Shamsher Chand And ORS v. Sonia
!
"#$%$&'(')*+,+(# -.
/
* 01
. ! " "
#
$
%
& & '
" "
" (
"
# $
%"
) !
"
"
#
$
%"
( ( (
&)* + &,
,
#-
.
# &
,
& &
# $
% " & &
/ . 0)1
+23"
*455 '
( &
, & '
1414)11+!
'
(
6 31*0
*453 "
-
. & (
& & (
( "
'
-
.
(
" 7
8
"
(
( 1414)11+
1410)112
'
("
&
&
0 :
(
& "'
&
"
*3*
(
3
.
((
*1
)11+ . +23
*455
& / ( "&
(
; 7
<
6 31*0
*453( ( "
"
'
*41**455
; . 0)1
*455 & '
*41**455( (
"
(
" "
. (
&( ( (
"
<
( "
1313*4==" & "
( "
"
(
;&
#
" & "
)0***4==
(
"
"
"*4==
(
!'
&
*453
"
, &! &
" (
( (
(
> '
(
+ < &
( &(
" # 6
&
?: / * (
?: 6
"
?:,
&
"
& &
&
&
# $
%
(
'
0**1)1*) "
&$ ,
% & 3 ;
#-
.
.(
" *11*)115 !
# ( ( .
&
# -
. $
% " & # ( &
'
" &
'
( ( "
,
& " '
011=)1*+ @ ( & '
" "
" (
&
( (&
( 8
2 /
"
7
(
= .
"
" (
;
"
" ( & '
# $
% /
(
; "
"
" (( &
'
'
A>) "
. 0)1
*455
1414)11+( &
(
(
, && "
# $
%/
!
# >
6#*
-& (
(
& (
8
<
(
&
"
>
!
"
<
# -
.
31 ! (
( (
-
."
< (
&
( (
&(
& (
A>* !& (
" & & / &
&
"
#>
6#*
(@
"
( ((
( & "
( $
B%
"
"
( ((
( &
&
( &
&
" "
,
, & !
&
(
" &
"
&
!
"
(
( " ;
B">
!" # $% !& "'( )!* !# +&!!& "' ,) - 5 @
&
" '
" '
A>)
1414)11+ . 0)1
+23 "
*455 ; "
&
" ;& '
A>) &
& '
( "
&
"
;
B" > <
'
(
!
"
" &
"
/
"
(
( " ;
B">
! * '. "!"( /'0 0 "!1", - - ( 23
( 4"'1", - (--
5"'26 1 -*'&.# 4 /
( "
/
(
# $
%" &
"
" (
3
&"
&
, & /
A>0
*450#5+
(
" (
( -
. &
( (
"
&
!
& &
(
)54 *01)*453 "
(
, &9
&<
(
, & &
!'
& !
A>+
*445#44
&9 , &
" (
(
(
" &
!
A>3
A>2
*444
)113 *1 !
-
.
6 31*0
*453"
&
;
&!'
&9 , & &9 !'
&
/
&
(
8
> #*
> #) "
0
)
(
8 &
3#!'
&
/ (
1313*4==" & "
"
(
! &
"8
)0***4==
" & "
(
*453
(
"*4==" "
;
! $%"#
+
(
(8
&>
" ;
&
C
6 @ $
#D C6@E% ! 1+1**4=5 ( "
0
(
"
(
&
/ &
(
"
. '
A>) 1414)11+
&
& "
"8
(
"
(
(
& (
& " (
"
(
&
8
"
& "
"
"
"
&
& & 8
&
, & ( 9
(
(
, &(
"
!
& &
> &
/ (
" -
.B
&
, &"
"
'
"
'
A>)&
# # #
-
.
( .
"
;
B"> (" & &'
A>)
&
"
"
"
&
"&
;
( ! * ' . "!"7 8 " $%
( / ( (
# D
!
"
!
#
$
# %
! ! !
!
& '
!
! !&
&
! %
( ))% )**+, -
!
.
!
( ! * '. "!"7
$%(
( " ;&
-
( 4"'1", - (-- / (
( (
&
'
"
% !
** !
("
&
&
"
(
31*0
*453
; &
; "
,
,
"
,
; C
! $%"(
&( (
/ (
(
(
!'
&9 , & &
&
&
"
*) !
&
" & (
< :
8
"
&"
" C
C
& ,@
"
"
6
,
6 31*0
*453 " -
.
(
!'
& 9 , &
# # #
-
.
&
&
& "
"
'
" '
A>) 1414)11+
. 0)1
*455 *0 / &
"
" C
,
"
(
&
, &(
" &
"
# $
%
( "
# $
%
"
*+ ! ( 6'
- !"'!& "' ( 9!& "', :+ (
"
/
"
A>0 (
&
(
C
, & &
#
!
(
, & &
!'
& ! "8
A>+
*445#44
#
" (
" (
"
A>3
A>2
"8
++
'".
*55= ' "
&
:
# $
%
&
"
"
#
*3 !
(
(
"
. +23
*455
&! &&
8
(
"
" *2
" &
"
&
- !
- 6#*
"
"
@
&
A>6*9
& (
A>*> "
/ # >
"
>
&
(
31 ! $
%
"
&
!
# -
.
(
*= ! #>
#
&
&"
"
,
&( ( # #(>
*3 *450 (
"
, & &
"
&
# >
! (
#>
&
&( "
A !
& & (
A>*>
6#* $
-% )+*1*455 (
( 7 "
&
"
" 6#*$
-%
&
(
!"# $% $%
(
! ( 5*'."!0;+ ( 6'&' 1 1 , - (--3 *)$&% (
#
!
%
'
' ' '% !
!
- $ %
''
$
'
'
! & /
!
! % $ ! !0!
! 1%!
!
'
' ,
!
2
!
2
%
2
!
% 2
!
2 . ! ( >
"
&
# $
%
"
& (
A>*6#*
-( 7 "
&
&
>
)+*1*455!
6#*
( "
& A
&( "
*5 / &
"
(
# $
%
"
!(
# $
%
& "
&
"
'
*4 ;
"
"
&
"
!
+,+(# -.
/
(