Mohan Goyal @ Soni v. State Of Punjab
!""#$%
&'%()" ***++%% ,$ ) -$./ ***+
!
- *0&#" ! &++%% * *)-)1" " "%! '% -$./* 222
1&"++%"" " $ 3" &.$34
5* *
/ &#$3 )+!"%$ &"")" 6* 7&/ &++%% 7&7!&37" & " !+$"&/%$)! " &6! "!$3-!& +"! )$/ ! !
8 " & 96-) ! 9 & / !"! ! $3"3$"4+"4 +" $ + " *
:" $% $ &$3"3$ "4+"4 +" 7* * 1&! &+!$ ""$ &%%" & *
);<"+%)"3& ;) &"%37" &+%"!+ 7+ % $ "34 &"!%* 1&73"3 7"%7 "
&" &$3&%'7*=&+%"!+ !&)&" " &!!$+ " &$ 7!4"3 4 &"%7
%"* >7!"3!//?&"&* =&&7 & +%"!+ & " 3/!0* $ & %%7*1&!//? %% & + &*)4"%!4$ &/?*$+"!" &&"!% 7 ++ &!!$7++&7" & &&%+ +%"!+ * 7&"%)$)&4%"<!&&"!& &+ *>7."" +%"!+ * 1&!!$"!%&"4&'%:)"* );<"+%)"3&!&!0 &"/?* !%%! "3 &! "% 4 &3$ &" &/? & %7
"% ?! !&
4%&"3/ !&6* *1&!!$ "% +$! &/"%% &4*);<"+%)"3& 0"%4+%*>++ 4+%+!%%++/$%0+!% &4""3! ?! "%%/ & &+!%7" &&"%/"3"4+" 9<)9*)4+%%@?*-=A:7+++ %*)% $7 & >>")"3&+" 7" )$&7&" "/"%" !!+ " *> & 0" +" & "!++ %37" &4+%%"44@?*- *!!$7+%%!& "44@?*-*> $B@?*-=: &$3&>."<$4*C; @?*-=:
73" /);'$")"3&*!!$7 "44@?*- *>++$3&" +%@?*-=:* $ +%"! "&+$!!!$%37" & "!++ 4+% % +% !& / "!" "3 )> ); -% )"3& " $ 4 44 @?*-=A:
* 1& 4+% 7 !&4"!% ?4" "*!"+ &+ !4+% " 4%" "!&%% 7+ *
1&+!$ "?4"$4/ 7" "" $++ * 1& 4 &!!$$)! "
*-**7!*>
" " &%%3 "%%%3" &"4+% %"4+%"! "* > & &"37! 4&"4*>7++& 4 "%7) ""% &$*6 4 "%74+% +37!" &!* )4% ! "& 0+%! / 7&"4);<"+%)"3&* ; ! &?4"= > )+)"3&* A* 1& ++%% 7 !"! ! /*>! &"++%* * =&&%!$% &+ "&3 &$3& &.$34 !*
-= );>."<$ & *
&7 + );:; -%"!) "< 7%"
&"* & & !" & "% &"! " "3 "*)4&! & 4 );-%)"3& "!" "3)>>-4")"3& 7& +" &4+%+!%7" &C)D&"3& &%"*A** &! & 4 > &"4)"3& 6-)'7 &"* !4+% " " "3 "!"+ &4"!%@?4"+ @?*- !&%%3" &!!$7++$/4" /;+! #3"&D% &)>-*)*< 7%"* 5* -=>>")"3& & *
&7 + > ;) &"*1& &%37" &;:);<"+% )"3& &+%"! "!"%7+ %%"3$ "'4 &"!%*1&73"3 7"%7) " &" &$3&% '4*=& &+%"!+ !&)&""+ 7 !4"3 4 & "%7 %" "%7 " 7" & !//?&"&*"3 &+%"!&"!%& 3"3
# /!0B$"!0%*> %%7 &!/7&"!&&7!"3&" & %% & + &*)4"% %%$ &/?*$+"!" & ; ++&"&"!%++& & +7" & &&%+ +%"! + * 7&"% +" 7" )$ )&4 ( <!&&" " $% " &"!& &+ *1&;."&"4" &+%"! + *; &+! 7" &;0 &+&"4 *>"!%&"4&'% " )"* !&!0"3; $
"% ?! !&! ""3
4%* &"3 / !&$4/ *+" /"30/ &; &!!$ "% +$!/"%%+4" &4*1&; 04+% "% ?! +$ &4""3 8 "% ?! " &4!/ ! &4" 4+%/$%0+!% !?! "%*; %/ & &+!%7" &&"%"4+"9<)9+ %++ &4+%%* $ &;& &% -= & "+ 7" )$ $ !"" *; 0" +" /"+!%%37" &4+%%"44@?*- *; 0" +"*
:4/"%+& 60"7" 7 !&"&" +%!&44@?*-*1&447 /-= +" 7" )$)&4*1&!!$%++&""3 $*; $B &$3&>."<$4 &+%"! " 3" " !3" &!!$* !!$ &;3" 4 " 6&'% & !!$ &$3&4/"%+&* 44@?*- 7++*; 7"4"%% "3*1&; ++$3&" +% !* 8* -= > -4" )"3& + ! &" "" @?*-= :7&"& & &7+ 3%$ -%"!
) "< 7%"*>&!" &!++ !6*
* "**4+%+!%! ""3" ?"! "% ?! 7"3&
D$%%7" &%/"3"4+"<):-)%37" & 4+%%":6*A 7" &"! " 3 & !0 ++ 4 & "! ))- &" & +" & 4" & "! C)D-$./ ))63&%"*> & & !" &+!%"" ! !" "*
3 "3 &!0 "$/ & "! ))- &" &+" &!++ " &C"!)!"!D/
&%"5*
/ " &!"+ 7&"!& $&& );-%)"3&8* *%3 &!++ 4"7" & &"4&" 4+7" &" %%7/% 4+7" &" *
* -=A;+! -%)"3& & *
&7 + "!" "3)> -)< 7%"* & );<"+%)"3& +$!!!$&'%%37" &!++ +%!& C46*
4+%%/ &"4* !&!0"3!4+"3 & % &+!%& "?&"%/"3"4+"9<)9* >% "?&"% &4+%%!&" @?*-=A:* >0+ &! ++ " !$ "44@?*-=A:
7&"!&7 /);
<"+%)"3&*1&!!$7+$ /&"/* > " &! ++ " !$ *>+C46* @?*-=A:+ C)D &%" @?*-=A:* ; 44 @?*-=A:@ ++%"! " +" "3 &!++ @?*-=A:C ++%"! "$)! " 6-)! @?*-=A:' !$ @?*-=A:>* * $ +%"! " &+" &/$%0+!%7" & "!&36-)'7 &"?!+ 4+%+!%4+%%
!&" C46* *!!$7 .$"!"%!$ * *
&&/4 "4+%+!% %37" &4+%%C46* >-4")"3&"! &"4 3 &!0 7 4 & "! ))- &" & +" &4+%+!%" & "! C)D&%"* !!"3%> -4")"3&3 &!0 7 4 & "! ))- &" 5*
&+" &4+%+!% +!"4%%"+" & "! C)D&%""" ! !" "/ " &!"+ * > & &!"+ -=A $* %3 &!++ 4"7" &&"4&" 4+7" & &4"&%%7 /% 4+7" &*>" 4 7!*
-=);<"+%)"3& & *
&7+ ); ;) &"*1& &%37" &+%"!+ 7 + %$ "34 &"!%*1&73"3 7"%7 " &" &$3&%'7*=&+%"!+ !& )&"" &!!$+ " &$ 7!4"3 4 &"%7%"*>7!"3!//?&"&*=&& 7 &+%"!+ & " 3/!0* $ & %%7*1&!/ /? %% & + &*)4"%!4$ &/?*$+"!" & &"!%7 ++ &!!$7++&7" & &&%+ +%"!+ *7&"%)$)&4%"<!&&"!& &+ *> 7."" &+%"!+ *1&!!$"!%&"4& '% :)"*-=!&!0 &"/?* !%%! "3 &! "% 4 &3$ &" &/? & %7
"% ?! !&
4%&"3/ !&6* *1&!!$ "% +$! & /"%% &4*-= & & 0"%4+%*>++
$ 4+%+!%%++/$%0+!% &4""3! ?! "%%/ & &+!%7" &&"%/"3"4+" 9<)9*)4+%%@?*-=A:7+++ %*)% $7 & >>")"3&+" 7" )$&7&" "/"%" !!+ " *> & 0" +" & "!++ %37" &4+%%"44@?*- *!!$7+%%!& "44@?*-*> $B@?*-=: &$3&>."<$4*C; @?*-=:
73" /);'$")"3&*!!$7 "44@?*- *>++$3&" +%@?*-=:* $ +%"! "&+$!!!$%37" & "!++ 4+% % +% !& / "!" "3 )> ); -% )"3& " $ 4 44@?*-=A:
*>! 4 7" $:
*-** !4+% " " "3 "!&%%7++/ & &)>;+! #3"&D%*>" " " &!++ "$ @?* * A* = > )+ )"3& +$! & "3"% $44 ! 3" 6* 6* *
"7&"!&-% )"3&);;!&3 -- $) "!" "3)> -*)*< 7%"+" +!%! ""3 8 "% ?! 4+%+!%! ""3 "% ?! "!% #4 %&""%0&*1&/" "!%7 0/;
* 1&;3"+" 4+%"%0&*1& 4+%7& >-7" )"3&
* 1$!+ &4"@?* * + 6* "@?* $!+ 6* A
"@?*
6*
@?*A !+ 6*
" @?* &"+ $ );-%)"3& "
%
5*
-%)"3&3"""+%"! " 5*
* C4 &/"!" "!% & +%"!+ &/ -=);<"+%)"3&7+ %$ *!!$7!4"3 4 &"%7%"*>7!"3!//?&"&*=&& 7 &+%"!+ & " 3/!0* $ & %%7*1&!/ /? %% & + &*)4"%%%$ &/?*$+"!" & + %&"!%7 ++*1&!!$7++&* 7&"% )$)&4!& &+ *>7.""+%"!+ *1&!!$ "!%&"4&'%:)"*1&! "% & " &/? %%
"% ?!
4%!&*1&!!$ "% +$! &/"%% &4* "%7 04+%* 1& 4+%+!%/$%0+!% &4""3!?! "%7 ++%* )4+%%@?*-=A:7+++ %* )% $7& >>")"3&+" 7" )$&7&""/"%" !!+ " * $ &+%"! "); <"+%)"3&+$! & "!++ 4+%% !*/ & "!" "3;);-%)"3&" $ 4 44@?*-=A:
* ; &+ ! &!!$7!"3!//? &"&*"3 &+%"!+ & $/!0*> %%7*1& !//? %% & + &!$"34 &"% +"%%$ &/?*1&/?7!&!0*; ! ""% ?! *1&! "% &" &/? %%
/ % ?!
4%!&* ; 7 &$!%% ! 9+%!&9 &!!$* 1& +"" )! " &6-)! ! * 5* 1&! &++&" &!!$&/
& +/ & "4 & "!"%7" *1&"+ 7" )$73"$+7*; &!"!$4 !4%&" ?4" "7$% &+!$ "!* 8* 1& ! ++ & 4" " ! 4 & "4 ! &+ "%% &47+$!/ &;%B3" &/ &&4"!%@?4"*1&&4"!%@?4"+ " @?*- *; & &3B$ " "3" " &+!%7
* 1& ! 7 ! 4 & !!$ * * + " "! "6*)** A @ 8* *
&"" C"!
+ 4 $4"3 " "! "
7&"!& " /%+!" "34%%!44!"%B$ " &! /
& "B$ " ! /"B$" / 0" !" " 4""3 &!44!"%B$ " .$ &+$$3! * !!"3% &""+$ & &!"9!44!"%B$ " 9*
1&$ &+!$ "&//% + &!3" & !!$//%$/ *1&"4" " &++% & 4""4"*
'
( '
(
)*+ & 3" =& &)+0"3: E =& &+ /% E:6