Karnail Singh v. Financial Commissioner, Revenue, Punjab And Others
!
"
#$
"%
& "
! !
"
!
! " # !
$% &
'''''
!
"
! $
'
( (
)* *) +*,- .% / 012
3
% " 4
5 0
5 +(
*6 *) +*,-( ( &
3!$ (
( (
&(
(&
(
( ( &
3!
5 )
( (
5 7
(
& (
*, *- +*,-.% / 082
(&
*- *- +*,-.% / 0-2
,7 *, +*,9 .% / 072
3
0
5 , (
&
+
"
&
&
&
& & *$,8
: (;
5 )88< 5 = "
0 ( (
(
>3! &? .
5 )2
&
(
/
5$ @
(
(
<
& (&A
,+ ,* +*,8 &
5$ @
(
>*- *, +*,-
5$ (
&&( (
(
&
<
(
,6 *+ +*,- )
" (
(
! $
&
0
3(
(
(
% 3(
0! & 3
% 3
(
3! 3
5 7(
&& ;&
B (
(
(
&
C %,997.& D
,997%E2
% " 4
3 &
0 (
(
3 !
0
!$
)* *) +*,-% /
( >
+) ,%
3
3(3& (
&
&& &
&&
& 0
B
"3&
&&
&
&&
" &
=
&
; = ! ! +*,-.12 :
79*
?
&
;
+*,6.+2 :
918 ;
)* *) +*,-.% / 012(
3 &
&
3
3 ( (
(
B 3
3& 0
*, *- +*,-.% / 82(
(&
*- *- +*,-.% / 0-2
& >
,7 *, +*,9 .% / 072
-
"
3
&
(
&
&
&
3
/ & 3 &
&
,997%
&
,997%( $
&
3 (
&(
>&& &
% <
4 ( /
(
,7&
,997% &
&
<
& (
,997%
&(
;(
(
& 3
3
,,7 &
,997 %
&
&
$
"
&
&
,997 % < / &(
&3
&
&
&
(
%
3
3 B
F .= 2
+**6.+2 .2 7,+(
&
&
( 3
&
( 3 3 (
&
,997% <
&
&
&
(
&&
&
,997% (
,*
3
B
(
#
$ 3
33 (
3 < &
&
(
& &
&
(
$ &
,,
"
&
3
(
,997% % 3
% (
&
3 &
&(
<
(
(
( (
&
&A
%
3
& (&A
3 &
&
% " 4
5 (
3
>
&
&A
&3&
/ ((
&$ @
(
%
3
3
,6 *+ +*,- ,+
& 3 &
+) *+ +*,- &(
(&
"
& &
3(
(
3!
5 -
3 & (
(&
(
( ( &
B & ( 3(
&
)
3 &
)* *) +*,-
(
&
&
(
(
$(
G &
<
3
3
(
(
$
(
(
&
&
&
&
(
!$ (
&
% "4
5
& (
( &
%
(
,) *) +*,-.% /
&
( 3
&
(( & &
,)
"
(
$ (
& $ @
( $ (
$ ( ( 3(
3
3!
3(
&
3
3!$
&
,1
(
3 &
= ! I . 2
I . 2(
&( (
(
(
&(
( 3&
&
,997%
,8
%
(
$
(
&(
(&
3 &
( J ,-
3
3 ?
:( <
% "" +**) .)2 .2,18(
0 D
!"#$ %& !
'(
) * ' '
(
( "
%
( +
*
,
- (' .
/
#
( 0 (
(
(
(
(
(
( + 1 23 1+456 ( * 7
4"5 (
(+45
( * 7
( (
* 7
4-5%
(
* 7
4.5 6
(+* 7
899 "! (+4-5
( * 7
(
(9 (
( ( * 7
* 7
4-5 ( ( (+ * 7
(
* 7
* 7
:
(+
( ( ( * 7
* 7
( 7
( %
(
( (
7 ( * 7
(
( (
"""99 "-:
(
;<
(
%
(
( * 7
(+45
(+4"5 (+457 (
(
%
;8 "- (
(2 ,7
" (&
&
(
&
&A
$ @
&
3(
( & 3&
,9
=?
&:
% 0""
+*,*.+2
.2)+8
(
&
30
(
(&
&A&
&
(
(
&
=?
&
&
(
&
3
&&&
&
(
(&
,6
(
(
& ,,9.12&
,997%:
% "
+*,+ .+2 .2)98
(
(
&
0 &
&
&(
(&
"(
&(
(&
&
0 &
3
>&& 3 &
" &
(
& $ $
$ @(
(
&
(
(
( 3 &&
&
0
" (&
&
(
+,-./-0#$ ' !
"
!( 1230.4
$ G
K G5
K G5