High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1792/2018dismissed

Krishna @ Manne And ORS. v. Chander Shekher & ORS.

2018-05-25Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal3 pages

!"#$#%&'&()** +,&'-(!!.&!'!((#!($"-#,'

//#..!("'

0#,'1'

-!($#,-#2-!,!($"-#,'

#'/($#("'

) 34 + 4 ,#'#(")5 ,!6&"-&!7$8%!"#7 ,!//#..!("' 9-#"-#,"-##/,"#,'.%!.(#:'/!/#,;!<=#!..:#$" '##"-#61$>;#("?

=#,##,,#$""-##/,"#,,(" @ 9-#"-#,"-#61$>;#("'-1.$=#,#/,"#$&("-#$&>#'"? 55 55 + 4

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

55 4!. -!($##($!("*&'%.!&;&(>"=#.#>!..<:#$$#$:&#4!.

-!($ -#,#,#7'-#/,$1%#$;!,,&!>#%#,"&&%!"#&("-&',#>!,$ -# (;&(!"&((%#;!$#&('#,8&%#=2%!(("=#%-!(>#$:&"-1"!(</, ##($!("'@"*&(:,&""#('"!"#;#("-!$"!2#(/.#!"-!" 4!. -!($:!';!,,&#$"$##($!("!($$##($!("@:!'=,(1" :#$.%2":!''"!"#$"-!"!%1'";!,<$&8,%#-!$"!2#(/.!%#=#":##( 4!. -!($!($0&$<!#8&!($"-#,#!"#,74!. -!($;!,,&#$:&"-/,#'#("

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

("*&'#("&".#$,"-#=#(#&"'$#%#!'#$ 4!. -!($? @ #.&# ,&!. 1," !"#, ,#%,$&(> #8&$#(%# /!,"&#' %!;# " %(%.1'&("-!"$&8,%#=#":##(4!. -!($!($0&$<!#8&&'("/,8#$ &;&.!,.<7;!,,&!>#$##($!("*+,&'-(!!.&!'!((#:&"-4!. -!($ &'!.'("/,8#$!($%('#C1#(".<'1&"/.!&("&':!'$#%,##$"##%" "-!"/.!&("&'!($$##($!("'"A!,##("&".

5@5 =#(#&"'&##B>,!"&!>,!("7.#!8##(%!'-;#("7>#(#,!.&('1,!(%#'%-#;#7 /,8&$#("1($7!;&.</#('&(!($!.."-#,=#(#&"'&(#C1!.'-!,#'=#&(> (!"1,!.-#&,' ##($!("D&',#'",!&(#$,;;!2&(>,,#.#!'&(> /!<;#(""$##($!("'"A;,#"-!("-#&,$1#'-!,#&# *"-'-!,# #!%- ( !//#!.7 ,#.&# %.!1'# :!' '.&>-".< ;$&&#$ =< .#!,(#$ $$&"&(!. &'",&%" 1$>#7 1$!'/1,7 =< -.$&(> "-!" /.!&("&' !($ $##($!("'"A:&..>#" D"-'-!,##!%-&(,#"&,!.=#(#&"'#B%#/"&( !;&.</#('&(1,"-#,7&":!'-#.$"-!"0&$<!#8&!.(#:&..=##("&".#$ "!;&.</#('&(":!'1,"-#,-#.$"-!";!,,&!>#=#":##(4!. -!($!($ +,&'-(!!.&!'!((#&'(".#>!.!($8!.&$7"-#,#,#7'-#&'("#("&".#$" >#"!(<=#(#&"&(%.1$&(>!;&.

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

+ 4

** '62' 9-#"-#,'/#!2&(> ,#!'(#$ ) #' 9-#"-#,#/,"!=.# ) #'