High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/52/2014dismissed

Ram Sakhi Bharti v. Panna Lal Sharma

2015-11-19Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan5 pages

!"#"$%&%'() * +,%, -!% .."// '!

0"-&1& '' 2 /, -* "&.'#"'!

( 32 4 2 -"&"'!(5

-0 -%'#"-41* - '#,%-6#7$ !"6 -!," .."// '! 8,"!,"-!,"".-!"-&/$ /'"9&. ."-* :;" //9"#!&"" !,"<1#=*"'!> ;"-""--"#!!,"".-!"--'! ? 8,"!,"-!,"<1#=*"'!&,1/#;"-".-!"#%'!,"#%="&!> 55 55 2 6

2 *.1='"#%'!,".-"&"'!-"=1/ -&"$'# .." /%&!," <1#=*"'! '# #"$-"" # !"# ??6 . &&"# ;: !," /" -'"# ##%!%' / %&!-%$! 1#=" #,$6 &! - $+ 1-!6 *-%!& -6 %-*%'=!,"<1#=*"'! '##"$-""# !"#@6. &&"#;:!," /" -'"# %7%/1#=" 1'%-%7%&%'6*-%!& -69,"-";:!,"&1%! !," ./ %'!% - .&&"&&%' ;: 9 : &."$%%$ ."--* '$" =-""*"'!!&"//# !"#@69 &#"$-""#9%!,$&!& '#!," .."// '!9 &#%-"$!"#!"A"$1!"!,"& /"#""# &."- !," =-""*"'!& /"# !"#@69%!,%' ."-%#!9

55 *'!,& !"--"$"%7%'=!,"; / '$"& /"$'&%#"- !%'6%' 71- !,"./ %'!%6 %/%'=9,%$,!,"./ %'!%91/#;" !/%;"-!:!"A"$1!" !,"& /"#""#;:! +%'=-"$1-&"!/ 9 ,"#""'# '! .."// '!

9 & /&-"&!- %'"#-*!- '&"--%'=6 /%"' !%'=6&"//%'=6*-!= =%'=6 /" &%'=1!6/"!!%'=1!!,"&1%!.-."-!:6"A$".!%'#1"$1-&"/ 9 &."-!,"$ &"!,"./ %'!%6!,"#""'# '! .."// '!

, #"A"$1!"# ' =-""*"'!& /"-"= -#%'=#%&.1!"#.-."-!:' @-&66 5&66 59"-". %# &" -'"&!

*'":,"& /"#""#9 &!;""A"$1!"#'-;"-"@ ,".&&"&&%''"-*1!!,"&1%!.-."-!:9 &#"/%7"-"#! !,"./ %'!%,"-" !"-6'!,"-"B1"&!!,"#""'# '! .."// '!6 !,"# !""A"$1!%'& /"#""#9 &"A!"'#"#!C '

!," & %# # !"6 !," ./ %'!% .." -"# ;"-" !," 1; "=%&!- -6 *-%!& -6 /'=9%!,; / '$"& /"$'&%#"- !%'%'!,"&, .". : -#"- #"* '##- !C?# !"#)C- &1*& 66 5 '# !,"- -"=%&!- !%' $, -="&6 ;1! !," .."// '!#%#'!!1-'1. ,"$ &"!,"#""'# '!

.."// '!%&!, !#"'% /!

9 & &! !"# !, ! !," ./ %'!% %& 4 -%: ' "-$, '! '# !,"

.."// '! 9 & ,%& $1&!*"- ," ./ %'!% #7%&"# !," .."// '! ! &"'# ,"- &' ;- #6 ;1! #""'# '! 9 & 1' ;/" ! &"'# ,"- &' #1" ! &$ -$%!: *'": ," .."// '! =-""#!%'7"&!&66 5-"A."'&"&!

5?5 ;" %'$1--"# - 7%& '# !- 7"//%'= "A."'&"& ," .."// '!. %#&@6 5%'$ &, /'=9%!,. &&.-! ,"-&' '#-%=%' /& /"#""#-"&%#"'!% /,1&","./ %'!% =-""# ! %'7"&! !," ; / '$" *1'! & ?66 5 '# !,"

-%=%' /& /"#""#-"* %'"#%',%&$1&!#: &&1-"!:,"!,1*; %*.-"&&%'&#""'# '!

.."// '!9"-";! %'"#'#%"-"'!&! *.

. ."-& &&1-"!: "%!,"-,"- #""'# '!3&&', & ;""'&"'!

;- #'-!,"-%=%' /& /"#""#!,".-."-!:%'B1"&!%' '# ;/ '+!,1*;* -+"# &%='"#&! *.. ."-& /'=9%!,&@6 . %#;:!,"#""'# '!

.."// '!%'$ &,!!,"./ %'!%6, 7";""'

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

55 $-&&5"A *%' !%' &,9& !, ! ," , # '! &%='"# ': !,"- #$1*"'!!%&$'!"'#"#!, !!,"&! !"*"'!#""'# '! .."// '!

$1./"#9%!,&"7"- /"'#-&"*"'!&&,9!, !!," =-""*"'!& /" %&- 1# '# ;-%$ !"# ,"."-1& / =-""*"'!& /"&,9&!, !!,"-" -" & * ': &%7""'#-&"*"'!&6"A!"'#%'=!,"# !""A"$1!%'!," & /"#""# ," /" -'"# $1'&"/ - !," #""'# '! .."// '! , & -=1"#!, !'!,""'#-&"*"'! A61'#"-!,"&%=' !1-"&!,"

./ %'!%6!,"# !"%&*"'!%'"# &??69,"-" &1'#"-!," !,1*;%*.-"&&%'#""'# '!

.."// '!6!,"# !"%&*"'!%'"# & D? '# !,"-" %& 7"-9-%!%'= 7"- !," *'!, %' !," & %# "'#-&"*"'! ,"."-1& /!,"/ &!"'#-&"*"'!&,9&!, !!,"-"%& '$1!!%'=-7"-9-%!%'=%'!,";#:!,""'#-&"*"'!6;1!!,"-"%& 7"-9-%!%'= 7"- !," # !" 1'#"- !," &%=' !1-"& !," ./ %'!% 9"7"-6 !,"-" %& ' 7"-9-%!%'= 1'#"- !," &%=' !1-"& !,"- !!"&!%'= 9%!'"&&"& '# !," !,1*; %*.-"&&%'& !," .."// '! +"&, 41* -6 &'

!,"

.."// '!, # /&&%='"#!,%&"'#-&"*"'! ," $! !, ! !,"-" -" %7" "'#-&"*"'!& '# " $, "'#-&"*"'!6 9,%$, ;" -& !," !,1*; %*.-"&&%' #""'# '! .."// '!6 &,9& !, !

!,"&"$ ''!;" ;-%$ !"#6 &$/ %*"#;:!,"#""'# '! .."// '!

55 ,"/ &!"'#-&"*"'! /&;" -&!,"&%=' !1-"&!,"&'!," #""'# '!69,9 & //"="#/:!;"&"'! ;- #,"-"-"6 * !,"7%"9!, !!," 1-!&;"/9, 7"-%=,!/:,"/#!, !!," =-""*"'! & /", &;""'.-7"# ,"-"-"6!,"&1%!9 &-%=,!/:#"$-""# 9%!,$&!& $"# 9%!, !,%& &%!1 !%'6 !," /" -'"#$1'&"/ - !," .."// '!, & -=1"#!, !%!%&!,"'/:-"&%#"'!% /,1&"!," .."// '! '#%!%&$ &"1'#1", -#&,%.,"-"-"6!," /!"-' !%7"-"/%"* :;"=- '!"# *!,"7%"9!, !!,"-"%&'!,%'='%/"!&,9!, ! %! 9 & "7"- ./" #"# ;"-" !," 1-!& ;"/9 - %' !," 9-%!!"'

&! !"*"'!!, !!,"-"%& ':&1$,1'#1", -#&,%.,"-"-"6&1$, ./" $ ''!;" //9"#!;"- %&"#-!,"%-&!!%*";"-"!,%&

1-!,"-" -"'*"-%!&%'!,".-"&"'!-"=1/ -&"$'# .." /'- ':&1;&! '!% /B1"&!%'/ 9 -%&"&%'!,"& *" "'$"6!," .-"&"'!-"=1/ -&"$'# .." /%&#%&*%&&"#

) &<+&