← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1397/2023dismissed

State Of Haryana And Others v. Raj Rani

2024-05-07Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Lapita Banerji10 pages

 



 

                                                                 

       !"#$!$%&' ((   '  ) ( *(*(*+,   *   )*( *    !

" # $ % "

""$"% %   " &&&&& (*(*-&$.-/-0#-,"1#&2.#!3451#"! 6-0 '

()**+( (,-,)  (.)/0(,-,)% '

()*+-( (,-,)  (.)//(,-,)  '

()+0/( (,-,)  (.111(,-,) ." 2    2  3      )4+(1-*      5 3 5   6 6 2   7   2"  )4+(1-*       7  " ," '

 "

2- '

()**0( (,-,)  (.)/0(,-,)% '

()*+.( (,-,)  (.)//(,-,)  '

()+4-( (,-,)  (.111(,-,) )" 896 2  5   " 1" '

 " '

()**4( (,-,)  (.)/0(,-,)% '

()*+,( (,-,)  (.)//(,-,)  '

()+4.( (,-,)  (.111(,-,) *" 2  2   ,-(,,       5  3  5     6  6  2      7       2"    ,-(,,      7  " +" '

 "  (.)/0%.)// .111(,-,):

 0" '     7  3 (.)/0%.)//

.111(,-,) 266 36 .."-*",-,,7   3#3 '; (,01,+%,01.+ ,01.0(,-.+% 2 5 5'; (,01.0(,-.+    

" 4"   5  5 3   7     3 #3 5 5    37   #  %./4+     5     (6 7   5  3    )-    27 2   3 = 2  ,/"-0",-.. 

9  (.          5         6    .+     2"  5  %  6  7 5 2  )46    3 5   "  2 52  36  9 '  #.-0*#&2. %1.!6575(*1-1!%3 4&8-9 %1.!65,  *:

3-   26  5 57 3 7  3  2 >     7   5      7  6   5  5  <  :2   2? "@5 2    2%

7  2 2.//*   %  > 6  2     >  2  7   7         6   3    36" /" '   6 76 2  ,/"-0",-.. 2   5 5  265     7  -4"-4",-.)7  2 %< 

22  3 27 3 %   26   3   3 =        2      5    %   %  > 7  2" .-" 6   3 

";

 35  3 =   2%5  2 2 6 2 22 2 63    6 66 >2   >  5    5 3   7  3" 2%55  35 '(@6 5  3 5    % 366 5 26 5   5   7  9 '    *1-1! %3 ;-6&-1-<- 75( ((;!5-6#, *

" .."    2   .4"-)".//+          )

  6)."-.".//+  3 3 = 5 (2  3 6 " 2 .0"-+".//0    ,     3 =   $ (' 6  5  3   ( 2 7    6 5  26)   #  %.//+"

4- 2   -*".,".///      $ ('     6 66 .*   2 6 72 

2   2  3 = 5 3 7 "  2   -.".-",--) 3    6 66  2)

 $ ('6  ( 2A2  2  537 $ ( 6 " .," ; 2  7 (2 *1-1! %3 -6=-&-  %1.!65 75( -0/#&$!6 *#&2.  %1.!65,      #>#0:"  36 7 9'  *1-1!%3 ;-6&-1-<-75( ?-!>#, : *%2 ,/"-0",-..5  65    7   (66 "<   5   .-      .-"-1",--+"        36    ! B.0"<   62 ,/"-0",-.. $ ( 6      2    36    ?- !># 54@6- 5    $ (  6     .-     2 .-"-1",--+  3  7 "<  2    !( B%1#3#"-1#%& .! 1.

40=,  %((*( (A%&51(A61(A (B@ 9 2 5   7    2,-/ ' @  5   2+ $ 6 %$   6    6  $    2% 2  C" *,)()$(0-A,-+4% ,4 #  %./0-% $      7 22 $ '% 7   6 66    .

5-  (67 7 3 =  5  % 6 !D < 6 A5    2  5  

    .-(1(,--+   27

  2      '  < 7 %3     2 "<  2  7  2  2  76   6 2  

 " < 6 A5   6 66 2 7 >2     6 A 336 "  <    2 2  6     7           6 7   7 86 6  3    7   A 33   7  266  67  6 2 '66  

 3 2   3    6  3     2 "   <    5    2 2  2  6    7 3  2    2    2 6   2 3 7  33  6"  < 6  7 3 =3  

2   23 "  62 2 2 26     E      2  77  6 6  2 "   2  73  7 2  $ 6   2 5    "   C 9     2     5  7    7 5" ,"    6 6   3 2   6   7   7 3 = 3     2  6   623 "F .)"   %     "*,  *)    36    G6

  %   7          2    3 = %  5 7  3    27 3 " @       2 26 2%  3 6  7"    36    !

6B*,"C 6 %5 3  7 2 6  6   2 2 % 5 6 6  2 6  %    6 %7 7 6    6   2    5  6  2  " @  9% >  5   6 627      2    "     2 %  5 7       2  ' E  '  "   E  "< $ 3E  C  '3H./+,",'.11I"< 2    6 5         223"  '             6 6 6    26   6 3%67 5  6  3             33     3 3        2"<  22   6 62 7    6  2 3 6 6 6  6   2   6  2

  5       27 3 3   7  6  7 7       3 6 6 6 " *)":

2 72 "<  6 725    3  6  3 6 9  "" C    % "C" C    %   E"C" C3   %     3  .

76  6 ";2   3 = %

  6%7 72%  7  7  36 % 7      7      7  3    > 6   3 = 3 6 3 6 %      2 2 6"F .1"          2  5  5     2   3   5  " 36  C   26 3 6 6 567 ' E G6  2" 9' 5      2  67  22 2 7  6 %5  35 2 3 =  2 2:2 "     36    ! B./"'6 3 36   7  3 '   7        C",-/  .

//, 5     26   3 =     6       5  2  3      3  2          7   3 =    2% 3 ' 6 72  3  2     3  2    3  5  2 6              5  6"5  %  2 2  2  "< 2     2     3      2    6  92   5         " <         2   2  7 2   6  6      2  32  2     6    7     9 2    5   7    2  .

     2 7 5   7   6  %5   2  3 3 6     7 32  3  " ,-"C7 5   2 .0 6  6 93 22 6  %2 %   7 25  

8-

 6 927    "<   % 63 

   3 2  3  2   6 " ,."E5 

2    2    6    2 3 67     2      7 7  "   6  "   2   6 7   2 2 2 2   7  6   6 " ,,"< > 5    2 2 26   7 2  7 7     2    6 72  5 ' E 2   2  G6 J2"< 5  > %  2  G6 J2 > 796 "@ 2% '  5 2   3   3     2          3   3  6 5    2  26 5    6  2 2 67 ' " B1"< G  % %   6    6    3  6 %2   5   3   2% 5    2               6   2  3  72 2'66    5         6    3           2   53%2       % %  3 5  >   2 2    6    26  "@      5  3 6 % 5    5 3   3   2   3 72    53% 2 2 % 3 2 6 6 6       3  2 6  2 2 "< 2   5  32 6  22      3  26 6 7 3 6   62%  2 3% 3  6     77 7  2"26 6 5 2   72B3 6 6 F%        9    6  3  2 6"2      9 2 55    2,,+ ' ";

   5 5    2,,+ '    7    2       2 2  2 2   >     %72 6 2 6 72

9- 6 6   23  7    ' %   7       "F .*"  2%   5     5     2  6 ./4+  5  63   5 ,-.)%  3 6  52   2"< 92  6 5 66   5 (2     7  2  3  6 

     2"@ *.!%-6-#&-2-675(*1-1!%3

11-6 6-$!5., C*  5 27 9'   $ 6 56    36  G6

 "@ -8&#5.;4?-6#5.6-75(*1-1!%3 11-6 6-$!5.,   *: C%5   3 =    7 5  5   .,  % 9'  2  3 =  3 5  3  2       7   3 =  2   7 5  5 "@ *1-1!%3.-6<.-&$75(;-?-0 6-5-$,   *

%6 5  5  ,/  #  8 3  5  3 7 7 9'  5 6  5 2     92 6 G6   " .+" 2 5     6)-    2%572 3    5 7   6      %  35 7      6 "< 9'     2E5      'C"//+*(//01 ,-.+    

 

   -/"-.",-,1 5   3 5  7   2   3  3 =   7 ' "

10- .0" '    36 9 '  &#%&%3&$#- %1.!6575(0?%!># -&%1.!6,    *  "         36  5 3     5     5  3 = 2 2 2  '  2

   6 6    2       2

 7   2  6  6 " 2% 2    7 73   6     2    "@ 5 ,-..2 26 3  2   36  G6  % 5     7  3    2  7   3 = " @  2 2 26 2% 36   7 ' 5  727 2 2   2 5  6 62 7%5 7 27 ' E G6  " .4" @ 2 2 26 2%5  2          3#3.."-*",-,,    6

 6 "<   6    "@      7  3 =   3      6 "   %          7 6"  32  6" (*(*+   *  ((           ;

   3A  !

K ;

   7! K