Rameshwar Dass v. Rohtash And ORS


 

       




!

!"





 



 !"

 #

##$$%& '(

!$ !





#&   %&'() 

*+ ,-)  *, ',,- &
) (#*+%(,*-.%& /&,%##$$%& ) 0,%-.%& /&,#&&1 /#/2%#&3%4 55555  *, ',,-.

*

,  %##$$%&
%2,6%  %  ,%  /*$  %##%$  %7%*& *2#(7  8(72&  %  .  %&  !!

9  #%  :;  $% *&*.&  (7-  %&,%:%  6,:;  &,  8(72&  %  .  %&

!!

#%:;*&*%$ **$(7<=***>-%&,%:%,% :&%*-6,*.,*67-%7%*&&,*.%&,$%6%&, %2*$*%:$&:&%* !

  #  &,  /%.&  /  &,  .%-  %2,6%  % %##$$%&?#$%*&*//,%/*$(*&/.$%%&*&&,//.&&,%&8(72& %.%&!"

"* **$=(*&9

/ "&*&$%
 

/.$%%&*&,%&&,8(72&#%:;&, (&/ =, %,%- =-*&*%$=*=(:(7-%&,%:%7%*7 @%%$ 2%$%/$%:*7A,%/&&%$$%2%(*7!@%%$3 2%$%:%*7+,%%93<!
3>7%*2(2@*#$&*&(%&**$$%7

!
,%7%-,*$%*&*.&%&,%:%#%*/%(/%* %2 #.**&&//%&%$$7$;(//:;*:%$*67 %7%*&  &,  $%6  %  &,  /%.&-  :;  6%;  /  .,%&*7-  /%(  % 2*#&%&*%&,%2*&:**7&,*7,&/&,#$%*&*// %  #/2%  /%&  %  2(&%&*  " "1  %&  "! %.&*&,:%*/%/%*8(72&%.%&!" "

*.#%&%%.&**/%(/%* %2*&,(. *%$67-%7%*&&,$%6-6*&,(&&*.-%.&*.&$;%&, %2*($$%*%*$*%:$&:&%*%&,8%2%:%*/ &,  ;%   1
 3-  



-  

1


3-  !

!

-  !

1
!

##%&,:%*/%/%*2(&%&*%%$67%$*%:$&: ..&*&,*/%(%&,#$%*&*//%#/2%/%&4B %6*#*/@%%$ 2%$%7%*2(2@*#$&*&(%& %&*$$%7,%7%&,:%*/C*$$!4%&

%$7 6*&,&,(*&/#2%&*8(.&*%&%*$*&,,%&/&, #$%*& "

,/%.&/&,.%%&,%&*:%$/%&,/#$%*&*//% #/2%/%&4B 6%6*#*/7%*2(2@* #$&:%*7+,%%93<!
3>&&,D&&/A,%*@%%$ 2%$%*&(%&**$$%7,%7%-,*$%*&*.&%&,%:% , %**:%$(*7,*$*/&*22%*6*#*/&,#$& %$7  6*&,  &,  ##&*    *:%$  D#*    ! 1!

3  %  &, #$%*&*//%#/2%/%&4B :.%26/&,##&; &,:%*/7*&C*$$!4%&

 =%**:%$ (//%;&%&2&*/%(/%* %27%*7&,#$&* *#(&%* %26.%/*$ **$=(*&9

/ "&*&$%
 

 7%*7&,#$&*E(&*%7&%.

"
%&!"

"*,*/%(6,*.,*($&//%( *:%$ %##%*&,%&.%,7%%@%$%&%2%*/%(/%;%.%& *&,  /*$  &,  6*&&  &%&2&   %*  %2  2%%7  &  7&  &, &%&2&./2&,#%7&%.*,*/%(:; 6%;//%(%2*#&%&* ,/-&,%*8(72&% .%&!"

"*$*%:$&:&%*%&,2(&%&*" "1 %&"! 37&%.&*&,:%*/%/%*8(72&% .*%$67-($$%*%&,%2*$*%:$&:&%* %&,(:E(&(.*.#%&*&,%2/%* %2 &,:%*/%/%*2(&%&*"

"1*$*%:$&:..&*:%$ 2%*6*#*/&,#$&**#(&(*7,*$*/&*2% %/&,*%&,-&,#$%*&*//%#/2%/%&4B :.%2 6&,:%*/7*&C*$$!4%&

 &* /(&,  #*&  (&  &,%&  &,  %/%*  8(72&  %  .  %& !"

"6%7&7*&-&,/&,6%%$*&*&$* /%(/%* %2,*#.**&& ,*#(&&%& 6,&,/%&&*&%*.&(.&*&,#$&**#(&% &,;  .%2  &  @6  %:(&  &,  %/%*  8(72&  %  .  %& !"

"&,:%*/6,*.,2(&%&*"

"16%%.&* %.,%;%&6%.-E(&*7&,/%&&%2*&&,*.$%*2 :(&&,;/(%($&*2%&$;&,#&(*&6%/*$ &*./&,(*&6%7*&&,/%&,/%& !&9%##%%.&&&,(*& ,;/*$&,*6*&& &%&2&&%@*7#$*2*%;:8.&*&,%&&,(*&/*$:;&,#$%*&*// 6%/%$-/*$(-%7%*&&,$%6%&,/%.&,%.%(/ %.&*&/*$&,#&(*&,,%%;  &/*$&,(*& %7%*&&,%6*7/%&,(*&6%&2%*&%*%:$,

9
/%&=,%&**6%;$*$$*&%&%(&*.*$$%7=, 6%&,%*7%;@6$77%*7&,/%2*$;&&$2&6,*.,&@ #$%.:&6&,(.$%#,6+,;%$* %2%*:%$6%$ :&,%* %2?+,;%$* %2%*:%$,%#(.,%&,$%* E(%$,%*:%$6%%(.%&#-,7&&,*%2*&, %$2&,%,*,%*3@%%$ 2%$%%* %2.%2& @6%:(&&,*/%.&&,%&&,$%6%&*.#%&*E(%$,%- %* %2%*:8.&*%%/%2*$;&&$2&&@#$%.:&6 %* %2%*:%$#&,/%2*$;&&$2&-&,#$&2%(*7 @%%$ 2%$%/*:%$6%&%/*&,%2/%* %2&, .**$(*&/*$:;%* %2-*:%$/%&%##%%%2*&&,* .

$%*2*&,6*&&&%&2&%$%##%*&,.(&%7%,* &%&2&&&,*//.&,/%&%,%*7@6$76,&, $%&*:%$(&#(&,**7%&(&,(2:*2#*#6, .%*7.%%$#(&,*&,(2:*2#*&,%$:*%%* %2 ,%  D#* , %6*7 /%&  % *  #* / #$&  * *#(&*.&,;% ",#$%*&*//,%&.2&&, (&6*&, .$%,% ,(*&/*$:;&,#$%*&*// 6% &*2:%  6% &##:;,*6%.&%.(.&&6%#%;&,%&&,(*&/*$:; &,#$%*&*//*$*%:$&:*2*6*&,#.*%$.&,&%&%@:; #$%*&*//2*&6%#.*/*.

#$*.%&*6%/*$-*6,*.,&,#$%*&*//*&%&&, /%.&&%&*&, #$%*& %*&,%2& 2% *&,6*&& &%&2&2&,#$%*7/&,#%&*-/$$6*7*(6/%2 !

!

1
* C,&,&,#$%*&*//*&*&$&&,.$%%&*%#%;/F

 ** C,&, &,#$%*&*//*&*&$&&, #2%& *8(.&*% #%;/F  *** C,&,&,(*&/&,#$%*&*//*&2%*&%*%:$*&,#& /2F  * C,&,&,#$%*&*//,%$.(&%*.%(/%.&*&/*$ &,#&(*&F   C,&,&,#$%*&*//*&##:;,*6%.&%.(.&/2 /*$*7&,#&(*&F  * C,&,&,(*&*:%:;$*2*&%&*F  ** C,&,&,#$%*&*//,%&.2&&,.(&6*&,.$%,%% ..%$&,2%&*%$/%.&F  ***

$*/ &#&,(*&-&,#$%*&*//D%2*,*2$/%C! :*#(.*7@(,+(2% $@%C-+*,%+(2%%C"- =,%2,=*7,)%$*@-%6*&*7%*7*&D#&%C9- '*8%;=*7,- 7*&; $@%C1-=%&#%$-C*&%C3-%8%7 %%C4%&.(2&D &D"%.$,* *. &:(&&,*./&,#$%*&*//-&,/%& +*,%  +(2%  ,*2$/ &## *&  &, 6*&  :D % C
 % &.(2&D&D",%/&-/%&.$&, *. /&,%*7&,%7(2&%%.:;$%.($/ &,#%&*-&,(*&/*$:;&,#$%*&*// %2,6%%6%.* 8(72&%.%&

!!

#%:;&,&,*&*%$ **$ (7<=****>%&,%:%$*7%77*/&,%/%* 8(72&%.-=2&=,%&**%&,,%/*$ **$##%$  /!

! %7%*&  %2,6%%#&?#$%*&*// %$76*&,

3
#/2%/%&?#&-6,*.,6%%$$6*8(72&% .%& !!

9$*7%77*/&,*8(72&%.- &,%##$$%&?#$%*&*//,%/*$7($%.%##%$ ,%,%&,%7(2&%%.:;$%.($/ &,%##$$%&?#$%*&*//-$%.($/&,#&?/%&! &3%,%.%/($$;7&,(7,&,&*%$.(&. ,$%.($/&,%##$$%&?#$%*&*//%7(&,%&&, /%.&/&,.%%&,*..6&*7,&$;.*:; &,*&*.&(7%&,%:%%6$$%8(72&%.%&

!!

#%:;*&*%$ **$(7<=****>-%&,%:% ,%  : 67$;  &  %* , %##$$%&?#$%*&*//  ,% /*$  (*& / .$%%&*7%*77%*2(2@*#$&:%*7+,%%932%(*7 !@%%$32%$%%$76*&,$*//#2%&*8(.&*%,,% .,%$$7&,8(72&%.%&!"

"#%* **$=(*& 9

/ "&*&$%
 

 ,%/%*8(72& %.#%:;&,&,*&*%$ **$(7<=****>- %&,%:%*67%*&*&,($&//%(*:%$&,*#. %##%*&,%&.%,/*$,*6*&&&%&2&%2*&&*7&, .$%*2/%* %2,6*&&&%&2&%&,'%@%$%&%2%%$$7$; /*$:;,*2*&:%,*&,(2:*2#*=%* *:%$6%% (.%&#%,(&#(&,*&,(2:*2#**& %##%*&,.(&&(//%;&%&2&7%*7&,%$$7/%2*$; &&$2&%* %2#.(&,#./2&,#%7& ,*&%&2&.%,2%%7&#.(.%&!" "

*,*/%(,2(&%&*"

"1%&,(:E(&(. .,%7    &,  :%*  /  %*  2(&%&*  %  %$  .,%$$7  :;  &, %##$$%&?#$%*&*//:;/*$*7&,#&(*&/%.& *:%$ %%/&,*

4
%&,&,%##$$%&% #/2% /%& 4% 2%** #*/&,*#$&  %2,6%% %C! ,%&##*&&, 6*&:D&#,**,%D%2*@(,+(2%- $@

.  2-  //*.- %&,%:% % C- 6,#(.&,/*$ :%*7.% 9

?

3 "&*&$%
 

 , .#;/#$%*&*D"-.#;/6*&&&%&2&*D9-.#;/%$$7 &%&2&/*:%$*D1-.#;/%$$7'%@%$%&%2%&,(2:2%@ :;*:%$*D3-'%@%$%&%2%/%* %2*D4%&,.,%$$7 8(72&%.%&!"

"*D % #.&*$;, .#;/2(&%&*"

"1*%$#$%..%D %.#;/ 8%2%:%*  /  &,  ;%  !

1
3 * D , $%  .($ / %##$$%&?#$%*&*///&&,&&*2;/'*8%;=*7,- 7*&; $@ C"6,#(.&,./7*&C*$$!4%&

)%@
 =%&#%$-C*&C36,.*:&,C*$$%%8%7 %C46, */2%7*%$6*&/&,%/%*C*$$/(&, ./*2  &,  D.(&*  /  C*$$  :; *:%$  *  /%(  /  &, %##$$%&?#$%*&*//%&,#/2%/%& &*%7(&,%&&,6%(//*.*&*..& ,6&,%&*:%$:E(%&,&,%/%*#$&*/%(/&,#$%*&*// % #/2%/%&:; D.(&*7C*$$ !4 %& 

6,*.,*)%@
,8(72&%.%&!" "D % D %2(&%&*"

"1D %.&*&,:%*/%/%* 8(72&%.&%//.&&,*7,&-&*&$%*&&/&, %##$$%&?#$%*&*//%$76*&,#/2%/%&,%##$$%&#$%*&*// ,%%$D%2*=,%2,=*7,)%$*@-%6*&*7%*7*& D#&%C96,,%.2#%&,E(&*&,(2:*2#*- &,6*&&&%&2&-%$$7&%&2&/*:%$%%$$7'%@%$%&%2%

:;  *:%$  6*&,  ,*  #.*2  &,(2:  *2#*    &,  C*$$  %&

 %  7%  ,*  &%*$  #&  DC  9?  %$7  6*&,  &, #,&7%#,*..,%&DC9?

&C9?

3%.%2&&,..$(* &,%&&,E(&*&,(2:*2#**&2%&.,6*&,&,#.*2 &,(2:*2#*,$%*&*.&(7-%&,%:%6,*$#%*7&, *2#(78(72&%& !!

9,%67$;*7%*.% &,&&*2;/=,%2,=*7,)%$*@-%6*&*7%*7*& D#&C9/%.&&,8(72&%.%&

!!

#%:;

$%  *&*%$  **$  (7  <=*  ***>-  %&,%:% *  6$$ %8(72&%,%:67$;:;&,*&*.&(7- %&,%:%:;#%*7*2#(78(72&%.%& !!

9& *#$%;&,%&%##%$#/:;&,%##$$%&?#$%*&*//2%;@*$;: %..#&%&,8(72&%.%& !!

9#%:;&,&, *&*.&  (7  %&,%:%  2%;  @*$;  :  &  %*  :;  (#,$*7  &, 8(72&%.%&

!!

#%:;&,&,*&*%$ **$ (7<=****>-%&,%:% 0%.($/&,#&?/%&&1 #*&(&&,%&&,/%.&/&,.%%&,*..6% *7,&$;  .*  :;  $%  *&*.&  (7-  %&,%:%  :;  #%*7 8(72&%.%& !!

9,%##$$%&?#$%*&*//,%*7,& &.,%$$7&,8(72&%.%&!" "#%* **$ =(*&9

/ "&*&$%
 

 &,:%*/&,* 8(72&%.-2(&%&*"

"16%%.&*"! %*&6%($;*.#%&*&,(.*$$/*$*7/&,*(*&* &,;%!

-&,%/%*8(72&%.%&!"

"&, 2(&%&*%&,(.6.,%$$7*&,:;*:%$ ,*  (..  *  &,  %##$$%&?#$%*&*//  ,  (*&  /*$  :;  &,

%##$$%&?#$%*&*//  6%  ,#$$;  &*2  :%  &  6%  &, #&?/%&6,:.%26*#*/&,##&; %/&&,%&,/&,*#.%* %2,*.*.*7 *..&#&,D.(&*/%*C*$$%&

,$%*&*.&(7%&,%:%6,*$#%*7*2#(78(72& %& !!

9*7,&$;%##.*%&&,&%&2&/=,%2,=*7, )%$*@-%6*&*7%*7*&D#&C9%6$$%,*#& DC9?,#&/=,%2,=*7,)%$*@C96%*.%% *&  6%  *7,&$;  ..$(  &,%&  &,  (*&  /*$  :;  &,  #$%*&*//  @*7 .$%%&*.,%$$7*7&,8(72&%.%&!" "6% ,#$$;:%:;$*2*&%&*,/-&,8(72&%.%&

!!

9#%:;&,*&*.&(7-%&,%:%&E(*%; *&/.%&,%##%$#/:;&,%##$$%&?#$%*&*//2%;@*$; :*2*

,%.*&,%7(2&%%.:;$%.($ /:&,&,#%&*%,%7&,(7,&,&*%$.(&..%/($$; &,.%*,% %2,6%%/*$(*&/.$%%&*.,%$$7*7 &,8(72&%7%&!"

"#%* **$=(*&9

/ "&*&$%
 

 7%*7.$%%&*#%:;&, .(&/=, ,%-  =-*&*%$=*=(:(7-%&,%:% 7%*7@%%$ 2%$%/$%:*7A,%/&&%$$%2%(*7! @%%$32%$%:%*7+,%%937%*2(2@* #$&*&(%&* '*$$%7,%7%-,*$%*&*.&%&,%:% */%(/%* %2 %$$7$;(//:;*:%$-%*$$7%$-($$%*-($&//%(% 2*
#&%&*  %  %$  .,%$$7  2(&%&*  " "1  %& "! 3%.&*&,:%*/%/%*8(72&%.%&


!"

"%6$$%&,(:E(&(.6,*.,6%.,%7 &,:%*/%/%*2(&%&* ,$%*&*.&(7-%&,%:%,%##%#*7 &%:$  &  (&%  &,  $%&*,*#  :&6  *:%$  %  %*  %2 ..*7&&,*#*7&%:$-*:%$6%(.$/%* %26,6% /,*%$:&,+,;%$* %2,/-:&,*:%$%%* %2 6(.$%#,6*$%&*,#$%*&*// %2,6%%%$7 6*&,#/2%/%&4% %&,(../*:%$6,% &,/%&&3%&,(../%* %2#.- %* %2,%/*$ **$=(*&9

/ " ,.#;/#$%*&* D"-&,.#;/6*&&&%&2&%$$7$;&,(2:2%@:;*:%$ %,*&%&2&.*&,.(&%D9%1#.&*$;, .#;/'%@%$%&%2%:%*7&,(2:*2#*/*:%$*D3% '%@%$%&%2%/%* %2*D4-&,.#;/8(72&%. %&!"

"*D %D #.&*$;2*&&$;-&,#& (*&/.$%%&*6%/*$ !

.,%$$7*7&,%/%* 8(72&%.%&!"4 "%/&%#*/2&,%!3;% &*2%&&/.&,%&*:%$(*7,*$*/&*2.,%$$7&, %/%*8(72&%.%&!"

"2(&%&*"

"1 %&  "! 3  6%  %.&*  #;  /  2(&%&*  *  D  % &,%/&&,*2(&%&*6%($;*.#%&*&,(:E(&( .=%**:%$*! 1!

3*%/&%#*/2&,%!!

;%  /2  &,  #%*7  /  *2#(7  8(72&  %  .  %& !"

"6&,%##$$%&?#$%*&*//,%:%,*.$%*2&,:%* /7*&C*$$%&

%$$7$;D.(&:;*:%$* /%(/&,#$%*&*//%&, *:%$.($,%/&&,


##&;**#(&*&,C*$$$;*/,6%$/&6*&,%;*&&*&, %2  ,%##$$%&?#$%*&*//,%&%@&,&%&,%&&,6*&& &%&2&/*$* **$=(*&9

?

3 "&*&$%G 

 6%&&,(2:2%@:;*:%$%2&,#6% #(.*&, (&/2%@*7&%&2&6,*.,*D1%*&* /(&,.$%*2&,%&&,'%@%$%&%2%D3&:%&,&,(2: *2#*/*:%$&6%%7(&,%&*:%$6%(.%&#- &,/,(&%//*D,**7%&(%&,6%%/,*2& %//*D,*&,(2:*2#*&,%/%*.(2&6,*.,%D9& 3&(:&%&*%&,*%7(2&-&,$%.($/&, %##$$%&?#$%*&*//,%D%2*=,%2,=*7,)%$*@-%6*&*7% *7  *&  D#&  %  C9  6,  ,%  .2#%  &,  *#(&  &,(2: *2#*H&H96*&,#.*2&,(2:*2#*&,C*$$%&

#,*#&DC9?%$76*&,#,&7%#,*..,%& DC9?

&C9?

3-,.%2&&,..$(*&,%&E(&*&,(2: *2#**&2%&.,6*&,&,#.*2&,(2:*2#* , $%  *&*.& (7-  %&,%:% 6,*$ %##.*%&*7  &, &%&2&  / =,%2,  =*7,  )%$*@  C9  #*&  (&  &,%&  *  &,  %/%*  #& DC9?&,*$;/./*//&#%&&6*&,(&*.(*7 &,  .2#%*  /  *7  .,%%.&*&*.  ,  $%  *&*.&  (7- %&,%:%/(&,/&,%&&,.%%$:2*//.(& #(&,&,(2:6,*$7**7&,(2:*2#*%$76*&,&,*@ %($&*2%&$;&,#&7*:;&,%6*&*7%*7*&D#& DC9?6%&$*(#&,%#.&/&,#&.%*&,%& &,*#(&&,(2:*2#*6%E(*&:.2#%6*&,&, %2*&&&,(2:*2#*/*:%$,%##$$%&?#$%*&*//,%$*

!
(#C*$$!4%&

)%@
&%&*7&,%2%%2*&& &,(2:*2#*=/%%&,#&?/%&&3% ..-/&,2&,&,(2:*2#*&,C*$$)%@
.%&: &%&  %  #.*2  &,(2:  *2#*  &  ,%  .2  *  &,  . D%2*%&* / =,%2, =*7,  )%$*@- %6*&*7 % *7 *& D#&C9&,%&6,*$&%@*7#,&7%#,/#.*2&,(2:*2#* &,%*C*$$&*.6%7*&&,##*&#%&;&,*.($ 6%*/2.$%*2&,%&/&,*#.&*/.,,%&%@ #2**/=(: 7*&%%&,%:%:(&,*&2%@%;2%@*7 &,./=(: 7*&%&,%*#.*2&,(2:*2#*/ *:%$ &,,%-*&*%$&,.%/%##$$%&?#$%*&*//&,%&*:%$ 6%(.%&#%,(&%//*D,*&,(2:*2#*:(& &,&,,%%&&,&*2/7*&%&*/%*C*$$!4%&

%$$7&,(2:*2#*/*:%$6:&%* ,/-.**7&,%/%*/%.&%.*.(2&%. /&,.%-*2;#**-&,$%*&*.&(7*7,&$;*.%&, #**/=,%2,=*7,)%$*@C9-%6*&*7%*7*& D#&  &  *  /(&,  *7,&$;  ..$(  &,%&  (*&  /*$  :;  &,  #& %##$$%&?#$%*&*//  @*7  .$%%&*  %  #2%&  *8(.&* .,%$$7*7  &,  8(72&  %  .  %&  !" "  *  **$  =(*& 9

/ "&*&$%
 

 .*!"

"* ,#$$;:%:;$*2*&%&* *6/&,/%.&%.*.(2&%./&,.%-&, *.& 7* :;  &,  $% *&*.&  (7-  %&,%:%  6,*$  #%*7 *2#(78(72&%.%& !!

9&E(*%;

*&/.*6,*.,&,8(72&%.%&

!!

#% :;*&*%$ **$(7<=****>-%&,%:%6%&%*

"
,/-  &,  8(72&  %  .  %&  !!

9  *  %..*7$;

(#,$%&,%##%$#/:;&,%##$$%&?#$%*&*//*%..*7$; *2* ,..*/2&,&6 (&:$6:&:%.@ &&,..E(%& *7%##$*.%&*<>*/%;-%$&%*#/

" !

!"

 *, ',,-  

*+#/) C,&,#%@*7?%

? C,&,#&%:$

?