← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4920/2014allowed

Ran Singh & ORS v. M/S Capex Projects Pvt Ltd

2019-03-28Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry8 pages



       

  

  ! !" ##$$  %"& '(#)*"+*,- #      

 *"

"%,./!"0, "!##$$  " +,!"10",2! "!.!"%"10, "+ + !0, "!"# 

    "    !   &$"     ##$   !+& 1 #45!(&"4$2" & " &  "

5'#"#51 ##&"& ! "1  $$ 11,4$#"#"5 ",2 !(&"0 $$2 &4 $ 7&  $2" 

 8!!1 "

59

 8!!"!+& 1 #45!(&"4$2""&$

1##$ +& 1 #45: ;4$!&#"1(&"

!    

  

   !"   #   

 !$  %9 1 ""7&"4  < #& "!!  "   "1 $$ "$ $ 1&" =. $ >1"$ !"  0> 0>

'#"" . $ ",=

' "

5'#"#51  ?

=$ $24 )& " "

= 2  !  #&    "  #$

"#   1# $1!2$25"5 2$$ #"

"1#"  "  

=

=2"!$50!" "0 !""#" ,2 !

 &4 ""

=   1 "2": 0#$

""#",    

,62 &"!"#$45! #$

!!  .$"   !!"! 0 #$!!52"#" !

 &4 ""

= "#" , #$

52 #" 62#$!#$

2 ,"

"5 2$$ #"

"1#" "  &"!"

#$!

=0!5 !"

,@!5 &"!"

#$! $$ &# !#$

1 

=

 " " &!"5  !$)& "1

!   "1     $$  2  &   =

=   

=0

      ,  !  

    !  &4 ""  4&  ! "#" , !#$

5 1 "2"@!" "0 !     ", 

=

"1

!#$

!!1& !4  @$$ " =0 =0

0 ?> A"

5'#"#51 =

'2!!$$4$!

B@!&2 $45!#$

?

+&4 "! 12! #" 5" "1!"  ")&  " " !$24&)#" #"! "1 $$2!! : 0!4

2" !!1& =

'!4 #"

5 #"#51 6 &"!"#", ($& ! "1  $$0)& 2!"  #&42 !#"0! #&"!"  !$" "2! !1#""4 ! $"

5!$$   ! "1 !$$   $$ #" "1 =

'2!!2! 1& # !! "1 $$2)&0  &"!"

#51 !4 1 @!2";"

5;!4  "45: ;4$! &#"1 (&"  ! +& 1    &

"  

 ' 

   ()  *!" +,+6 #"

0! "

!4  & "

 

        

 

            

 



    

         

   



      

       

         !

 !

 

    

 

"

                

  

  

#

  

             $

       

       

%

&  

 $     $                $   $  

       

 

 '

6  2$$$!!2"& " 4 "#" )!4 &@!   !#" 4 !" 1"$5 "1!&  #"&$"2"4& "1 !" ! " " 0##" !=

'2! 1& "

5@!2";#"#51 ;&$ 2!! 2"  ;"

  1 5;     4  #"#"$5   "& 6  #"     !  "1 $$2!! #" #" "10!2";"

 1 5; ;#"#51 ;!,4 &@!" "04$!4

"2 2!!1& #51  !,4 $$ 0



" $&1 6 &!"&1 0  !  "1 $$0!#51 21& $

"    ##" "1 ! "0"

5@!" "0!(&"!,""

""      !        #"  #51 0  !" "0  

  4

>

 A, !"20 "1! 2!!!,1 ""0 #",!2#$

2!2 "5 2$$ #"

"1 #" " " $$2 "   *$

5!#$ #$ !   .$"  " ! "1 $$0##" !! 2" "7&". 5$"  "1 5&!"5$$ &"!"0#$

! $ 5,  #",  !   5  $"   2  "7&"    4  4   45  ! 4 "!"  4 *$

!#$! "  #"   "1!

 &4 ""

=0 2 & ! 1 )&!$:2,"0&!

! 4 #"&   !,#$!!5!,",2 ! #$

 =

=

= $ #$!!5,!

 &4 ""

= 2$$ 

=

=A)

$@! " !4 #",!"& !)1 

!& $2!!&!  4!$ !  $$0!"  !#" !#$

*$

  , "!&! 2"#$6 !,"5 

=0" " !"$"  =

=  *$

!. # "

= !$

= )&@!"1#$$  "#" "$5!" 5"&  "","5 2 $  ?

@!$"$5 #",!!#$

52 "5 2$$  #"

"1!"#" "  *$

! $#",

, 

= A,

$2! 

,0! 4 )1  ,2 ! "0#$

52 "5 2$$ #"

"1#" " 2$&&!+& 1 2!!!,4 "$ &# 45!C"##$$(&""&"

  !" & $4$ 4" -"

  C"  ##$$  (&"  !  "  "$  &#  ! +& 1 # ! !D"&#"@!(&"! " &$$5"! "+& 1 @! "+& 1 "!"

!$#!  !#$

"# 1# 5 ! "+& 1 0: ;4$!&#"1(&"2)1 ""  !, D !+& 1 !$!: !(&"0

2!!& $"

5 ?0

'0>

'2#"1 4 2!" =0>

'2""4" & @! &#"1(&" ")1 " & !"

5 2  #    2  

"      0

' 

>  0

'

>@!&#"1(&"!$ "&

,"& +& 1  !  (&" !     $$" 2+&  

 !1&

B?0

'0!" "0!"$(&"

? 2$$C"##$$(&"!, ##$! "+& 1 

""#"#, @!C"##$$(&"! &"!""$&# +& 1 #45: ;4$!&#"1(&" ! % *"#" -  &#"  6  !   "  +& 1 0  !  &#"1  (&"  2 )1 !""#45, D ! D145: !(&" " "1 "1""#45!$"

 $E& 6 "0"

5!4 " & & "","52

$45!  #&"!"2!24&$" " " "6

! ""&1 0$"

 $E& """

!" & " >>=4 !@"  " *"#"50

2!!""21 45!, D !@!&#"1(&" ","!+& 1 !, D ! ""!"" $"

 $E& @! "+& 1  2!"$52 !! "

5#"! "

4  ($& ! "1 $$ $"

# @!"

5 4  !   #&"!" $#"

"1!#" "@!"  

! "1 $$ !" #&$ !& =

' !21&!!"

5 !21&!!#"#51 A"

5 #51 12"#" !#"  #"#"5 "#"  &" !! "2$$4 &$ $$ ,2 ! "0!7&  $2 "14, " 2" ,&" !##$$ 6!$!! "1&

=

''2!"

5 0!" "0$4$4

     !   " !$5    45  !    " $50!+& 1 #45!(&"4$2" !& $45!#$

!$$ 12!!"& !& ,2 !4,0!#"  &$" ##$ $$2 $$  !  #   1$$ &  ##$ 0     50  " # 0 ,2 ! "+& 1 

 !"#

*"5" !##$  "#"1 $ $ ,   ,2    !  +& 1 0    ""    "7&"    ! ##$ "#"1 $ $,  # $# % &

'

(    ()*+)*,-.*/01234,*/-2*5!

*-4 ()*+)*,,*.,+/67*!

*-4