Kusum Lata v. Veena Rani & ORS
!"# #$%&%'(
*+&+,-!.!
/##'!!'%!'0"1#2&
!"#$%& '
( ) !"'
* %"$%& '
( % + , ----
$.
!/%012 3)4
)" " !"'
" ("!%/% '" , ()"1" " ' #"0' % " (%!
3 (45% 3 6)"')) ''/%"("!"0)
! % &"00 % ) /71" " 1 %") !"'
" $) 1 " !! 6% %)%!
3 (45% 3 "("!"0) !$" )73 ' % %
)" !$"1 () %% %+849:4+5 %73
' %" ') ()" /$6 (% )%"
" ; '"!"
" ()" /( < ! "0) "7"!"3 ( 1"'
7! !176 ) " 6&$ % %944=:4+5 ()%"
$% " (( $ !1' /!%7 ')%76) " '' %"0!3$) " 7' "%% " 61"
)" !) 7 (%
"!"0)/%01 % ' % %+5++:4+> %""&"! ! *+:= (:4+,73)%%%!
" "'/%0$
") !$736)"'))/%01 % '% %9+4?:4+=
%73%"&"!/%0.
"&" " 2$
") !""&"! /" 948 (:448 7 (("1% %) !) 7%" 1" %73)@" !!
/
) ( ' 6)"')6 /!%7' 3( ' "% " () %/1 % /%* ) !
""(( . % )"2 " "/% '"&"! /" ( %'!
" ) ) /"!
%6)"') % (/!!3% '"7%") !
"$" 6%
% %73)1$ )" %' *"*" $&"A$ 0"% /1 $ % 'B/"%") /0) 0" % !%% :8>4C+$% %:+4?+884 <'/%73%(% +$&"A$ %7"0D ! 6 ( 3) !% (%(% :*"# " "0)$6) 6 ) 6" " () /"!
% "'))3'!
"1% 7 6 " " () /"!
%!
""(( '!
"1 ) &' /'%1 3 1 &) ! "%" / 6&$%(% 9$ 1!3$
%%(% =$ 1!3$ / /1 .
)"2 !!0%)1 !& /') ( ( "% ! (% 9'!
"1%) ( "% /" ! 1 /"0 9,91 !
.+4? B3 % 2" 6% % %73) %%(% = '!
"1%) ( "% ! 1 /"09,91 !
.+4? B3 % 2" 6%
% % 73) ) !
""(( !!0 ) 7 ) ) %(% 6 ) "0 % 1 " /!
"0 "( " ) !
6(/! % '(/!
" () !
""(( &) ! "%" /) /) " ( ) ! $)%(% 9) %%" " ( ("1 /"0
7 /+44 B3 % 7 / 3 0
4 "'$) /"6 ' %73)%(% (% +("!%6" 1%3"0)( ') )) & !%) 3 "%" / ) %' *"*" () ! ""(( (/) !!0%) ) !%%% %:+4?+884.<2" ( ! %( 7"'
%% '/1 ) & "0% /)" )/17 1 #/ " ! &%) ) " () 3"%" /6 &) %% & ) %' *"*" () !
""((
(% = ! 0 6")%(% 9$" )" '"& 6" 1 $'!
"1%)1 !& 7)7 ("% /') ( 1) &" / 6 (% =* / /1 .
)"2'!
"1%) ) /') %!
%1 /"0+4? B3 % / ( /" 3&"% !%% 99,,$% %94+4:44>( 1
! "0 (& !/ 7! ! ' "% " / " () "%!
% %"' %"( & / () &% $
!% ) %%!"&%) '/ ! )3 "'
! " %(% = !!
C (% =* / /1 '!
"1%")6" 1) )&%
! /') %) "%!
%( 1" 6 %(% +7"0D ! 6 ( 3) !% (%(% : /')$ )'!
"1%) !%%<'/%")3 +884"( & / () %' *"*" ( ) !
""(( 6 7 0/ $ ( ! % ("& ! / % '/1 %"%"% ' ( %"0)$"! " / ) !
) 16 & '%/ '/ ! " ()!
%6 &0"& %!"&%73)&% "( ""(( ))%(% '!
"1%) )367 ("% /') ()" '"&!
% ) "
! /$ '"
" ( ) "& ! ! %"0 ( )
" $( 1%( !! 6"0" / *E
3 F+G))) !
6" " () %C ! % '"7%" + () !
"&"%0" % !%% :8>4C+% %:+4?+884H :G))) !
""((67"0%" %( 1) /"!
%73)%(% 9 %=/%)0 7 ( !%% " )"( & /H 9 G)) ) !
""(( "!% ) !"( ( %'!
" % 1 " /'" "'
" / + %: &%H =G))) !
""(( ) & ! '/ %" ("!) /"H ,G))) /"" 1 " " 7!") ( 1H >G))) /" () !
""(( " !3& !/% ( ) / (' /( % /" %"'" H ?G))) /" () !
""(( " 7 %( * "%
%1" * "% (' 3 " H 5G))) !
""(( ) & / %/ %1 "
! ( ' ( 1)' /H 8 !"(I )"
! //%" ("%"0 " / + 9"( & / () !
""(( ) !%"0) ')D ! 6 ( 3) !% ( %(% :$"$%(% +* %) % !%)"!
6)"'))6 /) "A% !!&"%D<*$%(% :1 "% 6") ) ")"!
% ( )6 >:5 " 544
==4 %$)/ $)%"% ) & 3"0)) ( " !!)" ) '' %"0!3$) /" () !
""((6 %'%6")' %'!
"0) ""(( 7 6" " () /"! %% "!%") !
") %' ( " %(/) %' ( 1 " /'" 6 %" ( " )%(% ""0)1( 1"("0
" ) " () !
%( 1 !" "0) /" 3 )%' ()"
! /6 / ') !!07( )@" !!
/73("!"0"&"! ! *+:= (:4+,$6)"')6 %" 1" % % ' / ! ( ) * / /1 ) &)1!3
0/%) 6 7 ("% /') ) /0) 0" % ! %%<'/% %" '/ % 7 & '"("' ! /% '" =+ () ( ( 3') 7 " %73) 7/ " /6
( 1%73)"
! / ("%"06 ' %%6") ' ) ) (/)7/0%) )" !
'# ("%"("'
" (!
/') % 73) !
""(( $)( $ " /'" '
70 % ) ""(( ( "!% &) " (%(% 9 %=6 &) " ()!
%6)"')6 !!0%!3 /') %73)1( 1%(% :
) /0))" D ! 6 ( 3) !%$"$%(% + ) &0"& <" / ' "% " ) ( "% /71" " % 7) !( () " %1"% "" ) !%% ( ""(( " (1/') !"% $"$:+4?+884.<2 ) !%% ()
6)"')6 <'/%")3 :44> ) !
""(( ) & ! < 1"%) '"7
# ) /1 D/
() ( "%% '/1 G*: )) / ) & "'%) '"7
# ) /1 D/
% %) !%%6 '"7%73)"1")" 6) %6""0 )
#"0 (%( +* %$7"0D ! 6 ( 3 ) !% (%(% :*"# " "0)(/)% %) 1 0" % "
! 8:5")0" ( 1 ( 0" " !
""(() ! < 1"% &% D/ $ %6""0 %@"%"
5 < G*9$6) $ (' 1 "0) % "0 / (%(% +* %6"))%" /% "0 / ) !%% ()3 +884 .<2$ /71"% .<2 "0) )%" /% "0 / )
!%% ( %$%(% +
) )) %$ &"%'6 !%73)%(% %" &)( ') ) "0 / (%(% +&$%(% +* %' /!% % ) D ! ! (! %' / !( %(% 9 %=" ) )&"%' ( '"7" /(("'" &) !%% %(/)) ) &"%' ( %6""0 %@"0"< '
7!"%/ %)"
6 )%"% #) % "0 / !36") ) 1" " () /) 7' %%) !%%" B/"% 7 &%/% '" >= ()%"
&"%''$6)"')) 7 % 6&$") 7' 1 ' %) "06" ) & %"% % ') '"7" < 1"% %' *< 1"% %) %6""0 < ) /71"% ) "0 / ) !%%" (%(% +* %7"0D ! 6 ( 3) !% (%(% :$"$ 6 () /"!
%$6)"')' /!% 7/%73)%(% $ )" !"17 ( 0/16 /!% 7 & "!
7! )1)/ $7 )) / 7! 6) &"0)!3)!%) !%%<'/%"( ""(( &"07<'/%1/') !"")3 +884$6 /!% & "! % ) !!
# (' &) ) !%% )1 1) !" !%%6
<'/% %0" %$) !!6 ' 1 * !!) 3
37 %3) &"0 ! %3%" %6"))" "! &) 1
( )"%"3" ' '%$7 )) / ) &)!%) )"%"3 ()!
%" '! !3 7!" )%6)"')"
( 1) 6
( 36)"')) 7 / ' % % ! ) !" !%%)
$) 1 6 ( 3 !%$6) ) % !%)!
%"( & / ( %' *"*" () !
""(( $) % !%" ""( & / (%(% 9 %=)/ $)3'
# %) $( 1)D ! 6 ( 3$"%"3 ()!
%"%" /" 7!" )% )6" )""!
! 0 / 1 "'
!!3 /')0 /%
( )" / (7"07 ("% /') " ' '%$) / 7! 6) & "'%) )1/ " % !
'% ' %J@ % %:>4++885'! !30 ) 6) !
%6 %/!31/ %"( & / ( ) !
%) !
!%% :8>4% %:+4?+884)/ $" /') "/ " $%(% =6 %/37 /% < 1")!& ' %
% !3))' /!%) &%" 3' '( !)/ $") ' ( /')!
'# (%/%"!"0' )" "&"(3"0)&/ ' % $ %(% = '
) %!3 " B/ " 0 %"0 7 ("% /') ( 1) 7 &$ '7 )) / ) &/%) ' '/("%"0) !%% ()3 +884"( ""(( " & !"%% '/1$)/ $&"("" /1%) %(% =" 7
("% /') $ "!6"!!(! 6 ) )&% ) % ! %3 !" %) 3 (% =1 3) & 3!0 !1%3 " )&% ( /') / 7/ )'
) & 3'!
"1 " ) !
""(( )) / ) & ! )!%) %(% 96 $ ) < (+44 B/ 3 % $" " %)1 ""0 " ()!
" !3"0& '
" (& '
!
%6 /!%0 6")) 6 )" $"$ ) !
""(( 6&$ "')%(% ) &7)!% 7""!!0 " (+4? B3 % (!
%$7 )) / 7! 6) &"0)!3' 1
6 )' '!/ " ) " ) 7%!"&%"( "0)!3 %' (" /'" ! &"00 % ) ( "%%" '/ " $ 1 ()&"6) $ ' 00 /% /7 "
!B/ " (!
6' /!%7 " % 7) !( ()
6 "0 3"('")/%01 %%' %73 7 )) / 7! 6 ) /!$)" !( "! %" %" 1" %$) 6&$) 6 /!%7 % ' 6&$7( "06"))1 $6 /!%'!
"(3) ) % " !3 6") ' ) * / /1
.%(% =7( )"
! /""&"! /" 948 (:4482$ ) !("!%7( )" /$"$
:4,+ (:4+? (%73
.%(% 97( )"
! /""&"! /" 948 (:4482) ! %3 7 %" % ( 73 )" / &"% % ( & % $ "$ +,4?:4+8"&"6 () !1 ')%76) " 7( ) %"
" ; '"!"
" ()" / / +,4?:4+8
G)) #"0C %HK C G)) 7!H K C