M/S Associates Road Carriers Limited v. M/S United India Insurance Co Ltd And Another












 

 






!"#

#$%&%'(
)#*+#,
-.
/ 0&
&&$%!"#&
!1
!,,%#,&
2%*%"#1 33#44!'"

5#,&6& 0&
'%"#1
'1%!
'&6,!'$#
2"1

!'"7#,  #&3'1#'"& 
 !

"#$%&
'( )* & *)
+%

,#&#'"( ,
!,)##'
7!,*!.
1)$!"#
,
,
,6'
8,!.
1)$!"#.

,
"7#
!33#44!'" 99999







































 *)
+%,' 
: ;



,
"7#
,#!&'&
*#'"%'#1
%'
"7#
!334%$!"%'.
<7%$7
%& &633,"#1
+=
!'
!%1!)%".
1#4!=

>
1!=&
%'
,#;%4%'8
"7#
!33#!4
%& $'1'#1 
&"!'1&
1%&3&#1







,#&#'"
#864!,
#$'1
33#!4
%&
1%,#$"#1
!8!%'&"
"7# $'$6,,#'"
%'1%'8&

!$"
!'1
4!<.
<7#,#+=
"7#
&6%"

"7#
!33#44!'"; 34!%'"%
+#!,%'8
 :

>
&##?%'8
,#$)#,=



.

./0;

!4'8
<%"7
6"6,#
%'"#,#&"
@
/A
3#,
!''6*
!&
1!*!8#&
'
!$$6'"

4&& 
81&.
7!&
+##'
1%&*%&&#1
+=
"7#
",%!4
$6,"
!'1
!%,*#1
+=
"7#
2<#, 33#44!"#
6,"
<#)#,.
%)%4
6%"
+#!,%'8
>/-

--
%4#1 +=
0&
'%"#1
'1%!
'&6,!'$#

2"1

!'"7#,
!8!%'&"
!33#44!'";0& &&$%!"#1
!,,%#,&
2"1
7!&
+##'
1#$,##1
+=
"7#
",%!4
$6,"

4!%'"%
$4!%*#1
"7#
!,#*#'"%'#1
!*6'"
'
"7#
3,#*%&#

 "7!"
"7#
81&
#'",6&"#1
"
"7#
34!%'"%
<#,#
%'&6,#1
+=
1##'1!'"
:; 0&
'%"#1
'1%!
'&6,!'$#
*3!'=
2"1
7#
$'&%8'*#'"
<!&
1#&3!"$7#1 '
!
",6$?
<'#1
+=
1##'1!'"

!'1
1,%)#'
+=
1##'1!'"
>
7# 1##'1!'"&
<#,#
8%)#'
$7!44!'.
",!'&%"
3!3#,&
!'1
!&
<#44
!&
!1)!'$#
,#'" <#)#,.
'
"7#
!"#64
'%87"

0:.
1##'1!'"
>;
1,%)#,

"7# ",6$?.
%44#8!44=
&"33#1
#'
,6"#
"
7%&
)%44!8#
!4&%!<!&.
#<!,%
!'1.
"76&.

"7#
",6$?
1#)%!"#1
,*
"7#
!&&%8'#1
,6"#
'

!"
!'84% !7!,!&7",!.
6"

>
$,!"#&.
'4=
-
<#,#
1#4%)#,#1
!'1

<#,#
6'1 %'
1!*!8#1
$'1%"%'
**#1%!"#4=
!
$*34!%'"
<!&
418#1
"
"7#
34%$# !8!%'&"
1##'1!'"
&
"
>
!'1
"7#=
<#,#
6'1
86%4"=
,#$#1%'8
"
%4%'8 
"7#
&6%".
!
*!'1!",=
'"%$#
6'1#,
#$"%'


"7#
!,,%#,
$"
<!&
!4& &#,)#1
63'
1##'1!'"
&
"
>
+6"
%'
)!%' ##'1!'"

%4#1
!
&#3!,!"#
<,%""#'
&"!"#*#'"
!&&#,"%'8
"7# &6%"
"
+#
'"
*!%'"!%'!+4#
##'1!'"
&
!'1
>
%4#1
"7#
B%'"
<,%""#' &"!"#*#'"
!'1
1#'%#1
"7#
!44#8#1
1!*!8#&
"
"7#
*!"#,%!4
'&6,!'$# *3!'=;1##'1!'"
:
1%1
'"
1#'=
"7#
%'&6,!'$#

"7#
81&
+6" !&&#,"#1
"7!"
!"#,
3,3#,
&6,)#=
!'1
!&&#&&*#'"

4&&
!'1
16#
!334%$!"%' 
*%'1.
3!=*#'"


./.0;
<!&
*!

1#
"
1##'1!'"
.
%#.
6'B!+ **6'%$!"%'
2%*%"#1
)%1#
)6$7#,
1!"#1

%'
644
!'1
%'!4 &#""4#*#'"
+=
,#&#,)%'8
!
,%87"
"
,#$)#,
!8!%'&"
"7#
$!,,%#,.
%#.
34!%'"%
,
!,)##'
7!,*!.
1)$!"#
,
,,6'
8,!.
4#!,'#1 $6'&#4
!33#!,%'8
'
+#7!4

"7#
!33#44!'";34!%'"%.
%'
&633,"

"7# *#*,!'16*

!33#!4.
&6+*%""#1
"7!"
"7#
$6,"&
+#4<
7!)#
$**%""#1 %44#8!4%"=
!'1
3#,)#,&%"=
%'
1#$,##%'8
"7#
&6%"

"7#
'&6,!'$#
*3!'=
, ,#$)#,=
!8!%'&"
"7#
$!,,%#,
!&
'
!64"
,
'#84%8#'$#
<!&
#&"!+4%&7#1.
#)#' %4%'8

&6%"
!8!%'&"
"7#
1##'1!'"&
%"&#4
<!&
"7#
"#&"%*'=

$4!

- 1!*!8#&
&&#&&*#'"

1!*!8#&
"
"7#
"6'#


./.0;
1%1
'"
,#C6%,# !'=
6,"7#,
C6!'"%%$!"%'
%'
"#,*&

*'#=
!"
"7#
+#7#&"

"7#
34!%'"% 7#
,#3,"

"7#
6,)#=,
<!&
)!86#
!'1
%'$'16$%)#
!'1
%'
&6$7 $%,$6*&"!'$#&.
&6%"

"7#
'&6,!'$#
*3!'=
$641
'"
7!)#
&6$$##1#1 7#
"#,,%",%!4
B6,%&1%$"%'

"7#
$6,"&
<!&
$'&3%$66&4=
!+&#'"
!&
&6%" <!&
"
+#
%4#1

#%"7#,
!"
"7#
34!$#

+?%'8
,
!"
"7#
34!$#

1#4%)#,=



7!)#
7#!,1
"7#
4#!,'#1
$6'&#4
,
"7#
!33#44!'";34!%'"%. 33,!%&#1
"7#
3!3#,
+?
!'1

"7#
)%#<
"7!"
"7#
,#3,"

"7#
6,)#=,
7!& '"
+##'
+#4%#1
"7,687
%'1#3#'1#'"
<%"'#&&.
<7#,#+=
'
%'&3#$"%'
 $,!"#&.
'&6,!'$#
*3!'=
!&&#&&#1
"7#
$4!%*
!'1
3!%1
"7#
$*3#'&!"%'
" "7#
$'&%8'##.
%#.
1##'1!'"
.
<7%$7
<!&
,#$#%)#1
%'
644
!'1
%'!4 &#""4#*#'"
<%"7
!

,%1#,
"
,#$)#,
7#
'&6,!'$#
*3!'=
7!1.
%'
)%#<
 "7#
!$"&.
%'1#*'%%#1
"7#
$'&%8'##.
+6"
$!''"
+#
3,#)#'"#1
"
$4!%*
"7# !*6'"
'
!$$6'"

"7#
'#84%8#'$#

"7#
$!,,%#,
"
<!&
+4%8!",=
63' "7#
34!%'"%
"
7!)#
!
$7#$?
!'1
$'",4
)#,
%"&
#*34=##&
&
"7!"
&"%$?
" "7#
,6"#
7#
1,%)#,
<!&
%'
#*34=*#'"

"7#
$!,,%#,
!'1.
"7#,#,#.
$641 '"
1#)%!"#
,*
"7#
!&&%8'#1
,6"#

$'",!,=
#)%1#'$#
7!&
+##'
4#1 ,#8!,1%'8
C6!'"%%$!"%'
!&
!&&#&&#1
+=
"7#
6,)#=,
'
*=
)%#<.
"7#
%'1%'8&

!$"
!'1
4!<
!,,%)#1
!"
%'
1#$,#"!4
 &6%"
$!''"
+#
!64"#1
<%"7

8,6'1
,
%'"#,#,#'$#
%&
*!1#
6".
*6$7 4#&&
%')4)#*#'"

!'=
&6+&"!'"%!4
C6#&"%'

4!<
#&64"!'"4=.
"7#
!33#!4 %&
1%&*%&&#1
'
"7#
8,6'1

1#4!=
!'1
!&
<#44
!&
'
*#,%"&  .

/34 '(56& +474389 :3

 ;3:

+474
 70!

;3: