High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1664/2017dismissed

Gursharan Singh v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2019-02-11Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih7 pages

! "#$% &'(! # )#

**++ , !

-# &!.#

* &

*/!0 #$1

#**+ **++ & " +" 23" +)#**+ & ! + #**+ 4!+ #4##) !4# # # )1 # +" +) # **+ # # **+ **++4 4 #+0* +)# **+ ' 0 54 ! # 0 # 45

! "# #** ## ! +$4#*

+#**+ !+)#+" 23" +)# 0

-#6*+ # )1"#**+ **++ #**+

*$ * ++"#+)# # ## **+ **++ *+

+7&' +8

* #04 #* +0" $ ) +4 ) ! +)#**+ 4#0 -#+" 23" +)#**+$# $# 6*+# ! ".!

*) # * " # **+ **++ +"

-#**+ $# $ 1 0 +

# # ! + #**++$# # + 0 4 "# ! + # **++## ) +)+ !" )##* 1 #&!.&+ !+ $%3$4# ##1 0 6 #*4 ! #&+ $2#11+ 9 # + ! + #**++# * #++) # ) "#9:! ";

$4# # #1

*"#&! #)!# "$#++) 4 ## **++ 4 # 1 # 4

1 % % 0 !4# $ (! *! $ 0*+ 9 3 ) ! 33$3$ <9&&+ # 4+$ )# #! .)#.)##5** # $4# #4 +1 #

#1 ( +$ &!.$+)4## *+" 0+ ++! 33 % +"

! .)##&!.' "')#! !# 01#

1 * /! * +1 )# 0 #

# 1 ( +$ &!. 9 <+. )#$ # 9 # )$&+ & /!. $:! 0**++ *+

4# ) #+1 " #

1 * /! $4# ## 4 #

01 '41 $#6 # )$' + (! 0!5#)#$ %$4 *!#) #$4# * ##

#1 ( +$&!.$ #

1 * /! #1+* -#0 4 ! # :! 0 !##**++#++"$4#01#+*#

! $ 5!#

1 =*# # ) ##1) !$# 0 4 :! #4 !)!+"

& * * ! !

#!+ 4 ++4$4# ## #++)"# ! + #**++#* **+!## * 0 +"* !*

0*+ #0 "* 1 #%3!+ $

)4# #** 1+ # ) * * ) ) #*+

+* 0++"# $1) #* 0+ :! " :!+" # ! :! * )

! # ) ) 0 " 0!

0*+ # ! " !+ $#! $# * "# !* &+ 0* ) *! #0 **) 0 4# !0!+1

1 3 # 0 + # **++ " # *!" 9 * ( + &+ $ < )$0 $ 3$ ++)+$ ! 1+1 # ! " !+ $#! $ 1

> ! + #**++$ !** # $ # *+ + !* # .!)0 # !

+ %$4# # ! # #+ +")!*#.!)0 # !* 0!

! "## !+ 32 # &!. &+ !+ $ %3 0 "

0*+ # $1 #:! "* ) :!+"

# *! #0

9#1 # !0 0"+ ! + #**++4## $#1)# !)##0*!) .!)0 + #.!)0 +!*"#0$ 1

*!#+":! 4# ## * 1 "# ! + #**++$ #!+

#&!.&+ !+ # 0*+4#$4# # 0 " ! 9#+)# #.!)0 #!* 0! # ./!0 7 !* 8$ *!#!+ 32 0 "$ #41 $# *0 # !+# +5 # *! * **+ +"

#&!.&+ !+ $%3 ++4

$ %& '(( ()*(+) ,((-.*( -/(-(+')( /(' (-01)(-)('(-)-(( /(-

(- -((

-(--(1())(

(-((1())/(-2),((-.*(1( '-('1)))(+(*( )-/() -'-'/(-

(-0'+-'

*()+(*! 1 %3&4)(+(*( -)-/(() /( -( -0 '(-( /-( )

15))'(/' '/(

),((-.*(' -'' 4)(('-(''/-''/)/-' /-('( 36) 1'0

(- '

*(-)* ) '()() '(('((' % &7'((.*( 1)-/(*( /(-

(-(('/-'- '(-(8( (0)1+08('/'( )-) ,((-.*(01)1( 1'-/ )(/ )/(' (-2),((-.*()(

1((('/)/(' (-( - 1)(-)))( 9-*(:- %6& 2) - ;+ ) /-(' ) 1(* // /-' '/' ( ) -

-/(*(/(-

(-()'((-1) )11()) - +(-((:(*-)

(- )/(*(+(*((( 2),((-.*(

1(')/((*(/(-

(-) /' )( / ) -(' ) ) /(( (+ (-((0((1()()( '(-(9-()4))-(' 8(-)1()('(-(1)) ' ) // ) /(' (- .*( '(-(8(< ? + # ! #

+4## * !4 ""

3 3" + =((*)> () ') 3 $4# # #+ ++4

) 6' 1?@ @

!"#

$ $

!" $ #

% %& '( 4)/((8((+(*((-/( *(*)-(('/(-

(- -((

-(--(1())(

(-((1())/(-0 ()/( -(-0 '(-(/-()

14)0)1+0)/(' (-// /-'()-'/0)--- ),((- .*()('< / ) + 1')1)1)) /(' (-)( )/((8( (+(*( -'-' ( -/( /(@ -( () *( -(( -((

-(--(1() '/(-

(-(((1())/(-'( ) /(' (-(' ((((* '(-(/-(0 1)(-))' 109'-(('// /-'()-'/0))9)--- ) ,((- .*( /( ((((* ) '/ 8( 0) 0('(-)(-)/('

(-'-('/-'1()) '(-(/-('

('/-'*()'/(-

(-'/0 /(@ -(-(( -((

-(--(1())

(-((1())/(-)'()' )(( )0)/(' (-0(10-/-'*( ) ' /(-

(- ' --- ) ,((- .*((8('2) 0)//(-(( ) 61''/' --') - (++' )(0 1)(-) ) /(( '(' ) /(' (- & 4# #++) ) #**++ 4!+ ++4##0 32 #0 !

4!+ 0! 00 0+

"#0 4##

+ + 4##*!+

-#! $#! +4#1 )#+"#+ #!+ #&!.&+ !+ $%3$4!+ # #

-#.!)0 4# ##1 +!*"# ! + #**++

+ %

! "#4 $4# 0+

4 ! #1 00"#*+

+* 0)# !

4##

+ +4##*!+

# # 4 # 4 #! $# .!)0 4!+**+ +# * -#**+$# $ 1 0 )1 0 914 #1$**+ +" 23" +)#**+ 0 :! # 0 + #**+ +"$#**+ 0 "+0

9 # +)# # 0 + # **+$

* !

!"#$ % &

A## *5)

B A## * +