Dharam Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others
!" #$%&''(
!$%$)%* #$%&('+'(
,-$.# #$%&/'+'(
!
#$% &
'
'( & '
& 01
' 2 21 ' )
* +,- .&/ 0 1
./ - .&/ 0 -
(
#- .*- #$%
22222
213'
3
('
1
( -
( '
0,,&
& & & 4 5
.6# 5 (''& '( &
5- /&
10-
( '
% &'''& '/0 ,, ,'
&
'#%'9#
&'
(''&
# '- /&
10-
% /'&
&
&''', & & 4 5
.6# 5
'
% #(,&
+"
"0 '
0'
( $ & ,0
(
'
'
%,
7
'('
1,
( 1'
( '
& '
0
:- & %'
&#
&7'- #'
& # '
( &
;
3 /1
% /'& %'0- 0'
1'
''#&
( < ( &#,7 ",& (,7
0' <
'&
(
(,7 ",&
0'
1'
#&
% 0& 7 & '
'9#0
'-
&( , ( 0&'
1 & '
(
<
9#7
""0 ,&
0'
( /& '
( <
(#' # & 1
"&'
9#7
""0 &
(''&
& & & 4 5
.6# 5- /& 10-
( 1'
&'''& '/0 ./& '
& & &
4 5
.6# 5-
( ",& ((, %"
((,,
# &
' 1'
,'
&'''& /&
& & &
4 4
.6# ; ./& '
% /'&
&'-
( ",& /' ( %"
/' , # 10
1'
,'
&'''& /&
& ;; 4
.6#
./&
'
% /'&
&'-
( ",& /' 0#07
( %"
'( &
- 1/-
' 1'
,'
&'''&
= 4
.6# ./& '
% /'&
&
& & = 4
.6# -
( ",& 07 (
%"
> 0 7- #$%- 10 1'
,'
&'''& /&
&
& & 4=
.6# .'
(
( -
%'0
&# 1'
1,,"#, &
1'
%7 & '
, >0-
(
'
",&
('
1
( 0,,
% /'&
&'
<
,7 '&
,& ' #',
((
%,"
( '(0
9# #
(#' .'
(
,& ' #', ((
%,"
( -
( 1'
(( &
( ,0 &(
7
<?
'&
,
'/0-
(#'
1&&
'( & '
( ' &
&'( (
/
'0 �
&
#'
,%,
%
' '& &
&
(#'
&''', % / &
,'' (#' @& ' #', '
,&
$#&
(''&
& +0
'
#
% (
,&
'
.,4%# ! 24%56 7 ' 28.8 $9 )%:.; .%# $86 !
&0&&
4
;
&- ,& #', ((
%,"
'( & '
'#% '
(#',
"0 '
('
0' #,&
'
( & 1,,"#,,7 %'
&#
&7'-
#'
& # '
( &
;
> "# '#% '
( & , ,'
& %'
&# & "0 -
( 1'
,'
#&
% % #,
60 1,
&# 7
.'
'#0-
( '
,7 %
&'''& '/0
@& #', "# '#% '
?
'&
�
( -
(#'
( '&
'( & '
&''', '/0- 0
% ,&
% '
;
&'( (
/
'0 � .'
'#0-
"0
1 &
(#&
&'
(''&
'( & '
5
/ &
,& #', ((
%,"
( '
, & / (#'&
0 & 1
%, '''
0
4
&'(#
( & %'
&#
&7'- #'
& # '
( &
;
&
%''
% / %'0- (
1'
&'''& '/0
4 5
(#( '
&$#&0
'
0'-
,/
"
#, 4
#$% ,0 #,'-
5;
'
((,0%,
(
,/
6 0
'& #, ( �& %, 1)
"
!
" #
"
$
$
$ $
%
&
&
&
&
' $ $ $
&
&
( &
)
*
!
$
$ +
$ )
$$ ! $$
,-. / /
0
#
$
1
3 *
$
+ $+
$
0 ( '
"
$
$
$
0 ( '4 =
.
(#',
% /'& #, #,& '
'
(
#% #,
#, 4
#$% ,0 #,'-
( /&'
&''', ',, % 1&&
,7
/'
0 '
'0 �
'
0##, / ""0
#& '0 �
( / 0 %, &
(, #" ''
( ,0 '/0
"# ( /&'
1,
(''
&
&''',- &# & '
% /
,
'/0 & 0,
('
1,, '
,& ,1
%'0 &# %
( ,0 0 # '
/'
0
'0 � ,0 &
$#&
(''&
> B%, #( #
0'
,& '
28.8 $9 '
'7 ' 6$<=)>.!24%563! ,$!8 #. ( 2'
,/
6 0
$#&
( �& %, 1)
5. , $ 6 /
$
$
%" 57087
+ 7 +
$
9 :-"-
;
, ( $:2 :-
, * -:-< + ;
, ( 7 7
=
= 7
$
$
!
/
/ !
$
6$
7
)!
"2 +
7
6$
!"
4 -3 6/ ! *
7
76 /
6
$
6/ > ?
> $ * 6/
?
>
6 / 7
=
:#
$
6/ 30=:9<.::@ A00 ,7
7
= >
, /1 '
,'
%
?
> B%, #(
#
0'
,& '
28.8 $9 )%:.; .%# $86 ! 7 ' $64%# ! 24%563! ,$!8 #. ?
2'
,/
6 0
$#&
( �& %, 1)
5- 7
B
: ;
0 * 0 ;
%" 5
"
CCCCCC4
@;
3 6/
7
+ 7 !
+
7
1 27
7
3 9 ) *
$
6 7
4
,0 ,'
(,0&
$#&
(''&
/' +0
'
#
?(+
,& '
>.!:4824%567 '28.8 $9 )%:.;.%#$86 !
&0&&
;
3
% /'& 0'-
/' +0 '
,&
%'0 &#
%
&'0(,& 0 # '
/ 0
'0 �
,/
6 0
$#&
( �& %, 1)
C
# D
/
6> ,
/
0 # 0 / !
;
%" CCCCCC 6> ,
/ ! "
#"
$
%$
? >
2E
$
@@2@<
<= 9F
$
4
3 &
"0
'
#
1
9# #
(#'
0&-
1,, '
,& ,1
(#'
( '&
#(
(, 7 (,7 1
&
&'0(,7
# 7
# '
#'
60' '
& " " 1
9# #
(#' - #,''-
'',7 &'( (
/
'0 �
3
%4$%$9%#4..%#$86 ! 7 '$% 8.;- 2)%4-=)>.!3 2( &0&&
1, ,, 1
$#& '- > B%,
#( #
,&
"0
1
(#'
(''%,
,7 1
(#'
( '&
'
?,7 &'( (
'0 �
,0 &
$#&
(''&
&
+0
'
#
+/( ,& '
.5:4824%567 '28.8 $9 )%:.;.%#$86 !
&0&&
5 3
% /'& 0'-
( 1'
?
( '
'
%, & & %'
&# 5 &7' <?
'&
"0
(
1'
%'
&#
% /'& ( & & 1'
,'
% #, %' -
1'
,&
(#'
&''',
0
% ,&
% &'( (
/
'0 �
,/
6 0
$#&
( �& %, 1)
C#
$
-9 6
7
)
6 *
6 -9 @:@.::.@@::- .2 <@::: -@2::: 7
$
6
0 #
.
,
/ 5&'()*" "
+" " ,
/
+
) # 7 ! * % ?
7
,
= ,
) #
6 $ $ @- $
8
) #
" CCCCCCCCCCCCC -# $
* *" "
+"- %
./ 0122$
)#7 7
$ $ 7 ! 7$
4
, ''# 0 #( '& %"
&
+0
'
#
2
,& '
2.!.;6:48 24%56 7 '
)%:.;28.8 .%#$86 ! &0&&
5 3
% /'& 0'
,'
- ( 1'
?
#$% ,0 & & & %'
& ,"
'
&
1'
,&
## D& %'0
&# 1 #
,/ # '
/ 0
'0 �
&
(#'
&''', 0
% ,&
% &'( (
/
'0 �
,/
6 0
$#&
( �&
%, 1)
C $
$
"
"
' * 7 )
$
"
'
2 ) * 6G ,
/ $
' $
7
* 6G ,
/ / ((/3 $% /"
-"4""
%7
- * %" CCCCCC < 6$
$
;
/ 9 # $
2 $
#
$
$
*
H
@ 1
., $
2
1
$
"
"
2
1 7
$
1
7
"
1 @ 1 $
$
*4 ;
, ''# 0 #( '& %"
'
#
2+?
,& '
.6 %# ! 24%56 7 ' 28.8 $9 .!@.%.
&0&&
3
% /'& 0'- ( 1'
? '
'
%, #$% ,0 &
%'0 1'
( &
=;
&7'
&
1'
,&
& +0
%'0
&# # '
/ 0
'0 �
& &''', '/0
$#'
"& &
&'( (
/
'0 �
,/
6 0
$#&
( �& %, 1)
5@ $
"
*
$
7$
$ E
*
+
+ 8
"
D
$
$$
( +
( 6
$
( 6
=
$
"
2E
+
$
$
1
< E
$
$ 1
"
9 $
"
+
$
$
7
7 $
=
$
"
"
$$
"
E
$.<
. :-: $
"
' .<
/
"
7 $
"
+
' $ $ $
"
'
$
- 7 6G ,
/ /
((/3 $%/"
- "4""
%-
$
$
7
- * %" CCCCCC :)
"
$
@ ) * 6G ,
/ / ((/3 5 $/" !
6 - "4""
%
% $$
/
$$ / +
E
* / ((/ 3 /" 6
+""- "4"" %
- 7 3 2 2 /" 8#
!-"4""2
$ -
9 3 22/" -&':;"
!/
!- "4""
%-
/ ((/3 2/" 7 "
+"" -"4""
% 2-7 3 %2/" !"
7 - "4""
2- 9 3
2/" *(
;)-"4"" $
5 " / ((/ 3 5 % /" * 3 7/#) :(
" 4) <"
8"(
+" / 1!/- 7 :8("-"4"" $
$ E
"
E
$*
2F $ / ;
, )
4 5
, /1 '
%
?
& +0
'
#
2/+
,& '
6 )%:.; 28.8 .%# $86 ! 7 ' 26!4. A4%# !24%563! ,$!8 #. + +?
&0&&
;
4
3 &
'&
,& ' #',
((
%,"
(
(#'
&''',
1&&
( ' & 60''/- '
'#0-
'
,%,
% '
'& 3 &
% /'& 0&-
(#',
"0 '
('
0' #,& '
(
& %'
&#
&7'- #'
& # '
1,,"#,,7
;
,'
&'(#
,
00' ,'
-
( & & %'
&# &
1'
1&& (#'
0'#
,'
&'(#
( 1'
#& #&
60 1,
&# & (#'
" #
7'
'/0 1'
( '&
< ( #,& ,'
'
1'
%'
1,,"#,,7
1'
%7 & '
,
$ &# &#
( &
%'0
=
<?
'& -
#
'0 �
( /&
'
( ,
&# '
& '( '%, '
0&
( '
-
0
% ,&
(#'
( '&
(
&''', '/0 '
&'( (
/
'0 �
% / , /
. 0, ;
'
#
3 &
,0 &
,& ' #',
((
%,"
(
$#&
(''&
0'
.,4%# ! 24%56 ),!.
0&- (#',
% /'&
$#&
#,& '
,
'/0
(
(#( '
(' 7 %" '
1'
?
'& 1,
(''
&
(#' > 1/-
('
0'-
(#' # '
'&&
(/ #'
'/0 &&
( &
"
- (''&
&
(#'
%7
,
'/0
(
(#( '
(' '
%
?
'&
(#' # 1, (''
&
&''', 3 /1
% /-
$#&
,&
,& ' #', ((
%,"
( 1,,
%
((,0%,
('
0'
<?
'&
"0 '
('
0'-
,/
#,'
&
% / "& $#& '-
'
#
"&'
('
1
( &
' %7 &'''&
& '0,, #'
((,0 '- "
7- ,'
'
&'
&'( '&
"
21 ('+'( &(
'(? '
&
F'
( %,
F'