High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/7866/2016allowed

Malkit Kaur And ORS. v. Harpal Singh And ORS.

2019-03-12Mr. Justice Sudip Ahluwalia7 pages

!"!#$ %

& '

()!

* +, #- .,"

,/ (0!#1. #- .,"

!"#$%&$ '

!"#$%&$'(()) ")'$!"#$%&$ ($"$*+

%$ (, ----

) "/ 0 '( (()'

1(&"1,'%)2

&$'% $&'3""%$ /"$%%$ $& "'$&// 2/' $$&'42"2/'#2"' "/ "3"

""565*6578(

"2$9:*$&657;1,'$$%%2" )2

21 )!<'1".'2&&"$ ='21 )>0 '%)2 .(22$ 1&$'21 )03 &2)"

' %)2 (22$ " %2$ 788 $& ' $$ '2%) %! 7?::

.'2&&"$ ='%0&$%$ 2$$%%$ $&"'$& // 2/'"

$'2 2

&&"1,'2 2 $$#'2% )%%2" 3'2%'$$@()%2'&))2/32'2' 2 "2%2$$&$)2%2$!

2$6*57657;1$ ;*5 '$&% 3'2%'%

,&$%$ 2"2$$&' "

" "+

'% $&'%)2 9(()) 2 '$6*57657;!//

2/'.

2%"% "03'2)/$2/&$ )2$ 2$'2 $$%,%)12/

/2 2$$ +;?987?5!3'%'"$)"4 "3!)2 $"!

2 1$ ;*5 ! %$ 12/ /2 2$ $ +;?98;A* .'2&&"$ '=$&&"2/#'2%)>0% &$ 2 2"!3'2%'

12/"2#1, ($"$7+()2/'!'2/' (""2 '"/)2/ " %@/2 ' $$%,%)$&// 2/'

)$&3'2%'!'&))"$3$'$""

2"2 2 '2 "

@$2#2)$ (2)! 23''3 "2%$)/)),B 2"!

'$3#! 2 #23 $& 2$

2 2 ! 2 "+// 2/' 3 &" $ ! /$'&$ 1 '2 "3 &2)),"

2"22") $ (2)!2 3'' 2""

2"1 $6C57657;!'

$ ' 2 2 %%$"2/ $ ' %)2 ! ' %%2" 3

"1,$'$)2/' $$&42"2/' % 12/ < $;? "" 6*57657; " %2$

6C?9**C9**: " *5A+ $& ' "2 ) $" 3 /2 " /2 ($"$72 %)2 "1,'%)2 ''2 $&' %%2"!'/$&'"% "3 A;, 3 B($($$& /)

% 2/!/2"2/"&2B2/$&/)

2'1 2)"2/ "& 2 "

7;!5559+( $'&$ '1$# 2" %"3 ) 2/

75!5559+( $'1,"$2/B3$@$&&2B2/'/)

& '%)2 "''%)2 !3'$&2#2

1 2%) "2/ '2 32"$3!$ $ $!$ $"

/'"3$ 2$"

/' !3 "(" ($'"% ""',%)2 "

A5)% %$ 2$&$

' ($" ($ $2%! ($" $7 " 6 &2)" '2 $2 32

%$$#2/ ' # " 2 ' %)2 (22$ #) ()2 2,$1 %2$ /"2/ 2212)2,! %

$& %2$ " )$%

"2%3@"$ 2!23 ()""''%%2"$$@()% "

$/)2/"2#2/$&' $$%,%)2 '2

)&"&) < '

1 /2 "/2 32/ ($"$73 & '()""'!' 2 $&%%2"!'%$12/ /2 2$$ +;?98;A*3 2

32' ($"$*!244)

%$ (,")) $'# "2'(22$3) $%$$#"""2

)$&' (22$3 (,"&$ '&$ 2"1%@/$ "$&&% ) 2B!'#'")"

)&$'(()) 3)) ($"$*+

%$ (,"

(

"'%$"

$&'2 % '21 )'

')"''))/"%%2"'

@()%"

$ '"/)2/"2#2/$&'$&&"2/#'2%)!2!%$$3#!2 #23$&)%@$&,#2"%!23 1)$%%('2%$ $&'"% "

6;!5559+( $'"'

$),%%("

8!5559+( $' 2%$ $&'"% "&$')#( ($ '

)2()2$&7*'

1@ "2#23$&&2#

1 $&"(" !79A'$&2%$ '

1""

$3"

'( $)B( $&'"% "&$'( ($ $&%)% )2/'2

)"("%,

7!55!5559+'

1/2#$)@2

2!32"$3$&'"% ".(22$$71&$'21 )0$3"

$& %$

6:!5559+'

"$3"

& )B( "

:5!5559+$3"

'B( 2% "$' $&'"% " '$ /'!'%)2 '#%)2 "'

;!55!5559+3 ( $3"

' "2%)B( $&'"% "!1 '2 $&''2/$& '% !)"%$ )( 2/'(()) "$ $(

2 2$ /" 1, ' 21 ) " ' '" $& "2%) B( '%)2 @'% $&'%$ 2$

%'2&),$3$ (% <2 2 ' / $& , " ' '" $& < $ (% '

$1%$ 2"" (')3)2""$31,$ 2 2$ %' $&$1)(B$ 2

!# (#"+, # 3/ #45 -6" , # 40 .! #- .,"7

8298!:!(9

& %%$"2/$' %)2 2%'/$&'"% "'

1@$1A:,

1,'21 )!'& ($ (% $' $&6;D$&'2%$ 2 $1 """3'2)%)% )2/'%$ 2 B%$""' )

(

7!55!5559+'

$),1/"$'2 32"$31 '

$ ""

/' '#$13""()%$

"%$ )( 2/ ($"$*+

%$ (,

2"' $& '2

$&%$

2 %$%"!

7!55!5559+'

)",1 3""'&$!'2 $E 2$$&3"2/& '

$3#! '2 $ 2 ($ 22$ $ %$$# ' %)2 $& ' (()) ''"

2" "''"$&< $ (% '$ )"

1""" $& %$

(2 %$%"!'$1)(B$ 2 '

#, (#"+, # 5 -6" #+ 3 (!

".+,+ 3 #- .,"7

829 8!:!(9 %%%! & %$ 2"2/ 2 )2 "%2 2$ ""2

!# (#"+, # 3/ #45 -6", # 40 .! #- .,"7

8298!:!(9

&!'

$1 #" "+ )/) ()%! =%$

> 2 %$ ("2$

3'2%' %$ (

F ($

) %$

G! F() %$

G! "

F&2)2)%$

;

'2/'$%$

3$ )"2%) "'%$ (,!%!

')(!%$ &$!/ 2"%! $)%"&&%2$$&'"% "!3'2%'2 )$

$'2 & 2),H2' (%$ ($

!23$ )"2%) " B ) )2$ 32''"% " ($

<". #-,": <=!,0!#1.

,"8

%9&0;2 ($

)%$

2 /)),"&2" 2/' (22/ $')2$ '2($&'

1"32&3'2%'))$3 %$ 2$$'

#2#2/ ($

&$)$

$&=%$ (,! $%2,!%$$(2$!&&%2$!

"2"$&'$'2#,%$ /))2$> ) %$

2 /" $ ' %'2)" ($ ' ( "' $& (! &$ )$

$& =() 2"! ($%2$!

&&%2$! $%2,!"2 %2()2!/ 2"%"22/> <2)2)%$

2 '2/'$&'( $%$ 2$ 2'% $&%%2")"'$&%'2)"%%2")"2/$' "'$&%'2)"%

/ '$%@"/$,$'( "& 2),$& '"% "'/ /$,&$(2 $)$ '2%'2)""

2/ '2 )2&2 '2)" #) " &$ '2 )$#! &&%2$!

(2$ '2("'2$)2'& 2), 2 $

2 (%2)(2

&)%2/%'/2/$

1$ '

"3$'$&% ))2$ '2( $" 2 "2%2$

3$)"$#'#%$/2I"''#) $&%'2)"G %$

& B%"

'%$$ 2%#) $&'%$ 2$3""2'% $& '"'$&%'2)"$ 2 "2%2$ '&$( 2( $1 3""%$ ")$

$&%$

$'"'$&%'2)" ' 3""$'( 2 %$ 2$&$)$

$&')$#!

&&%2$!%"%$ (2$ '2($&'"% "%'2)" '$$ '2%) %2 1&2%2))/2 )2$2 " ($#2"2/)2&$'#2%2

$'2& 2)2 !2% $&/ 2 %)2

% 3'('

)$ '2 2$%'2)"!$ 2" $ $"

/'!'( 2)"$13"")$

$&%$

"''"$&<2)2)$

2 3""$%'2)"3'$)$ '2 ( 2 $$#'2%)%%2" "'% &32/'$ '#3""%$ 2$$'2

;$3#!'3 $%)2,32' (%$'(2%2() $ 3'2%'%$ 2$%$ )"13""$)$

$&<2)2)$

' $&%$ 2$$13"" %$

32))1/$#"1,'(2%2() $&3"2/%$ " F$

$&$

G )2""$32

(0 '( % !3" 2(($(2$3"' &'"' $&'"% "!

A5!555%'&$ )$

$&<2)2)$

> '( % !2#23$&'"%2 2$$&'(B$ 2 , # 40 .!8"+/, 9"'

#, (#"+, # 5 -8"+/, 9!' %)2 +(())$7+)@2

.32"$3$&'"% "03$ )"$),1 2)"&$ ($

)%$

A5!5559+$3#!' %'2)"!2!(()) +%)2 $6$A3$ )") $12)"&$() %$

'$&

A5!5559+%' ','#)$ '2$$&' ( 2' $$#'2% )%%2" $$'2

12 "1,)"%$ )&$'(2

#"B%('$ 3'2%' "

%$ 2""""2 %

" 1$# %%$"2/),!'2 $ 3$ )"" 2(($(2$3"' 32"$3$&'"% "+)@2

.%)2 +(())$70&$ $&

A5!5559+&$)$

$& ($

)%$

A5!5559+%'$'&$ %'2)" $& ' "% "! 2! (()) +%)2 $ 6 $ A () %$

&$)$

$&$$&'2( < '!2 ,%$ 2""$(22$!'2 $&?D(

3$ )" #'( ($ 2

%' 2 2$3'( $'

)$ '2

)2&"

$/)2/"2#2/$&'$&&"2/#'2%) %%$"2/),!'$&2 2 2 "&$ C;$?D(

$1%)% )"&$ '"$&&2)2/$&'%)2 (22$2))'"$&% ) )2I2$

%'!'3"$&'21 )2 "

$"2&2""+ %)% )" "+

0, -" 3/#"

!# 3+#

7 %$

8!5559+( $'

6 ""22$$&< $ (% .J$& 6;D$&2%$ 0 .

8!555K

7;550L

C;559+ *

%2$.79A'0 &$ ( $) B(

C;55+

7:C;L

;!86;9+ A )2()2.//$ ($&A;$;50 7* ; $))$

$&"("%,

;!86;B7*B76L

:!CC!;559+ 8 ($

)"()%$

$ &2#"("

A5!5559+$%'"("!2!

6!55!5559+ C < )B(

6:!5559+ : "2%)B(

:5!5559+

( 3/#"

!# "7 ;7;

> #.

# - 3/#"

!# 3+#

"7 ;7;

"&7

> ?" 7;7;

> %%$"2/),! ' %)2 ')" 2)" $ ' '%"

6!C;!5559+',3$ )") $12)"&$'%"

2 J?D(

$'3"" $1%)% )"&$ '" $&&2)2/$&'%)2 (22$2))'"$&% ))2I2$$3#!'

$"$&"2 $&'%$ 3)) '%$ (

%$""2'2 ( /" "/ "3"$&'21 )@(2% 2 "%)'$1#2$

),'$) (,1)3$ )"1 &""

%2/'% ) 3'2%''

)",1(2"1,'

% $ (,$'(()) +%)2 !'$3#!'2 '

$1%)% )"

& ' '

)!'2 (() "

))$3""2 ( /" "/ "3"$&'21 ) "

$"2&2""'3"" 2 '%"

$'B 2"2%"1$#$3#!(2 '))1'2$3%$ 869 765*657?

) @.

.,"/ )!#1>, "#-A "> @.

.,,/,

=(A ">