Manoj Kumar & ORS. v. State Of Haryana & ORS.
! " # "
$%$&'$()
"*+$ ($,-%-)
*)./01*&*)(+2$&% $+-+-)$&% 3$&%0% 4+*+$ *&5*)**)(+2$&% $%6)($)+% 7!8 4 8/4 8
!"#$$%&'#(%$)* + ,
-
!"#$$%&'#(%$'* , -.
/
0 1
1 () .+12*
/
1 3%33 !"#$$%&' (%$)* + ! 4
5 / 6 5 1
1 37 3& !"#$$%&' (%$)* 5 -
1 (7(8 !"#$$%&'#(%$)*
$ 5 # / 6
5 /
$( %7 (%$)6/ / # # 6
: ( 5
/ ; <#
!" #$ " #
#
%&'(& %% #
&'(& %%
# )"
&& ## ((&'*& +
," - .
- /.0 $
1#" 2 # #
.& '& % ," -(
- /0'
," -(( - /0.
"# # " 4"$
# "6 +
7"
.% 8 8# ##
&'(& %%
," -
- /*+
# ##
/&'(&
(&'.&
( &'*&
'*&'/& ( '+& (& (
(& '& / ," -(+ - / %
# " 4" $
##
&'.&('
"# "6 +
7"
.%
)"
"
"#6 ## "
4"
" $
9 : 9# # ;
"
)#
"# " # $< 5.
/ 9 /
=.9 =*
/6
6;/
6
/ 9 / /* $87'
= $87' =*
6 # :
$8))
=$8))=*
6 9 /
9 9 * $8)&
=$8)& =* > <#
!"!#$%&$!'( = &2 >#
8 1? "@ # " # "# #
A
# "# #
># # "B
" # # ># # "
# #"
" # "
" 4""B
#" (C # @ ># # # # B
#
,# " ># "# ('B
#
># "# (/ # " #B
"
># "# (.B
#"
#
># # # #B
, 1# 2B
9
"# .+B
!
"
># "# . B /C !!
,# " "## "
# "# "
"
*
"# "
(
0(B@
" >#D " "#
,# "A -## " "# "
.C #
# !!
@
#
" 7 1 # " "# "
#
# " " &
')$* !&$'($!' ++ !' , !-(!'($'&!!-(
#
# #
, 7 -"!
# #
" 7 -"!
" 4"#
# 9 1
" 7&
(
# #
9 1
# # " 7
# "
# # # "
## &
/
# "# "
(
" 7 #
# " 7 " #
# "
1 # #" "
##
9 1&
.
2 9 1
# #
" #
# # " 7B #
" # 4" #
# #
#
" &
*
2
%
&
E
## # #
9
- 9" # # G
7A -## # #
# #
# "
"
(
# ## , " 9 1&
')$* $ .!$/ - !0 '&'( $ '&' #'
&$!'( +1 + #'!-($*#$/*$'!0 #!/( '/$/ *!" $( .!$/ #$ /#''$$(2
>
# &
>
## )"
>
#
1
7
># G# 1& -## " 9## # # 4" # : 9 # #, >
" # # # - ,
# 1#" #
) +*'
,# & 2 1#" 2
#
" ,"
>#& 2 >#
2 #6 #" #" # &<
4 5 6 .7
4
G /*H 2
" #
# "
" 4" 9"
7"
)" " " 7"
# "# >#& 2 " /*H 4" "#
A
7"
# " # 4" I" 4" #
'
J" K 7"# 7"
7 8 9 ) 8 "
##
>#
4" #
L J" ,
'H 2 &
7"
# # # # I ?# " *
># "
"
J" &&& ,
.H M" - &
:
: # # #
# 9 : #
, " , .H M" &
#
7"
# > I #" >#&& , +H 7 -
"# 4" &
2 " #
#
7"
#
##
-
#
#
7"
#
" /*H # ># " /*H %'H # ," " " 7"
# # # ," &< & 5 # ; 6 ; 6 )&?* 3&?*
5 # ;
/ 6 /; /; 6
) @ %8 %' $8A7; 9
: 6 <#
: )" 0*H
- : ('H
N# 6I
O"P *
#
&I& & "
*H
: E# #
'H
# 2&I&
2 I
5
(( %$ $8A8 <# &$!' !0 ')$* $ .!$/ - !0 '&'( $ #'
&$!'( +1 # "
"# A G /*H " #
# "
" 4" # " %'H ," " 7"
# "# ># 4"
7"
# " # 4" I" 4" #
'
J" K 7"# 7"
7 8
9 "
##
>#
4" ,
'H "# 4" &
2 7"
# # # # I ?#
"
># "
"
J" ,
.H "# 4" &
7"
# : # # # #
# 9 N# # # #
, " , 0H "# 4" &
#
"
# > I , *H "# 4" &<
'
"
7
; 9 6 9 > <# ;
$<0=*+-)>- G /*H 2
" #
# "
" 4" 9"
7"
)" " " 7"
# "# >#& 2 " /*H 4" "#
A
7"
# " # 4" I" 4" #
'
J" K 7"#& 7"
7 8 9 ) 8 "
##
>#
4" #
L J" &&& ,
'H 2 &
7"
# # # # I ?# "
># "
"
J" &&& ,
.H M" &
: : # # #
# 9 : #
, "&&& , .H
" &
#
7"
# > I &&& , +H &Q
$8 %( $8''; 9 6
5 ; 3&? 6# /=- = =- = 5 ;
6 /6
> 5 > <# 3 *2 &$!' & !0 &$!'2, ($ * (*(/$('/2
M 1 9#
2 # : " &
Q "
#Q J" M#67"
76269 J" 1# M#67"
76269 /
: I &
M 1 9# 26N #6>>I> & Q "
#Q J" 2
B I M # 7 7" /
: 6I &
>
9"
7"
)"
)"0
"
"# "#A
>
," ## )" &
9"
7"
)" #
)"0
"
"# "#&&
>
," ## )" &
:
)"
"
"# "#
)"
#A
>
: )"& 0*H
>
1 9# "#A (( B?
; 3&?
9 6
9 - !
> 9
* @ 9 6
- !
( * * & / 7
, 9 #C - !
:
5 D./D
*@ 9 6
- !
C9D E
& / $( B?
* / - !
<#
* @ 9 6
-
( *
* & /
!D @
(( B?
; 3&?
9 9 6 - !
6
9 - !
:
5 D./D
*@ 9 6
- !
C9D E
& / $( B?
$% + / $( $% $883 $8)&
<# :&
)"
"
"# "#A
)"
#
>
# "
0*H
>
1 9#
/*H "#A
M "
#
((RH ## 1 9# "# )" ('
'
*
J" &
M "
#
(RH 1 9# I 6: 4" # *
"
>
1 9# "#
M "
#
((RH 1 9# ## )"(
*
J 6> 9
M
(RH "
# 1 9# I 6> 4" # *
"& -## " 4" L
"# 5
& -## " 4"# ##
#
# "
, "
#
4"# # &< $$ / $8 %( $8'' $%?10 . 10.* 7?0
6
5 9 6
6#
* 6# 5
6 6<# %%-%+*)+)<-)$$&* +$&> >
F)&?
- !
@ * - !
F3&? - !
F3&? - !
)&?
(( &? 0
6
& / * $( &?
C9D 6
& / * (( &? 0
6
- & / * $( &?
C9D 6
- & / * $( $8 %( $8''6
(( %& $8A8 <# $' %( $8''* )&?
F3&?
)&?
9D! #CC $7? 0
6 & / * $%?
1# 6 $%/ * A? C9D 6 7?
D0
$3 6
6
9 / / $87'/ / 9 /
6 9 / =9 =* ,
6
6.
/ .
1!5 0 G $' %8 $8))
6 # :
$8)) C
( 6*
/ 16$8)) = /= )A
6 # :
$8))# :
9
.
/ / .9 $8)& 6 / 9
6
/ / .9 6 $7
5 5 ;
)&<3& / /
$& / # 6 9
6 6 ! !
" 1 )&&A $883 $)'/'&
/ $'/ $'! -( $$'$ $ .!$/ $'/ !( , ; , 9
6/ $$'$$ .!$/-( $)'/'&
/$'/!( 21 )&A $88A $A $( (%%7* / $(07%,*%$%06&*! # 6
C
6 6 ; G ! #CCC / 6 /
/
/ / 6
/ / /
9 6 $)
# / 6 C 4 '$'/$'/!( -( $$'$ $ .!$/
9 - E& '*/.
* ###
'& (&(''%
# 60 . C9 5 ! /
$3/ C
$-'!$$'/!(-( $$'$.!$/6'$!'8!!$!' #/$'/!(
9- E& 0//'
(''*
0
:
:
G(3 $% (%%) <# N#& ## :&>& "
# )
## , & # # " # # #
# # "& 2 #"
# # "# 9- E& 0**+
/ ### ( &+& +& K-& E& 0*+
+
# 7 J"# ##& N # " # # ## ##
# "& 2 #
#"#
# " #&
# ##
# 4" "# 4"
"#
##
"# & 7" "# "
# 4"
#
#!"# &
," -&
##
*& &(''*
##
# # " #
##
#& #
" # # #
##
*& &(''* 4" #& 2 # K- E&0*+
+ # 9- E&0**+
/ ," -&+ # -&%
# &< $A G%8 %$ (%$7 6
$A %& (%$( 6/
D ! #
6 /
6 > <# HI #"# #
&& 8
*&*&('
( 9 N - G
I&: &
#" #
"
" 4"
"#
/ ; / / /6# / ;
6 5 6 / $883
D
$88$
9 / 6
/ ;
6
#
> / /
> ; #
/ ; ;/
> / 5 /6 6 6/ /
/
8 & (%$( I $'
5 / 6/
> &
C /
6 $( %7 (%$)
6
$8 2=
; C+ +
( (% G A8 $87' 6/2 = /= = = . 6
= = 5 A8 $87'
G ! # * *
*
A8 6 / - ! # * * 6 / G ! # * A8 $87' ; 6
- / ($ 5 6> / 5 6 ! * / 6 / C
6 / C 6
6
: 6# 6 C 6
- /
:
/6/ 6
/ / / / # 6 C
6
C 6
6
6 4# /
> > $)( ! C
6
5> - $)( ! C
> 6 ! (( 5>
> 9 / $87' / (%%3 5 $87' 6 (3 C /6 $87' 6 6/ 9 /(%%3 $'& (* * (%%3 6 6/ - 6/ - C /6
/
/ / / /
/6> 6/- 6 (7 5 6> / C ; / 6 6/ 5;
5 6
6/ #; 6 6 6 C
6 ;
6 C 6
; 6 H" > ;
3&?J (& C 6
6 9 /
9 6 / $8)% >
! # * A8 9 / /*$87'
5
6 6/ .
/ 9 / $% %& $8)A
6.9 C ! #&
6 .9 () 1! ; # +* (A 5
> 0 !
6 C /6
#
6 6/ /
!
9 D .-!2 >
: 0 !
6 9 6 @
/ $8A%#$8A$ / > > #$$ 6 ('
1! > E 1 C* CC* CCC* ( (8 C /6
3A%
6 9 / $&$ .9
6 # :
$8)) ./
$&$ 6 .9 >
9 5// >#3 / :
;
9 5
! 5/ / > #7 #& 5 >#7
:
;
.9 >#& / $8))#)A 5
.9
%$ %7 $8)A $&$ 5> 6/ >#A
/D 6/.9
5
@ / > #' / 6/ .9 3$ $( $8A% 5 / >#&$ (' $% $8$& ! G
! 6 9 9 9 * .9 $&$ 5
/
; > 5
! 6 /
$&$ / .9 .9
9 5 () $% (%$&
/ 3$ $( $8A% 3A(
3$ $( $8A%
6 9 / 9> 9 9! #C* 5 / 6 (' $( (%$&
!
/ ; 6
5
6/
/ 3% 5 / / $A %( $88&
/ )73 9 * 3$ %A $8'7 C /6 .9 %) %3 $8'7 /
9> 9 3$ %A $8'7
/ 9> 9 / / $8''#'8
5 / /6 6/>
6
/ 3$ C /6 ! 6 6/
/
/
; 3( ; CCC* - 5
-5* D #5
D9 ! #CC 5
-5D9#5
/
9 ! #CC 5 -5 #5
6
-5 6 6 6 / /
@ ; 9 ! #CC 6 -5 D #5
. 6 ; 1 CCC* 5 / $88$ ;
6 !;/
3&
/
&( $?&0*&5@
8/4 8 )+
" 2$+2$&%6$*A-)<B&$*%)$( #4B 2$+2$&&$6&+*?=$ #4B