Devi v. Dakshini Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd And ORS



 
 


 

!"# $#%&'&(   ) #*& ++#,,!(" *#-'.' !/'0&(&!-1!(!&2,&3&"-!(&4!56"$!($"0#-' 
#'+($#("' 
7896
:
 ;0#"0#-
#+-"#-' 6%!,#<'+!+#-'5!1=#!,,<#$" '##"0#2.$45#(">

#' =#-# #--#$""0#
#+-"#-'-("> #' ?;0#"0#-"0#2.$45#("'0.,$=#-#+-"#$&("0#&4#'"> #' -#'#("7-!(2!1&""!,@$*%!"# -"0#!++#,,!("
 0&'&'!(!++#!,$&-#%"#$ =1+,!&("&

A!++#,,!("!4!&('""0# 2.$45#("!($$#%-##$!"#$B  +!''#$=10-&!-&($#-:.5!-@ &'"-&%".$4#@!-(!., *&$#<0&%0"0#!++#!,+-# #--#$=1"0#+,!&("&

!4!&('""0#2.$45#("!($$#%-##$!"#$)  +!''#$=1-0!($#- !''@  "0#  "0#(  ,#!-(#$  &*&,  .$4#  #(&-  &*&'&( @  !-(!.,  <!'

$&'5&''#$
  

 

 

   

  



    

 

  

! 

   

 "         #      

    "  

  

            $%

% &  '       %(  

  %
(       $!

 & '     )%*&+))
)

 !
(       ,  ,  -         $
*)% &       .
+  ,   '"

 ,  " 

  

 

 + +
+ $) !!+&

, ," 

 ,   $+
(* &

   

" $
%++(%& "

,  #    

+ +
+ 



 ) '    

"     $+
(* & 



 " /

 0     

$
%++(%&      

     





 , " '   

0    



 



1    ) .  ,



 "   )  ,   "        "  2

       

  "2 





 

  



?



  ' -   





 

   

       

       



 



    $
%++(%&  

 

  "     

 + (
+  , 

  ' 

#  



  

 





  

  



     

   '



,  " 

 



    $
%++(%&     

   

 + (
+





   

 3 

  ,

   '   

 4

 
!

  

  

   

   '



 

 

  $
%++(%& ,    

  '"     "

   '    '        "

 

  



     

  #            

    

  
  
!  

  ( (
!   '    

   

 1 "

5

"$

"

    $

    15$ &
& %  

 
! (
%  ,

' 

 64 " "0        7   

      3   ,  

"  ,

          "   3   ,    "  



"0 3       " #    

  





 





"



 

,  

       

       

    , $)(*% &        

 


 !
(      



  

   $!

 &          "

  '    $
%++(%&



$      '  "  "  "      

$

 ,



   ,  8      ,  , 9

: 

 

     2

  " ;-//
 :     

    ;-/4 ) : 





  

     ;-/4

:       ;-/4 % : 

   

)

  ;-/4 ! $  B 0#+!-"&#'0!*#,#$"0#&--#'+#%"&*##*&$#(%#("0#! -#'!&$ &''.#' ("0#,&40" "0#'!5#@"0#"-&!,.-"!

"#-!++-!&'!,"0#'!5# $&'5&''#$  "0#  '.&"    "0#  +,!&("&

 *&$#   2.$45#("  !($  $#%-##  $!"#$ )  

 0#+,!&("&

+-# #--#$!++#!,=# -#&-'"++#,,!"#.-"0# &-'"++#,,!"#.-"*&$#2.$45#("!($$#%-##$!"#$B  $&'5&''#$ "0#!++#!,

 "&,,  ##,&(4  $&''!"&'

&#$  <&"0  "0#  !

-#'!&$  2.$45#("'  !($ $#%-##'@"0#+,!&("&

+-# #--#$"0#+-#'#("!++#!, C 0#!++#,,!("'&(+!-!4-!+0 "0#4-.($' !++#!,@ 0!*#5#("&(#$"0!" ,,<&(4'.='"!("&!,D.#'"&(' ,!<0!*#!-&'#(&( "0#+-#'#("-#4.,!-'#%($!++#!,78 < = :    "       '  "  ,,     

   2

 "

 ;

<=:      '

   

"    ,,     " 

&  ;

% ;0#"0#-"0#'.&" &,#$=1"0#+,!&("&

A!++#,,!(" - +#-5!(#("&(2.(%"&(%!(=#$&'5&''#$<0#(( ++-".(&"10!'=##(4&*#(=1"0#-#'+($#("<0&,# &5+'&(4"0#&5+.4(#$'.($-1%0!-4#'>

$ ;0#"0#-&"&'=,&4!"-1 -"0#-#'+($#(""#E+,!&(!($ "4&*#"0#$#"!&,' '.($-1%0!-4#'""0#+,!&("&

!++#,,!(">

#  ;0#"0#-"0#-#'+($#("%!("!/#"0#'.($-1%0!-4#'

-5"0#+,!&("&

A!++#,,!("<0#("0#'!5#0!'=##($.,1 +!&$=1"0#+,!&("&

A!++#,,!(">  0!*#0#!-$,#!-(#$%.('#, -"0#!++#,,!("!($0!*#4(# "0-.40"0#%!'# &,#<&"00#-!=,#!''&'"!(%#  6#!-(#$%.('#, -"0#!++#,,!("0!''.=5&""#$"0!""0#-#&'! $#5!($ 
' @) @

)A85!$#=1"0#$# #($!("A-#'+($#("'@<0&%0&'("

4#(.&(#  "0  "0#  .-"'  =#,<  0!*#  ("  !++-#%&!"#$  "0#  !%"  "0!"

%((#%"&(0!'=##(-#,#!'#$""0#!++#,,!("<&"0."!(1=2#%"&(0# '#%.-&"1!5.("<!'+!&$=1"0#!++#,,!("!($"0#-#! "#-%((#%"&(0!$ =##(&''.#$   0!*#%!-# .,,1%('&$#-#$"0#'!&$'.=5&''&(=."$(" &($ !(1 -%#&("0!"'.=5&''&( ? "0"0#.-"'=#,<0!*#4&*#(%(%.--#(" &($&(4 "0!"

&(!$*#-"#(",1  "0#  !5.("  &(  D.#'"&(  <!'  ("  4"  $#+'&"#$  -5 "0# +,!&("&

0#$#5!($("&%#<!'&''.#$-#4!-$&(4"0#'!&$!5.("0# #'"&5!"#<!'!,'+-#+!-#$@<0&%0<!'%55.(&%!"#$""0#+,!&("&

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

 %+1 "0&'2.$45#("=#'#("""0#"-&!,.-" - '"-&%"

%5+,&!(%#