Jagtar Singh And ORS v. Labh Singh & ANR




    
 

 !"#!$%&%"'()*) + ,%'+-" -!,& ..!//' & 0!,&1& 23-%'+-'" -!,  !&."'4!' &
 


     

,!&!' (

,)&-"5-,467849"$ !#", -!..!//' &) :::

     

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

,".!, <8-&3!!' ,!9!,&!4)
%&+%'& &1$-3$54,". -  -!./%' %##&..!//' &,!%' &!$"'4..!/3!#",! -%&"1, ) 2!,'!4$"1'&!/,!.,!&!' %'+ -!..!//' &-&9!-!;!' /< ,+1!4 - $";.,%&!-43!!'!##!$ !43! 6!!' -!.

 4!#!'4' 23-%'+-6% - -!%' !,9!' %"'"# -! '$-< "'))?

'4&1$-$";.,";%&!-43!!'41/<441$!4"',!$",4'4.,"9!4&A)  >)
%&1,+!4 - &.!,&1$-$";.,";%&! -!!A$/1&%9!."&&!&&%"'"# -! ./%' %##&"9!, -!&1% .,".!, <4;!&1,%'+5'/;,/6&41/< .,"9!4'4% %&1'4!,&1$-$%,$1;& '$!& -  -!,%/"1, -4,%+- #1//< 4!$,!!4 -!&1% +,' %'+,!/%!#"#.!,;'!' %'71'$ %"')
' -!&;!/%;3% %&$"' !'4!4 - 23-%'+-4!#!'4' -4'" 4%&.1 !4 -!$";.,";%&! 4 !4))?A) >'4%'/6"'$! -!".."&% !., <-&4;% !4"' &.!$%#%$#$ 1/&.!$  -!,!6&'",!B1%,!;!' 1."' -!./%' %##& " -9!441$!4'<#1, -!,!9%4!'$! "$"'$/1&%9!/<.,"9! -!%,."&&!&&%"') ! '" -!,&13;%&&%"',%&!43<$"1'&!/ -  -!2"6!,..!// !"1, 6-%/!4%& 1,3%'+ -!#%'4%'+&"# -!,%/"1, -&'" 4!/ 6% - -! $";.,";%&!4 !4))?A) >) 9%'+-!,4$"1'&!/#", -!..!//' &'4-9%'+.!,1&!4 -! $&!..!,3""58 -%&"1, %&"# -!$"'&%4!,!49%!6 -  -!.,!&!' ..!/ /$5&;!,% '44!&!,9!& "3!4%&;%&&!4)

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
-&#1, -!,3!!'

> $"'$!4!4 -  %//4 !'"., % %"'-& 5!'./$!&,!+,4& -!7"%' -"/4%'+) -!-!9<,!/%'$!./$!43<$"1'&!/1."' -!$";.,";%&! 4 !4))?A) >%&;%&$"'$!%9!4)4;% !4/<8 -!&1% .,".!, <%& ., "#7"%' -"/4%'+$";.,%&!4%'=-!6 ")?)"., % %"' %//4 ! -& 5!'./$!)9!'&.!, -!./%' %##&@..!//' & -!$";.,";%&!4 !4 ))?A) >6& 
 ./%' %##&..!//' &'44!#!'4' 23- %'+-)
'" -!,6",4&8&1$-$";.,";%&!4%4'"  5!6% -%'% &&6!!.// -!" -!,$"&-,!,&"# -!7"%' -"/4%'+)&&1$-8 -!$";.,";%&!4 !4 ))?A) >!9!'%#$$!. !48$''" 3%'4 -!" -!,$"&-,!,&"# -! 7"%' /'4-"/4%'+ ",! 1,'#%'4%'+  - ./%' %##&..!//' &6!,!%' !A$/1&%9!."&&!&&%"'"#$!, %'.,$!/"#/'4) -%&  "1,  %&  "#  -!  $"'&%4!,!4  9%!6  -  -!  %;.1+'!4 714+!;!' 4 !4 )) .&&!4 3</!,'!4 44% %"'/ %& ,%$ 14+!8

 %/., /<$$!. %'+ -!..!/"# -!4!#!'4' ,!&."'4!' %&3&!4"' 41!..,!$% %"'"#!9%4!'$!'4 -!$",,!$ 9%!6-&3!!' 5!')
6"1/4 3!.."&% ! "'" %$! -  -!., %/,!& ,%' %;."&!43< -!,%/"1, 6% -,!+,4 "'"& !.& "3! 5!' "4%;%'%&- -!9/1!"#&1% .,".!, <8 -& 3!!'  1.-!/4 3< -!2"6!, ..!// ! "1, )  -!%' !,!& & "# -! ./%' %##&..!//' &8&&1$-8& '441/<.," !$ !4) -!,!%&'";!,% %' -!%'& ' ..!/)..!/4"!&'" ,%&! '<&13& ' %/B1!& %"'"#/6) ..!/8$$",4%'+/<8%&4%&;%&&!4)        

 

!

/1$5< C-! -!,&.!5%'+@,!&"'!4( !&@"

C-! -!, !.", 3/!( !&@"