High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24020/2024allowed

S S Services Providers v. Deputy Commissioner Of Income Tax Circle Patiala

2024-09-19Mr. Justice Sanjeev Prakash Sharma,Mr. Justice Sanjay Vashisth3 pages

/0 1% #

, ,465

1#2!&!(

5 "!

&6&7 0&

5"&+ "!6&7 7

3 %

./ -

0! "

#$ $

4-%"5

! "

#$ % %

", -- &#

! "#$ %& %&'! !()* +& & (!( ($!% %($ *#-& '( ( )* ')'+ &

% / 7,

, ! "#$ % %& % !($#- !()* *%(). +& (!( ($!% %($ *#-& ,( ( )* ')'+ "%&'! !

!()* 123" " .

"","!4 !$ !$"* "4! -"()!$"

!" "#$ $% !

!$ ! &'#$ #

#'%

'#!

&()!$"

#'% !$ *"("" &&'"

! *"

"&! !'! )+ * & & !

!, -"!$",!

&" (&%"!" ".

&% !

*" " #!,"

!& $ * . / # %

/0,

,465 %)#

,+% # !

& " "8'

! ("

" /%%4"

#!%) , , !

%) ) "9"

# & . !$" +4"

& #!

"#!

& 11: 1;< / !$" #! 1:21 & 4"%% & "#!

1== 6> ? @7 !$" '!$

"& # ! (" %%4"

! '&'

+ !$" %". % + * & & ! !$"

4 & & !

&/ #!

#*"

"#" # '& . $

&$ + ! !$" &&"&&""&! %&%" *"&#/'& !$",

&/!$" !

! 9+ )"

& !$" +

/ !$ $ & '

! &!

'#!

#'% & # (" &&'"

%) / !$" +'

+&" / & &'++%","!

. !$" &! !'! ) + * & & / !$"

,+%","! !

1> * "4 / !$" / "&

&#'&& !$"

" & ## & !

&$ ! -"

//"

"! * "4 & & &'.."&!"

()!$"%"

#'&"

"%/ !$" "*"'"/ , 4$ !$ & % "

)(""$"% ()!$ $"

!""#$ 1@ A""+ . * "4 !$" % 4 4 %

4 () !$"

!""#$6&'+ 7!

# #"& &&'"

()!$" '

"#!

1=@ / !$" #! 1:21 !$" + + #""

!$"

" /!"

4 !$'!# '#!

.!$" / / #"%"&& &&"&&,"! &"* & ."

"#!

1== /!$"#!1:21$ *"(""/'

!("#!

)!!$" + + * & & / !$" #! 1:21

.%) !

#"&

;@<;;<;B 12<B;<;

;B ;<<B;<;=

B<<B;<;B

B< <B;<;B "&"! &

" / / 4 !/C'

1: $" "&+ "!&E "*"'" 4 4'% (" $4"*"

! % % ("

!)!/%%4!$"+ #"

" &%

!$" #!1:21 + #""

.%) /& * &"

;

;< %% !$" 4

! +"!

& " %%4"

$" !"

+ &&"

()!$"'

!&$ %% &!

4 !$!$" + + "&"!

D / / -1 - 1 % %""8 2

"- - &,'! !

& &

/0,

,465 %)# ,'!

& &3

4 4 ,+5 ,7 )+ + ')'+ # 0,

& "#$' "' ! "

&&A ) %& ! 3$"!$"

&+" - 3$"!$"

- .0 " &"

! (%" F "& 0 "& 0