The Fazlika Co-Op Sugar Mill Ltd v. State Of Punjab And ORS
!"#"$%&%'() *" +%,- ."/ !%0"123 / %,,4%5%!"#6 +%,- 6%&!/%$! +%,- !*/23*%!&"'"/ , ' 3"/1*/% &7%/1%'3* 88..",, '! & 1! !" 2'9 7!*/23* %' '$% ,55%&&%'"/:$%&" '# : !%'
2'9 7%0%,1"$/"! /% !6* '#%3 /* '#!*"/& 8 "&.'#"'!& ( ;4
1<
4 ;4
1 1
< 4
!" # !$ %&'( '(&) 9 =<25 / %!! ,6 !
)( !* )
"" !" "#","$,!,",,,$,-,*$ $!$# $ . .## !$( +
( /0 ) 1 ""# !$ #
"" # !$ ) )2 3
45 %6 (+ 7 ( $. (&) ( 1# ,8 9 :+ , !!
# !, 1( )2 6
)((&)6 + 9 )(: #** # ,3 $ 2!***3# +0 +() ;( 03
< ( 1( !1( #1( +2( ) 0=
< ( )((&)6 + +2 ( + +> 0%0 ( 2 ( ?1 1 > ( )2 @(2?1 1 6 )20 + &(+
/A)6(0
( +) /A) (6(8 0 )+=
< ( )((&)6 + +2 ( + +> 0%0 ( 2 ( ?1 1 > ( )2 @(2?1 1 6 +2 ( + 0
0
) !"
# ( ) ( "
#
0
2 (+ ) !- , #
6 )( % +
( ( 1( =
< ( 2 +1( "B+(2)+) % + (+ )2 " ( )2 )( 0
0( ( (&) 2(1 0 0 ( (
) = < ( 2 +1( "B()( (( +) 1)1+ 0 ( )
) + )2 "( )2 )(
0 0 ( (
) = < ( )((&)6 + +2 ( + +> 0%0 ( 2 ( ?1 1 > ( )2 @(2?1 1 6 +2 2 +( 1 ( "B (&)' 1 )2 1( !=
< (
)( (&) 6 + 0 ( + + > !- !
# + 2 ( 1 (+ C .
.D #, !
# !
# 0 ( ) +2 10
# #D + !"
# ) #.
.
!**.=:
0 2
"" # !$ 2 )
3 2(2+ ( (&) 6 !*$! + ( (&) ' 1 !*". 9 !*". : 6 1 !*,$ 9 6
:
++ (( +(+()+ 8 ( 5 ( % 0 ( (( +
(+) + 0 ) +( )0 0E
+ (
(+ 2 ( +
0 (
(+
1)2 '8
' 8 @( ?1 '
8 !*,- 0 )2 ( 1 0
+ ( +(+
;(2 ( ! !*".0
(
0%(( 2( !! !*".)2 (
+ 0
+ ( (+ (2( 1!*" -!",,E3
( 0
))2 ( 2 ) + (2 ( 1)2 ' 8 2 (
+ > ( 1C#D ((
+> + 1 C ! D ( 1 0% ( ..-"#*E3
+> ( "B !*".0 + 2( 1 1
?1 1 6 3(3 +( 2 ""#E31( ! ++ )2 ) @(2 ?1 1 6 F@?
6G
!!
- # ,1( # @?
6 ) )( 0
, !!
# !,1(
)( ( )2
(!, - # !,
!-$# ! !, - # !, + ' (&) # !# !*.#
( ( !*". (+0 0
) ++2
#.
.
!**.1( , (+ 0 !$ ( H6A !*".
1(+ #D) ( + ) (
' (&) ##
# !1( $ (+ ?2 ( HA +2 H8A )2 % (+ )1 !D) ( + )( + 0
+ " 1 +(2)+ ( )2 ( % + (+
+ + 1) 2) (+ 1 )( 1 ) ) % +
(++(2)+ / )2 "
< ( , 8 0 ( )2 ( I( + I(
+ )2 &(+
6(
A ( 0 +2 I(
0 )2 ( I( $ < +;( ;(21 % (+( "B !*". +(2 )+ ( )2 (+ ( % + (+ 01 )
(++(2)+ 80(+ 0 + % + 0
+ % +(+
(0+ 16( !*.* 66#$#
6( !**.!# 7 "# - 8 ( 1 6( 0 + 2 % + )2 +( 8 0 % + 2 % + 0 2 % )1 0 +
) (3 9* 8 2 (0 % + ) 2 ( )0
% + ( ( 2 2 0 % +)(0 2% +
+ ( 2 2 % + 8 0 % +
2 % + 0 2 % + ) 1 0 + < % + 0 ( ) + 9!
% + 2 0
2 2 (J #
+ 2 % % + ( + J
% ) ) + (
)(J "
% ( ;( 2 +( % + ,
% +0 (0(% % + + ( : 8 !
" #"$8 !*,*
6 "$0 )0)2 ()(23 )% ( 2 ( ) 0 )2 ( )(2 ( ) : .
8 ( ()
(00 )+0 )()()&
+ 1 80 (21 ) ) < 0)2 0))))
+)0 ) )
()&( +1 )
+
) (3 9 $
;( 0
) 1 0 )+0 )) ()&
+ !E *1
! + "1 )
K
+ +( 0 % )2 + ( 2 ( 2 )( (21 ! + 0 / () 0 + )
)0 + + ( +1 ) ! L
K
+ > /) )
((M6 F!*.#G,!
6 " > &
M6 6 7 6 1>
6 K ( (
(M6 F!** G-$
6# B0 N !**.!
66$"! 6 (
( ( ()
K
++(
0 1 ) ( () L6L) + ( 2 ) - / (+ (2 () 0 +(
K
+ 2 1 ) ) 2 0 0 )2 0)) ))
+)0 )) ? ( 0;( ) )
)0 +0 ) 8
+ )2 + ( 2 ( 2
)(
)&( +1 )
+ " ( 2( L6L) ) +( +1
+ : * 7( 0() ()2 ( /0 )2+ ) ++ + + +(2)+ 533 5 + (+ 0
)( ( 2
( )( + 0 )%+( ( 1 +2;( )2 ) ( )( 0 0
!
+ ;(
+ > + ( 1 .
.D #, !
# !
# ( + 2 !***3# 0
) )2 3 80 ( 1(+ ()# #D ) (+( #.!**.
0&)2 +( 2 ( 2
@(2?1 1 6 F@?
6G
+)2 @?
6
+ (3
!"! :/5>!??
+( 2 + 2 +( 1 .
.D #, !
# !
# ( + 2!***3# ) +( 2+ #, !
#
#"
!
# 1 0 # #D /0 #, !
# (+ 0 2 ( + )2 0 ) + + .
.D /0 0 # !
# ! 1(+0+ C !D 8 ( )(2 #, !
# ## !
# !(+01 .
.
'% 2 + 8 ) 2 )8 0 : !!
)( +
;( () 1 .
.
D() (+ 0 #, !
# !
# + #.
.
!**.0) ( ) )(+ + ) 4( 0 )2 ) (
)0
0 +( ) )( !# + ( 3 ( 1 (+ #, !
# !
!
# ()# #D .
.D ) #.
.
!**.
80 (+0
( ( H6A !*". 0
( 1 0 ) # #D+0 ( + > 0 )2 ( (+ 2( ) ( )0 3 8 0 () (+(#.!**. (+0 ( (H6A !*". 0
( 1 0 ) C # #D +0 ( + /0(&)' 1 > # 9> # : (#, !
# (+ 0 ( 2 ( !*". + 6+2 88 ( HA + 0 0 1) .
.D +0 ( +
> # 0 )2 (&) ' 1 # ) 2 9 # : 0
0 !
"
# , # > # /0 2
+2 %( !*".)2 > # 0 )%(!*". )2 # +2 > # 0 # ( 1(+K(2#,# 0 +)
.
.D +0 ( + 80 ( ##
# ! (+0 ( 6+238 (HA !*". ( 1 6+2
( +(+ !D + ( ( ( 1(+ K(2#,# !# > # 0 # ( 1(+ 0 ).
.
8 0 )(
(+ )2 + > # # 32( + ) * # , ( 6 (+
(&) 2 + 8 $ 1( . + + +( 1 #, !
# !
# ;( 0 ;( ) % )2 ' 6( /0 ) % )2 ' 0 + + + ( 1 # #D #, !
# #!
# !
!
< () (
8 ) ( 0 2 ) % )2 ' 0 + + +( 1 # #D #, !
# #!
# ! 2) + * ) # , ( 63 (+ 1( .
+20 #, !
# !
# ( 10)# #D
.
.D +2 ;(
0 + 3 !"
0(+)
6( !, 8 0 )
)
9 =<25 / %!! , 2#3"
"7/2 /=6)
'9 /%"*/2< 2, @3&; 2#3" < % +E "& < ) "&