← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1491/2018dismissed

Malook Singh v. Pal Singh

2022-12-13Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul15 pages



     

 !"#$%&''

!$%$(%)#$%*+'' 

   

   *  ,-

'   

. -

    

             !     "  

 ! #           "   

$$$$

 

. -/'

"  ""%  "  " " "& " & ''

() *(()

 + ""&   ,      -  , &   *( '( *(''

-  " "  %     , &    &  .    '( (/ *('0 - "   "        

    " "       

1""    ""  &    2"   "   & 3/  (& " " & 45 (

 & &  ! ))&   ! '(/&   ! '(46/7(8 ''(6/7(8 '''6/7(8 ''*6/7(8 ''96/7(8 ''36/7(8 '')6/7 (8 ''56/7(8 ''06/7(8 ''/6/7(8 ''46/7(8 '*(6/7(8 7'*  7936  8     - -  

2   :   6  "  "      ;   ;8  - "     "& ,! 1     ,! 1     

  "  &     & ''

() *(() 6<= '8 "       "" " ) )( (((%7   

  "       "         &    &" (4 (((%7   "&  ""  =     "  "  "" "9( '* *(() > "       &"  "=     "  9( '* *(() >    "    "       "" &"=  "  & 

"      "     ""

? +& "    ""

 (9 (5 *(() &" 5( (((%7   &     "   ? '4 (5 *(()

  "       +      ""    &    &   "

 *( (((%7" & &        &       ,         ?

** (5 *(()     & " 5( (((%7

+  "" "  

,

   =     &         

"            &  "   '( (((%7    

  "  "&  ""

? '5 ''

*(()  ""



 "   +"        &   &   "& &     "& "  

"        " "&   -  ""  "" ,   *'

''

*(()    "   "&    -  ""  &"  "" "  -   9( '* *(()        = "  "  " "

      &       ""   "        

-        ""           (3 ('

*((5     "  

   & 2      "   "  =  " "  ""

?             "         &           &     &   "   -       &"  "  "        2&  " "   &  @  ""     & "& "     

 "   > "  ""  "  

  "  ; !   A

    " 

 &- 

2

  ,



>  ""   "     "  " 

1&  "  ;  A  " 

 ""  " 

  ''

(( (((%7"&

& - "  &" * (( (((%7    ('

() *(()   ""   &   & "

 (( (((%7  "      

     A

     "  ; 

1& (/%(4 () *(()   

  "=  "  

   - 

? ''

() *(()  "" 

  "      

      "                    &   "     &  "

 (( (((%7 - "  "" "          -   &     -              &  ""  "   "

   &             &        "    "    & 

 & 

&  ""        & "  "      "              "         &   "  (4 (((%7 "&      ""

 B    "  ;  "&1&  ""+ "    & " * (( (((%7



&  &"    A

 ""  5( (((%7 (9 (5 *(()  *( (((%7 '4 (5 *(()  5( (((%7   ** (5 *(()     "               &   "

 5( (((%7        "      A

?  " &     

      ""    & ''

() *(()6<= '8      "& "     

  "          "   

   "  ""

C   .    "  %"   

&   & , &   """&       &  &         "

 .    &  "           ""      "      "  &    ,     "   *'

''

*((5"  &"&     B     "    " 6<=          "   "" " "& "   & 6<= '8 

 &"

  "    

 " +   ?**"  "

  '4(/6"  ;  ;8 .    

0 " & 

& " + 

 ?**"       &  "                &    .     " &  ""  

       

" & "&"         ""  "    

  &  "     &  6<= '8+ "       ""

- "        & .         & 6<= '8"  "  & 

 "   > " &       

 "     "" "     ! 

 A

>    "     &" * (( (((%7   ""

"

 & " '

3( (((%7  "        "          ""

 C      ""

&    "   "    6<= ''

'* '58    "" 

       C      "    "    ""

.           "   &          , C "& 

1 "    

    & + & > " &                

    

 ! "

#  $   %  &   

 ' ( &   )*+  !  )#, -. /  )**0  //  (  0* #  1

((   ((& (   ((&

& ()*2$/ !

2#  34 - 56  )**2 //  ( 2*    &((  5 /  )*)* 0 ! *

             "      ""

     & &   

    "  ""     

   "     .   & "     &     "  ""  ?**"     "

 & "    " 

 C    "  "    "   +   ?**" "& -  "            "           &   &=+ " " .   " & 

"  



 " ""  " &     & - "    " "   & ''

() *(()    "  "" "

      & > "  &         7(/

7   /)**

// ( 22 # 8!(  . )*+

// (

+# $

 (  $

   6  3  '  '  9  :

'(   ;

      .,      )*2+ // ( 0#7   / ( 5  )*20 // ( *#-5  < (

)**+ // ( )0)#     7(7    )*+* // (

0   / 7    - , 

(  , 

  )*+) // ( 0

>    "     &   

   " "&   "     " "   +  +   ?**"  

-    1

"C ;&  

"=<.> -((='  ))*0

      

?**"   "    7  

   



 







  

 



  



   !!"

 # 

   

   !

     

 

$ 

          

 !

 



 $     %    

   !

  



       

 



! 

  !



 

 

   

    

  



 - ,   ?**"     & " "   "& =  "   &  >   

 "?**"  &=+ "  "      +%       "

 "      "

"    

       "  & " "           "   "   ?* *"   -     "  "     

"& - +    ?**"   &   " .

   

"   ?* *"    "        " "&   "   

    "  && - C ;&  ?3 (?> (!   37- 51  )*)$/ ! 

) 0  &"    &      7

       



 



!

&          

   '#(()  

       %   ! $



 & 

 !

$

 %!







 

%

  !

$   

 %

 

  

        

   * 

  



  % 

 %

 

%

 %     '#(()  

" %!

!

    % +, -   %   



 &   

    

   %                .



   %

!

      

 %    

&  



      

!    

  /          !&  

  

 

    

  

 %

   

 

 

    %    %  

'

     

 %

  

   %    .   %  





  

   

     

 

    

0 

  





1

234.

0 5

 3666%

   '  #()  ,

!



   )$  ,   3     34  7  

  

! & 8   9#9        #:  2  9#9  

  ' ;

< %!

'<:-($ =& , %  

< 9###  >)29###

' ;

< %!

'<:)) > !, ?

&8 * 6   



 % 5 '#(>-,

!



 #:

   

  

   %

 &



&            

   &     

!

   

   &

     %      

 & !

   

&  & 

    & ,!    







  *0 6  6!3 5 99(#  >))299(# 

' ;< %!

'<)-:@ @  &       " "         "

?**"   "   "

        

 "& ! " &  "            

      "   &                     "" >   C ;&  11 ( (  

2 +")  7 

 !

 

 

  

 %

 %

 

    %  !

   

   " %

  

     %  

!

 

!

!

   %

/

 

  

  

 &    !

     %. 



  

!

 !"

   &

" %

!    

 %

  

  >      "?** "   "    "    ""    &  "                    "        &       

  "  " 

 + "    &= + " " 

         

 &" "&    

 - "   ""    &   +  +  ?**"    ,                      

  &  

   "  &"   ""

    & 6<= '8=&   6B'8   6B08 &  6B98   6B38

   &  ""&

 "  ""     &"   

7=&  !   "   &" 

    & 6<= '8    & 

-  """ ""           "& "  

-  "="=     "  9( '* *(()    ""  &"  "" "    -          =  >&"   ""    &"   -  " "" 6<= *(8 1 

 "

"& 6<= '/8     6<= *'8    6<= ** *98" ""      "  """& "   2"                & "     +  & 6<= '8 "   "  &   "  "& &   ""

?      "           "

  @   " " "   =

"&      

+    "  ;   A

   &" * (( (((%7 "    ""

    C      " &" "&   &  "" "       7=&  "  &         7&  &   ""

 @ &     "              ""   &         "   &  &     ""   

  "+

  "

   & 

   + &      "  " "  

   "  <= ''  6   "   5( (((%78  <= '* 6 " 5( (((%78 <= '56 " *( (((%78  " &   & + "5  "   " & " (4 (((%7  5( (((%7   *( (((%7 !   <= '56 " *( (((%78  &  &  +  " (((%7

                    & " "   &"

      " &&  &  ""

-  "  "   & &     " "    ""   

          ""

          "    &"     &   "

 &    "  &"  - "   &     ? 3'*0"  6 794('7 7*('/8"   

= 7)  

,&      " *((47'( *('37') "  

- " &     "      ",  "     ""    

    "       & C       6 794('7 7*('/8"     &

 

&             "               "     "          "      

&     & +     ,  !      "   "  "  

   ! "     <= 2'

6  "&8 <= 2* 296 8  &    &     "  

- "  "        & 

        &  6<= '8     "    , C "& ?        " "  "    "                  """& & 

&

+     "             "              

      " &&

+''  

. -8       %   D%!    D%!