Nawanshahr Co-Operative Sugar Mill Ltd v. State Of Punjab Thr Financial Commissioner Excise And Tax, And ORS

I N THE HI GH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDI GARH VATAP- 58- 2016 ( O&M) Dat e of deci si on: - 31. 01. 2017 The Nawanshahr Co- oper at i ve Sugar Mi l l Lt d. . . . Appel l ant Ver sus St at e of Punj ab and ot her s . . . Respondent s CORAM: HON' BLE MR. JUSTI CE S. J. VAZI FDAR, CHI EF JUSTI CE HON' BLE MR. JUSTI CE ANUPI NDER SI NGH GREWAL Pr esent : - Mr . M. R. Shar ma, Advocat e, f or t he appel l ant .

* * * * S. J. VAZI FDAR, C. J. ( ORAL) The l ear ned counsel appear i ng on behal f of t he appel l ant f ai r l y st at es t hat quest i ons No. ( i i ) and ( i i i ) sought t o be r ai sed i n t hi s appeal ar e deci ded agai nst t he appel l ant by vi r t ue of t he j udgement dat ed 15. 07. 2015 passed by a Di vi si on Bench of t hi s Cour t i n vATAP- 176- 2013 t i t l ed as M/ s A. B. Sugar s Lt d. Vs St at e of Punj ab and anot her t o whi ch one of us ( S. J. Vazi f dar , CJ) was a par t y. The ot her quest i ons do not ar i se f r om t he i mpugned or der . 2.

The appeal i s accor di ngl y di smi ssed.

( S. J. VAZI FDAR) CHI EF JUSTI CE ( ANUPI NDER SI NGH GREWAL) JUDGE

31. 01. 2017 Amodh Whet her speaki ng/ r easoned Yes/ No Whet her r epor t abl e Yes/ No Amodh Sharma 2017.02.01 11:55 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document chandigarh