Avtar Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&,
- .$#/ 0*,12 ------ %$*$*&,%/
3%/+4+ 0$#$% 4,5#6 &$2%/+ ------
%+7&,(%,$+
8 9
0 0
/%+%,$ /- -:-0- 2&&;<#=
(.&)#$% 7%$*$*&,%/-
/- */>#;5*$ 0*,12 !*?#,#= 0%,*&/ ! 4,5#6-
- - 0 =
9
- %$*$*&,%/
.$#/ 0*,12 '*;%( 4,(%/ /$*);% &,+$*$4$*&, ,(*#= *,$%/ #;*#= +%%<*,1 # ,#$4/% )%/$*&/#/* +%$$*,1 #+*(% &/(%/ (#$%(
-
,,%@4/% = 7#++%( &;;%)$&/= 94(2*#,#
+2&/$ 8&;;%)$&/8= ?2%/%6A
#/(%%7 0*,12 #77&*,$%( .*;;#1% :#&,<% :#;#,= %2+*;
#1/#&,= !*+$/*)$ 94(2*#,#-
-
'4/$2%/ 7/#A%/ >#(% +%$$*,1 #+*(% &/(%/ (#$%( -
,,%@4/% = 7#++%( &>>*++*&,%/= #$*#;# !*.*+*&,= #$*#;#
+2&/$ 8!*.*+*&,#;
&>>*++*&,%/8 &/(%/ (#$%( --
,,%@4/% = 7#++%(
&>>*++*&,%/
77%#;+= 4,5#6
+2&/$ &>>*++*&,%/8= ?2%/%6A #77%#;
/%.*+*&,= 7/%'%//%( 7%$*$*&,%/= (*+>*++%(= /%+7%)$*.%;A-
- /*%';A= &, (%>*+% 02/* :%2#/ 0*,12= 7/%.*&4+
0 .*;;#1% :#&,<% :#;#,= %2+*;
#1/#&,= !*+$/*)$ 94(2*#,#= 7/&)%%(*,1+ ?%/% *,*$*#$%( '*;;*,1 #'&/%+#*( .#)#,)A= ?2%/%*, 7%$*$*&,%/
.$#/ 0*,12
#/(%%7 0*,12 ?%/% )#,(*(#$%+-
2% %2+*;(#/=
#1/#&,= /%)&>>%,(%( )#,(*(#$4/% #77&*,$>%,$ #'&/%+#*( .#)#,)A= ?2%/%#+ !*.*+*&,#;
#1*+$/#$%=
#1/#&,= /%)&>>%,(%( )#,(*(#$4/% 7%$*$*&,%/ #77&*,$>%,$ #'&/%+#*( .#)#,)A >#$$%/ ?#+ 7;#)%( 6%'&/% &;;%)$&/-
- 9%#/,%( &;;%)$&/= #'$%/ )&,+*(%/*,1 /%;#$*.% >%/*$+ )#,(*(#$%+= '&4,( >&+$ +4*$#6;% )#,(*(#$% #))&/(*,1;A= #77&*,$%( 2*> 9#>6#/(#/= .*(% &/(%/ (#$%(
-
,,%@4/% -
- 9%#/,%( &;;%)$&/8+ &/(%/ (#$%(
-
,,%@4/% '4/$2%/ #''*/>%( !*.*+*&,#;
&>>*++*&,%/= .*(% &/(%/ (#$%( -
,,%@4/%
&>>*++*&,%/= .*(% &/(%/ (#$%( --
,,%@4/% - - , #'&/%>%,$*&,%( )*/)4>+$#,)%+= 7%$*$*&,%/ '*;%( 6%'&/% $2*+ &4/$= /%;*%'
+= ,&$*)%( 2%/%*,#6&.%- B- %#/(- - 2% &,;A #/14>%,$ /#*+%( )&4,+%;
7%$*$*&,%/ $2#$ 7%$*$*&,%/ +&, 7/%.*&4+ (%)%#+%(
0 /%>#*,%( 0#/6/#2# #,(= $2%/%'&/%= 2% (%+%/.%+ 7/%'%/%,)% #77&*,$>%,$ 7&+$ 9#>6#/(#/-
- )&,+*(%/%( #/14>%,$ /#*+%( )&4,+%;
7%$*$*&,%/= 2&?%.%/= (& ,&$ '*,( #,A >%/*$ +#>%-
2% 2%/%(*$#/A
);#*> >#$$%/ #77&*,$>%,$ #;/%#(A 2%;( 6% 4;$/# .*/%+ &,+$*$4$*&, # !*.*+*&, %,)2 $2*+ &4/$ 8
.%, 7/%'%/%,)% # )#,(*(#$% &, 1/&4,( $2#$ 2% /%>#*,%( # 0#/6#/#2 ?&4;( $#,$#>&4,$ 1*.% 7/%'%/%,)% 2%/%(*$#/A );#*>= 2%;( !*.*+*&, %,)2 $2*+ &4/$ )#+% !"
#
$%$& '()*)&*+(' -
7%/4+%( &/(%/+ 7#++%( &;;%)$&/ ?%;;
!*.*+*&,#;
&>>*++*&,%/
&>>*++*&,%/- ;;
)&4/$+ 6%;&?
)&,)4//%,$;A '&4,( # 6%$$%/ +4*$#6;% )#,(*(#$% #77&*,$>%,$ 7&+$ *,#+>4)2 $2#$ 2% A&4,1%/ #1% >&/% %(4)#$%( $2#, 7%$*$*&,%/- $ ?%;;
+%$$;%( $2#$ >#$$%/ #77&*,$>%,$ 9#>6#/(#/= )2&*)% &;;%)$&/ )#,,&$ 6% ;*12$;A +%$ #+*(%= %.%, *'
$?& .*%?+ #/% 7&++*6;%= 4,;%++ $2%/% #,A 7#$%,$ *;;%1#;*$A &/ 7%/.%/+*$A $2%/%*,-
%)%,$;A= &,C6;% !*.*+*&, %,)2 $2*+ &4/$ 9 $*$;%( ,- +
#
= (%)*(%( &,
- - &6+%/.%( 4,(%/
.
/"
#
$% &0( )*) &*+( !
"#
1*""
#
$
$2-D
B
- &,+*(%/*,1 $&$#;*$A )*/)4>+$#,)%+= '*,(*,1 ,& )&>7%;;*,1 /%#+&,+ *,$%/'%/% *>741,%( &/(%/+ '*,(*,1 ,& >%/*$= #))&/(*,1;A (*+>*++%(-
%,(*,1 #77;*)#$*&,
+= *'
#,A= +2#;;
+$#,( );&+%(-
0
!
-
+5<+ 2%$2%/ +7%#<*,1/%#+&,%(
"%+
& 2%$2%/ /%7&/$#6;% "%+
&