High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-AS/338/2022dismissed

The Haryana State Co-Operative Suply And Marketing Federation Ltd. v. M/S Hanuman Rice Mill And ANR.

2022-11-07Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary21 pages

! "#$!!% &' ("

) & "

*&+

',- $. "/'"%% &

'0 1*'

+ '

!" #$$% &"

'! ! ("%&" ' 2+ ) !'! ' &' " $('

* +

, -. " /!! (! 0% 1' 2( /("!% ! "!" '! 2 * +

% &!

! 34&"2(!-) ' % &"5"6% !'!

*' 3 #!&.%"' '! "'! &!-." '! 7 ",3

8! 4 9( & . !&''!! (" %! '& ('

+% ! - "! )" "! (!&! ("'&'" "%!& "&:348

9(% (!" ' ! ;" ' -' ! ( 4%%4<7 )&" ! " '! " ! !"( & " ' =!! ( !-!!. " !"8-! (2 :44

%&' & * 9"% " # 9 & ) ! /("!% "!" ! +

%'-!" !''&" !""'9>& ! &&!! ?

;""8(! :

%"!" !" !''& !" " '9 >& ! &&!! ?

;"&% ( !

" % '9 " 8!! .' !"! * . @% 7.' & " ' %"'! &!-." 3

%"! " '' -."!0!& % &"! ) "!'! %"'! (='! $! ! ("A %@&%1' (0B %A"'0B % (! (! ("( ! "C'%09% #) 0B3% ! "!! "!&!.&"8 (! = 0B3<%' & = 0B3<# "!"!. = 0B3<0

&"! &"'! %"' & " ! 3 3 0 "! " " " - 9 "8 " . - 9 -. " '! &'"!. (!"DA& 39"%"!'

" (' ! "!"8"- '!-. " '! % " ! ( ' " '! ) & %"='! %@!E'09%&&!& A.0''!! %1' (AB %"= = A+% !"! $ "'% ! E&&! & @&% AB % " ! "! ! % " ' & ! ! ( ! ( - "!= A

%"9 %! &'"&&! &@&%1' (%AB3%"! "!! ' = 3 = ,% (! ( &!! ( & !' -. " & "!" -!! ! ( ! (% / ! ("% AB,%"! "!! !

-."!' -"&&"'! "7 = A,%A $%AB*% "'" ! ("C'-$%AB: ! . ! AB3% " " " " " ' = * = :% A %D !A' =% AB% " "! ! ! = AB< "("!"= AB<#= AB< "" ''" - "8! 8! "- &(-.&!! (" & ;"&%"& ! -.0 E ! ("! -."! "! ( " " % " ! 0 ! " !'( $(' !'!"'! 8!"&""( A! % " '! 7 " & "

' F &" -'!""!0 "''!(! !'!! ("'! 8!! (" !".!! ("! -."'! E & " ( & !'!! ( " '! "% " '! "! (- &! " ,".' ) "!(%"-'! " "! '! ! ! '" % " ( !G & " '! "- 9 " ' . .% "'! "- "-7' ;" !0". " !""!!'!! ("'! "-! F &" -'! " " 0 " (. " " '! " - &! -. "! ) "!

(% "! -'!! !""'! "! (- &!-."A!! ( "! " % -! ( &&! & " 0! % 8! &" "!! D" " ( & " 8! & " " " ' . & " " - -. " '! % !" ( " 8 !. & " . "!" " - !" ) "! =%"-'!"! '&" (' %8 !.&.!

48! %-" "&! "'% "!"%"'! &!&"'&'" "%"&%!& "& :34

8! ;"&%" 8!' & ."&& ! ( -9% "! "'( & 8! #!"&!%"-'!"! "!' !&" ! &"0! !&!& "."! (-

!" &''!! (! "&0! ' ;"!0"& """8"!"%"- !" ! - ) "(% -'!" "(""'! ' !-.".&""8"! - " % " ! ! "! -'!! " " !(! "8 "! ( "

% -8 . " !' ! @%"!0" (.! "". &""8! &"!(! "8"!"-" F &"'! 7 -'!" . " ( "!" " ! 0 " 8! " % " " "8 '' ! !(! % - ' !!""'! %- &!"""! !- " B!" ( " " ! 0 (. (&! ! ( "-!""& ! "! !( 8!! "'" "!''&( D"'%"-'!""!("!"" !0"! &"7 """8 (!

-..&!. ! !"(&(. &-- ) "!(% "-'!""! ! -. " "&&"""8%'&&%(! -..&!.

@&"-'!"! "(' "("" ' ! & "8 - (! !.% " ! """!""8""- (! -..& !.

@-'!" ' '' !! "-

-." """8! 8! !-."' !! ( !! ""!&"&!. @ !"""8"(!" &!"(&(. &- - " " !( !% " '! ! 3+&"( @"" "%""! 0 !.% &" -'!" "!0"!(".8!" "( "" '! !& '% "! ( - &! " ," .

;" &'&9! ("( !G "'.. % '9"'! '! ! - ) "!(%! ! " $(' & @ H- ;" ' 0 & ) ! ! " & 4 & 5$. &"6 #-+ %" / &$- "-*&+6 -+7 89:99 F & " &" -'! " ! &"'! "! (- &!-. "! %" 0 " !(". ' " ! ! " ( ! &"% "- -."'! !"("8 !.& " . ! ! & '!! ( & " ' . "& @&"-'!"!"(" "8 " -! ( ! ! " ''% " ( " ' ='! &'" !! (=%""(! "! = AB<%"!"5 < < 6 ! 5:< < 6! "'' =

@&"-'!"" "='! "09

&' " &&! & " A. 0''!! "! (' !( " !."8"- -'!= A7

) " (% " -'! " " !. "8 -'! (!" " (' % & " ' " "!" ! " - !" ) &" - ! "! &! (' % " & " ' & " ( !

% = A,% -. " '! 7D! " %"! !!&!.' ! ""!."8% "!".! ( !"!%"- !" F & " -'! " " " ( "(" " '. & " ( !G! % " AB

;"" &""8-(! !. ' &'"&" ' ' ! ! ' @!- &!"((.& &--%""8 " - -".""' ! "&&!&"A.0''!! %"! "(' ! " - !( (!" "!" " ! !. "8 " - -'!%" &!'"!(! -..!. ! !"(&(. &-- F & " '! 7 ! - -'!" !' % &!"8 "- (! !.%! !&"0

))&"(' % "!"!&!"' &

*%%<7&" &'!! (

@"(' -." &" ! ("

* ) '. - % " % " " '! &! 3

"'.%"09( !G "&% " !'! . ! & " '! % " " ! &"'' ! ( ;"!0& "'! - 7'! '"! !&"( !

-. " '!

"(" (! % " ! & * . " =! ,

%"% " '! " - &! . ! " ;" ! " '! % " '! "(='! $! ! ("A @&%0B %"! "! 7='! ! """ = %"!"" -" ".&""8%"!"&!-."'! "!'& &!! (&"'! @'!"&" "".& ""8= % "- ' ! @"" 9 ."! (-"!(! '' @&"""" "!. &' @&% "9% "!! ( "!' &! " '! @&"""(" ! "- ! "! &&!"'! %-"' @"&" """&!'!

-"&&"@&%1' 2( "9! ( "&A!! (%@&%1' 2( ) " ' ! 3 3 0 % "" (' "- ! - " "'! ! ". +7 "!'"'!

"9 DA& 39" (!" "8&'" !.% "!""" '!% -!-'!! ( "" ' ! ((! " """" '' &( &-! " '! ! & ! ("-!! ! (. ! (- "!% "&!"! '! AB % @! E'% 09 &' " &&! & A. 0''!! %1' 2(""' = "82 :44

A+

!'!.% AB % !"! $ "'% ! E&&!% ! " &&!&@&%! "!' "" ' A7 A7

%! ! ("! (- "! AB3% "9 % ! % &' &&! & @& = 3A ,%"&'""&"" !'" - &! -. " (! " '! & "!" " -!! ! ( ! ( AB, / ! (" % " ! "! ! % " !

% = A,% -. " '! " 7 ;"D !=%ABA %("!! ! % = AB7<%"!"" 7 >D' " '! && & " -! %"! ! ! E! ! ) ;" ! ( H 7:7 H ! ( " !(! "8 = ="!-! 3

3 "

- ! -8 " ="!-!! & " " ! & "! "8 " &!% "!" ' '! ! ! " !(! "8 !

% " !(! "8 = ="!-! 3

3! ' ! ! 8 ! " ! = ="!-! 3

= A7 ="!-!

3 "&! )) ;" !(! ! ( ! " ! ! '9H#H&''= 07 ! < < H%"!""- ! " ! ( H:< < H -. . & & !! ? ;"!0"!!'!! ("'! -! (' "- 7 >

) " " ( ! -. '!

7 7 "(" (! % ! & "!"

7 "!" = 0, = 0* !& " ! & " '! "(" !-"&&"( ! -. '! " 7 7 -. " !"'! (-!(! "!& *.!

!,7

-&&!! ( " '! ;" '! ! " "&!-.'! 37

& "! 9 ( !G " '! 37

!& !'! .! &'! "'. '' ! ( (! " ' . .

;"! -! ( " " " '! ! " " - & ' &!! ( ! !' '$! (! & " && ! 8! ! -! ( &&! " '! ! " -!'!

"! ) ! $(' & @ H- $- @. @!("0! ! ). "

) #+ &! )) ;% %+ '"-/+

+'9<=9 >9 ?99"! ' &!! ( & '! -. . ' !" " & & '! -! (8"-.@ H- $- @. @!("0

@% & " '! " ! $(' & @ H- ' 0 & ) ! ! !

) -- !&" #+ # & -- " 8:?"! !"- "-.@ H-

'0&) !""'! < 34& " ! '% " '! !" ! '!.- "'! &&!! ( '! -!'!&" "! ! @ " ! $(' & @ 6- 9" @!(" 0! ! .

-& );%#+ >

( &98:9@"!! " && @% "! " " ! $(' "'-.!9"! -.@ H-=0! "$(' &@ H-

' 0 & ) ! ! ! -"

) --!&" 8-$!

: " - "!" ! !- " & & " - ! -"

)--!&"8-$!

:" - " "(" &!! ( 9 '.% - ( !G 9 -. '(! -. ! ( !'! . ! ! ( '' ! ( "" (' ) " !' " @ H- = 0"""'&!! (&'! '. !!'!&'! '!. "- " "!"( !G !9 -. '(! "!" " - "!" '(! ! "! '! -. (! ( !'! . ! -.! ("'' ! ( "! ( ) !9 ! $(' &@ H-"-@!("0! ! *( "

)#+ >

98: +++A@ "! ! " - " -. @ H- "- @!(" 0 "! ! ( !" $(' & @ H- = 0! ! -"

)--!&"8-$!

: " " ( !G 9 '. " 8! & " ( & ' '! ( !G "! (- 9 '. " ""!!&"!"! " ! " '! " - &! '. ! !' ! (! & " && ! 8! ! -! (&&!"'! ! " -!'! ? D'"&(! (%!'(" 7

!" .! ."!. "!! ( &! " '! ! 8! % "!" & " - '!-."'! 0B I

"'! "&!".&"!" "8 -! (2 :44

= %' ! ( *%%<7%"!"- %"!""! "!7='! ! '! %"%! "'-"%"""" ""!!%""8 &! %""

I I " " ' "8 = % -! (2 :44

%' ! ( *%%<7%(! -..&!.% --! ( %"!"-.&&!!&'"E&&!& A.0''!! %1' (%"""!(! &! !- !" "' - " ". !- ! "! % "!" " - -. "'% "! ! !& - " !-!!.&'!&"!."8(! -." -I B ! ! &' 0

!! & & " (' % =

% ! - "!%"! !! "!.%" '!< .(!!! ( ! ""& !( "8 ! && @& J

*9" " '!! ( !. " . ! - < " "8 !"! &"@&I I! 3&"(' %!' ! ""!. -&&!&( ! ( !.! " !<

.&! (-&' .&"!-!(! " %!"-&&"@&<( .&&!"!.& ( ! ( !. "" ="8" - - & &' " !< . < ! ) !! %" ! "! !'!"-!-- -9 ! & & @% ! ' ! ! " &! ""!( "8!! ( "-<7 %"! &&!! &"' !! & " (' % " ' - " % !& .% ""!""-& I I""8 +

%"!"!" "'%"% !" %&"!"" = ! -."'! %"'"8(! :

% "!" (! ! '' & " % . "&%( !

= 03

&"&!( !"""'! "' !( !&! !'' "! !

= A,% "!" " -."'! 7D! % -. AB, / ! ("% % "! ! !' ! " "8 -! ( :

' ! ( *%%<7 (! !.<( "!'&(' - &""8 ' ! % " " DA " "8 -'! " !' & (' ! - " "

!!"- ' ! "&&!!"! .%&!! ( "!""D! "- ! 9(! ! "' 0 & % "% ! & " ( !

= 03%!' ! """8-! ( :

' ! ( *%%<7

%!&=!! (!-!!.I "'! &!" -9 "! (! &(. &--%"! & " - (! !% ' !. ! ! & " & " ! " " ( " ! ' "(" " AB ! E&&!&'"&&!&"'! "!'&= A7

I I"&.&." " - -."'! %"! "!7='! ! " " 9 " '" . ! E " " " % "='! "(""'.&"&&!& "'! 7 !

AB "' & = A7 % " " ' ' ! ! " "8 ! ( (! " "&"8%"!" ! " ! &"-."'! I "!(! ''"! (!" &"8 :

-."'! ! "!7='! ! "" '! -! (! ! "& 0B3%"# 9E&&!!" " "8 ! 8! " - !" :

% "!" &' " "8 (! = 0B3<

' & = 0B3<# " " !! ( =% AB% -." %! "!"' ! " " ''% = % " " - &' < < :< <

) !&"'%"&!" &"8 :

! "'! ("'!! &" 0"".& ''= -..& . ! %! !'! ! ,:& " " &&% "!" - F - " % " '! &! 3

.!'! & *. &'"&( !"-' * & !'"$(' &@ 6-;" ' 0 & ) !% ! " ! ! ) " & '++ '

#-+ >5 % & :: 00 3+%"! "!!"(! & - ! '! -9 " &" """8! 8! "- !-..&!.%! " 7 4A B"-"&&&'! " "&&& !! -&D# " &" " " @!("0! . 1 !&! K! L) +4 3+M ) ! !$(' %%/ @!F"!" 9! (&"D# " !!!! & "! ( '-& "!! ! ! ! ( ND' " &! "!!% "" "& ! " !&! & " 0 " & --!!! " ! !! ! " ' ! " ! ! ! " ! !&&H ! % " - "!& " ! !&& "

'! H!H " " & . ( N ) &" " ND " &! %&"!""%! ! '!. %"&"& " !' "!" " '!. =! %!! "& ""-."! !&& "-!& "!! "'!. %"! ! ! ! " ! ! - " '!

4-."! ( &--!!!! "!& (! "! !&& @ ! !- ' & !! &-!"! (""'!. ! -. . !! " ;" H !" .!H!

4 ' " " & ' !. " " " ' ! -. .&'& !! % - " & " " ! 9 " 0 !" 7=! & !! -- " ' ("% "!' &" % "!! " !! ! =! ;"(""! !- !! !!. "& -.!&

4! ---. " & -. "! ( & --!!! " " !! ! " % ! " ! ! ! " ! =! " '! ! -% "! '! H!H D"&-! (" ! !!! !- %"& . ! ! !' !! '! && E " ! ! (-! ! -."0%"! (( "!' &" " & --!!!% " ! ! - "!& -9 " ! !&& " " " ( - ;"&% " '!

4 (! ' " ! !&&H E -" ! " ! % " 0 " ! " ' " - &&!!' N )&&"&!!!!(! %"& '. . ! !"( " ! !! - "!'%H&!!H ! " ! -= ='! " ! ! & "! & @% ! ! - !! % !"! ! ! !."- "-."@!("0 ?

! ( " & & " " % ! -!-.% " '! '!-.&!"! (! & ! 34&" "! 0 &! !& " (! " ' '! "'! %!.! - & .'! ( ! - ! " ' ! -! ( " -. ' & -%"%"-! ('! -." !("!''-."'! %"!"'-. !-."!0 @ 6- ;" ' 0 & ) ! ! " &

D & -#-+',- --! #+*&+2

00 *4->D"%" ((& ! , -&" """.-! &"!! ! '"'! ' -'!"! ' "&" "!"">&! ? 0&"! ! 34! ;"=! >& ! ? ! &!( !'! $! +7 ) &" - > ! ,,&"%"'&!&'' ! ! !!%"! ("' ! ! ! :

:,0 F!9!% ! ,*%! !-(! -."'! &&!!% ! ! (! ! !! ! (% !" ! ( ."! ( ! ! " 0

!' .% -. ! ,% " && "!' -!" .! ! &"0%! 8!-. ! 3 0 ?)&"">.%(! " ".-! &!! '! (%!->8!7!'! ? -.$(' &"!0%"! "! ( (!""'

!! >8!7!'! ?-! (! ! 34! (& " (! -. .!&0"O))&"2(!- ) ' ? D"% @ 6- ;" ' 0 & ) ! ! " & # #-. 6 "

/"% -$% /

"# *"."& & #-+*% &-2 )"- >"!!"

)2 &" >>"/ 2>>

#"&

$ & & 2 3 00*3%""> ! 34&" ! !! ) ! ! ) !! !-!!.

"- &&'= ! " @! ( ("&"!!! ! !&"&"! !& .%"!! ! ! ! ! 34 ! - )! " "! ( ! ! " '! !! " . " 8!' !- "! '! !"? ) &" " >0 % ! " " " & " "8 ' - (! !.."' ! 8! !"! *.&"!& "! ! ? (! ( " ! -. " ! !"("!&'! ! -!!.&"'! %!"! (- &! " ,". "( !G "!

(- 9 "'.% !!!'!!"!! &%!. ! -. @ 6- ;" ' 0 & ) !% ! $(' ! " & D & $ ) #-+ *E." & %2 0!'

%"!.! (

" " /( # " !! & " @ 6- ' 0 & ) ! ) &

)#-+#"

" & " ,

00 ! "$(' &D &$ )8-$!

: "!" >* ;"!"!"!!! "!! ( ! ( !-."7/(- "!! & "!0! 1( ! (" !! . " , 00 3+;!&' &!! -&""7/(# "%"!" >

! 0 ( !G & && !"- ! 34&"2(!-) ' %

-9 "-!&'! &!-& "=!.&"!& *.!! " ! 8! - " &" "8 ! ' & ! 34 & " &' ! P %

!!)& K! !! " (!% "'! -'! "'! (! !" ! ("&""!& ' "! ! , -&"&!! (& "'! "=!P? :

;" &! ! -. (" 3* & " $(' %"!"!=- >3* 0 && ! 34&"2) - ! " - ''! " " !!! &"!" =!P ! & " 0 &! >'! ?

! ( "! &! !! % '! ' .(! '.! !! ( (! !" ! 9! ("! ! (! " " ''! && 0''!! & && ! ! 8 & &!! ( '! & 9! ( ( !G &"&& -! (&" !! ! ! & " ! '9!" '! -&!& && ! 34&"2) " !& *." .'! &! -& " =!. & * . &' " "!" " ! " - " <! '! ! ".& " )! "8! &'!.&" '! "!!&!-&"=!.& * . &' " "!" ! " -

"!'%!! '! '&&% ! , &"2)%! !% ( - " &' 9! ( ( !G & && ! 34= ! '! ! '! &! ! 34&"2)-&"=!. & *.&'" "!"" !" - "<! '! ! ".&"%-!.% ( !G & && - 9 " -! & " '! . - " !' & 9! ( ( !G -."%"!& *." =! &' " "!" ! " - " <% " ! "!""$!!! 9( !G & && ! 34 '! &! -& " =!. & * . &' " & !& !-."&""8 ?

7. In the present case, while the notice was received by the appellant on 8 November 2005, the complaint was filed before the period of fifteen days was complete. The complaint could have been filed only after 23 November 2005, but was filed on 22 November 2005. In view of the legal bar which is created by Section 142 of the NI Act, as explained in the three-Judge Bench decision of this Court, taking of cognizance by the Court was contrary to the law and the complaint was not maintainable before the expiry of the period of fifteen days from the date of its receipt by the appellant."

;"!! 3&!'( $(' ! "!% " !""'! "! "$(' ! " & -"

)--!&"#-+ # & -- " 00

43%"!"@ 6-;" '0&) !! "& ) &

)" ;" %"I 3 B%"&% "!9 -."! 0 ! 2! (" A !&"9 & - %- D$&). - ># " $-") $ -> %% ;"

) -"

) -!&"9"!&"'! ! 34! &! -& =!. & * . &' " "!" !"- "<"'! ' !& " & 9! ( ( !G !& *.&'"&!& !

" < " =!% " '! (.'! ! - %" %"'!

? ) ! "% - " " ! 0 " !(". " " '! - '! ! -%!-! (7'%"! (- &!

,".% !' !! &!! & ! 34 &"%! !-. '+ @! ( !&" "!0 "! ( !' !& !" - ! ( ' & &% "! 0 &! !(!. !. ! ( ! & ! " 7 $(' -. " ! 0% !'( ! " 0 8 .% 8 "% " !'! -! (-&&'!%!!'!

8' : ( B""9! (<

1<2 B""-

1<2