← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5341/2014allowed

M/S Rms Estate Private Limited v. Hari Ram

2016-08-31Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh18 pages

Paramjit Kaur Saini 2016.09.14 10:23 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document

   !"#"$"%""" "$ "

 &" &'()

( (* + ,(-(" ."/0$ 1122" .( ""0 (1$

"0) 3#2(4 ('5""2 ()  

   

         

        

       

   

      5""2*4 ! 

 " 

  #      $%&$'%(   "  )   *

 " 



  #      +%$$'%$   "     ,  )- *

 ,   "  . 

 /-    

0

   "  !

0

     # 



       #  

      

    

    1     

  

  

 ) ) *

 

  

 

   %&  

 %

     (   

 2   34$''3    

  

           

    

 

 

  " 2      "      56)  ! 

      $+$$'%'      

 

 

           ! 

                  " 

   

      7       

          

  "



 

            !          

 

 2   7 2    

 2  *) 89% :

 ; 89$     <2 8%  8= ! 

      "     

                       #

 

     "       

             "    !



  #      "  



         > ,%-  

0

        # 

  

 

   34$''3 ,<2 8$-

 2  "      

    

    "        "

   "     

   " 5?"

      7

 

    

   ,$-!





 2   34$''3  



  " 2  " 3@$''3  3@$''3         "   "  

     #      

   "  5?"

 5   !" #$  

%& #$  

 '

 # ( )&

* #$   '+'

,   

  

    "      

        +=1   !   8  %&&$ ,  .!8 /-  #   A

  "

 5  #

 %$ - * .$, 

     B   "      7    #      

  

           "

    #   / 0 #,     

  

  "

   

  B    7 

    / 0 #,    



    7      "      

8     8  $   %@@' , C $$  %@@'- "

    

 "     5     7     

   $'%= 7   

 

 

 "    

 2      $''3  " 



 "     5     7     

     "    8      %@@'  #   / 0 #,                9 

        #       "    !" #$  / 0 ,

 # ( )&/ 0 ,     

    !" #$  / 0 ,   # ( )&/ 0 ,    

       +=1   !8  !           

 "  

    #        "

     (% ,-    :   %@3= 7     "    # ( )&/ 0 ,  

 

     "   

         " 

+ 0

   # 

 "  

      "  



 "  

)   A   D        

   

      A

   "

 5   #

 %$/ 0 ,

  B  

   .

     #      

   +=1   !   8  

/

         

  "           

       

# 

 " "

 "

  B

         "

      "

   (%,-    :   7   

           #   "

 5        " "

   

  

   

   

 

  "

        (%    :  

         

   "  0  "  

 

    

7      "  

   

    

    A          #    

 5  1* # -00 %

,0&

 % *   '+2 34 35 62

  "  "       0    "      56)           

   2  "        "        #     B

        

      "   A        #     ) #$ 7 #$   ''+  *

6

             #    "    

      "         

  

 

"

        

    / 0 ,  7      



 "       8    7         %@@'

8

 "     5         $'%=            

  

 2     $''3 5     "           

             "    56)          

  %+($'%'   

         CD

           B    

       

                 #      

   

  0 

         

  

            

    

  

  B

              #  1    "   "   "  

 #     !    "  

          B   1 "   

 

  "       " 

   A 

9 "   

      

      #   1* # -00 % ,0&/ 0 ,

       

  "

     (%    :  

     

      7                "      "

  #    "

    "  "    

          

  

  "

       

  

         7     "       8    "       5  

  2 

    

 "     5     $'%=

 

  B        $''3 7    

      

  

   "

  

        "   ! "       

   

 

  1 "      "    

    "   

 "    

   #   1* # -00 % ,0&/ 0 ,   "           

 

  "   

  "  

   ! 

  

 

  "

  (%    :   

  

  "   "   "  

   7      

   

       



   B   "         #                   $'%'   "

 

 2      $''3

"  

 

  " 2   2        

        #               7            A

 #   "

 5  #

 %$/ 0 ,     #    "    " 

 7 !" #$  / 0 ,  " 

     

       #  

    0

 

    

 , "#

 

  

   $3%$%@3$-       

0 ! B   "         "

     (%,-    :   %@3=

    

 

     " 

0

  "  

       

   

"  

)   !

  

   

     %3   #       # 

 "

   (%,-    :   %@3=  B

      

 "

      %4    

>1 

        



 

       

 

    



      

 



  

     



   

          

   

      !



 " 

      

   #$%&          

  !



                

  

 

       '  

    2            

      

  



 " #  

      

         

0          0

   

      

 

     

  B    0

     #       

 "      +=1   !8  !   #   !" #$  / 0 ,  

      +=1   !8      #    "             

  # ( )&/ 0 ,      

     +=1       

 

   

  #   "  

   

 7      7      

      

  #          +=1   !8  ! A

  "

 5  

    

  "     #  " 

   +=1   !8  7  3   #  

       "    "    

     +=1   !8           E,-   "             F ,-     " 

    "     "    "

F ,- 



 "                  "  F ,-       1                 F ,-                 F  ,-         "

         7  @    "        "  +=1               

   

  

  

  



                +=1 !   

     

    

 1       "

             

  

     #  *  

* 7" (,&   34 '' 35 6  8  3

, - 0, * '66 #

 ) 7

%, 34 '6+ #, , ' # 8  7 )  # 34 '+ # '+' 7 7,5 79 :," ;" 8&  # 34 '2 #  ,     %'

 %%-      

   %%    +=1   !8                      !     

    "     "  +=1   !8       "

      

 "          "

   +=1

    7  

                         

 "    A                            +=1   "

             +=1 

        "

      +=1   

          

   !                

 

  

# 

        +=1       7  %=        B  

"       #        (% ,-    :   D               #  

             

     

     

    

                 

 "      D $ :

 $

     

      

 "

+  "

       

#     

  " "

 7         (%    :            #        "

  

   2    #  *     #       

  (%

          " 2 7  

    %=    "           "

 "  G

 G       

  "           "

  +=1    B     



            7      

                     "  

  

    B           "  +=1   !8  7      

    #

 %$/ 0 ,    "   #   

      "

   "  "

 5  7      

       



7  "        " 

0

       #    

        

"  

 

        

     

       

 #              "   "  "   

  

 " #  

  B   

     

    +=1   !8         !    

      +=1   !8     B   "   "

   

       

 B  "   B      B   "    "    

       "   

      "       "    "

 5    " 7      "    " 

 

  #      "    

 

8

          

     

 !   

   

  

 "    

 $$@$'%3 ,5""2 $ 

( (* + # ( 



 !



)* !" 9   > H0C