← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4692/2019disposed of

Narveer Singh And ANR v. Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd And ANR

2020-02-06Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh10 pages



    



 

    ! "



# $ % !

  &'( 

)  ! "#     *  +(,     ( +(*- .('     (

 $

 

              -

               %&       (/(01   2    2  343(  (5,&   6      & "



# $ % !

  &'(4

 7#$!'85 -   -   2       

 3 ,&  &  %&       (1(09 





2 -

 

 



2



     ( :    

& 

   &        &          

 #$!'           &  

0/;1//<= 

      0(>(0;

    -  %  



  %    

  

   &&(

&   

- 

   



 

      ( 2=9>    2=99    &&      & &        

    &

      &  -

    -  "    &  & ( :

  

&   ( 2=99



 & 

- &

-

- - &"  3? /((0;(: 

     

 &   & 

 

   -  6

     

   /((0;( 

     @((0; 

&        &  

    &

 & 

& 

 /((0;

  & 

&

&    

  

-     &( :      

  

       

  "      =&





       &    &        -    %

   2  2(A &     & -        

(

:  2& -





= 0( B 



     CA** ( B 



   &

% CA** /( B 



   & 

% CA** @( B   

   &  2 -    CA* ;( B

&



 CA* ( B 

       

   CA* >( B 

      2  %

CA* 1( B 



 &

  

-      CA* 9( ) ( :  

   &  ?D(*0  ?D(*00 



 *B0 D&

*BE&

(:     D&

.  B0!

" F B + 3? B/  & ?D(0 ?D(<0 ?D(< 

-

   

-      

6         2   

(   -        &

 %&'()' *'+,- )-,-.*-)  /0(120 0'* #  3* .4 .(5.*0 /0-(*" '3'6.77-.6

88 9#

 

:; )-,')-)+ : $ # 8 &2       @0* % 2 0901-    * %  # 

  

&

    6  - 

   ('  

       %1+'/.3* //.(.(<.+.'=6'>'/(.+'2.4#/).+).+/0-("  ;

?  '3'6 

 

& ( E  

 +(  ,        H+(*- .('          ( :            

-         

   &   ((0;  &  & 

 -

   &  -  -    &"   3

?

- 

   ?D(*(:- -

     &  B0 .   A

 

 

= D&

        "&-   &   & ?D(0

  &   & &  

    " -"8 &    

     -      

   &    ( : &

 

      &

  

= D&

 B!

" FA-   

 

  &

  ( 2=99-  

       -   & 

  &"  &  3? G 

  

  & 

 -    

&

  "- -     -     

  &H       &&

 -             

     

          %      

       "            

( &



&



-



 

= D&

            &    -    &      & -        ( B    - 

      

    -    

- (+  -   D  ((/((0; 

   -&

 -  ?D(*>     

  

 

&

-  

 & ?D(*1( '     2 



        &  

  #$!'   = 

     -  & -       %

 2  2    (+   92*2&-  2   2  D

  %

 -  

  

    &&

   

%( G       

         

   

   ?  

  /    0

&-  %

             2( ) 

        -   # 8   & 2

 %1/0-(+ 6-,/(','/< 1776<   ('**.#/)3*('--/.(.4 ',-'66"# 8 

# 2

 &  % >.(.6.5*04' .+) /0-(* 3* 0- 17-('+/-+)'+2 +2'+--( **-**4-+/* $.*/-(+ @-('*/('A1/'++)0(.

(.)-*0" B('/ -/'/'+ :   )-,')-) + 8? $      

        



           

 

            

 !"#   $     "  "     %

"  "  &" 

   ' &              

 !

" 

 ! "" (      "" "  ( 

   

 )&

      ( (&  (  " & "   "    "  ! %  " *

+       "   %   

 "  ,,  #     "   (     "     %  "" "       "  %%%"     ! "  ,,  #  #

      

(&       ( "     "  %     " 

",, # -      % % "    " 

!./ !./",, #   &%       0 (& "   

  % &    

 "  !"# 

) ' &  " 

"#    " * ) '(  & ""  (        "   %0   " &      "   %  0  "      " %  &   "     

       1     ""    "  (

&% " (    "   (  0 " 

.!/

.

/ )" ,,  #        (  2&""   &  "& "    &  "  "    "        

" 3333 3333 3333 3333 3333 3333

+    

 

   



     



     

&       %       (( " #  4 "   " $         "    (   #       % 5       

       (  % %  ""  %   

!"#   6    "   " "   "   %      

  " "& "   % %  &       % %    "

  " 5 "  7  "       "

 % 8               ! 

 , 9&                 (    (&   " 5  " %        

. / "  #    & "" 1 "  ,%" "( " " ( $"     %  (    " 5   " ""&   %     & ""          " "   

.!/ 

.

/ 1  ""   "( &%"(   ":  .!/ # & "    (    )        " % &  "   

  ,%"  &  (  "   %   %  & "" ; :  & 

  

    

          -            

&     &    % 

 - 

   &&

   04/5 - 



 

& - 

 / &        

  

&   &   &    

&

 %

  

( ?    &   &  

  

        

     

&   &  I   

 -  D

    -  

               2 -(:    2  -  

I    & 

  

 -         &%   

()-    

     2

    - -

  & 

 

 & %&         

-  

     

 

  %&         2  



      2(:   



 & (

    

-A(1.(<$   B "

<   F < B  F <