Kulwinder Singh Bhatti v. Naseeb Kaur & ORS


   
  


 

!" "#$%$&'

( )



 

   









 











  




*'+ ,
 
 
  



 
 


!
 


"
# $
 

!  
%&'

(


 


 
%&'

 


) $

"
 

!  
*

+

,,,

     -%.

! 
%/ 




 
 


 


! 
 
0

) 
 
-(.

!!
! 


!
" 0
$ 
 
  
& ! 
%'




& 
!"0
" " '

" 0

1 
 
!
 0
23%
 
 


# 
4
1 
  
" 
0
 !!

 

!



 
 

1. Sale deed No.8300 dated 16.01.1976, measuring 10 marlas in favour of plaintiff No.1.

2. Sale deed No.10010 dated 19.03.2010, measuring 10 marlas (sale executed by plaintiff No.1 in favour of plaintiff No.2).

3. Sale deed No.2068 dated 01.06.2010, measuring 4 marlas (sale executed by plaintiff No.1 in favour of plaintiff No.2).

4. Sale deed No.33 dated 05.04.2010, measuring 10 marlas (sale executed by plaintiff No.1 in favour of plaintiff No.2).
!!
" 
 0
 
 ! 
%





!"0
" " 


 0
23%
 
 


#


 



 
!

" 
!
 ! 
%

!!
%


! 

 ! 


  
" "  


 
!

 0

  



!

!!
 

 0
 " 


!

 ! 
! 



 
 
5

!

  
0

!!
 
!!
%

 0


 

 ! 
!

"


 0

!

!
 ! 
%




 
 "
 
! " 

-*.

6

 ! 
  

! 
  
 " 

  

! 

"  



5

 
0

 ! 
 




"


!!


"


) 

 



  
 

" 
! 
!

"

) 
7
"




" 
 
!!
%




1 
!
%8
" 

!



 0
" 
98
" 
5


 
 
0

 ! 
 

 
 
!

 
 0
!
98
" 
&(
:'

; 0

 "


6 "


4

 0



 
0

!

 $
 
 
7
!





  
 
<
%8
" 
!



1  

!
!
!!
%
&"

!
 ! 
%'

%=8%%>+=
?

"
*8
" 
!






 
 
%@8(%>>+

1  

!
!

$
 
 
5

 
!

  
0

 ! 
 
!!
%


! ! 

%8
" 
!





$
 
 

!
 
 
8@89%>+A
5

 
!

 
 

$
 
 
 
! "



 " 
1  

B
 
%@%8(88A

!
!
 ! 
%3

 



 
!


B  ! 
%

 "



 
!
  0

< 
4

 
1  

!
!
!!
(

 








!

 ! 



 

 


sham
  
! 
%

 ! 
*

9


" " 

 ! 0
  


  
 " 
 

$
 
 


benami 
 
 
%@8(%>+>




*8
" 




!



 

 


0






" 






*8
" 




" 
4

!


0


 
!

 0


 
0
"
C
$

 
 

 0

!

(
:
!

 

 
!

"
;0

 "


6 "



!



1  


 
 0
!

"

  


"
!

!
 
!!
%
!

" 
%8
" 


 
 
%=8%%>+=
? "

" 
*8
:





 
 
%@8(%>+>

1  

!
!
$
 
 

-9.

!

!!
! 
 


  
 " 
-@.

!  

  
!

  
! 0
 

!

" 

%=8((8%(



!



 
!
!

"



%%8@(8%@
 


!

" 


  
 

 


!
 3
"1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the mandatory injunction as prayed for? OPP

2. Whether the suit of the plaintiff is not maintainable? OPD 3(a) Whether the plaintiff No.1 was the owner of the suit property and whether she has any right to execute the alleged sale deed in favour of plaintiff No.2? OPP

3. Whether the plaintiff has not come to the Court with clean hands and suppressing the material facts from the Court? OPD

4. Relief."

-=.

5
 

 


!!

1" 
;  

&!!
('

B3%


  

 "
!




 


 ! 
 
!



 

"  
 
4

 

1  

21%

9


!

1  


!


 0

21@

 
!

 
 

 

!!
!  
0

 
!
 ! 
%

21=

A
!!
%
 
 
  

 31

B3(



1  

"
 " 

1  
0
B3%
) ! 
 
!
4 5
!  
 
0
  
)   #


1  
0
!!
(

21

21)



!

 

 

  
 " 

-+.

7




 ! 
%

" !
1" 

B3%

  

 
"


  
 " 
;
 


! 
0
!
B
 
%@%8(88A
1  
0

!


21 %
  
0
!
 !
 
 
8@89%>+A

:
%/ ! 
0
!
 
! 
0
"  ) 


) 
!

 
#

#

21 ( 
"

21 9

! 
0
!
$ " 
 
%9%%(8%*

21 @
#

 0

1" 

B3 (

 
) 

1" 

B3*
 
 ! 
   
!
C" 
" $

& 
 


B
 
%@%8(88A'
4
 
!

 ! 

 
0

!

) 

%98>(8%=
-A.


) 
!  

  

 



$ " 


 
(9%8(8%=

 


! 
0

!!


! 

  




 
 
!


 0


!!
 

 
!

" 
!

"


!

!


$ " 

->.


  
   
$ " 


 
(9%8(8%=
 
0
 
) 

! 
 !

 
#

#



 
" 
 "
!


 
!
 
) 

 
;    


 
 
-%8.

C   
 
!
 / ! 
%


 
 

) 
 

! 

  



  





" 
!
  
!!

! 

 "  


 
!



 0
 
98
" 
4

 
 



0

!!
0
 

  
!
%8
" 
;

!



 
 
 ! 
%

 "

!
 
 0
0
0
!
B
 
%@%8(88A
1  
0

!


;
!

 


     



  ! !

"#$%&$'()! %%"

* +   
,!  "##-&.'

& / '".

 
!

 

-%%.



   
 
!  /!!




 




 0

! "0


$ " 

 
 
0

) 
 
4
 

 
 




   
5

 
!



 
 

 ! /  

< 


!

  



 


   


" 
C   
 
!

 
 *!+ (

! ! 

 0 1!2!   "##3&"'

 & / ' 4%  5   ! 


!

"##-&$'
 & / ' .$ 2 &'

! (
  ! 

!2!!   !

 &"##6' $ ! !

 "%#  *  0    !   78 !  &"#$#' 6 ! !

 99#  *  2  

  00
    !  &"##3' $4 ! !

 ..-

 , &  ' &' ! (
    !   

 &' !(
 &$--3'$$ ! !

3%$  2 !   

 00: * &"##%'$

$#9

!  0 2 2!   !   !    :! !

"#$.

(*$9%"

 
!

 



-%(.

5


 

  

 

 






   
 
!
  
-%*.

5
"0
 

!

< 
!

  
 
!
 
) 3
"(1). Whether the plaintiffs have been able to establish the ownership of the entire suit property?

(2). Whether there is misreading of evidence, resulting in failure of justice?"

-%9.





21@
" 


 
"  

 
!

 " 
!
B3%
;  
 
B3(
 


 


 0

" 
98
" 




 
 



"
"
0

 ! 


  
 "  !!
%




1 
!
%8
" 
0
 
 
!




0
0
!

 
A*88
 
%=8%%>+=
&219'
4

%8
" 
!


 !




$  
 
0
0
!
!
 
 
8@89%>+A
& :
3%/'



!
 


 
  





  
!
%8
" 
!



 " 



!!
%
7


 
 
21%

*


 
1  
0
!!
%

!
!



!!
(


 

 
"


0 
(8%8


!


" 
(9
" 





 !



 

  
!
!!
%
!
(9
"  

0
 
!

 
 
%=8%%>+=
&219'



0

!
%8
" 







 !


" 

 
2 

 3 1"
!
B3%
;  


B3(
 




 
" 
 
!!
%

0


 1 
!
%8
" 
4  
 
!
 3 1"
!

! 
  
1   

 3
1;<$! ! "11.It is correct that my father has purchased property measuring 10 marla in the name of my mother on 16.01.1976.

My mother has not purchased any property except above mentioned property. I do not know if my father has purchased property measuring 151/2 kanal from Naunihal and Udham Singh in the year 1979 as I was about 657 years old at that time. My father had expired on 10.11.2008. I never inquired from my father about any purchase of property during his life time. It is correct that mutation of only 10 marla has been sanctioned in the name of plaintiff No.1. I do not know if the remaining property of remaining portion of the property E51 New Beant Nagar still in the name of previous owner Naunihal Singh and Udham Singh etc. I have seen TS51 Form only in the name of my mother. There is no other documents regarding the ownership and title in the name of my mother of the property in question11.."

1;<", ! "11.The property was purchased/owned by late Major B.S. Bhatti. The same was purchased by him. He was Army Officer at that time. It is correct that the sale deed of portion of the entire property measuring 10 marlas in my favour, the same was executed by him11."

"11.I am not doing any work. It is correct that my husband has purchased property measuring 10 marla on 16.01.1976 in my name. I have purchased other properties also in my own name besides the above said property of 10 marla from Udham Singh, but I do not remember, date, month and year. I have produced on record the sale deed/ownership of the other property on record.

 /   +  =

  ) ! 0  $3 #$ $-93)  7> 1.      0   ?!    !  !!))0)!= ! !!

. The property which I have purchased Ex.P4 is the property E51 New Beant Nagar, Chogiti, Jalandhar. I do not

know about the khasra number of above said property. Mutation was sanctioned in my favour with regard to above said property of 10 marla.

!!  0,  !  !!

0 ! $<$@" 2  =!   5  . It is wrong to suggest that the property measuring 151/2 kanal in the name of late Major B.S.

Bhatti, vide registered sale deed dated 15.02.197911."

"11.It is correct that the 151/2 kanal land purchased by my husband forms part of house No.E51 New Beant Nagar, Jalandhar. It is correct that the entire land i.e. 10 marla + 151/2 kanal is entered in revenue record11."

"11.I have brought the original of Ex.P1 to P4. I have no proof of my ownership regarding the properties which I have transferred in the name of plaintiff No.2 vide documents Ex.P1 to P311."

-%@.

 
!



 
 

!!


 



  
<



 0
 
98
" 

 
 
%=8%%>+=
0
!


  
<
%8
" 
!

5


  
 
!


!!






 





0
 
 
  
 
%
!
 
  0
 
 

!!

1 
 
!
  0
23%
 
 


#

!



 

 
!

 


!

  


!!
4

 
 
%>8*(8%8
8%8=(8%8

8@89(8%8

 
1  
0
!!
%

!
!
!!
(
4 

 

!


" 
(9
" 





 
"

!!
%


  
!
0
%8
" 
!!


 




0
 


  
<



 0
4
  
" 



!
 



!

0


!
!

!!
4
  

 
!
 
)"" /)  

0
!
! 
  
!
 " 


!

1 


0
 


  

 " 
!
 
4 



* +  A  &!'


  A  &!'



 

 
 1


-%=.




" 
 
0
   
 
!

 
 

 

 0


!

 





"


 ! 


  



  



 

 ! 

   
 " 

 ! 0
  
 
!!
%


0
0
!

 
 
%=8%%>+=
0


1 
!
%8
" 
4




!!

 

  
<




!!

:
  !
!

 : 
!


!

 ! 

:
 !

0
  ! 


  
 " 
 

$
 
 

0





 
 
%@8(%>+>
!
*8
" 
!


 !
 

!  

 
!
 ! 

 0
  
4 
 



 
  

0

) 
 
2 
!


$
 
 

  0

<
 

" 
*8
" 
 


 
!





 
&



"
: 




" 

 
 
" 0
; 0

 "


6 "


%@8(%>+>'

"
 



 
0


 

!

$
 
 


 
!
 !
!

B

!
!
 ! 
%
! 
%
 

!

 

!

$
 
 

 

 !



 0

 !
 


$ 

 


! 
! 


 !!


 
0
 
 

 

  


 0
0
0
!
0
 
 " 
 
!
 ! 
%


1 
!

 



 0


 "


!
 
 
!

 

!
  "
!


 

 /




"

 0
!
  !
$
 
 

!
 ! 
%

 
 


1 
!
%8
" 

!
98
" 




$ 

!
 
" 


:

 

!


! " 0
$ 
0
 
 ! 
%


 


" 


!
 
0
0
!
 

 




-%+.

 !
 

$ " 



 




 

0

 ! 




B
 
%@%8(88A
1  
0

$
 
 

!
!
 ! 
%


  


! 
 
0
 
) 

 


C
 
) 



!! 
 
 B


  

 
=A

=>
!

5
2 

 
B3%


 


 

! "

3 1"





 

   



 





B

B3*
 
)  C" 

 

  

 ! 

  
!
" $

C" 



 





!!  

 

" 
"
!

=>
!

5
2 
 


 
!

 
 

! 
 

 
 



!


  
 
!

"


B





B


1  


"
 
5


 
  

 D 



! 
 
<


B

 

-%A.

4:

 


! 

< 
!


 

!! "




 

) 
 

" 

"   

  
!!


 



  
!

 
 0
4
  
!

!!

 
0
<
%8
" 
!

!!



 0

:
 
!

%8
" 
!


  


0
" 

 3


!

 0

 :
 
4
  

! " 0
$ 


  
! "





"

 " 0



!!



 :
 
0
0
!
 

 0

 
0

 1 
!
%8
" 




 0

-%>.

? 
 


5
"
!
  


! 
 
0

) 
 

!
" 
!
 


"


 0
 





-(8.

5
 
!

$ " 

 
 
0
 ) 
 

 
 
4
  
 

   0
 
4

! 
0

!!





" 


 
 

   0
 
!
 "
 <  

!
















   

  (+8@(8(8











 
-."!."//" %&"01%2" 3$&4  "%1 -."!."//"2/! 56" "%1