The Hoshiarpur Express Transport Company Ltd v. Jagbir Singh And ORS






      
   

  !

"#$%&$'%$!!$#(!% $) *)+ ) $ &, ")!"$-) $&$.) "(,  )")" ($ /$!&!

#,0"$ "(, #(+ ) $!

 !% (+()!

1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

 2

  !

"#$%&$'%$!!$#(!% $) *)+ ) $ &, ")!"$-) $&$.) "(,  )")" ($ /$!&!

#,0"$ "(, #(+ ) $!

 !% (+()!

1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 3 

  !

"#$%&$'%$!!$#(!% $) *)+ ) $ &, ")!"$-) $&$.) "(,  )")" ($ /$!&!

#,0"$ "(, #(+ ) $!

 !% (+()!

!$4+ (2 

 $ ( &(-+ (5 6 

 5  7* 


 /

 8 

  

!"#$%&

   )'#(*#$%&

   "($%&

  

 

 --------  /

 89 .'(&,,

'##(! /% 

(,(#

(    0  

 ( (&#  (  

  '*

    2   &% ( & 

(3

&

 ,




  0

'(!

((# 1

(5 



 *( '$

(&#  
 (6(( 71'(3

 

 $

   !   /0

(# 
1

  %( *'(&'   ((#

+&&1 1

 6( 8%(

&!0

5

/0*0# (3 *(,(   "

& & 

 

(#     & (,(#  &,!#(  3(  !

+&,!0 

+&,!0

3

*(  2

! ( */1 / (3

3(

( "" 

5#3*( 1

 ,:'( !1 ! *( *

(!( (# 1

 ,:'( !1 "' !1 *( '

(! !#0(3 6 (1

&,!#( &&1  9 ;(

 (3'* )(


,!0 (, ( (

&,!#( '

#3*( '<1 ; (3'#(

 3

*( / '#

+&,!0

(3

&&1 '3

 2 ! ( */1 #3*(

1

&& (3#0/1 *

' %

&&1  6 *1

3

3

&&1 '## !0&

(,1  (#( 1

'*

*'

9 &&1 (# !0 (,1 &,!#(  (,

#

 

+*3

/ !(  /0

( &&1  = (!1 ! 1 &'

 #,1 

+

5

 *

(1 &&1 *'(&'*

(3 /0

( *!

)(


,!0 >'

&'

/

/2 *

('

*(

, 2 ?(1(&( 1@



1 !

&,!#( *

(#       (  *'(&' 

(# 
1

 !   

 

   9   1,,(3

+&,!0#3*( ';(

 (3'$&&'

(3'  '*   .'

 &  (  *  (4        

+&,!0!!#(& (*,%

1

 6(8%( 3  (3!

,((

&!0

5 /0*0

6 (

* 

(  

  5   %(  *'(&'   

(  ;(

 (3'

.'

&&1  9*

,%  , ! 3(3)(

&1,<

#3

A%(  (3';*!!(

3(3 )(

#3

+&,!0 .'



'1!# 

(

5 *

 84 B( 
(%(# 1(  5

   #  
 

              6

(&(%(#1( !!#(& (*,% &'3

 ,    A%(  (3'  C  ;    3(3  )(

# 3

1/

'(,*( ' ;

 (3'D##(*'*

5 !#( ( 9( (&(%(#1( 6 *#

  (3(# 

     ( 

(  

  5  (    ( ! (

+&,!0'*

( &

&!0(!



(&(%(#1( 

#  /0!

%(3

(

(/0

2(3( &

&!084 B( (&(%(#1(  6 (#

&(%(#1( 1/ (3!#( ( 9 *##* 
(%(#
1

*'(# && (3 (

(( *   1(  !

((3    (!1

 /

  
   ,3   '

'#

&,!0  .'

&

(!!#(& 

(#
1

%( (,!13 

  

(,(

( .'

!

(% !

1

:/"+) "!#%%;"-#)" (9*+ &(!;< $#--&!+ #!4"$ "(,  #=#>#()!) %$ +&-#(+%$ 4)

-$)"<"+- %? <$! ;&)" (+#)+ 6 

0?>#?

<!- (+#$?4"+(-8") $,#$+) %$ +&-"(,)

!#"+-$)"<"+- %?9")"!!&<<"-"()) ( )) #)-$)"<"+ - %? <$! ;&)" ( #!#;$#+?0(%;#-+ ($- $+ #; (,>") ) "!#%%;"-#)" ($&!#; <!#"++ -&.() $4#;!) #)'@>#!.#$A+"() #)"4"; &") &% (  )   !#"+  $! ;&)" (  #  #("  -#!  "!  ( ) #%%;"-#0; $#!.$'

"0")" ( <+ -&.()"!

! . ) $-#!+ !( )+"!%(!>") ")!. + < %$ < 
)  #!  0(  #;;,+  ) #)  + -&.()  '  @ B $","(#;C"!( )#4#";#0;"() #)-"4";!&")))

. !)9  ) "!  -$)"<"+  - %?  #;$#+?  %;#-+  -#(  0 4$"<"+
< $","(#;>$;?"(,) #)<";) (!")&#)" ( - &;+ #40(+"<<$() (;?>#?) %$ 4) "!

+ -&.()  "!  )  '#."(  #&) $  <  ) "!  + -&.()

&.. ("(,-"4";!&")<";>";;( )!$4#(?%&$% !   ) $  #&) $")"!  #$  #;!  ( )  #%%;"-#0;  #!

-$)"<"+- %? <$! ;&)" ("!#;$#+? ($- $+#(+ "( ) $<";#;!  $","(#;"!( )#4#";#0;   #%%;"-#)" (0"(,!#(!.$")!)#(+!+"!."!!+D

  &1 #

+&,!0'

!  (

&!0

5 *'(&'*

84 B(&(%(#1( ( (&#  ,

 5  ! (&(%(#1(  /(

 !#( (*1/

  (1

 (3(#





  5  (    (  ! (     !

+&,!0  

' ,%   (!

0(3  # (3 *'(&''/

(,(

(#
1

&1 #

'

1! 



!!

"

#$ %& !''   $    ( ) *" +    *'

(  '( 
1

  *'(#  ##*(3    !!#(& (    #    (&(%(#1( ''

# *'

!#( ('/

/# '* (3(#&1, ( 3

 ##

(!

'%

# (

3 '

'#3 

!

*( !#(&

(  &&

  4(

    &1,  (    (!1

   ##*

 &1 #

'#

1! ##,

- "

    .-/

0+
 1 !  ! *  +   *'

((,(# %( *'/

2   6

!#0# &1 #



/(     '(  (%( +

!#0  '  1/,(

   !

+&,!0

13'( 3(3)(

#3

;(

 (3' <1 ; (3'#('

3

2(3! (  */1 #3*( 1

 ,:'( !1 ! *( *

(!( (# 1

 ,:'( !1 "' !1  '

1!&!0 3

  *'(&'(

(1

1/,(



+&,!0#3 =6  

   3(

 '(&(



& (33( (

&,!0

,%(3,

#3*(

3(

& ((3

(%( *'(&'

  ;(

 (3' *## #0

,%  , ! 3(3 )(

#3

0  .'

A1(&(#3(

=( 
#:'( !1 %( ( ;13,

9  

'&71(

(&&1 

(# ## 3 (3( '(,

  &1 # 

' 1

1/,(



## 3 (* (

# (3 '/

,% *( '!#  '#

0 /

(/ A6
:'( !1 *'(#  &((3 (,(#

(# ((31 

(=6 

(1

1/,(

(3

( &( (

# (3 

 , 1

&

('/

,% ;1  #0 &

(3 & 

 !(

'%(3



# *(  '%(3(1 1 &'

  #1, 

+*'(&'*

#

('

/2(

0(3 &

*'(&'(

,((/#  ## 

(1

 * !

0(

&(%(#1( *'

(

(*!



%

0 &  (  * !

  

  #0  !1 !  

 1/ (3       !#( (  (   
   (!1

 /

 

,3 '

'#

+&,!0'*

(%(#
1



&&

(

(# 3# ( * #0 !1 ! 1/ (3 !#( (

(

&

!1/#(&&1, !

 6( 8%( :

&

( &%

1

%(( 9 6(8%(

 $

'

(3# &1 # !

'%(33

13' &1, %(#/# 

6(,

(  $!

1# !' &!0

(*'(&'(!#& 

$

9*1#'* ( (

(*'(&'* , 84 B(&(%(#1( 

'*

!

1#



 5 

1!/0

*'

, (

(3(# '(

5 *!

/


(%(#
1



*

 .'

(#(# /1

& (/

(

( 0!

*''(3  *''!!

*(  (&1, 

( * #3*( ',(& ## 1!!#(& (/


(%(#
1

1/ (3 !#( (


(%(#
1

' &&( !!#0( ,(*'(# && (3 (&1, 
1

'  

 

    (3(#     ,    & (/

   0   

(3

('!!



 (,0!(( &

&

&!0



5 !

9 6(8%( 

&1, *'(&'(,((/# 1

( 6(8%(

 (#*

' (&(3

(&(3!

 &1 (!

&

(31

 3 (/# 6

1, $&  &&1 (' (31 &'

  #%#1  

+ *'(&'!

*

(1 

#

&,!#(  ((31 3

!#0(3 */1 (%( *

#

  /

,  8% 1

+&,!0'(# 

0&1,

*'

((

 4,( (01&'133 (*3(% 

&&1  9;(

 (3'* 3(3)(

# 3

&,!0

*'

(3

*

/

'

(#(3 ( # (3 (#0  #0 &

(3 /

(#
1

6%( * /% (&1(((33 1 ##*

# !

! 

(

'

/0 (,(    .'

(#
1

((

&&#1

(# 4!

( (1#0



/#0*( '(!

((4, '  #(&#$? 69

 B /

 8C