← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/190/2018dismissed

Mohd. Abid And ANR v. Gurdev Singh Deceased And ORS

2018-05-15Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma6 pages





    



 !""#$%$&' ()*

+,-$,  &!+".

//"00 &!% 1".%2% 2.,"3$&4+ %$&#","#" %",!+.24+5 % !+".%  "%/&,"&!%  !"#$%&' ()%)(*$

."%"&!'

.6 .7$! .8 &*,3# !"* .!+" //"00 &!% 99999 )(*$+&

:);

.  !+"  ." %&%  6"&!$&",  $&  !+"  //0$# !$&*  <+$#+  $% %2//.!",  -(  &  $, 3$!*  ,"0 (    :  , (%  $&  .";$0$&4  !+"  //" 0  $% #&,&", %! &,%,$%/%", :=;

. (".$&!+" //0$# !$&$%.-.$&4$&4&."#.,!+"5 % 2.,"3  $&4+;."%/&,"&!    +"  //0$# !$&  $%  %2//.!",  -(  & $, 3$!

.  !+"  ." %&%  6"&!$&",  $&  !+"  //0$# !$&*  !+"  % 6"  $% 00<",%2-7"#!! 0072%!">#"/!$& &,!+"/".%&%6"&!$&",$& . ? !+" //0$# !$& ."$6/0" ,", %5 %."%/&,"&!.!+"/2./%" /.%"#2!$&4!+$% //" 0&0(

 //"00 &!;/0 $&!$% ." 44.$"3",!+"#&#2.."&!$&,$&4%*



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

"%/&,"&!;,""&, &!    //" .",  &,  $0",  <.$!!"& %! !"6"&!,"&($&4!+"">"#2!$&!+" 4.""6"&!!%"00!< %%! !",!+ ! +"< %# 00",$&!+"$#"!+"/0 $&!$%!/2.#+ %"%6"/./".!($&!+" & 6"+$%<$" &,%$&#"!+" //"00 &!;/0 $&!$%<"."/./".!(," 0".%* 4!!+"%$4& !2."% &,#&3".!",!+"% 6"$&! 4.""6"&!!%"00""&, &! % &,?$0",!+"$.%"/ . !"<.$!!"&%! !"6"&!% &,%! !",!+ !!+"( ." -& $,"/2.#+ %".%.3 02 -0"#&%$,". !$& $&#"!+"/ .!$"%<"." !3 .$ &#"*!+"!.$ 02.!. 6",!+" 00<$&4$%%2"%';

  



        

    

     

,



  



  

   

   !!"# 

          



$

 !  

   

  

  

   

%

  !        

         

   



     

&

 !  

    

   

                    '(  

   







     (  

   



$ )  ! 

  

*

 !  

       

    





$

+

  

  

   

     



       

  

  



 

) 

 

, '  

- 

$ )

   !

   

 .

   )             

,/$     



   

)

,  0 1 //"00 &!;/0 $&!$%"> 6$&", +,+ -$. % A;* !!"%!$&4 <$!&"%%*<+< %&&""0%"-2!!+" !+"./0 $&!$ &,/0 $&!$ -,20 !! .+$6%"0%!"//",$&!!+"<$!&"%%-> % A; &,/0 #", &."#.,7 6 - &,$.!+"(" .B;> *% 0","",, !", > ?* 7 6 - &,$  .!+" (" .B; > :  &, !. &%". ,"", , !",  %> )

-

&!+"!+".+ &,*!+",""&, &!%"> 6$&", %6 &( %$3" <$!&"%%"%*$"*A;2.,"3$&4+*A; &7$!$&4+*A;? "+ .- & $&4+! 6/1"&,.*A;?+2/$&,".$&4+*A;: 7.$&4+ &, A;)+ + -2,$& +"!.$ 02.!*&!+"- %$%!+""3$,"&#"-.24+!&."#.,* ,$%6$%%",!+"%2$!&!+"/."6$%"!+ !!+"/0 $&!$% $0",!/.3"!+" ">"#2!$&    !+"  4.""6"&!  !  %"00*  62#+  0"%%  / %%$&4    !+"  % 0" #&%$,". !$& &, //" 00 $,-"."!+"5<".//"00 !"2.!< % 0% ,$%6$%%",

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

+ 3" &(, 24+!" !  < %  &">!  #&!"&,",  !+ !  !+"  %! 6/  / /".%  <"."  0% /2.#+ %",& &,A; ,6$!!",+$%%$4& !2."%&!+" 4.""6"&! %"00 " ,$&"%% &,<$00$&4&"%%+ , 0%-""&/.3",*.*$&3$"<!+" -." #+!+"!"6% &,#&,$!$&%*!+"%2$!< %$0",-"."!+"">/$.( !+"%!$/20 !",, !"00!+"%" #!.%+ 3"&!-""&08",$&!$&#.."#!

.

/".%/"#!$3" &,*!+2%*!+"."$%$00"4 0$!( &,/".3".%$!( + 3"+" .,!+"0" .&",#2&%"0.!+" //"00 &!;/0 $&!$%* //. $%",!+"/ /".-8 &,!+"3$"<!+ !!+"."$%&.#" &,6".$!$& !+"%2-6$%%$&%!+"0" .&",#2&%"0 2.$&4!+"#2.%"!+"+" .$&4*/+!#/(!+" 4.""6"&! !%"00+ %-""&%+<&!!+$%2.!+"% 6"-" .%!+"/+!4. /+%&!+" $.%!/ 4"*<+$#+,$,&!+ 3"%$4& !2."%!+"/0 $&!$%*,""&, &!. + . &7$!C 2. &0(&" !!"%!$&4<$!&"%% +,+ -$.*<+$%&&""0%"

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

$% 0% $0",!%/"002! %!<+!(/", &, ,. !",!+" 4.""6"&!!%"0000!+"%" #!.%<"$4+",$&!+"6$&,!+" 2.!%-"0<$&.6$&4 &/$&$&!+ !!+" 4.""6"&!< % #!2 00(&! "&!"",$&!-"!<""&!+"/ .!$"%*-2!!+"% 6"< %/."/ .",&-0 &8/ /".% -" .$&4!+26-$6/."%%$&*!+".<$%"*!+"!+26-$6/."%%$&%<20,+ 3" -""&&!+"/+!4. /+% 0% &#2.."&!$&,$&4% #! &,0 < ..$3", !-(!+"2.!

/

-"0<*62#+0"%%!+" .426"&!%!+"0" .&",#2&%"0$%&! -0"!-.$&4 !+"# %"<$!+$&!+"." 06/".3".%$!(!.6 ,$"."&!/$&$&!+ &!+" &" ..$3", !

.!+"." %&%%! !", -3"*!+"."$%&$00"4 0$!(./".3".%$!( $&!+"$&,$&4%2&,".#+ 00"&4"4.2&,.$&!"."."&#"$%6 ,"2!* 62#+0"%% &(%2-%! &!$ 0D2"%!$&0 < .$%"% "%20! &!0(*!+" //" 0$% ,$%6$%%", 0.+  )(*$

123 &'45% *363278 92

 :29

*363 6; :29