← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2386/2017dismissed

Baldev Singh v. Chaman Singh & ORS

2018-10-17Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu12 pages

    

 

          

  ! "#"$%"&'(    )*" &"+,#,'(    - .

      --      ."$#/# 

!



 0        ( 1- ! 

2-  

    2)3,)44 

   

!   "# $ "$% &'  (  )

      

 !      * $ "$+,&'&' ,      '. "#$$$$$/-  '    ,012     3 4  , 0%2       5 

  "

)     .               

    &' , '   

 

     $+ $6 "$$#   ,   '      -   3          

  %78$  &  7  %1+/*%"7  %#//*/"9#-#: 1/9#-#: ""/9$-;: ";/9$-;:        '  "$$"-$;        <  )    7   = 

,     ,                  &       !    '  . "#$$$$$/- ,      /  " ;! 3 

   >   ', ' . 6+$$$$$/-      '  . "#$$$$$/-  '  &. "#$$$$$/- 

 ;

 ?   , &3&$+ $% "$$* @, , 3 6 $% "$$*  $+ $% "$$*



     6 $% "$$* &   ' % $% "$$*&  ' &.  

,    , &'       &.  

,   # $% "$$*&  3      &'   /  "?;,     

, 

&     &    ! 5   + A  , &'             , '           $+ $% "$$*   ,    '      



 !   /  " ? ; ,  '       

       * 7   8$+    

  &    , 3     3      '      -  "?;4   # $% "$$* 

 '& - 3   6 =     B (  9  : )

& & 3   , 3  9C3 -;?-6: &  &'& &     ,      . *$$$$$$/-   3      

  ', 

D& & .   ,    

  , 3  3       

 ,  , '     &  &3, '& D' "$$#    3

' # '        &      &3 3 

  9C3  -; ? -6:   &      -  ,      . "#$$$$$/-   

' &               ' D  

 , 

 

  

&!,& - ,    &  '!  ,            ! 

% )   ,  

 

!   &'    B (  9  : )

   * $ "$+ 

   '       

 E+."#BB      '!  ;$ $ "$+

, 

 ', &' 

  @,     ,       !  ;$ $ "$+ &   &,   

 =

,    !    ;$ $ "$+    &     &'  -  

&'( 

 



  

'&         

   

!   * $ "$+        ' ,  ' ,           ' ,   '      -  " ? ; , &                ' -  "?;' D  -               ,  3 &        4 &       

      E + . "# BB          ,  3   

   /   "?;  

  & ,  &

D '

              !  

   , & 

,= 7  = 

 ,  &'  (      '. *$6$$$$/-

    ,   

  . 1$$/- ,    =  7  ,   -   '&   ,      '       , =   , ,   &        ,        '     &' 

E+."#BB,    =   F   B ,     4   ,           

 ,  '    ,       )  7   ,   , , ' ' ,     G= H, B D     ,&3    , 'I!   &  ,J



 

   

K    & ,      ,  &        

 4     D,     ' ,, ',  &'  &           '     '

-3

  ',&   

     '      &  ,

   ,       , &3  -3

 &'   # = , B I!   ,  '       - 3

  A-      9C3 -":. $$$$$$/-9C3 -;: . #$$$$$/-9C3 -6: 3     $+ $% "$$*6 $% "$$*9C3 -+:    9C3 -":,  , '&&  ) 7 &      & ) 7      )  ' "$$"-$;9C3 -1: ) 7 ,, )    /+ '  &  &' A- ) 7   - , 

 ' '  &3,   )  7  ,   &   3     ,

 

& '    4       * =  B  

&    &        )  7                    * 7   +          /  "?;  . "*#$$$$/-

  A-/   9C3 A-/:  

 , $+ $% "$$*-  "?;

D     &        &

       9C3 L:        $+ $% "$$*  3             9C3  -": ,  ,   "?; & D         &

,   '                '

   . "#$$$$$/- &'   1 =      B      - ,  ' ,     &  4   ' '&        ,  ',

      '       

 ,. +"6$$$/-4     $   >         &       B      &'  ,      H    & &'&B  ,  ' ,       &           '   

   & ,&  "

  >     &       

   &D 

;

   '&B&,   -  ,    '  ,         

 4   '

D '

. *$6$$$$/-

  

   . +"6$$$/-4    @,  

  $+ $6 "$$#, %D 8 $

         . $#6$$$$/-   C '  . "#$$$$$/-   &      ,   &    $+ $% "$$*&   , 36 $% "$$*,   , 4 '&     . *$6$$$$/-  +    -         E+."# , 6BB      

     &' =  7  ,   -   . 1$$/-  $;

$% "$$* ,   '

  & 

                  -  " ,      

 

   "- ", &       ,    D    -        ,  3       8 "

      ,

     

D  &     ,         ',    & 

 &  D   >           ,  &' 

& B         ,  3   

  I       

  &   ,   & 

D  '

        ! 

 , &     

   , =  7    =  

  ,    &'      (        '. *$6$$$$/-

    ,   

  . 1$$/- ,    =  7  ,   - 

  '&    ,    '    ' ,= 7 ,, & 

,     >    &>  D ,   D&'  B  

         &   A- '  

  9C3 A-/:    ,    $+ $% "$$*   - "   D    &     9C3 L:  $+ $% "$$*3     9C3 -":

=

 &  ,  &'     - " ,    &       A- 

'       '      

) 7   -  ,  '&3      /+ '/      ) 7 , & 3    '    E+.

"# BB  

     HD,     

 ,    6   >          B &,   & , '              '. "#$$$$$/- &'    ',  >J     

 



        K     @K&  B   

,         

       '  

  '    '

    



 

,   &  ',   ,012  

@K&  B  ', 

  &   

   ,&&' #+B     #+ ,   &  

 &' &   

 ,      &'

    #+  ,   ,         #+, '   '   . 3     -

   ! "

 # "$      "$

" % "$  & 

!  "  #

   $ # "

 "    "  '   

"" "

  #  & ()   *$ 

   "

 "  "  

"!+ +&+ #, %"$ ! "+ !,

#  $     

  !  " 

$

 "  

" + # "    ,    !

) ""  # , #- + "$! " #

"

 

$+"$  

"

. "$  

%&$ 

   "

 "   " 

"!+ +&+ #, % +



  !  "     &    " - , "$ 

"

 ""   +% 

&$ "$ 

" #-     "$  "

 # ! "+% + 

 

!  "   &   " - ,"$ ! "+



""  . "$ 

%"$  " 

"

! "+  "$  !!

 "  +  &$ $ "$  

"  " , "



  !  " 

  

  !  "  &   #-   &  / &!

 ! "$" !!  "

"$ & # "

 "% &$ $   "

   #

 "

    "  ' # "$   "

 "0 "

      "  ' &   

  !  "  #

 , 

 

 

 +    $ # "

 "% , 

 

 

         #

 "$  !! "+ #"$  "   1$  " !! &$ "$ !

 !"##

 # "

"

   1$ 

 !

/  # +  +   !

   !+ # "

   1$  -!

  &$ "$ 

  "  "

 , 

 

   !

  "

 $    

 "$ +2    "$" &$ " !

 "

!

  "

, 



%

$ !

#    "  !   &"$   ."   +  

 &$  , 



 ## "

!

 "

!

 "$""$   " 

" "$  "

 "%#,   !

)

""  #, 



%  &     '

  " '&!!+"

 

 ##

# "

 #  "   +   "

 "

*$ %$ &  %#

# "

"/  !   "$ "

  "  #!

  "   #

 ,  "    $ %  "  ' &

 $    !! " 2 

%   >     @K&    B   ! @K& ) @ B, 

!    ( ,      

 

   '  ,012   !        (    =

    , 4 '  &'       @K&    B #  

 &   4   ,       =

&   '   

  &,    2- 

    ! A D /   M/  A &  M/