← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5294/2014dismissed

Chand Ram v. Bhagwat Dayal

2015-08-18Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Garg5 pages

   



!"# $#%&'&() )  *!($!+ ,,#--!(" .#/'0' *!12!"!3!- #',($#(" 45678 9*#"*#/#,/"#/' 7%!-#2',!,#/'+!3:#!--2#$" '##"*#;0$1+#("< 3#'

:#/# #//#$""*##,/"#/'/("<3#'

=9*#"*#/"*#;0$1+#("'*0-$:#/#,/"#$&("*#&1#'"<3#' /#'#("4/>&.#?7!+:!@$.%!"# /"*#!,,#--!("   *!($!+,-!&("&

5!,,#--!("*!'$&/#%"#$"*#,/#'#("!,,#!- !1!&('"  "*#  ;0$1+#("  !($  $#%/##  $!"#$   

 ,!''#$  :3  */& *!0*!(@  -#!/(#$  &'"/&%"  0$1#@  *&2!(&  .&$#  2*&%*  "*#  !,,#!- ,/# #//#$  :3  ,-!&("&

A!,,#--!("  !1!&('"  "*#  ;0$1+#("  !($  $#%/##  $!"#$ =,!''#$:3*/&!/#($#/&(1*@"*#"*#(-#!/(#$&.&-0$1#

0(&/&.&'&( @*!/?*&!$/&2!'$&'+&''#$ /&# !%"' "*#,/#'#("%!'#!/#"*!"(= 

)$# #($!("

://2#$!'0+ ' @

A5 /+"*#,-!&("&

!-(12&"*&("#/#'"B C ,#/+("* /*0'#*-$#D,#('#'!($*#0($#/"?"/#"0/("*#'!&$ !+0("!-(12&"*&("#/#'"($#+!($# #($!("#D#%0"#$!!*&#("/3&( "*#!*&

&(*&'2(*!($2/&"&(1""*&'#

#%"!($'&1(#$"*#

'!+#  !%/''  "*#  /#.#(0#  "&%?#"  &(  "*#  ,/#'#(%#    2&"(#''#'@  :0"  "*# $# #($!("$&$("/#,!3"*#'!&$!+0("!'!1/##$#(%#"*&''0&" (("&%#@$# #($!("' &-#$2/&""#('"!"#+#("!($%("#'"#$"*# '0&"("*#1/0($'"*!"(#&"*#/*##.#/://2#$!(3!+0(" /+"*# ,-!&("&

(/#D#%0"#$!(3!--#1#$2/&"&(1&("*#!*&

!($ "*#/# /#@"*#E0#'"&( /#"0/(&(1!(3!+0("""*#,-!&("&

$#'("!/&'# !"!-- #(3&(1"*#/!.#/+#("'@$# #($!(""?,/#-&+&(!/3:;#%"&('

/#1!/$&(1  +!&("!&(!:&-&"3@  %!0'#    !%"&(@  -%0'  '"!($&  F  #'",,#-  !($ %(%#!-+#(" +!"#/&!- !%"' /+"*#0/"

#;&($#/2!' &-#$:3"*#,-!&("&

/+"*#,-#!$&(1' "*# ,!/"&#' --2&(1&''0#'2#/# /!+#$45  9*#"*#/"*#,-!&("&

&'#("&"-#$"/#%.#/"*#'0&" !+0(" '=G@G= A5 ,/&(%&,!-' @

A5H&("#/#'" '@G= A5 !-(12&"*,#($#("&-#&("#/#'"!',/!3#$

/< 9*#"*#/"*#,-!&("&

*!'(-%0'5'"!($&" &-#"*# ,/#'#("'0&"< 9*#"*#/"*#,/#'#("'0&"&'("+!&("!&(!:-#&("*# ,/#'#(" /+<

9*#"*#/"*#,-!&("&

*!'("%+#""*#%0/"2&"*%-#!( *!($'<  9*#"*#/"*#,-!&("&

&'#'",,#$:3*&'2(!%"!($ %($0%"" &-#"*#,/#'#("'0&"< I 9*#"*#/"*#,-!&("&

*!'%(%#!-#$"*#"/0#!($+!"#/&!- !%"' /+"*#0/"< G #-&#  *#,!/"&#'*!.#-#$"*#&//#',#%"&.##.&$#(%#("*#! /#'!&$ &''0#'*#"/&!-0/"!

"#/!,,/!&'!- "*##.&$#(%#$&'+&''#$"*#'0&"

"*#,-!&("&

.&$#;0$1+#("!($$#%/##$!"#$ =

= I ##-&(1!11/&#.#$@"*#,-!&("&

,/# #//#$ &/'"!,,#!-!1!&('"

"*# ;0$1+#("!($$#%/##$!"#$ = *#-#!/(#$&'"/&%"0$1#@ *&2!(&.&$#;0$1+#("!($$#%/##$!"#$ 

$&'+&''#$"*#!,,#!- 

G "&--  ##-&(1  $&''!"&'

&#$  2&"*  "*#  !

/#'!&$  ;0$1+#("'  !($ $#%/##'@  "*#  ,/#'#("  /#10-!/  '#%($  !,,#!-  *!'  :##(  $&/#%"#$  :3  "*# ,-!&("&

A!,,#--!(" ) (,!/!1/!,* "*#1/0($' !,,#!-@,-!&("&

A!,,#--!("

*!' /!+#$"*# --2&(1-!2,&(" /!$;0$&%!"&(:3"*&'0/"45

& 9*#"*#/"*# &($&(1' "*#-2#/%0/"':#-2!/#:!'#$ (+&'/#!$&(1 #.&$#(%#/#'0-"&(1&(",#/.#/'&"3<

&& 9*#"*#/"*#&+,01(#$;0$1+#("'2#/#,!''#$2&"*0" %('&$#/&(1"*##.&$#(%#"#($#/#$:3"*#,!/"&#'""*# '0&"<

*!.#*#!/$-#!/(#$%0('#- /"*#!,,#--!("!($*!'1(# "*/01*"*#,!,#/:?  

                    

        

   





   

     



 



          

     

   

  

   

  

   

        

 

           

   



 !" # 

  

  



 

  

      " 

             $ 

   



   



$                    %,3 "*&';0$1+#(":#'#("""*#"/&!-0/" /'"/&%"

%+,-&!(%#