High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4794/2014dismissed

Ashwani Kumar Verma v. Sanjiv Verma & ORS

2018-12-17Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh6 pages

!"#$%&'($$) (''#

!" #$ % & '( ! "#$ & ((!!

!" ***** $) (''#+% )& ( (( ! $ $& !!* * $$+

* $ ,- & .+ %&,- + ( &+ /

01" + %.& .& 2 " !" ! & 3 &(!

!,-( % $,-& !.+ # 4+*2 $ 5

)& (( ! ( ,- $ * &&% +2 2 % 2 ,- & !6 $ +*" ! 7

8 (+ ,!-" & + &+ % (# +!- % ,- & 6& 2 !2 " & &( &6& 2 !2 ( % - 7

! # * ,& & (!

" & % & !* !& )&% % 6& 2 !2 ! /

)&(0(!

2& *& &+ &+

&, + !+$$ &6& 2 !2 & %

, * +*& 6& 2 ! 2 & $ -" ((!! 0 & +(9 !! 7

/(+(, :$+,-&6& 2 !2 & #+"& "&$!

2 & 2!

, :$!+ # % & &+ ;+ & , 2 -+$$ )& !.+ 2 +& !!% *

$3 9&&&(!

!$ ( <+/

01"%.& .& 2 " ! (& & =

9&&&+ &(!

2 ,!=6 / !

>& & .+ 4$ 9 !! 7

/ ( % &! ! + + ! +$$ $$ *!- (!

-$% ( $! *,&&(!

!07&& $& !*% & &+ &+ .+! & ((!! %+! +* & & .+ & # $22 + & (# - ,- 4$ * & 9 ((+,-& ((!! ":$+,-& &8 *+& & ((!! : 2 2&693 " & *% & !! & +2 " #$ " $ , & 9 !! 8 +& *+& (($ 2 2& +2 " $ +& *!- , &! & & ((!! & (# & 9 $$ $% &&(# $ 5/ &8 +$$ $"

7 % &$ 51 &8 ?# $$"1 8 +& *+& 4 #2 3(!

$&@+!

/ +*& & 6& 2 ! 2 2 ! & 2 2-"& "&6& 2 !2 :$+&9 #+ & &% +2 2 %& & ,

* & + &+ && !-$ * & %

"% +*& .+! %+! 2 & & &% +2 2 + * ($- (( ! !! & $! 38 & & # , 2(! !* ! ( # # / 1

5 ( ,- & .+ < %+!( -& #;+ ,!$ " !- &&%

+2 2 &+! , !!% !

# ( $ +!!- & &+ ;+ +*& &&% +2 2 2 * ,! * & !-& +$ $2 + + 2 & &% +2 2 .+!( *&(0(!

& +(( 4+*2 &.+% &&+,2 & 9 !!((+,-& ((!! & ,(# $$ $% &! % &.+& # *&!- + !- +( 2- 2& +2 " #$ " : 2 ,- & 0 ((!! .+! & $ & .+&+*&$: 2 2&693 +2 693 / $& & 2- !!+

$ # ,!

& - 6& 2 ! 2 " !!* 9 !! ?:6/ & %+! +& +,2 & !- & &% +2 2 & -* #& &(0(!

&- % !!

* ( -( $ & & "( $+! !- &$ $+2 $& %

4 # 2 +

* 2 . $ & 2- & 2

8& #& $+! &( "(+&( (3,@ $( $+2 9 !!?:6/ $: 2 2& +2 "#$ 693/ > # *&+,2 2 ,-$+! & ( " ( 2 & (++ $ 7

1( ,-& .+"( ( & .+)&-& #:(& , !

-!& (+:$(

&A &&% +2 2 *( -( $ & & <%#"$+! & ((!! & ( )& (+& &(!

& +*& &6& 2 !2 "%& !% &+ &+)& ((!! & $!

2:$!+ #%& ( &+ &+ & , 2 - +$$ ,- ((+ * 9 !! 7

/(+(,:$+,-&6& 2 !2 )(# & 9 !!" 2& 693 +2 " #$ 693/ % : 2 2&693 &( *!

& $: 2 %+! & && $2&.+% &&% &@%& 2 $$& !&!# : $ 2& $: 2 < ,+ ! ?*!

& !!%3 B?:6/2- * + & % ,+8 22,& %& $&8 ((2- * +8 @% %& ! * ?:6/ !+ !- & 2

& &% " # )-( #$ %&8@% # #$ 8 @%%&& # *& 9 !!9 % #2&% % % &2)& 2

!!% 8& *.+ 2-%@ &&- $ !!28@%

?:6/ *,-6& 2 ! C (!

,+$ +! * & : $! # 2 +, & $ !

$ $ : 2 2& +

$ $$!+& & 2- +*&(# &9 !!,-&% 2!- #(&!( ! %" 9 ;+ , ,-%% ,+ ,-& $ , (# ,- : 2 * &2 8 & # % & 2 " 8

2 $ & ( & 2- 2& +

$ (# & 9 $ $ % & & (# $ 51 ?# $$ & +2 "#$ 693/ &$ , &9 !! .+! & ((!! & & 2 $ ,$ , 2 * % & 9 !! + ! $ : 2 & +2 "#$ "! ( #

*& & @%6& 2 !2 ( !!-"& "& + ,! (#& &$ ,&9 !! & $ &6& 2 !2 "

& & ( )& % %+! & & & 2

-$ 6& 2 !2 +,-+4 , !> @,+ $(- +$& -$ % @(,-&% (+$ & .+ ,!

&& &$ ,&9 !! & $ ( %&2& -$ ,!*8& # % &2 "& .+& # *&!-$$!+& & ((!!

!(#&9 !!" $$ $ % & ! %" & " & $ $!

2 :$!+ # %& ( + 2 - +$$ & 6& 2 !

2 +$&"2+$&!(# -$ , $ $

* $ ,- & .+ 4$ * & 9 !! ((+ ,- & ((!! + !$!! -$! *&(0(!

, ! 07& & $& + + ! +$$ &( & , D& * * "& (( !

! $$ *!-

2 "! # *&( , & %$

E6'+! F 9&&( @ *0 -0 9&&( ,! -0