Krishna Malik v. Punjab National Bank & ORS
CWP-22106-2016
!"
# KRISHNA MALIK
PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK AND ANOTHER
$ %&$ '( ' ) *****
!
"
#
!
$
% #
"
#
&&&&& ( ' )+ , -./ '
( ( " #
)***+
$$!
#
, *-./#
,, !#
/ $ ( !
#$ $
, "
$
$ "/ (#
***+./# , !#
/ # %
#. " , "!
/ #. $"
( #
*1*+ 2
3 ,
.#," "#
##
4
#
5 '
***** #.
'
( # 6 !.$ #%# ,%
'
( (,7 %
8
#
%
% # # (#!
# ( , (
-**9"
#"
,, ( $
! "#
# # $ %& '( ) (
*
+,, - ! . ## #! /!0 1 23- -4 5 0/
! 1 & 236+4 *5 " ! # ! 1)5
$ ! !1)5 (!#
7)8&&9 : #
( "## 6 :
4,,-,,4 * 4,,-,, *
; )
1< ) 236+*+++ "
; ;/ 1# 236- * *5 #! - $ ! %&) ! ##
,= =+-4 ; > '
!
# %& <'3) ? @
; *- A6
:
;
$
;
;6 ;
:
; $
;
* *)*9 * <3
!
6 :) =1)) *9*9 *)*9 * <3
!
6 :) =1)9 *9*+ ) *)*9 + <3
!
6 :) =1)- *9*- 9 *=)*9 * <3
!
6 :) =191 *- + *=)*9 * <3
!
6 :) =19 *-* - *=)*9 + <3
!
6 :) =19= *- 1 )*9 *
>6 5 '
!
:-1+* 1= *+
) )*9 )
>6 5 '
!
:-1+* 1=* *+* $ "
# # # # B #(
! (! 0/
;/ 0
= +
+
! " : 1 ! ( "5
!## ( # , +
+ ) !.$ # #
# ,,(
, , ( # #$. (", # %
#
/
(!, $ , / .
! # $ ;# 6 8"" !
"
( ( #
% # ( # # $ / "
(# # (( #
#
. , 6 !.$ #%# ,# " # (
%# #
# "!,,/!# $ , 4/!$ %,,
!,4 (# / "/#
#/$%# ,#/% , ((
,/!,4 (# % 4/!$ "!
!.$ ##
# ( ,
, ,,( # .
!./! (# $ , "$# 3# $4 # %
"# % #!!.$ ## # (#! $ !
/ "
(#.
( #
"!
!.$ # # !(# # $ , / % # #
/ !
#$ " $ ,"
$
#. $
% # (# #33;
<
( %# # # ,/ , !
./#
5 '
# # ( #
. ?# . ./#
#
9 $ /
# . %# " # # ( !(# . ., # #
.
! #!
(#"
(
./ #6 /8"" , ., . 6 , (!./#3 ,"
#
##
(./#6 /8"" %
! , $
% # !""
(!
!
/ #
#
# # # .
,
"
, !
, 4! 6 #! (!##
,
(% ##!.0!
" $ , "
$
./ #!
# ( !#
/ $ "
$
,"
$
,./# ,, !#
/
. 9 , "
# #$ ,/ (! # # ( # # .
!
#
"
$$ ( $
! ./
( "
( . ! ( "
(. " ##% # % $
/"
$
2, /, #!
"-) @#
!(# ? ""
"
$
; "<35 ' % ""
"
$ ; >6 5 ' !
;#33;
"
( ;% !,/?$ ./ #5 # ( %# #
% , ,/ $ ! ( #
;3 #%
"
% ## 33;
"
(%# !
# , ( A 0! "
# , !.$ , (/
*9*9 ,
, #$ "-) @ # # . % # %
!
" # 5 # ;# , (/ , % !
!,/ !.$ ./ # # # % (
0!
"!
" ;# $
" (! , ./ #
# ," ,
"
# !# $
# .,(
+ "!
# # "
$
@
"
% ( ./ # . ' "" %# , % # $ " !
"#. '!
(# /
(;# % # "#-) @./#
, " !
"#,,(
;#
#
( '
%,(# , . , / $
! ./!.$ (# , (# $
##
!#"
,,(, ,/$( # !
$( " # 5 ' ;#
5 ' # , / ' , % %# , $ ( !
#$
( # # $ #. ./# #
( $ , ( ( # 6 "!
!.$ #!""
!
/%( #
# "
# #
(" , #$ #6 /8"" !
# # (
( # "!
!.$ ##
,,(
" /$,
. ( /
# #
$ A
"!
!.$ # # $ ,
(
(
./#!, $ ,4!
! ;# # (
#. "
"
.. ,
# $ !"" ,/ ., # " # ", % # "
$ . ,%"!,,/ %
(!$ , % # #, $
% 3 %# , ?$
( $ ,
# !
#$ $ !
#! # "
,/. $ %# # ,,(, /
!
, $
/
# '
(
, / #!
#$ ##. $ , ,
#4!($ "# 3 #$ "
!!"
-
#)1+ 37*+*9*= %# # 3 # " ,,/ #, # # (# 3 % !,
,/ , !. !
!
#$ ## . $ ./# , /!#
"!
!.$ # # # %
# ( " $.AA,$ # !
#$ " $ ,"
$
%!#,./# 3 + :
(!$ # . ./#3 ,"
#
4!($ - 6 $ !
!##
%
# ( #"
#
(% # % !$ "-) @"
$#
"# 2, /,#
!(# (# ""
# !(## ,"
#
#$ ""
!# # ( , , # %
"
$ !,
## # 8"" !,4 %# B 2 (
# . ! ./ #
"/#
# #% .
?
# # ( # $ $ "" , %# #
!.$ #, "*9*9 $ # (! , # % # "#% # % $ ./#
# , " !
(# /
(;#
,,(
## % /. "# "" ,
##/% # , ( /( !( % #! ( ",,/ 5 #
,,(
" /
!
,
,
./ # 6 / 8"" !
( # / 6
/# # /% .?$ ."
# (
6 #0!, / "#
#0! / "% %# # , "
# # ( 3# ( . "/ (
1 #
!(#, (( $! % $, /
%
# ,,(
.
# . ( % "
# $ !
% $
?$
.
./ (# 3 #
,!
% ./ 6 / 8""
. ..
# ./7 .!
/
, 1 # !(# #, . (!##33;
"
(#
. # #
# %
# $
# " ($ % :
) # % # # # " ,,/ $
C% # <'3) CBD0D8; (! .
( # <'3)
B E ##: B" "
( : ##
F
?$
,/ 0!
./ #
%%## #33;
"
(% !
,/ ,., %# # # ,/ %
;# 0!
. !$ ( / # ? "33;
"
(
##
%
"
% # # 33;
"
(
( # # "
./ # # ( % # # # ,' #
" ( # "
( # $$ (#$ ' $ % .
! # $ :
0!
%
! # 5 # ( ###
#. # #33;
"
( ."
#5 # (
"
#$
!
# ;#! #" ,!
# "#
" ,,/
"
#%
"
""
.!$./ $ " = 6% !,, .
$' " #"
(
./ # 6 / 8"" # ( ;# $ ? !
%' ' 0 D
:8 +*-+*911) 68:*)*9 D
) 6; 7 6 ; 58
:
D
9 8: *)*9 3 7 66: @3:81=*9)= D
- ; 3 7 6 :;68<)*+)= : 6<6 5E6:89=- D 6: ; 3 3 :5 7 : : 83:;6; 6 6: ;
338:; :8 1*9)=6; 6 8: 36:;6<63 6:3 6: 35 E; 3;3 6:8;
; 22 D 7) 3 ; 863 22E;
;; ; 6 78 : 7 5E 88:2 :8;38:<6 786;6; :; ;6<:7 786;; :< 782
5:;3; ;;6:6;6 2;
6; 38:<6; ;88:; 2;
;3 6:F;68: :66;6: ; 338:; 7 7622
;8:87;8;6 <86 :38< ;82: <8 3;86 :
6 :3 6: ; E; 5E 6: 88:2G6@ 78 D 6;6 28 6:;; ;;8<<636 2 786@ 787 7:8; ; ;858E 6; 6; 5: 6 5E ; 8
= 8: ;8 8 8: 6; 782 :8;2;6:< 2:; D ; 8 63 6; 5E <6: ; 6:3 3 * ;# "
? ,,! " # # %# # # /8"" #(
%# ,
("
(.
!# # (. ., #
** % # $ ,
(
!
# .!
"
" $ " ? $ ,
(;# , / !$ # . ;#
!
" #
$ ( # (! , ( # $ " -) @ ," !""
$
! # %##
%,,"
5 #
"#
! (#2 (
,
!
(# $ ,
(
" # , % % .
? 6 #!
. #, # # "
( #
* ;#
,% %,,,## (#3
3 ",( # $ ,!#
!. !
"
# ;#.
,%#. %,,"
,, %./
5 # "# 3 4!($ )1+ 37*+*9*= ,
$%& ', (#
"% 4!
$
( # , /
(
# (
* *) 6"
## # (, ,( #
"#
!. ./ $$ ("
!(
# , # " % # % ( # $ "
# ! ,/( $
! $ "#$ % !,
$
(#$
! ##. !
!,/., # ( #
14.
Consequently, the present writ petition is dismissed. The order passed by the Appellate Authority dated 30.11.2015 modifying the punishment of dismissal from service to removal from service is accordingly upheld.
,( ' )/ & + # G 7## '
(@
E@:
7##
., E@: