← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/889/2015allowed

Navdeep Singh v. State Of Punjab

2019-12-20Mr. Justice Ajay Tewari,Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill25 pages

           

!"

# $%&%!'

(

) )



    

   (

*+ ) ,  

- *+ ) ,, , ++ ...

 

      

  !

  

   "

  #

 

  

  " ...

 

-/

) $ %       "    

  &'

() &($*

+ 

         ,(&  -.   /-   '&    $0 ('

&($$              '# 0 , $%!'

, ' '$    

,(&-.

%  2 -"  "  +   $( (((34  5 +"       "  "  "

&  

+

 &*+

-   "+ 6 " 6 7   +&($( "    "

 8 $0 ('

&($$ 9



$: $0 !+ &($$   

".



 $& ,( "       " "  "

"""   + 

 6  " 

       6 

      "    " +         

 % "  "      ;

 <= *3

(& (* 

+  

      

   

      

 

    

   

  



  

  

     

!

, 6     +  #-

 8 +   "     " ;

 <=*3 "  () &>    "    + 

  

*" 

 4%  "  ."" 6  .

         &( ('

&($$5 % " 

"    "      88 

 . 

    ?$&$$0*

 

+

8 

+   " +

 

       

   8  - /- "   "  8

    

     

 )     ;"

                    

 "#$

    "#$ 

 %    

  "#$

  "&#'  &

  "&#( 





 





  



 "&#(

 



 







  &



     

   "&#)

 

 



        

    "&#)

 

 



  

  "#    



 &  

 *  + "#%  

 

 

    





  

    &      ,  

 &     









       

  

   "#)

    

   &     ,  

   "#-    

"#+ 

    

 

  &  "# $

 

   8

"8@;

  =$(  * &( ('

&($$ "

   8



  

"

  +         &) ('

&($$  > -"+"      "  



+ " A.

 

 

   

 #

  !

2 8    " 



  " / .

  '   *(-*012

  

 & *- 3

3 4  5 

  & '  



 & '

 

  & '  ,

 

 (   



 !

'

?    "            %  %    . B     %      "    %    % .  " +  +            . 8  $(> @   $:'&4 C C5 

:

<

  " +$,  ;"

+  

   ;"

* 



<=, 9  

  =$  8   

 4" 5  4      5 =&6 7"   =,%



=)#  

='< # B

 

=:6.< 

 $$ =$(6. +!

=$$6.

"



=$&< 

-  

9  =$, ! 

 -  "   -  " +&) ($ &($&-

,3456%'# 0 ,%'75 37 8

   " "    

$& ,(  +  +

4 +5    6  

       

=      

   "  #-.



    "   8  8 8     % 

 

       +



 +

 

         "     

  "  C 6  

+ ;  

    "      

8

 /     

8    

 +

  

 "  " 

  

  "   %

   

8     

6     "   " + 

"" 

" 

   8     8+"   $( - B  " + ($ (, &($& =$  #  

  C "  "   

   

 "  

6  

 ""    

  +     

   6       8 "   6  8



  .  6   " + 

 +

   6      

 

"   

+  

  "



 8  /"   

   

 

       $("

    6     +" ;  "

   "   

    "<

 

"   / 

"   

"  8  <+



 +

  

        + " .

    $$ -  0:% ;

30 8 

"    " +&) (& &($&

8

 +  9 $) ('

&($$ 

45 

" "

6

 

  

 +



"          

      /   ""  " 

                          

$0 ('

&($$        

+"+  /   +   ++ 

  "       

 8         =$ /      8

+  

"      

"   $& -1  :<%'# 0 ,%'75  8 

 " +(* (> &($&  "  "    $0 ('

&($$    45

 +"     

  

    #-.

           "     .  6  

      + 

&> ('

&($$  

  

  

-  8



    -! 

 6   

      8

  

     " -  

$:3$0 ('

&($$   "  4  5           

           +    6   7 45 

    "  

-  +

8  

      + -   "       

"  -   

"     ."" 6  .

             8 " "   + "      "  

      

+  8            "            

% =,%



  +      - 

8



-  !                

  

   +  " 8



       "  -

 

 

8  ! 8 -  8        $, / -2 30$5 '

,%'75/

  8+    

 " +$( ('

&($& 

$0 ('

&($$   #-.

 

  " 

 7

   =    " +  "  " + 6 B 



  "       

" ""  "         

+ 9 =) 8 "  

&( ('

&($$ "   "   

" 45   "  "  %      

&$ ('

&($$ ?     

    

 +   -

   ""  "

     %  8   "

 +  "  

  D   "

   8  

$) / -9 0) 30%=> ?

,%'75/ 

.   6   +    @;

='3  "                  +       .   6      

    ""    6 7 6 ""+ ;"

 

 6 

 

""

 @;

='3?

   

  +  / 1    "#

6 

     





   

  

 8

9   8   8  



 "#:









  

   8

9     

  "#:







3  

      



&8

9    '   



 



 8    8 &8 ,  &

    8  

       





 

  

  

 #        ;

  

  





   

<   8   

' 



 



    

 8  

   

 8   

   

   #      

   

  

  



  

     

  

  

   

 8    6 

6 

  



   

9       

6  

   , 



 ,  6

   = 

  

  



   8

9  

 '  

  >?

"#   

  

, 



  "# 3  

  

9  



"# "#   

  



"#!

$* /  -   @%'# 0 ,%'75     ?" .

8  ??

?

             @;

=:3 =:  ($ (:

&($$6."



4= $$5 8  + " 8  $*   +  " 

"   "      8 "        " < /   )    6           6      

  +  .8  8   

          + 

.

   8   9

(& (:

&($$ "

  6."



4=$$5

8   " 8     "

  +    %        +   + " < /  )           6+<   %  

8     +   +6."



4=$$5 8  %  &, (:

&($$6."



4=$$5  6.< 

4=:5  !



  + .

< / < <   % 6+  9 &* (:

&($$   

    &0 (:

&($$ 

   6."



4=$$5 /   

       +  "   "       "   "    +   " " 

$> -

 , ':

!&5%  " +$& (& &($,  8    @;

=$(3$@;

=$(3)$

 8+ "  " 6   * ,(

      6  8    

4 5        + +

 

+

    ?88 +

    &(&*  "8 

     +

      +

   /"        8    $'

/  -

  06%'# 0 ,%'75          @;

=$$3  ""+  ;"

   -      

(0 ('

&($$ 

.

  



  8   

9 $0 ('

&($$-  < 

  

  " /( '   

 

8 

   7  43 8 





  &  8

  8

  8

 

 

 @*

  

     &  @@ 

 34= $ '     

 

 

 

 

 @* + '   * 

 

 @* @ '   %



 

 

 

 @*

A '    

 

 @* % '   



  1&  *# 

 

 @* 2 '   

 



  

 &        



 &  

   .$?1?36 

 

 @* ) '  



 

 &      

  .$?1?36 

 

 @*  '  



 

    

&     8 

 

 @* : '  

 

 

 @* B '   



  

 &     

  )  B  C '  .$?1?36   



    - '   



  



  

   &     ,    

  .$?1?36 

 

 @*!

&( ('

$$6 .

 "  

  

" " << $0&( ('

$$ /( ' 

 &

  )  B 

 

 4 

 +)  $ ' & 

 

 

 +)  + ' 

 

  

 +)  @ ' 

 

 



 !

$:

%   

    

"    &$ ('

&($$  /    &> ('

$$  -     



  

 " /( ' 



 

 

 +) 

   1&  *!

$0 /    " ?

.

< @ # - !

 8    "     8             <   / 2+ )$   

6 .

  

 

  "   .

"   @;"

  7      

 "   ?

.

<   6+  &( %   " ? .  .

"  2+6+ 

6 .

< 

4=:5< /  

 +" 

   " "    +    " "  &$ -

'&B $!0 ?>%0 ,%'75    " +   $& (, &($,         $0 ('

&($$         " 



  + +

   =

  

     8 

4  5" " "   "       

  46   75    "      

 8

-   "+ "   "  8 $0 ('

&($$ /    

$& ,(    "  !   7   "               



6 7     =   .  6     +

"  " +.  6   

   #- .

 +    8 ".



   88 

       

 ?$&$$0*  +

8     

    + 



+

    +  

  "  8   

 

      

   6  " ;

 @;

=$3  ;"

              

    

  %     8     .  % 

    8   /  8   "   

  /"# '





 

 





       &    

"#)     

  

"#)  

   

   "&#$

     "&#$

  

 

   "&#)  

         & 

    "&#' 

   



 

  

                 "&#'          "#' 

   &       "#D   





"#. 







  



 !

&& /  +6 7  +

 

     ;"



    +       B          8      -<

<   "  6 7 

  



   

" 

     

" /  ""  

      

 -  !    "  .    6    %  &( ('

&($$ 

"

        + - !    4=$,5   9  &, ('

&($$

 

  "  

  

"  +" 4@;

=$&3#5   "

 8



 "

    &) ('

&($$+=$& 9 &> ('

&($$ 

 " 8



"    &'        "            "      

 -

 0:::&0,&>(  

    8    8    

   " 8   +"8

 %       +-!  -

6 "  " " " <

     8  "        %    @;

=$&37    @;

=$&32        "/2  6       " </



< 

 6+ 

 +   &, -

'

 -    " + (:

(:

&($,  $0 ('

&($$ 

69

      

8 

" "

       "      

   "    

 

"+   

+      8    + " +""

  "   " - < 

4=$&5  /   

     

   "  



8 

6 7   &, ('

&($$       

     "   @;

=&3#           "     &> ('

&($$ @;

=,3?

+ 8



4       5   %      "     &* ('

&($$   @;

=$,3< 9 "+   "

 "  8  

8  4@;

=$,3@5 

+ 

 / 

;"

     =$,  

   

@;

$ &) -

 ''

,%'75  " +&& () &($) 

!   

 #-

+    .  6   +  #-& ,(

  " :

((

 %      " +" #-       8  ++    &* -

7#%&5 ,%'75    " +   && () &($)   $0 ('

&($$ 



 #-

 +    .  6 

   " " +  +



4<=$5 &> /  -1 @# B ,%'75     " + && () &($) +     

'"   " 

6   "  + + + "  

 6 ""  "     "  "+   +    +     6    "8 +  +""  "   "+   +     "   

 %  "     "+  

&'

/    " +    &) ('

&($)         " 

"    + "   +



"    

+

+ "  "     +8 

       8    

  8    " +    8 "  

   8   

  1

  8 "  $ *8""   - 8      6 "    

  6  8

 8 ""

 #- .



6     

    "    8 6        8

   #- "8  "    6

  + +  +"+     &:

/  " +$) (:

&($)                +        +   +   "     

 /  "

"

.

 +  $:

('

&($$ 6 "

.

 '3'

,( $:

('

&($$ . 9 + .

.

  8 " +" 6 "8 " 8   "+;"

 

6    8# 

 "

 

 %   8+  %     8   

8 "

  +  6

" +;     #  

 +    6 

"  



"  " 8 " .  6 

     

" 6   +    

  "+  % +"

   $) ('

&($$

+ -   + = 



  

&0 -2 30#% ?

,%'75   " + $& (:

&($)    $0 ('

&($$ 

 7

.

?

 

  #-> ((

 %  "   +"> (( > ((

<

 " +    

 



        +  9   +> ((  +8  3

."" 6  .

 "   + "#- +"> (( > ((

,( -

,345:% ,%'75/

     %

#- @ .

  " +&$ $( &($)  

"  $0 ('

&($$) &>

6

  +<" ,$ "    % .  +     ;     "#  

4=)5 "

        $(>       ,& 2       ;     "#  

4=)5

"+"   " +#  

4=)5    +  

8 

4=$5       " +  #  

4=)5  

   #  

C 

 +

    C" +"+ 

   +  @   8 # 

4=)5 C      "8   +          6       "       < # B  

4='5    +        

    "      " +

      4 

 5 "       "

     "   6."



4=$$5

 +      ;"

    " +  6

    "  

  B  4      .          B5           +   .        +  

 6    .C  

         .   6              +   ; +   . "+  "+

" 

+  + -  "   

         " +   "   

      "   "  " E         8

   

   "  

  $(>       

,,  +    "   <+#        " + -         ;  

 " + "8   

  +  8 



 %   B    

 4

  

5 8

   +    +

  

+ "  D " + +  %     + " +  

 "+      +

8+" +   +  ""+ 

   

"" " 8 "   ""+    "

  +

  

 

          8+   



   4@;

=$(3)$5 -  

 

 +

8+ " + 8 " +  

+  +   + % +        @;

=$(3,(     

   8     

 +

 

   -                    "           +    +  ,) % +        $(>       "  

       

"

      +;  

"

       +  + ;

  " ,* ."

    "+     

  " 

+

     $(>     

 B "

       "   

 .   6  (& (*         " <  "    >";F";

$F" 

    8

 "   +   

 ,> -   

  

;

+ ++"+

    < 

  + ++  + - """ + +4   +5

+  + 

   ++   +        %  "   

+        

        "8 

    +  +  +            ++  +  + 

,'

2   "        

"A-G 2       "+    +B     ;"

      

   +   "

,:

. B + ;         +  ; +  

 "   

      

   6    +    

        

 "  6."



4=$$5

  +    

 ;"

    " +

  <   .  

     .                ;    

 " +    # 

4=)5    

=$ 8 

  "  #  

4=)5  

  "       D "   



  +"  +  8  " ,0 % 

     .               "    E    " "+ 

    "  

        +"      ;    "         )(  +        

6    

)$  "     

.

  

  +     

-



, , ++



) )

, ? =  8

3  H3 =   H3