M/S Gurdial Singh Kirpal Singh Bardana Merchants & ORS v. Punjab State Co-Operative Mils Producers Federation Ltd & ANR

 



    
 

  



 !"#$%&"'#$%(""%%"

''## )"! *%+!,-.'"/#0+"!"1"2 %"

'     
 +"

"

 34#5/4% "

 2##5/ "%''##

"

,$%5/ "

!#&!%05/ ""'6



 *%"$!#"''#"$%,!$8 "   '-9#"3!$58"" /4%%%%8%''#$%,!$8"  :



'-9./#3!$ "

/ 58""/4%% %.!"%"%!'#;"'

*%  ''##  #$  $$"/  -9  % ,!$8"'-9%.!"-#4%/''"%% .!"'"9$%%''#-'5%8'!$,!$8 "'-9%.!"-#4-!#-9% '#"'-8

  ("#95%"%%'#*% +!,-.'"/#0+"!"1"2804 #05.%$"%%"!$%$$""*%+!,- .'"/#0+"!"1"2

.#1+#5 % &($"5*%#(#5" !"'!"%"!$% "#$" %  #    !  "  "/"9   


5 5    '"'#  
 :5 "%"%" <'"!85# 8!$


=5:5 $ !"#$%&"'# $%(""%&"$%%->
858"" %"!$%    '""  !"#  $%5  &"'#  $%5  8 !   8 +!%'#&!"%/"8%6

4'""%'

"%-""9$-!%89# !"#  $%  &"'#  $%  !    &   $%%-  >5 8""?%'#6 "@!""48"#"4"0$% '#54%%4-$'!"%"8%8"0  $!9-$50 #-$#04"-$'-9%'#-9 /$"?%%'#/""%##$!9 -$    #  0  "  %  '" 

=    :

  -9  !$ /"8%4''"

 ?%
,(" . (,"$(A"& &"8$%58""!-8"54%% 4$ B

 "4"#%"


'"#$!9-$ ''"0  
  '"%!""# $!9-$


'"%!"#0?%%'#%# "/""8%"'!"%"  ""3!. 2!%5 $"
##%%""$4C

: B#$!9-$  
 B'"%!"#$!9-$=B ''"#0  
 =B'"%!"%"
, ("4'-$%$%?%%"/4"" #$!9-$ #0%"
,(".

8""4' B

 ?%%%#! "8"9,!'"'!#,!-"#"./# 3!$ 3"

/ 5(#0$""""$%'# "8#/"$""8/$% #$!9-$ 0 % ,!4$"%-9%.!"

 ?% "!-8-9%4#4"%%
,(" .  8""?  %""5  %  '#  %  8/    ''#  

    8  8  !"$  %  '9    %  !  

 '"9$%%!%'#-" -"#%8"#4%'"  95%4/"% !  #  -9    4  8   

 ?  %    % ''#8/-9%'#54!-8%%$4" #0#9""%!#0#/"9%$-! %$"%'"'#!48?% !%#$%!$%'#-9%5% '#  !"    #   
   '"  %!"  $!9  -$5  #


5#''"05#


5?%#!" %0#/"9%8"#5%'#!"% /"8##$"""#%#$!9-$# 05%4"!#8#9#.%!2#.%82#58""5 4%%8%%$%-$/$"



  '"

 %!"#-$#0"'/#95%'#%49 !"#
 : '"%!"#$!9-$
 :B'"

%!"#0 *%#%#!"%''- !"

"

6 D8 "-4% "#4%
, (".

"  -4  % "  #  4%  !9  -$ #


5 5 


55 & 


5
 5 *#


5 5


5 :5  *%'#%%9"#"/"% 8!"8%#$4%"C <'"!8 >% %  #    '9 % 8!5 % '# # ! " "/"9%.!"8',!"8""

  $$  5    6

5  5        '!   ''" !-@!#956

5 #,4" 80$-,%%!48-""4 8-#?%%./#.!"(##0"""#,!" ""9%!?%!"%'# -"$%'"!?%%!4#-9!#9!%"A 8''"%%!4-",""9 '" /"#%""%'#4" "$ %5%9%!-8"%"#" $$4%%4
 B '"%!"#$!9 -$= ''"#0  
 = '"%!"054%%4

 %%$%%""#0%%88-"%*" 88!" B



D4% "%4%%$% *%'##/"% $!9-$0%'!"!%"" %    "/    #$"'%      :

  !'  % '#-!?%%""%#!" 8"9,!'"'!#,!%.!"./# 3!$ 3"

/ 5(#?%%.!"%',!""?% %'#%8/''#

 %! 88!"$%'9%!

 % !$#$%'#80%""54" !804%$-9%'#?%%E "9/%'"8%'#"'%0 $!9-$0'!!%$!9-$0 '!%-'#!%$#$%'#?%"" %8/''# =

 %!(# %%'#-""'#%"$#-$$"-# '#-$-!%'#54%4"%! 5"%"88

 $%"! (#  8    4%"4  *%      %  '# !"9#


5 5!"-4% "#4%
,(".8'9"9#


5 :5 !%"-4%"#4%%

9$%"8$##$5!%'"9"8# %!

B 6 %4"8#-9%"0!' /"!#$#-, !%#'"9"8#% !

*%'#%#"'#%4"8 6

5 5"/"$%##$%4" 84%"""$%/"8%'#

%'#$%'"5##4$!4""8 /"" 

B

>%%"%'#6

"$"'"/9 % 8"0  $%5    $$  ""    !%"A   8'#%'"!F ++

>%%"%'#"#"/"9


=5:5  #$4%"'"9"F ++

:

>%%"%!8-""F +

>%%"%!8-#F +

>%%"%.!"%,!"""9% '"!F +

>%%"%'#%/!#%'" !F +

= >%%"%!-",""9'"F +

#

D  ""    '"/  %  5  %  '#  %  G8 &"8,$%+> 5 '#&00"+> 34$%+>:

 3-"&!"+>

  % %" %5 % %  G8  !"'

= $%>  !"#$%>

"%"$%#"!#"%'"5%"# .!""%!%'#

1#$  $$"/  -9  %    ,!$8    "5  % %#''#%.!""3!$58""5 4%%4$#"3!$58""54%/ ,!$8   8  *%    "  #$    4%  %   ,!$8"'-9%.!"-#4%/00 %"%.!"-949#$"$!#"''#'"9$% %8-'5%8'!$,!$8"'-9% .!"-#4-%!#-9%'#$%8 -8 

$$"$!#"''#5%"' %''"-"%.!"%"!$%!#

D%/%"#"!#"%'"-$$ %"!$%%""D%%,!$8"'-9% .!"  -#4  "  4## "5  -  !'  '"'"  ''"#   ''"/"""'"#4 *%" ##$#9""89%"  6!-#@!#48!-%" *% .!"-#4%/#"9#4%##%8"#'% %4!$%-"%$"!''# '!"4"-9#"!#"%''##%%$!9 -$4"0''"'"#9%"4"'"'"$5%"

  4"#%'"'"85%#"'"40  5%"!%$8"%54%%%/-#4%-9 %.!"-#4'"'"''"'"8"- #4%$ 

8""$!8/-9#"!#"% ''##4%#"3!$58""%$/ !4$%!%!8 >%"D %          2"  #  "  3!$5  8""  % "%"/#5/!-9%'" !-8  8  -9  #"  !#  "  %  '"  8$    % #!%%"4%$4"$4%%,!$8'-9% "#  .!"      ""  4  ##5  %""5  %  8  4 "8

2"!#"%''##%!"%"% %"8!4/48-"" (!%'"!# %#,!$8'-9%"#.!"$%4% 6

%,4"8#-9%8%0 ##%-,54%%4"" '!6 : 4""8%"$" 

:

>%%"%!8-""F +

>%%"%!8-#F +

*%'"4""''"!#/

"  %"$  "$!85  -%  %  !  4"    $  % %"$%#9 2"!#"%''##!# /8%!48-#"%-#

 4%8  *%""5D98"%'"''#    9 "  !"-% #$#5/#  4## " ,!$8"'-9%.!"-#4

*%''#8"$#9





 (",  

 !"#$ %&"'

!()$*   "&#

 '# !+,

  "&#