Hari Singh And ORS v. Punia And ORS

   

     

"#$ %$&'(')*

 
+ ",'')-.")%#.$,( //$00")#( 1$,(2( 3#2)'"")%#.$,( $(/)%$)#(

 *  45    6 5  ,$($)#*7 ,%",(."')8%9&"#$8 ,#.$"//$00")#( ,":$(.623",.",3"8%9&"#$8

,,$(/)%$)#(
 ;.$#.$,#.$$/,#$,( 0&"0)$<(/"/$,3"=>$"00<$%# ($$#.$?2%-3$)#@

 >$,$ $,,$%##.$$/,#$,,)#  ;.$#.$,#.$?2%-3$)#(.20%>$,$/,#$%')#.$%'-$(#@ 77 77 5 

5!

3/2-)$%')#.$/,$($)#,$-20",($&)%"//$"0'(#.$ ?2%-3$)#  ")%  %$&,$$  %"#$%  A 
8  /"(($%  >=  #.$  0$",)$% %%'#')"0'(#,'&#2%-$8"0<"08"

',3')-#.$?2%-3$)#")%%$&,$$ %"#$% 

 
8  /"(($%  >=  #.$  0$",)$%  '9'0  2%-$  2)', '9'(')!8"0<"089'%$<.'&.#.$(2'# #.$/0"')#'

,%$&0","#') ")%')?2)&#')"("&)($B2$)#'"0,$0'$ #.$,$ 8<"(%'(3'(($% .$(.,#&)#,9$,(=')909$%')#.'(&"($'(#."#.2,"8 #.$,'-')"0<)$, #.$/,/$,#=')B2$(#')8%'$%0$"9')->$.')% .'(<'%< ")-""'8()$%"3")%#<%"2-.#$,(1'%.="")% 2)'".$/,/$,#= .2,"<"((2&&$$%$%>="00#.$("'% 2,

0$-"0.$',( )
A
8 ")-""'(2

$,$%"&)($)#%$&,$$')

"92, .$,%"2-.#$,2)'"8<.$,$>=#.$(2'#0")%<"(#,")( $,,$% ').$, "92,.$/0"')#'

(8<.."//$)#>$#.$()( $%"3

)<%$&$"($%!() .2,"8."9$&."00$)-$%#.$("'%?2%-3$)# ")%%$&,$$%"#$%
A
)9",'2(-,2)%( ."9$.$",%#.$0$",)$%&2)($0 ,#.$/",#'$(")%."9$ "0(&",$ 200=-)$#.,2-.#.$ '0$ #&3$(2##."##.$&)($)#%$&,$$<"((2

$,$%) 
A
   ")-" "' %'$% ')  #.$  =$",
AC  .$ 32#"#') 

/",#'#')<"((")&#')$%>$#<$$)$%"3 )<%$&$"($%!")%.'( ('(#$,2)'"')#.$=$",
AC8<.'&.3$")(#."#$%"3."%&3$ #:)<#."#.'(3#.$, ")-""'."%#,")( $,,$%.'(/,/$,#=')

"92, 2)'" )($B2$)#0=8#.$0'3'#"#')<'00(#",#,2))')- ,3 #.$%"#$ (")&#')')- 32#"#')'$')#.$=$",
AC$%"3 0"#$,)%'$%')#.$=$",
 2,')-.'(0' $#'3$8.$%'%)# &."00$)-$#.$("'%&)($)#%$&,$$.$/0"')#'

(8<.",$&0"'3')- #.$',,'-.#(#$%"38 '0$%#.$(2'#')#.$=$",  8'$"

#$, ">2#3,$#.")
D=$",(8#&."00$)-$#.$("'%&)($)#%$&,$$ "3 #.$9'$<#."#>#.#.$ 2,#(>$0<."9$,'-.#0= .$0%#."##.$(2'#'(#'3$>",,$% .$/0"')#'

(."9$),'-.## &."00$)-$  #.$  ("'%  &)($)#  %$&,$$   .$  &)($)#  %$&,$$  <"( (2

$,$%>= ")-""'')#.$=$",
A
")%<"()#>?$&#$%>= .$,#<#.$,0$-"0.$',(8)"3$0=8$%"3")%1'%.="#>$')-(8

77 #.$/,$($)#(2'#'( 2)%#>$&3/0$#$0= ,'902(")%"//$",(# >$"#"&#'&#&3/$02)'"#"#0$"(#/",#<'#.(3$(.",$')#.$ /,/$,#=.$,$ ,$8#.$0<$, 2,#"//",$)#0=$,,$%')-,")#')-) &(#(  # #.$ %$ $)%")#(  2&. #=/$  ,'902( (2'#  ."( # >$ %'(&2,"-$%")%%$"0#<'#..$"9=.")%(((2&.8#.$&(#( #.$ (2'##.,2-.2#",$"00<$%##.$&)#$(#')-%$ $)%")#
.$ /,$($)#,$-20",($&)%"//$"0'("&&,%')-0=%'(3'(($%<'#.&(#(

( 87

5 !

 



 
+ (?:(