High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4719/2014dismissed

Diwan Singh v. Krishna And ORS

2017-07-24Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi10 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

( ) * +*,

+*, * !

!

"" !"

" !

# ! # "

! # ! !#

$% & '(()

# "

# "

! # ! !#

'* $ '($* " !

!#

!

+

"

! , '# ! !# - !

./!0#

# !

# ! /!

" "

! 1!

" 2 3

, $'

, 4$'

# #"

/!# 3 /!#2 # -

" " 3

#

! -

/!

-

# - # - !

# # - # "

# /!# 3 # !

"# # #"

/!# ! # !

" !

3

! #

# $6& !

4$( '6&

!

$47) ! # #!, $)4 $$ $44$ !

, &$( $% $44( !2

! #

# 7 3 #

!

# !

"

-

"!

!

!

# # #

# /!# 3

!

# #

&8 "

3

, $'

!

, &8

'% '

$44$ !, $8$44$ 2 !#

!#

!#

!

!

# $(( "!

# 5

9!

# ! # # 2

! 3

, &8 !

, $' - 5 -

5 $6*

3

9!

# # ! !#

'% '

$44$ !, $8$44$#!, $)&$)4 !" "! ! 3

464) -

#

! -

!

!

#!, $)&$)4 !#

'% '

$44$ ! " "

"

!

3

, $ '4"

# "

464) ! !

"

##2

!

!

:

# # # "

; # !# !

- $ <

!

9! = ; '

< !

"

" "

-

/>0 -

5 =; & <

, $( # #"

/>0# =; * < ? # !

# !

!

! # - ! $6&

=; <

'% '

$44$! "!

=; ) < # =3

=; % < !#" #=; < !"

#=; < !

!=; $( <

# ! " !

=; $$ < !" "

# ! ; %! $$@@=; $'

<

! " . #!" !

! =; $&

< !"

2

" "!

!#

! !

"!

! #

!

3 "

"

!

!

# ! # "

# " ! # ! !#

$% & '(() 0

# "

# " .!

# ! !#

'* $ '($* /

!

!!

!

"

"

!

+ !

# ##

# @ !? ># #

"

" @ !? ?

@ !? $4$%-$8#! # "

A5 $6$ !># # ># !

$4&8 # .

"

" @ !? ! # "

!# .$& $4&8 :

!

#" $48*-87 ."

- 5 3 ! ! ! !

#-" >#

# . # -

# . 5

"

" --# @ !? 3

! ! !#

# # "

# #"

-

3"

!

-

"2 ## # .

!"->#

#

"

" @ !? / @!

! !"

! # ! !#

#

"

!

0

"

!

!

#2 "

! #

"

! !

# "

!

# ! A # ! !#

'% '

$44$ ! "

"

! " !

# . 3 # "

! !

! ##

# ! !#

#

"

!

+ ! ! ! .! 5#

!

"

@

"

! $$ # ! !#

"

! -

!"

#

$% &'($% &$

)

*+

,, -

.

/)

$% &

1 +

,, (

+

,,

!.!/ $% &2 $% &3 +

!/

1 2 1

4

$% & 1

!5 !

!/ -

65.6 2

,, 1 .1 4

,,

67.66

2 $% &80(

67.66 07 21 12

9 :, - 2

65.6 2

,,11 .

1 % ;

(

/7./6:,

21 % ;2

,,% 9 11

<

6$% &=1

4

07 2 >,<?

@1

:

A1:, ( 2 ;

)

+ :

-

67.66 07 :,

B 4 .

1 1 + :, , ; 21 B

,, . 1:,

21

07 21 >% ,, !$% @/01

: /B

:

> *,,,

$% @/0 1

> ,,%

0!

1 (

1 ,C?

>C?

( $% @!0!

1

:,21 ,, - 1

) 2

D2 @

E,1

, , % )

1 % (

( 1

,C

>C 1 1

1

( 4

!/1% 1

-

) 2

D2 @

E ,1

! ! !

!

!# "" !"

/ !

9!

#!

!"9!

9! !

@!

! !

$(( @ @

! 3

"

" /B" !

# @!!-.!'!'!/#'0-!'!'0!'"1#-2&

*#3&14.!-/%'%!'0"1#-&5 $%6%7 89 !'"&1 !:!-%2& ;-&1""!4%<!-%5 =

, !# @

! !#

"

!

# @!

#

"

# !!"

: ! #! ,

"

# !

! "

" #

!

#

'* % '($% +*, >C:

C

0 =0 G =0