← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaVATAP/43/2015dismissed

M/S Manju Sanitary Ware v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2016-09-30Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan5 pages

       

 !"

#$% &%'()(*+,%-$%./%0

1

2  

    

     !+ 3 4!,,  4 3 4!, ,, 0%)%*$+ !0,#*&%%-5#61&7'#$% 0$8%#--%66#*$ !0#9.8#* #*)#61&&6&7'#$%%*%0#61:*;#/  #;%)8 (*&#6 8%  -0%)%*$  #--%#6  8#)  /%%*  (6%&  0#()(*9  $8%  66<(*9 ):/)$#*$(#6=:%)$(*) 6#<#0()(*9:$ $8%0&%0&#$%&> 

-#))%& /5#6:%&&%&#?0(/:*#61:*;#/ 0)80$13$8%0(/:*#63"(*--%#6 

 + @("

A8%$8%0*$8% #'$)#*&'(0':.)$#*'%) $8%'#)%1$8% #--%66#*$8#).#&%#*5#$$%.-$$%7#&%$8%$#?%7%* $8:98*$05#?8#&/%%*&%-)($%&(*$8%#'':*$

-%0)*<88#)$8#*&7%0.*%5$$8%&0(7%0%7%* /% 0%$8%9&)8#7%/%%*&%$#(*%&B (("

A8%$8%0*$8% #'$)#*&'(0':.)$#*'%) $8%'#)%1$8%

 

(*&(*9)0%'0&%&/5$8%#--%66#$%#:$80($5#*&0(/:*#6 #0%-%07%0)%(**#$:0%(*#).:'8#)$8%58#7%0%'0&%& $8#$$8%9&)8#&/%%*&%$#(*%&#$ !1<8%0%#) $8%&%$%*$(*0&%00%'0&)($$8#7%/%%*&%$#(*%&#$  

!B ((("

A8%$8%0*$8% #'$)#*&'(0':.)$#*'%) $8%'#)%1$8% 4&0(/:*#6<#);:)$( (%&(*:-86&(*9$8%-%*#6$5:*&%0 ,%'$(*C"'"<8%0%#)$8%9&)#*&7%8('6%<%0% )$(66<($8(*$8%-0%.()%) BD 4%#0*%&':*)%6 0$8%#--%66#*$):/.($$%&$8#$(*$8%$0:'E /%#0(*9    F F CC 1  $<  '*)(9*.%*$)  0.  $<  &(

%0%*$ '*)(9*0) 0$<&(

%0%*$'*)(9*%%)<%0%6#&%&8%&%)$(*#$(*<#) !9#8%9&)(.-0$%&<%0%%?'()#/6%8%)%<%0%-:0'8#)%&/5$8% #--%66#*$  *  '*'%))(*#6  0#$%    $#?  #9#(*)$  0. 33  *  *%    $8% '*)(9*.%*$)1$8%'*)(9*%%<#)!G)!#*;:,#*($#05A#0%1*#.%651$8% #--%66#*$1<8%0%#)(*$8%$8%01$8%'*)(9*%%<#)!G)!#*;:*$%0-0()%) ,$#$:$05 0.

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

  9%*:(*%*%)) $8%$0#*)#'$(*1-%*#6$5<#)6%7(%&1<8('8<#):-8%6&(* #--%#6/5$8% (0)$#--%66#$%#:$80($5#)<%66#)$8%0(/:*#6 8%):/.())(*()$8#$<8%*$8%7%8('6%<#))$(66#$$8%/#00(%01 &':.%*$) /$8$8%'*)(9*.%*$)<%0%<($8$8%&0(7%01$8%0%<#)* =:%)$(* **F&%'6#0#$(*  *%'*)(9*.%*$8%-:0'8#)%<#)* '*'%))(*#60#$%)#9#(*)$)$#$:$05 0.33*'#)%1$8%9&)#0%*$ %*$%0%&(*#'':*$) $8%#--%66#*$18%<(668#7%$-#58(98%00#$% $#?

$:;#0#$&%#6%018%*'%1$8%0%<#)*/%*% ($$%7#&%$#?8%0%'0&<#) -0&:'%&$)8<$8#$$8%$0#*)#'$(*<#)%*$%0%&(*$8%/E) #'':*$) #*&%7%*)$#$:$05 0.33<#)#6)()):%& *$8%$8%08#*&16%#0*%&':*)%6 0$8%,$#$%):/.($$%&$8#$ $8%7%8('6%0%-0$%&#$$8%'8%'E-)$#$ !1<8%**%'*)(9*.%*$ <#)&%'6#0%&#*&$#?&:%$8%0%*<#)-#(&)$8%9&)6#&%&(*$8% 7%8('6%<%0% :*&$/%.0%$8#*<8#$.%*$(*%&(*$8%&':.%*$) -0&:'%&1 $8%

('%0#$$8%'8%'E-)$9$):)-('(:)#*&'8%'E%&$8% '*)(9*.%*$$<#)&:0(*9$8#$-0'%))$8#$($':6&/% :*&:$$8#$$8%0% <#))%'*&'*)(9*.%*$#)<%661<8('8<#)*$&%'6#0%&8%$0#*) %0

.*%5(*$8%#'':*$ $8%#9%*$#*&**F&%-)($$8%0% #$$8%'8%'E-)$ #$$8%(*($(#6)$#9%1().%0%65#)$05'*''$%&/5$8%#--%66#*$,:'8#* #9%*$()*$0%'9*()%&(*6#<$()#-0(7#$%#00#*9%.%*$ $8%#--%66#*$ *'%1#''0&(*9$$8%#--%66#*$1$8%#9%*$8#&&%-)($%&$8%$#? 0*% '*)(9*.%*$1<8%*($<#)&%'6#0%&#$$8%'8%'E-)$#$ !1$8%$8%0 '*)(9*.%*$':6&#6)/%&%'6#0%&#*&$#?-#(&8%#.:*$<#)*$8:9% $()*65# $%0$8%&%$%*$(* $8%9&)$8#$$8%-0'%)) 0&%-)($

.*%5(*$8%#'':*$ $8%#9%*$)$#0$%& 0'0%#$(*9%7(&%*'%8%#.:*$ $0#*) %00%&/5$8%#--%66#*$(*$8%#'':*$ $8%#9%*$&%)*$$#665<($8

  $8%#.:*$ $#?(*767%&80%%#:$80($(%)8#7%#60%#&59*%(*$$8% ()):%(*$%0 %0%*'%()0%=:(0%&#$$8())$#9%#)*):/)$#*$(#6=:%)$(*

6#<#0()%) %#0&6%#0*%&':*)%6 0$8%-#0$(%)#*&-%0:)%&$8%-#-%0 /E 8% #'$$8#$$8%0%<%0%$<'*)(9*.%*$)0(9(*#$(*9 0.$< '*)(9*0).%#*$ 0$<&(

%0%*$'*)(9*%%)(*$8%)#.%7%8('6%()*$(* &()-:$%8%7%8('6%0%-0$%&#$$8%'8%'E-)$#$ !1<8%*$8%%*$05 $#?&:%$8%0%*(*'#)% *%'*)(9*.%*$<#)&%-)($%&8%'*)(9*%% $8%0%(*<#)!G)!#*;:*$%0-0()%)8%#--%66#*$())()$%0'*'%0*$8%0%  $  ()  *$  (*  &()-:$% $8#$  $#?  0 $8% '*)(9*.%*$  (*  =:%)$(*  <#)  *$ &%-)($%&#$$8%)#.%$(.%8%)$05-:$/5$8%#--%66#*$'6#(.(*9$8#$$8% #.:*$':6&*$/%&%-)($%&#)($<#)$0#*) %00%&(*$8%#'':*$ $8% #9%*$6#$%().%0%65$/%*$('%&#*&0%;%'$%&8%#--%66#*$'6#(.%&$8#$ $8%#.:*$<#)$0#*) %00%&(*$8%#'':*$ $8%#9%*$/% 0%

!1 8<%7%01($<#)0% 6%'$%&(*8()#'':*$6#$%8% #'$<#)9$7%0( (%&/5 $8% (0)$#--%66#$%#:$80($5 0.$8%/#*E%0 $8%#--%66#*$#*&($<#) 0%7%#6%&$8#$$8%#.:*$<#)&%-)($%&(*'#)8#$  C!,$(66 :0$8%01 $8%#.:*$&%-)($%&(*$8%#'':*$ $8%)F'#66%&#9%*$<#) 1

GF1 <8%0%#)$8%#.:*$ $#?&:%*/$8$8%'*)(9*.%*$)1<8('8<#)$/% &%-)($%&#$$8%/#00(%01<#) 1C GF18%*'%1%7%*$8%#.:*$#6)&(&*$ $#665  :0$8%01  (  $8%  #9%*$  ':6&  &%-)($  $8%  #.:*$    $#?  0  *% '*)(9*.%*$  /% 0% $8% #.:*$  <#)  &%-)($%&  /5 $8% #--%66#*$  (*  8() #'':*$)18%':6&7%05<%66&%-)($$8%)#.% 0$8%)%'*&'*)(9*.%*$ #)<%668%-0'%)) 0&%-)($ .*%5)$#0$%&*65# $%0$8%9&)<%0% &%$#(*%&#*&<%0%(*$8%-0'%)) 7%0( ('#$(*$'0%#$%%7(&%*'%

 0$8%0%#)*).%*$(*%&#/7%1<%&*$ (*&$8#$#*5 ):/)$#*$(#6  =:%)$(*    6#<  #0()%)  (*  $8%  -0%)%*$  #--%#6  8%  (*&(*9) 0%'0&%&/5$8%#:$80($(%)/%6<'#**$/%)#(&$/%-%07%0)%8%#--%#6 ()1#''0&(*9651&().())%& #;%)8 (*&#6"

:&9% 

#0)8#*,(*98"

:&9% ,%-$%./%0

1

2 .E A8%$8%0)-%#E(*9G0%#)*%&+

%)G A8%$8%00%-0$#/6%+

%)G