High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1944/2018dismissed

Gora v. Bir Singh And ORS

2023-01-18Mr. Justice B.S. Walia8 pages

!"#!$%&%"'())* + ) ", -..!//' 0!,&1& %,%'23'4" 3!,& -)!&."'4!' &

",+( "'56/! ,)1& %$!))7/% ,!&!' (

,) 3'4!,3&40840"$ !#", 3!..!//' ) 999 ))7/%8) ,/ ) !21/, !$"'4 ..!/ 3& 6!!' #%/!4 6: "'! "# 3! ./%' %##&..!//' 3!,!%'

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

, &%& !,3",8 %' #0"1, "# ,!&."'4!' ") ;& $'$!//!40%4!,!2%& !,!4$'$!// %"'4!!44 !4))) *) @!,'!4$"1'&!/$"' !'4& 3 3!"'/:."%' %'%&&1!%&;% 3 ,!2,4 " ;3! 3!, 41! '" %$! 34 6!!' %&&1!4 6: 3! ..!

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

") "# %' %+ %"' "# $'$!// %"' "# 3! ,!2%& !,!4 .";!, "# ",'!: "' ))) ., #,"+ 3! & !+!' "# ..!//' "# ,!&."'4!' ") 30%'2 $$"+.'%!4 3!, 3! %+! ;3!' &3! 34 $'$!//!4 3! ,!2%& !,!4.";!,"# ",'!:4 !4))/"'2;% 3%//18'"" 3!

A*B !0%4!'$!%& 3!,!"' 3!,!$",4)$$",4%'2/:8% $''" 6!!& 6/%&3!4 3 $'$!// %"'"# 3!,!2%& !,!4.";!,"# ",'!:4 !4))8;& " 3!C'";/!42!"#,!&."'4!' ").,%", " 3!!>!$1 %"'"# 3!&/!4!!48 3!,!#",!8 3! $"1/4 '" 30! !>!$1 !4 &/! 4!!4 4 !4 <))8 %' #0"1,"#,!&."'4!' ")).!,1&/"#.,2,.3")*"# 3!=142+!' .&&!46: 3!/!,'!4..!// ! "1, ,!0!/&,!#!,!'$! " 3!!0%4!'$! "#=:D1+,8!2%& , %"' /!,C7* 8;3"3&.,"41$!4 3!,!$",4 "#.";!,"# ",'!:")*4 !4))8$'$!// %"'4!!4")*E 4 !4))'4&/!4!!4")*FE4 !4<)) >)8 '4 * ,!&.!$ %0!/:

'4 /&" & !4 3 3! !' ,%!& ,!2,4%'2 $'$!// %"'4!!4;!,!'" +!' %"'!42%'& 3!!' ,:"#,!2%& , %"'"# .";!,"# ",'!:).!,1&/"#.,2,.3")"# 3!=142+!' .&&!4 6: 3! /!,'!4 ..!// ! "1, ,!0!/& ,!#!,!'$! " 3! !0%4!'$! "#

+,= 7 8 ;3" & !4 3 "' ))8 3! ..!//' '4 3!, &%& !,3", 34 $'$!//!4 3! ,!2%& !,!4 .";!, "# ",'!: 4 !4 ))8!>!$1 !46: 3!+%'#0"1,"# 3!%,'!.3!;%)!),!&."'4!' ") '4 3! $'$!// %"' 4!!4 34 6!!' &$,%6!4 6: "'! "3%'4!,

3143,:8 ;3%$3 ;& ,!4 "0!, " 3! ..!//' '4 3!, &%& !,3", ./%' %## ") ) %& /&" +!' %"'!4 3 ,!&."'4!' ") 34 #1// C'";/!42! "# !>!$1 %"' "# .";!, "# ",'!: '4 #1, 3!, 3 "'1 '!.3!; "# 3! ..!//'

&"' "# %,% /8 6," 3!,"# 3!..!//' 34 $//!43%+ ";% '!&& 3!&/!4!!48/ 3"1233!;&'" 3! "# 3! 0%//2! %' G1!& %"'8 ;3!,! 3! .,".!, : ;& &% 1 !48 3 3! %+!"#!>!$1 %"'"# 3!&/!4!!48"'18..!//' &;!//&3!,&%& !, 3",'4,!&."'4!' ")*3", ;!,!.,!&!' '4 3 3!34&%2'!4 3!&/!4!!4 3!%'& '$!"#"'1&"'"#%,%./'4 3 3!;&'" $G1%' !4;% 3 3!..!//' '4,!&."'4!' ")*./%' %##") .,%",

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

) %+%/,/:8%' !

8 % 3& 6!!' 3!/4 3 %' 3! 6&!'$! "# #%/1,! " 4%&$3,2! 3! "'1& 6: 3! ./%' %## " &3"; 3 3! 2!' 3& 6!!' %'#",+!46"1 3!,!0"$ %"'"#2!'$:8 3!./%' %##$''" !&$.! 3! $"'&!G1!'$!&#,"+ 3!$ %"'"# 3!2!' %'&!//%'2 3!.,".!, :'4 3! "'/:6!'!#% ;3%$3 3!./%' %##$'"6 %'%& "&!!C#",.,".!,$$"1' #,"+3%&2!' %' 3!+''!, 3 3!/;$"' !+./ !&'4$''" //"; #", %+.!$3%'2 3! ,'&$ %"' "# &/!) !/!0' !> ,$ "# 3! #",!+!' %"'!44!$%&%"'&%&,!.,"41$!4&1'4!,(

A<B

" #

% & ' (&

" #

) ' *

+ , , -,, (& .

/ -,0 1

!+ /0 $ % ! 0,

+ /02 /0 3 4

+ 4

( # &

)' *

AEB

"#& (&

$ ! "#

5 ' " # ! 7 1

% 8 9 ! ! ' !$" -,/ 7 ,: 2

$ 7 $ % ! +

; )0</* ! = .0-

!94 94

! !

9 9

!4 >

AFB

< + 7

% 8 1 7 3 4 % % $ + ; 7 + " ; !$"-,7

@ - 2 ! : ?-:< 6/ + -:< +

+ /0 % !

"# (

+ /: %!

! ? + /:

+ /, % !

- /, --<

% 3

14+% @

AB B " %

B " -,: ) * +%%</-

E) $$",4%'2/:8%'0%!;"# 3!."&% %"''" !46"0!&;!//& 3!4!$%&%"'&"# 3%& "1, %'

$ % "# $ % "# 84"'" #%'4':2,"1'4 "%' !,#!,!;% 3 3!;!// ,!&"'!4=142+!' &"# 3! "1, &6!/";)"G1!& %"'"#/;+1$3/!&& &16& ' %/G1!& %"'"#/;,%&!&#",$"'&%4!, %"'%' 3%&$&!) F) %&+%&&!4) &'

(") ))* ,=!&3 73! 3!,&.!C%'2H,!&"'!4 ( !&H" 73! 3!,,!.", 6/! ( !&H"