Indian Oil Corporation Ltd v. Mukesh Kumar Jain And Others
! "#$ % & ' )&& * "+ (,-
!"! # ! !!
")((, &
)
&& ".( .
) / ( ". (
)
")0 0 - . 1
23 $ 5)$ 6.$ 05.$ 53 7('
)&& ( 8
1 ( 91- :: /)&&!
;
/(
/ (
- + & -
< & ! 1 ' #$ ! < = - +
(-8 &&
7( && "#$ % & '- > ! ? % @ , .
, ?,.,@ >; ! /(!(! ! 1 )&71 7 (A &(+ ! "
/ ?5 @
8- &&! ; ( ! # && - ( ! 7( ! / - & &
C !( >: $ % & '- 7( - 1 ( ! /
8 !( /(!( & !
/
•
!
"
# $
• %!
#$ "&$
• '
#( " (
) * + , # - ) '
# - ) +%
"
.
$
$
($ ($ /
0
$
$
($
1 & &
/# & & 2
"1 $
,
.+
0"
4
1
, * % 5 #
/
"
- # $
% *
1
$
# ,
$ 7 8"
9
2 7 8 "
9 "
:
1 ($ 7 8 2 78
" )& - ( &&! /
- +" +/ & ! & -
+
& 8 & ! # ! ! & 8 &
!
6! D ! ! & 8 1 8 1 !
% < & 8 & ! # ! < - E-- - +/ 7( ( !
8 / !
B F%/ ' G FA-% ' GA F%/ G ( - E--- + / $! / FA-% G ( - E--- + / ; )& ?
@ ( ---D 1- +
& !
! / ;H - +7( ( & &&! ( ! ;- + D : C !( & ! ( ( / 8
F%/ G ( ( / ( FA-% G > 7( !- ( / D 8- ! / + / & ! & 1 ( I. %/ (&< 7( ! & !
/
1
;*;
< = '>!#
"
?
'>!
$2
0
!"
!) )
#
7 8 #
# 7 8
'>! 0
?@
<
A
% 7 8
B2
'
?
5 > C B ? :
<
' ?
! > C $ ?
# $%&'' %('"
!) '
?
" * " A ? " ? "
?
### ### ### 5 )
" ) ; " ; 0
!
>9 "9
"
!
D"*%D"1 551?
+>'51?6E51
'
?
0?
*+ * >
*
5 0 '
"
9 /
* 4 + > /#
7 + + A
> * # 8 , + A
!%
> & * *
'>!
0 + A
>
& $ *> *
'>!
0 + A
4> *> *
'>!
0 + A
4> > + + A
4> = >
* + &
$3 '>! 0 +, 5
*
+ & 5
*
$3 4>
( ( / / 8 ( &&! (
/ <%/ < ( <' / 8 ( F - G - -8
E! < <' / &&! E! / (F - -8 < <' / &&! 1/ ( & (
&&! ( -
$%< D </ 8 11 &&! 89 ! &&! & !1 (
B 1 ( !
J / 7( / 8
F%/ ' G FA - G/ & & ; C !( /(!(
' 7B 1,, '!12' 'C>4-E ', /5/1 /9*6',+>9- 9/ 1'>+*6',! 1E*/ ') 9 ! , ' ? " ?
>9 ' ? " ?
%
+ " >!
" >' " >!
/
! & %/ 1 - ? ---&
- (@/
<%/ < $ 1 F%/ ' G &&! ( (
& / (- - / #/(!(/
- FA-% ' G .!( - / #/ D ( - B 11
+( #+( -8 - 1 # ! / (& !
( 7( ( & ! 1 1 (
& -
F & 8 & ! # ! G 7( D / /(
( 8- ( D !- # D -
8 !(
( / & !
7( 1,(
:###?J;@ 1 1 ( ( ( 1 - - ( /
/ >) ( / - (
- ( ( & ( ( ( F%/ ' G ; ) ( / ! -
D
$%( & !
-& ,(
##?J@ 7( - 8 (
J( / / (& ( - "
( # $- -,( # -?( ( @ -
#
)B9# $- -,( ?( ( @"
( (
&& ( ) 1 / ( ( &&!
8- 9 " B ( "
( # $- - ,( -
# )B9 ! ( 1! 8 1,(
##?J@/ ( / (& K( !(
( "
( $ / 9 1 ( !
-& ,
:### ?J;@$ ( & 8 1 && (&
,., (
/ 1
8 ( ,(
-8 (- :
/ / < $'<- + ( & -
< & 8 & ! # ! < ( ( 8- ( (
J( ( "
( ( (5 - +/ : - +)( (
8 ( ---D 1;H- + ( / / (
(&C 1 11 ( ( / & > 7( / & / -
7( ( ( (
> / ( !
8 ( I. %/ (&< 7( ,
:###?J;@!
8 F%/ ' G ( ( 1 - ( ( 1
,(
##?J@( ( 8- / "
( - " 9
=(/( / - ( "
( ( /( ( & J (-7( & J ) / ( ( ( "
( 7( D
/ 8- B / /(!( (
( )!!
1
( / 1( / < < - +
/ ( ! &
/ &&! /(!( / / 7( / ! 7( .1 1 ( ( ( & & ,(
##?J@/ / - -8 &&! < -
( !
! /
/( ( -< - <- - /(!( ( &&! - -8 ;
C !( $ / ( ( ( ! / 8
:7( D & 1 !
:/ F
B G F
B 8 / &&! G$ / !!
1 ( ( B -
/ / !
) (
( 8- !(
B ( / ( <<- +7( && / - + (&8! ( ( 8
! $ ( ( /
/(!( ( 8
!( 1 $ % & ('
)&& ' & & ( 7( & ( ( !
-& ,
:###?J;@ 1 1/(!(
( 1 -
/ 8 F%/ ' G5 / ( /
!
!
-& ,(
## ?J@ 7( ( <. %/ (&<
/ &!
.
>? ( 8 ! ?@ C !( @.
> / ( /( 1 (
<%/ !
< ! !
.
: -
$% D
( ( ,(
##?J@$ / E! / 5 !
( / (
&!
.
: 7( !- D & ! 1 (.
-8
<
B ) <7( D /( ( D
B ( J / J / ; ?8@ 8 !( ( & /(!(1 (
& &&! / (I- -
/ <$ D ( 7* " A ? " ?
"
?
8 : 7( 8 -& ( / !
/ & - !( / !
9 / $ ! / ( !( !
J / / 8
FA-% ' G & ?8@ 8 !( > $ ( ! ( D ! ?8@ 8 !(
- ( ! ? @)& ! ? @ 8 !( (
! < / < ( J / - - -8 / &&! 9 / (( -
-8 <%/ ' < 7( ! 9 / ( D & ( J / & J!
8 ! 8 I%/ ' < 1 1/(!( ( <A-% < 7( - - I
B < .
:
( & $ 1! ( ( D <
B < < - J / <
$
- E& ! 1 ( !(!
J / / !
7( ( 1- '
( - J / / 8 ! !
!!
& '
!
( !
( (
/ - & (& 7( ( 8
8- & ( 7( 1("
( ( (
8- ( &&! 8 / ( -
:; K( "
( .($- -,( ,(
##?J@/ ! ( - ( / " 9 ( 1 ) ' ()+( # ( !( ' ()+( & J "
( (
:; / / ( ! $( ( + / ( ) / J( ( ( / !
( 1 -(- / .8 D
&&! ( &!( ( ,(
## ?J@ 1
- -
# )BB#
$- -,( ?K( @ )# )+( # "
" 9
(
"
( # $- -,( ? (
D ( ( ( @7( -
/ - ( - -
:: 7( ! - ( & 7 ( &
-- $ / ' 6 --
/(!( ( 8 !
8 !!
& ( 1- '
% )& ?1@ 8 !( 7 +
)& ! ?@ 1
%
?
1 ? !
?
'>!
.- 8J! ?!@ ?@ ?
@ (
8 !( I0 7 - < & ( !- !! 8 !!
& ! &&! 7( - & !
/ 7 + ""
+
%
% ?
'>!
; 7( ( ! (
( &!( ( 8 D ! 8 (- : $ / ( &8! +1
& !8 18 1 (& $ (
8 !
& / E ( !
18
( 8 ! ( 7( &&! ( 1(
(
( & !8 ( - ( & -8 & (
! / ( & 1 >
& E ( 8
'
)
-& / ( (
D 1 18- B ( J
/ ( / 1( / < <- +8
&& & -
< & ! 1 ' #$ ! < )!!
1
( && / 7( 91- ' .1 1 :: 7( / &
- )"! * ) !! * +,- %#
1 ( .& +1# L ( & 8
L #