High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4562/2016dismissed

M/S Rana Chillers Pvt. Limited v. Union Of India & ANR

2023-05-088 pages

!"!#$% %&&$&' (')&'* ' "+ ", * ')&'& -( . ,,!"%/#)#$

(% 01( # 2#2#2*1 01( # 2

2

!

" $% "

"

&

&' #( ) "

&* +++++ #2#2 ",3

5# (')&'* '

- "

"

" - "

'./0*/'1

"" , $

"

* ')&'&

#

**2**. "

,

-

***3'**/'0 4

5'* #

"

-

, "

6 7 !

67!

#

7 "

- # "

67! 4

50

$

# - $

$ -

"

*

,

***3'**/'0 4

5'* $

&*5& 8

) !"

$

!"

" '12/# , # '2/'*//*

*9/:*//1 4

5' ) # "

$ - 0* 92 29*5 ,#

; '1<

-

= 7

, (,-

# $ > " ? !

@, /2'**/'' 7

A &*'::. */''

#

#

"

,#

$"

% 67!

=

&*9:*/'0

$ ) # *2/**/'0 # " # $

"

,

" 3 $ #

5"

) "- ""

"- $

67!

, #

- $

"

#

"

#

$ ,$- )

#

" , $" # " #

67!

"

-

,"

:

$

'1/3*/'2

$

'9/3*/'1 #

-0 % #

% # "

Page No.2

$"-

# # './0*/'1

- #* /9 *9 '305

*1 % ""

#

$#

#

, -$-

67!

,# -*/

% # - # " " "

$

5 ) 0

5)

#

-%

$ $

. %

*1'/'991

"

#

"

"

#

#

67!

$# ,"

' ?9

5 B ' 444444444444444444444444 "

#

"

" "

#

7 > !

$--

>!

" $ , , >

" # 4-

"-- #

"-- #

67!"

C 2 "

D # #

67!-

, %

# # #$

4 3 6"!

" !!8

9 ": 1 ;

,5 6"!

", !

3 < =<# ("

>

",!

3 <5 /5 ,

"

#

$

-

Page No.3

.

5%# , # #

#

, "

, 3* '* ///5 $ '99:, -3. % 7 - # $

D

# 0$ 7

#:<

-

"

6 $

. %

*1'/'991

#

:: '3 *:'5 3//2*//' $ #

7

#

# $-

E

$)

" E

$ #

0* 92 29*5 ,#

;'1<

-

*9/:*//1

67!

# /2'**/'' 1

$

" #

*3/9*/': 4

5'/

, #

" !

&'32**/'*#

, "

"- % 67! " #

$"

7

)

) " # *2/**/'0 4

5''

"

$

" #

" #,

67!

:#

%

#"

$

*3'**/'0 4

5'*

$ ,

#

"% Page No.4

9

4 " 3 6"!

" !!8

9 ": 1 ;

, <8

67! " "

-

, $$

# & ,

# # $

.

% " "

"-"

4 # "-

$ #

5 B.

" ""

#% $ )%#

!

$--

) F *1'**/*/ /1/'*/*' E

, #

$ !

$ --

*0/**/*' 7 8 ,

, (,-

$#,

"

$ "

"7

"

( 1A

, (,-

8 ,

- )%

$ -

, -

- $

,

!

G E! "

- ,, " "

,

!

G E! "

$ )%

$

$ 7 ""

$$-

"

$

"

,

!

G E! "

, $ )% "

- & %" A

D

"

""

$ )% )%#

- $ " - ,,

$

" - $ )%

Page No.5

- ,

- -

$ )%% ""

#

, & % " "-

""

-

67!!"

" )%

- $ "

$- ,,

$A $ % ,- $

% #

#$% ""

% "--

- 9E

#

" -

,

$ , 6 7 !

!"

, " -$

#

# , - 4-

'//

-$

$ $ $ - #

,

-%

8 # #

$ ,

67! !"

" #$

- - $

""#

7

,

$

$

- # " "

$

- ,,

"

-

,

$

"

# , ,

-

#

"

-% " %

-

$

- ,,

-

, 7 "

67! !"

$

- " - $

""!" "

%#

,67!!"

"

!"

" -$ " , " $ '/

$

"-

" "

% Page No.6

5

-

$

-

$ ,

# " # "

$

- ,

$ -#

% ,

A #

% ,

$

"

$

- -

$

""H

"

-%

$ #

"" ""

$ $ " "

$-% #

"

""

" ,

-

"" "

$ ,

''7 -"

" #

# --" $ 8 ,

**2

, %

$, 67!

7 ,

67! #$( "

$"

-

,

%

" "

$-% %

- $ " - ,,

$

$

-

, % # (

, ,

67!!"

-

$ "

"--

- % # - #$

-

%

%

#

,

,

"

, " #

C '/

" #

$

#

$ ,$ Page No.7

$# " #

, $#"

$ './0*/'1

"

$ ,

$( - "

, "

, , $ !

"

$

#

"

"

, # ""

$

$#" './0*/'1"

"

- 67!

" "

"-"

#

"

4 5 $ # (

"

"-"

) "- ""

##

- 67!"

" " "

#

, # #( "-

"

,

, '' $

-

#

- #2#2*1

2 /#)#$

% ,

I & A

I & Page No.8