M/S Jainsons Appliances v. State Of Punjab And ORS
Gurbax Singh 2017.07.26 15:21
!"#$#%&'(
)
*
!"#$ % & '! &() ' * +& ,-+ ./ + +- ,-+ .+ 0- + % , % ' - !,'! .&() / + +-)
' ' ' & ! /"
$ '&()&
0
"' 1 ' 1$, ' /
"%%1'23
$
)2 '&
0 )&&()3' , '"' 1 ' )&1$/
4, ' -,&) 5& -+ 6"$ 7' ' ' &4 ' 2 4 % ' 0 ! &()) -' ', '%) '#4' '
!0 ) , '! &()
& 38 4) 4&() -& ) 4 2 %2 0#4' '9 "$ 7' ' ' ' &4 ' 2& ":$ ' )4
4 2 , ;33 -'
2 ' ) & ' &4 42, ', 9 "$ 7' ' ' % *& <3 *&
) 24 -' ' , - 4,)2 )2 -2 )2 )2 2 9 "%$ 7' ' ' % ! ":$)
24 -' '
0)& '&()
"%$ 7' ' ' 2 4 ' ' % '24 0 & '
&() -'' ' 2)4 & !
":$ ' 9=
- 2 (& ' % 2 %% '42) ' &2 , & ' % '#4' '
&
0
& '3 !0 > "' 1 '3! 1$; ,, ')& 4& & , , '4; ' 4& )& '4 , <
4' ((? @ & % %
>
A > >
)B - ' ', ' &BC , ' 4
"#4' '$ & "&()$' 0 '3! ' )' , D EF
>
A& & ', ' 4
5& 4 '%'4% - & 7' '%' '4 &() ' - ' 'B
A , ', -'B 'B , 3'' ) - ' & @ * FB, ' % & % &4 ''B,
', & ! "$")$ ' ', & ' ' &4 4 ' , - , - ' -4B, 4 % ' 0)2 , ' ; 4 3 3 "' 1;331$-' , ' ! &() '- & A
"0& <$ - & ' ) '
, , ,
' ) ''B,
,- ' ')B & ' % &4 , ' , '
- ' ' ',' & ' 2 B, 2 & ! ":$"$ ' - ' ?0 0 344 &4 ? 4 ";% , $ ) 7, "&()$3' , '"' '?31$ -' ' ' ' 4 4 % ' 0 & '! &() -& ' - ' ' % &4 ! ', - 4, '! &() 2, ' 0 & '3! 4 % ' 0 & '! &() & ))' ', - , & ', )B,& ' , & ' 2 '
A "0& $ 4, 2 /<:> :
< >A & ! ":$"$
$ ' %2 ' ' ', - 4 )2
<
&4 ' % ' ;33-' , '! &(),, % )2 ' ' ) '8 & ' 2 ' & 2?0
0 344 "$ % G' 1 '
?3"$H 04, '4 ' ?3"$&' ' )2 '?3 ', & ' 4 -, ' ;33-' , '! &() ' ' & ' % &4 ! ' ) ' )&; - ) ' )& ' ' % *&<3 '&()&
0*&
- ) ', - 4,)2 8& ' ' 2& !
$ ' -,2 4 )2 ' ,
'4 ', ,-- '% /
"0&
$ ' )& 2- ' ' 2 & ! ":$"$ ' -4 -' ' & !
$ ' - # ' )2 ' A 7'%' & ' < , ' ' , -
' 4
& ; -), 2 '
% ' , ?;33 ' ;33-' , '! &()'&,' ' % '%' -;33&& ,2 ' )& ', 2 '4 ; ') , 2 )2 '
)& ' ' - --2 4
' & % ( I B& ' ' % ,&& ' ' % '% ' I B& 2 ' ;33 , '-2)& ' ' & '- ' B , 3'' ) & @ * 8& ' - )2 ' )& ' ' & )2 ' % -&
- ' ' ' 4 % ' 0 ' )& & ' ' - '&()0' ) ' - ' ' 4 ',-'% , ';33 4 224 3!- &
- 0& % 24 &()0 B ' & )B & ! ' 4 2 - '),, - ' 4
2& !
$ ' '& ' )&-' 2 , ' 24 ' 2& !
":$"$ ' '& !
$ ' % , )2 ' )& ' ,
'&+
!
" # $%&'
# ( ( ) "
&(* +
,
"
- &(* + .
+
- "
/- 000/,
( 1
2 23
4
&
5 #
, "( 1
1
5
"
(
- " # "
6
(
( + 1
(
-
" #
# (
1
&*
7 5(
1
#
( (
# (
,"
1 " # 1
,88 #
( (
"
1 (
7 5( +" # ( ,88 7 5(
-
1
7 5(
,88
+(
(
5
+ # (
- (
"
1
,88
"
:
8)- (""
+
.( "
1 &(* + - .
5 ( "
+5 "
(
, (
(
!
,88 1 "
(
4$'
( ;
. "
"
+ 1 " <!
$ '
=!,88 >( + +
"
. "
( ) "
&(* + $? (
4!#' $+'
, "
"
) "
&(* + " (
!"
##$
( " "( " ( %&""
' ( )
(
" " *
+'
"
"
"
+" ( " . ( "
" +
:
"
" (
. 1( ,88 " /-! , "
) "
&(* + +
+
(
4!8
1( ,88 " /-!
+" 5 1 "
(
+" "
(
+
1
-
"
+
+
1 + =!,88
(
1 + +" 5 1 "
(
+" "
(
+
1 , ( +
%&""
'"
-
"
- (
" '
'
"
(
4!#
+( "
(
4!8 "
=!,88
+
1 "
( "
- (
+ "
(
4!8
=!,88 + +" 5 1 "
(
+" "
(
+
1
,
+
(
(
4!8
+
(
) "
&(* +
" 8)- " (
4$'
+
,
"
:
"
.
( "
8)- ( + (""
(
( "
+ ) "
&(* + +
"
5 ( "
+5 "
(
(
1 .
"
( + "
(""
/ "
1 .@ Learned counsel for the appellant-assessee has not been able to show that the findings recorded by the Tribunal are illegal or perverse or are based on misreading of evidence on record warranting interference by this Court. He has also not been able to produce any material to substantiate its claim made in the appeal. Thus, no &) 5&
- 35& 2 ,4 ' '4 ' )2 4 4/ + +-5 4+ 0-5 '(
)
* 1,1 7' ' B, $ 7' ' )9 $