Sunehri Devi v. Naresh Kumar And ORS
!" #"$%&%'(
) *'"+,% "-% .."// '!
0& ,"&+1*2 , '#!+",& "&.'#"'!& (3 4 5 5 ,"&"'!(3 ,+",6"/7#-$ !"7 ,!+" .."// '! 8","
",,"#!!+"".,!",&,'!9 :+"!+",!+";*#<2"'!&+*/#8",".,!"#%'!+"
%<"&!9 57 +%&%&!+"&"$'# .." / !+"#"
"'# '!7 %/"#86!+"
/"< /,".,"&"'! !%-" #"
7%' &*%! %/"#86./ %'!%
,"&+ 1*2 , .,"&"'!/6 ,"&.'#"'! 7 &""=%'< .",2 '"'!
%';*'$!%' < %'&!/ !" 2 ,*.3#"
7 & /& < %'&!'"
1 / 27 8,!+", 2 ,*.7 >+ %& .,"&"'!/6 ,, 6"# & ,"&.'#"'! %'!+%& .." /7 /&!+,*<++%&&' '#/"< /+"%, +"./ %'!%
+ # %/"#+%&&*%!&! !%'<!+","%'!+ !+" /'< >%!++%&2!+",7&%&!", '#8,!+",7 ,">'",&%'.&&"&&%' / '# 2" &*,%'<?
= ' /%'-%// <"1*';.*, 7"+&%/ '# %&!,%$!1 ,' /7 >%!+!+"&*%!.,.",!6 *//6#"&$,%8"#%'#"! %/%'!+"./ %'!!> & ./" #"#!+ ! !!+"!%2" $'&/%# !%' / '#%'!+"-%// <"7'!+"
',!+>"&! !+"./ %'!%
&4/ '#7 #;%'%'<!%!7!+","> &!+",/ '#
%'- ,%*& '# '*28",&7>'"#86'"2! "-=%
% +"%&&! !"#!+ -"&/#!+"&*%!/ '#2" &*,%'<?
= ' /&%' -*, ,%%'<+ '# '%'<+&'& *'&+% 27 >%!+!+"./ %'!%
,"&+1*2 ,8"%'<!+"&' ,%%'<++*&7%!
> &$'!"'#"#!+ !!+"&*%!/ '#> &&/#!!+" !+", '#*'$/"
!+"./ %'!%
-%#"& /"#""## !"# @)!> &$'!"'#"#!+ !%'
!+"& /"#""#%!> &$/" ,/62"'!%'"#!+ !!+","%& , &! A+ ,7
= , 2%'>%#!+7!> ,#&!+"',!+",'&%#" ,"$! '</"
71%// '*28",& 7 '#? '#!> ,#&!+"" &!",'&%#" 1%// '*28",&B '# ? ,% %'<+ '# ' %'<+ + # 8""' *&%'< !+" & %# , &! A+ , ,$2%'< '#<%'<!!+"2 %', #7 &#"2 ,$ !"#%' !+"&%!"./ ' ''"C"#>%!+!+"./ %'! !",!+"#" !+ ,%%'<+7!+"./ %'!%
/'<>%!++%& 2!+",7&%&!",& '#8,!+",&> & /&*&%'<!+"& %#, &! ,%'<,"&& '#"<,"&&!!+"2 %', #7 ,2!+"&*%!/ '#+"&*%!/ '#> & &! !"# ! 8" %' !+" $!* / $*/!%- !%'< .&&"&&%' !+" ./ %'!%
>"-",7 //"<"#/6!+"#"
"'# '!&>","8"'!*.'#"2/%&+%'<!+"
, &! A+ , ,$%8/6 '#%//"< //67#".,%-%'<!+"./ %'!%
,2 '6 .., $+!+%& %"/# !> & *,!+",./" #"#7!+ !' B ? )7!+"#"
"'# '!& /'<>%!+&2"8 #"/"2"'!&$ 2"!!+"&.! '#!,%"###"2/%&+ !+", &! ,$%8/6 '#%//"< //68*!$*/#'!&*$$""##*"!!%2"/6 %'!",-"'!%' ,"&."$! 8/".",&'& !+"-%// <""'$"7!+"&*%!> &
? %'&!%!*!"#'
? ) !'""#&2"'!%'+","!+ !!+"!>#"
"'# '!&7%" 2 ,*. '#1 / 7 ," /&&+>'!8"&'& *'&+% 27%"!+"6 >","!+"8,!+",& !+" !+", ./ %'!%
,"&+1*2 , ? .''!%$"8"%'<%&&*"#78!+!+"#"
"'# '!& .." ,"# '# %/"#!+"%,;%'!>,%!!"'&! !"2"'!&7>%!+!+"*&* /.,"/%2%' ,6 8;"$!%'&'''32 %'! %' 8%/%!67/$*&3&! '#%"!$'2",%!&7%!> & $'!"'#"#!+ !!+"./ %'!%
7+%&2!+",7&%&!",& '#8,!+",&>","'!
>'",&%'.&&"&&%' !+"&*%!/ '#& 2 !!", $!7 % + #&/#&2"/ '#$2.,%&"#%',"$! '</"
71+ &, & D = ' /&7
B= ' /& '#
A?B= ' /&7!!+"#"
"'# '!&7 !+,*<++", !!,'"6 + <> '%'<+7-%#" ,"<%&!","#& /"#""# # !"# ? B @D!> & *,!+",$'!"'#"#!+ ! %+ #'!
&/#!+"&*%!/ '#! ,%%'<+ '# ''%'<+-%#"& /"#""## !"#
@) '# *,!+",7!+ !!+","> &'2"'!%'%'!+"& /"#""#
@)!+ !!+","> & '6 A+ , !>= , 2&>%#!+,*''%'< !> ,#&!+"',!+",'&%#" ,"$! '</"
7=%// '#? '# !> ,#&!+"" &!",'&%#" =%// &'*28",B '#?!> & /&#"'%"# !+ ! !",!+"#" !+ ,%%'<+7./ %'!%
'#+%& 2%/62"28",& >","*&%'<!+"& %#, &! $'!%'**&/6 '#." $" *//6 , '6.*,.&" //%' //7%!> &$'!"'#"#!+ !!+"&*%!/ '#+ #'!$2"!!+" &+ ," !+" ./ %'!%
'# +" > & '! %' $'!%'**& .+6&%$ / .&&"&&%' %!7',+ #+" '6,%<+!7!%!/" '#%'!","&! %'!+" , &! A+ ,>+%$+!+"#"
"'# '!&+ #$ ,-"#*!%'!+"%,>' %"/#&7
,!+"%,>'%'<,"&& '#"<,"&&
.' ,"./%$ !%'+ -%'<8""' %/"#7!+" //>%'<%&&*"& >"," , 2"#86!+"/" ,'"#%-%/ *#<" , %-'71 ,' /(3 E% :+"!+",!+"./ %'!%
%&"'!%!/"#! #"$,"" , .",2 '"'!%';*'$!%' & //"<"#9 %% :+"!+",!+"./ %'!%
+ &'!$2"!!+"$*,!
>%!+$/" '+ '# '#+ &&*..,"&&"#2 !",% /
$!& & //"<"#9 %%% "/%"
F +"./ %'!%
"C 2%'"#D>%!'"&&"&%'&*..,! +%&&*%!7 %'$/*#%'<+%2&"/ 7>+"," &#"
7 2 ,*.7"C 2%'"# +%2&"/ & :3 !+&%#"&,"/%"#*.'$",! %'#$*2"'!&72 %'/6 ,"-"'*","$,#7%'!+"%, -*, ) -%'< .., %&"#!+""-%#"'$"7!+"/" ,'"#%-%/
*#<" *'# !+ ! !+" & /" #""# # !"# @) + # 8""' #*/6 .,-"#86!+"./ %'!%
7%'>+%$+%!> &$/" ,/6,"$%!"#!+ !!+","%& , &! A+ , !>= , 2&>%#!+7 &#"&$,%8"#%'!+"./ %'!+"& /" #""#> & *'#!8".,-"#'!+"!"&!%2'6 2 '< :37 >+&! !"#!+ !+"+ #!, '&/ !"#%!%'!%'#%7-%#"C:A7!+" ,%<%' /& /"#""#8"%'<C:3 A '!+"!+",+ '#7!+"#"
"'# '!&$*/#'!#%&.,-"!+"
,"& %# & /" #""# '# *,!+",7 "-"' %' !+" & /" #""# # !"#
? B @D7!+", &! A+ ,%'G*"&!%'> & /," #6&+>'!+ -" 8""'/"
!*!86-"'#, %78"
,"&"//%'<!+"/ '#!!+"
#"
"'# '!&' $!7!+"#"
"'# '!&#%#'!"-"'.,#*$" $.6 !+"
& /"#""## !"# ? B @D '#%!> &%' $!!+"./ %'!%
>+786
> 6 ##%!%' /"-%#"'$"7.,-"#!+"& %#& /"#""# &C:)A7
*,!+","C 2%'%'<:3)7 "& ;7 ,"<%&!,6/",=7%'&*..,!!+"," "+ # /&"C 2%'"#'" + <> ! ,&+ #7! ,6*8/%$71 ,' /7 >+ !!"&!"#!+"!, '&/ !"#$.6 !+"& %#& /"#""# @D '# .,-"#%! &C:DA '&"G*"'!/67%!> &+"/#86!+"/" ,'"#%-%/ *#<"7!+ !
!+"./ %'!%
+ #.,-"#!+ !!+","> & , &! A+ , !>= , 2& >%#!+7 &#"&$,%8"#%'!+"&%!"./ ' ''"C"#>%!+!+"./ %'!7>+%$++ # 8""'&/#!!+"./ %'!%
&4<, '# !+", '#+%&<, '# !+",&48,!+",7 86 %7 &. ,! !+"& /"#""## !"# @) D +" %,&! .." / %/"# 86 !+" /"< / ,".,"&"'! !%-"&
#"
"'# '! .,"&"'! .."// '!&7 > & /& #%&2%&&"# 86 !+" /" ,'"# ##%!%' / %&!,%$! *#<"7 1 ,' /7 ' !+" & 2" ,"& %# <,*'#& B !2 68"'!%$"#!+ !#"
#%#'! .." / < %'&!!+";*#<2"'! '##"$,"" '#> & ,, 6"# &,"&.'#"'!
%'!+" %,&! .." /7 &+"+ &'>8""'& ,, 6"#%'!+%&&"$'# .." / !2 6 /&8"'!%$"#+"," !!+%&&! <"7!+ !!+%& .." / + #8""' %/"#%'!+"6" ,
78*!+ #'"-",8""' ,<*"#"-",&%'$"
!+"'7>%!+ #;*,'2"'!&8"%'<&*<+!86/" ,'"#$*'&"/'" !", !+"!+",7!%//!+%&*,!7 -%#",#",# !"#
)7+ #2 #"%!
$/" ,!+ !% !+"2 !!",> &'! ,<*"#7 ..,.,% !",#",&>*/#8" . &&"#"-"'>%!+*! ,<*2"'!&
) @ '&"G*"'!/67,+",6"/7/" ,'"#$*'&"/ ,!+"
.."// '!7 .." ,"# '#%'+%& ,<*2"'!&7-%,!* //6,"%!", !"#!+"&! '# !+" .."// '!3#"
&%!+ #8""'.,;"$!"#8"
,"!+"
*,!&8"/>'&."$% %$G*",6!+%2 &!+>!+%&*,!&+*/# %'!", ","%' %'#%'< $!78 &"#*.'#$*2"'! ,6"-%#"'$"/"# 8"
,"!+"*,!&8"/>7/" ,'"#$*'&"/$*/#'!," *!"!+" $!!+ !
!+","> &'!+", ,<*2"'! - %/ 8/"7!+",!+ '>+%$++ # /," #6 8""',";"$!"#86!+"*,!&8"/>
'&"G*"'!/67 !+"," 8"%'< >+//6 ' G*"&!%' / > %'-/-"#%'!+%& .." /7!+" %'#%'<& !+"/" ,'"#*,!&8"/> 8"%'<>+//68 &"#'!+" $!&>+%$++ -"'!8""'&+>'!8"
.",-",&" %' '6 2 ''",7 %'#%'< ' 2",%! %' !+%& .." /7 %! %& #%&2%&&"#7
7>%!+',#", &!$&!&
) 2/ !! '%'<+ '%/
*#<"