'0'#2")'."56'5'#$%")%")#/$2 
$(,)%$)#( 
 * 76

 8
 69
 

         


    

 8
 69: 
6!

  !

 "



"

  "   #

 % # & &#$  $ 

'   !



 

%    "

"

  (! !) *)!+



  !'



  ,"   "

"

  )- ). *)!/  "

"

 

% 0  



 

 %

*  "

"

  !'



 "

 '    1'

2!3)**'
 

   !

"



 44

 

"  "

 5

  

6 *2 ). *))+ $    !

4 "

 

   " &

 

 4"

 

&"

"

'



                

      

                       

   

        

 

 

8  "



4"







   " & "

# 4"

$

&

 " 5  #  4"









 "

  !/))))3'

8  "

    !(+

!+* $  &

    ! #   $ 

    !

4

# 

$

"

&  "  8  #   *

  " 

" 

#

  !

7

 :

"

$ # 

 "



  $ #   *

  #

# 4

$



 "

8 

     

$

 
 "3   22//./3'  $ 

    !

 8 

   !



 

 #  %  



;  &

  *2 )* *))/ #

 # 

    !/ )/ *)!!

5   &

4 

"

4

# 

 # 



  &

    !



  "

&  "

 

 $ #    *   

 &  6 



"



 

%   

&"

 '

!

<

   $



$ 

= 6

*

< 

    #

 = 6
(

<

 



 



  = 6

<

   # = 6

+



8 

     4 

" #

 #"    $

&



  "

 



""

"  #" 

'   !  $ 

 

%    "

"

  (! !) *)!+ ; "

""   !

  

& 

 

 %   "

"

  )- ). *)!/ 7  "



 

;   !

7 

 

8 

    > 

'%   

  *  $



   " 8

    '



  #

'%    

 $  ( 07
!+ 07
 & & &

$

 



 5

   

 "

9"

 9:
+
"



: 

  9:
+ %4"

 9:
!

 9:
*    !(+ $  &  

"

8"

$  " # 





'%   7& 



 #  %  



; 

,

"  70 ?

  
54    :



'%  

<( &    "

&

$  

# % ; 5 &

  9:
- 9:
!! & # "   "

&

$  

  4"

  @  $ 

$

'%  





  A%B  " 

 &

 %

  "

"

$ &

 $ #  7  

#"

        

  

+ " "

   %    

 % # & & &

& 

 &

"

 "

"



  # % 

  #  



 #



  4"



"

  "

% ;8

 ((/  !. !* *))+  # "

"

 

7&    " 

"

 & ;8

"  )* )C *))- 

"

"



#  ;8

& 

 "      !- )- *))- 

 #" 

'%     #"



"    "

 

 4"   $  "

"

1"



#>  

"  4 &   



 

"

8 



 

$

  &4 &  5   >

  "

  *) $  8

  &

   

 7 # "

# "

 



 44B "

$ "   >

# "

    7& & "

&"



  ""

"

  "

   #  & &  $ 

#  



 D    

    #  $  



% # &   

& &

"

    "

"



  #   

 

" 

 

9'2")')./")%#/$2(0(/"5")"(<")")%#/$2(:=+; 
 ! ;

:"%/>")%#/$2(0(".%'(/
"5:== !'?=+:

#"#$ >42"#0(
"4$(/9>5"2/'5")-"-"2#")%")#/$2:== 

!

;:
"4"(#/")#"#$-$&#2'&'#3"2%0( "-',')./")%")#/$2:

!
68 @=:>)4"A#"#$-$&#2'&'#3"2%0((/<")'9>5"2: == !

 '?'-!;:"2(/"%/'5")6"- %'0( 6)'?$2("- ")%")#/$2:

+ ;!

 '?'-!

:/$B$&>#'?$).')$$2:96 < :'%"20((/<"2"55"")%")#/$2:

! ;

:

/"2"#")&/"2'."56#%0("<")9>5"2>,#":

 ;!


'?'-! :>,$2')#$)%').).')$$20'2>%/>)"."2-$&#2'&'#3 '(#2'A>#') '2&-$"5'-"%/>-$&#2'&'#3"2%0( >2"-'
"4":

@ ;!'? :(('(#")#).')$$2:&C>'('#'):"5'-"%>-$&#2'&'#3"2%")% #/$2(0("(1"2"):

@ +! :
"4%/")'<$26#%0( (/19>5"2:

@ !  :0:")',"#")%#/$2(0(0')% 9>5"2:

= ;!

 '?'-!==: >2/"5"2$-')$)%'")?#6#%0( #>%'6')$")%#/$2(:

@!

 '?'-!@:
"5"9",'-"0(#"#$ >)4"A:

;!

 2-! ;:9",>20(/$/"'25")")% #/$2(:

 

! ;  "2'/")%0( "1(/')"23")"'4-'0'#2") '."56#%")%")#/$2:

+ !

 '?'-!+@      

# #  

 &  7& 





"   # 

$



 #"

" # 

8  

 

 

   

# :

 

   #

$"

$  

" 

    



    4 & 

7E#   % "%5">(>)%2"
"")%")#/$20(#"#$

"5'-"%>")%#/$2(:

!+ :)') )%'"0(52'#6"- ")&/")%"")%#/$2(:

; !+:#"#$ 2'(("0( %--'3"(:

! + #"#$ 
"4"(#/")0(")$(/'6"-:

@

! +

<

&

 

 4 #$ #   7F#   %

!!

!* 



" ")$(/'6"-F  A B  "

  & 4 52'#6"- ")&/")%"F  A

/%--'3"(F  A B & # "



$ 

&

 

'

   !"

                 

      

  #    $      %     

     '  

    (      

 ' )      

 

  

              #  *       

 

 +, -        #

@

       

 '          



 +  ,

-       





         

+,

-(          

 & #       .

          &    

                &    &   (       



    / 



   ,0

10 2 &0  3 2,#%"4560/578-9 %  2&:

 :

2,445,5-0//77-# 

     ;

     '  

(    

   #<  %= &> ,4?- #/74@,A>- $A >/  &   (          

           &      &        ;

  

       ;

 

   &  

   

 

 ;

         / 

                    

        <  ># 

 

    &



=         &     <  >#

      ( 

  

  

  

     <  ># 

  (

  $0

0 2 B 3 %  , ??5-0// 8@  6    @!/                     

    2  &  / 

  $ )  

&     

 ;   &      ; 

 

 &

 ' / 

    

  &  

   (               ;

        '                (     +

 

  %>C& :/>B A,4@#/8D8 85- >3:

  & 1,#%% $" 7/*:-
   

     

 & .

 '       #    <      

        

   

  

    

   

           ( 
 5%A 2 &: E /,48?, -#$" 47-> "

 ,#$"  48* - 
># )

 

     %     

   
3  ' 0

A >B 0 ,F -,48-.>"?5   & 1,#%%$"  87*

-
2  

  & (  " >'   #<  
# A   &G " G,48 , -.>"@D8->3  1 ,#%%$" 85-
 

   

 (                    

                  (             
8/   ;

          

    :

          



 @  >:

    

 

 &   1,# H&/%

#%"45 0/56?

$  

    



      

                   

      &      ,  / - 

         



         

   

<     

(

    

                     

       3        

     (        



$0

9 % B # >3  , ??7-D0//8@

6D*67 @*6
%4"



  *2 ). *))+ %4"



  9:
!

 9:
* 

"



  " 

 #"



&

$   



 #  %  



; 

""

 9:
* 5 

 

$ 



%  



%  "

% ; 

 $  



  >





5 

'%   

  $ 5

 " # 

'%     "

"

  '

#

 % # & " $ 

#

$

 > 8  &  #

 % # &  #  

$



 "

  " 

 "

"

  #   

&

0

"



   

 % " $ :

 

    

&

 #"  

  5 

" "   ,"

!/ **  "

" &  #  

 '

%  

     ' 0       /   
'   B :AGBF> 
   *F  ;  0<   #&    <.D         A &0 

     ' 0   / A 

  $;<6   A   $;<4$;<     A &0  #    A &0     

   &' 0    

&  

#  

    

      

             

                   

    ' 0    

         

 



  

 $;<@G &     

 &   





     

  ' 0   

 A &0   

   

     

     0F       

   &  H  



&      0F 



      & 3      :

 F     

  /:   A &0 

  



  

       /:  %    &              

  

 A &0         

 '   0                               %   

              

         

 

      $;: I#

  

&

 ;                "

/    & 

           

      #

' 0       

     F      

    /   A &0              &                

        



   

  F     

;     

&     :

F F& 0  

       F #

&  0   6 % /#   

I  * ;      

   

 

   

                                                



   

      0      ;             

    

 

A <(         

         

         

         

 &  ;   



            "

 G  :

/           

        /       I  &       A 

                 J "

 "

 

 

$



"

$ 

$  "

"

+





 % # & ;   

$ >

& 

 # 

>

& &   >

  "

"



  % & :"





   !)) % %

 8  "

  #



 & 7E#   % "2"3")")
"4$)%2")")%")#/$20(6$1(/53 "24')'")%#/$2(:

= +! ;  

"  %"

 

   

# 

& 

  %   &

 "



 &

$  # 

&

$ #    

 "  #  

 $ &

#  #    "



  & &  

  D
 8
 69E *+ )C *)!C    < 4"3  G3  <  # G3